Retention ponds loaded with algae Province orders city to stop using herbicide By: Jura McIlraith Posted: 5:39 PM CDT Tuesday, Jul. 30, 2024

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 30/07/2024 (775 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Retention ponds around Winnipeg are packed with algae and murkier than usual this summer after the city stopped using a previously approved herbicide to clean the man-made bodies of water.

Diquat, known by the brand name Reward, is a common aquatic herbicide used by municipalities to limit plant growth in retention ponds. The product has been registered for use in Canada since 2000.

But a discrepancy in the product’s label was reported to the province earlier this year. An inquiry found Reward is authorized only for the treatment of aquatic invasive species, and the city’s licence to use it was revoked in the spring.

“We were only made aware of the issue when our licence was changed,” a city spokesperson said Tuesday.

The manufacturer’s product label indicates it can be used in open bodies of water — including retention ponds — that drain into water where fish live.

“We were only made aware of the issue when our licence was changed.”–City spokesperson

However, the federal Fisheries Act does not allow chemicals to be used in water where fish live unless it’s specifically applied to control aquatic invasive species, a provincial spokesperson told the Free Press Tuesday.

It is unclear who brought the issue to the province’s attention.

One Whyte Ridge resident said he’s noticed a difference in the amount of algae in the pond near his home.

“The algae in some years is quite a bit worse than other years,” said Larry Rigaux, who has lived in the neighbourhood for 24 years. “This is one of the bad years. It seems to be evident across the whole (pond)… it started several weeks ago and it’s still building up, I think.”

Rigaux’s home is on Georgetown Drive, which runs along one of two retention ponds in the area. The other is located near Scurfield Park.

Rigaux, who is in his 80s, said he still sees ducks and other waterfowl swimming in the pond, but the surface is “quite covered” with algae.

Several people in the community have talked to him about the amount of vegetation growing in the water, he said.

“It’s quite unsightly,” he said. “It’s not the end of the world but it would be nice to have a clear pond.”

Chemical vegetation control in Winnipeg retention ponds began in 1989, with different chemicals used over the years.

The city spokesperson said the province has confirmed it will not approve the use of any chemical for vegetation control in the ponds.

When used correctly, diquat does not impact human health, said Mark Hanson, a University of Manitoba professor and the Environment and Geography department head.

“If applied properly, diquat does not pose any undue risk to wildlife or aquatic organisms,” he said.

Herbicides can be safe, effective and economical in controlling nuisance plants, Hanson said, adding mechanical and physical removal are alternative methods of removing aquatic plants.

The city regularly monitors the retention ponds during the summer and, depending on the amount and type of vegetation in the water, will hire a contractor to physically clear them.

There are 195 retention ponds in Winnipeg, 117 of which are owned by the city.

Once removed, the plants are taken to Brady Road Resource Management Facility and composted.

Retention ponds collect and store runoff to prevent the city’s sewer system from being overloaded and allow for water fluctuations during snow melt or heavy rains. They also naturally filter out things such as fertilizers, oils, street salt and animal waste from runoff before it goes into other waterways.

jura.mcilraith@freepress.mb.ca