Biidaajimowin
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

The world is watching how Canada treats Indigenous rights

A fascinating and perhaps chilling case surrounding Indigenous rights and what constitutes ceremonial space and an “Indigenous home” — and whether police can enter it without a warrant — took place recently in B.C.

Last week, the international human rights groups Amnesty International and Peace Brigades International were in Smithers, B.C., to observe the sentencing of three Indigenous activists who were arrested in 2021 for violating a court injunction related to the construction of the Coastal GasLink pipeline.

The three were arrested while protecting Wet’suwet’en ancestral territories and specifically a traditional village site they were occupying — a case that went all the way to the B.C. Supreme Court and was decided in January 2024.

After months of arguments over the legitimacy of the charges and RCMP conduct, Gitxsan activist Shaylynn Sampson (a Gitxsan woman who has Wet’suwet’en family ties), Kanien’kehá:ka activist Corey Jocko and Sleydo’ (also known as Molly Wickham), a traditional leader of the Gidimt’en Clan of the Wet’suwet’en Nation, were given various short, suspended jail sentences and 150 hours of community service.

Supporters of the Wet'suwet'en hereditary chiefs and who oppose the Costal GasLink pipeline, work on a support camp just outside of Gidimt'en checkpoint near Houston B.C., on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2020. A report by Amnesty International says police in British Columbia conducted arbitrary arrests and

Supporters of the Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs and who oppose the Costal GasLink pipeline, work on a support camp just outside of Gidimt’en checkpoint near Houston B.C., on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2020. A report by Amnesty International says police in British Columbia conducted arbitrary arrests and “aggressive surveillance, harassment and intimidation” of First Nations protesters blocking a pipeline project. (Jason Franson / Canadian Press files)

This is somewhat surprising, as earlier this year, a B.C. judge found that RCMP violated the rights of the activists because they had established a traditional ceremonial village and a residential structure on the proposed path of the pipeline — both of which were entered illegally, without a warrant, and under the jurisdiction of a court injunction.

The activists sought to have the charges thrown out, but even though the judge agreed their rights were violated, they were found guilty of violating a court injunction to not block the pipeline — a decision Amnesty International called “a chilling message.”

Essentially, this decision sends a signal that a Canadian court injunction supporting the construction of a pipeline supersedes Indigenous rights.

Figuring out long-ignored Indigenous rights in this country is a complicated, costly, fairly inefficient endeavour made much worse with violence, capitalist economic interests and the fact Canada makes it up as it goes along.

The problem is, Canada continues to resort to old habits, beliefs and violence against Indigenous communities to complete resource development projects, as evidenced in the case of Wet’suwet’en and the Coastal GasLink pipeline.

For a year, Amnesty International has studied and documented what they call the “criminalization, intimidation, and harassment of Wet’suwet’en land defenders.”

And Amnesty isn’t alone. Other organizations throughout the world are watching the way Canadian authorities have treated the Wet’suwet’en and are paying attention to this case in particular.

From 2019 to 2023, Coastal GasLink built a controversial 670-kilometre pipeline across two mountain ranges and 10 major waterways to carry natural gas across northern British Columbia to a terminal in Kitimat, B.C., for export to Asia.

The project has been deeply controversial and, in many ways, illegal, violating environmental regulations and dividing Indigenous communities, resulting in numerous arrests and conflicts.

Until Indigenous rights are fully implemented and respected, curious, complicated and controversial situations will emerge — particularly now that Prime Minister Mark Carney is promising to “speed up” economic projects.

 

Niigaan Sinclair, Columnist

 

Advertisement

 

FIVE STORIES ON TURTLE ISLAND

Manitoba lost one of its most well-respected Indigenous elders this week.

Stan LaPierre died suddenly on Oct. 18. LaPierre, whose Anishinaabe name was Ogimaw Giizhik-iban (“Leader of the sky”) was wolf clan and spent years working with justice workers and Indigenous individuals in correctional facilities throughout the province.

He became an advocate alongside his partner Thelma Morrisseau to search landfills for the remains of Morgan Harris, Marcedes Myran, Rebecca Contois and Ashlee Shingoose.

LaPierre’s legacy is wide-ranging; he built programs and supported people everywhere and anywhere. He was also my uncle.


After a long repatriation campaign by Indigenous groups and the federal government — and a long negotiation processa series of traditional Indigenous items that were inappropriately taken are coming back to Canada from the Vatican museum.

Among the items are a kayak from the Arctic Inuit, gloves made by Cree people, a Gwich’in baby belt, and a wampum belt from Kanesatake.

Many of the items are from the 1925 Pontifical Missionary Exposition, a world expo overseen by Pope Pius XI, who ordered missionaries to collect Indigenous and non-Christian items of cultural significance and send them to Rome.

The removal of these items left communities harmed, confused and in a state of loss.

For years, the Vatican stated the items for the 1925 Exposition were “gifts,” but they clearly were more like souvenirs — and even stolen property.

An ironic part of this story is the Vatican’s requirement that the Canadian Council of Catholic Bishops receive the items on a “church-to-church” basis rather than let a museum handle them, because to do the latter would spark “a precedent” for governments and Indigenous groups to demand the return of thousands of other inappropriately taken items.


This week, Canada’s Auditor General Karen Hogan will be releasing much-anticipated reports on Indigenous Services Canada.

The reports are expected to delve into the department’s program commitments and spending in key areas such as health-care services in First Nation communities, on-reserve safe drinking water and emergency management planning.

Considering this past wildfire season was the second-highest on record, with Indigenous peoples affected and evacuated more than anyone else in this country, the persistent boil-water advisories and a lack of nursing stations on First Nations, these reports will (hopefully) give Canadians a picture of where the country is at on some critical issues.


Long-sought answers in the death of a Manitoba woman have started to come to light.

Melinda Lynxleg from Tootinaowaziibeeing Treaty Reserve disappeared in 2020. Her remains were discovered three years after she went missing. but the case remained unsolved until RCMP charged three individuals this week.

Lynxleg, a mother of six, was last seen on the morning of April 2, 2020, after leaving home in the rural municipality of Grandview, about 300 kilometres northwest of Winnipeg.

Melinda Lynxleg (Handout / RCMP)

Melinda Lynxleg (Handout / RCMP)

Her remains were found in 2023 at an abandoned property near the Saskatchewan border, around 55 kilometres away.

After declaring her death a homicide, police pursued an investigation that heated up last spring after “new information” was unearthed.


Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Woodhouse spent this week criticizing the federal Liberals for failing to deliver on a long-standing promise for First Nations policing.

Woodhouse said the service must be declared “essential.”

This comes after Woodhouse’s claim last week that she and First Nations leaders have been left out of this week’s first ministers meetings on public safety in Alberta.

First Nations policing has become a hot-button issue for many Indigenous leaders, demanding jurisdiction and pointing to conflicts between Canadian authorities and communities over justice.

In 2023, The Canadian Press reported the federal government’s primary issue with First Nations policing was whether or not they should develop a program or simply offload the responsibility for policing to First Nations (as was done — with very mixed results — with child welfare).

IN PICTURES

Indigenous people shoot arrows at police officers near the entrance of U.S embassy during a protest demanding action from President Gustavo Petro's government on social, environmental and security issues in Bogota, Colombia on Oct. 17, 2025. (Fernando Vergara / The Associated Press files)

Indigenous people shoot arrows at police officers near the entrance of U.S embassy during a protest demanding action from President Gustavo Petro’s government on social, environmental and security issues in Bogota, Colombia on Oct. 17, 2025. (Fernando Vergara / The Associated Press files)

RECONCILI-ACTION OF THE WEEK

Every week I highlight an action, moment, or milestone forwarding reconciliation, illustrating how far Canada has come — and how far the country has yet to go.

This week’s reconciliaction is for the provincial government of Manitoba.

Advanced Education and Training Minister Renée Cable announced $4.5 million in funding for the University of Winnipeg and the University College of the North to create bachelor degrees in Indigenous languages.

Owing to decades of policies and practices that undermined and attacked Indigenous language use, many Indigenous languages are dwindling in speakers and some already have no speakers left.

Focused on developing fluency and language educators, U of W will focus on Anishinaabemowin, or the Ojibwa language, and UCN will focus on Cree. Programming in both languages and others is already offered at the University of Manitoba.

A focus on saving Indigenous languages is quickly becoming part of Premier Wab Kinew’s legacy.

After launching a pilot project to translate legislative proceedings into one of the province’s seven Indigenous languages, the Kinew government implemented changes to Manitoba’s Public Schools Act so it now places Ojibwa, Cree and others in the company of Canada’s official languages in the kindergarten-to-Grade-12 system.

 
 

Advertisement

 

WHAT I'VE BEEN WORKING ON

Niigaan Sinclair:

Never-ending trauma takes toll on Manitoba First Nations

What would it be like to live in a perpetual state of trauma? Trauma, according to numerous psychiatrists, doctors and scientists, is like memory. Caused by singular or multiple events of pain and suf... Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

Proposed status legislation an ambitious attempt to right Indian Act’s historical wrongs

Imagine if the United States had the power to determine Canadian citizenship. It would mean American lawmakers, American judges and American voters would be able to dictate who is and who is not a Can... Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

Taglines aside, First Nations investment could nearly double Canada’s economy

Canada’s Indigenous services minister had a startling response in explaining why First Nations infrastructure projects, such as nursing stations and broadband internet, don’t qualify as “projects of the national interest.” Read More

 
 
 

LOCAL NEWS

Kevin Rollason:

Wildlife federation asks court to remove blockade after First Nation turns hunter away

The Manitoba Wildlife Federation is turning to the courts after a blockade prevented a Manitoba hunter from passing through a First Nations community last month. The province’s largest hunting organiz... Read More

 

Tyler Searle:

Three charged in slaying of Manitoba Indigenous woman who went missing in 2020

Mounties arrest and charge three men in the death of a Tootinaowaziibeeng Treaty Reserve mother who vanished more than five years ago. Read More

 

Aaron Epp:

Common thread weaves through love, loss, healing

Shahina Siddiqui has trouble recalling the exact date — grief will do that — but she knows Riaz, her eldest son, died in the month of November. Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

U of W emphasizes revitalizing downtown

The University of Winnipeg has charted a course for the next five years that leans heavily on its position as a member of the downtown community. A business professor, physics researcher, Indigenous s... Read More

 

Marsha McLeod:

U of M Indigenous studies department reaches milestone

It was a day of celebration and of recognition Wednesday, as the University of Manitoba Indigenous studies department marked a half-century of scholarship, honouring decades of students and scholars i... Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

Children’s advocate calls for ‘urgent action’ after province fell short on wildfire emergency preparedness

The Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth is calling on the province to do more to protect the educational rights, and lungs, of young wildfire evacuees. Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

School renaming ‘process that requires care’

Truth, home, nature vie to replace Wolseley Read More

 

Kevin Rollason:

First Nation lifts member’s five-year banishment, but he’s taking band council to court

A Manitoba father of five who was banished from his northern First Nation for resisting a police officer is being allowed to return home four years and seven months early. Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation’... Read More

 
 

ARTS & LIFE

Governor General’s literary short list includes vermette, Edwards

Winnipeg author katherena vermette has made the five-book short list for the 2025 Governor General’s Literary Awards for fiction for her novel Real Ones. Buy on mcnallyrobinson.com Published in Septem... Read More

 

Ben Sigurdson:

Local author wins Dafoe book prize

Winnipeg author and historian Gerald Friesen has won the 2025 J.W. Dafoe Book Prize for his biography The Honourable John Norquay: Indigenous Premier, Canadian Statesman. Read More

 
 

OPINION

Sonya Ballantyne:

Portage Place of old an oasis for music-loving rez girl

As the structure surrounding the iconic clocktower at Portage Place came down on Wednesday as part of True North’s plans to redevelop the property, I saw a flurry of social media posts from Indigenous friends honouring their memories of the downtown mall. Read More

 

Tom Brodbeck:

Province makes powerful investment in righting devastating wrong in Canada’s history

For more than a century, governments in Canada worked deliberately and systematically to erase Indigenous languages. Through residential schools and the federal Indian Act, the goal was not only to ex... Read More

 
 

FROM FURTHER AFIELD

 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app