Brent Bellamy

Brent Bellamy

Columnist

Brent Bellamy is senior design architect for Number Ten Architectural Group.

Recent articles by Brent Bellamy

Need more congestion? Route 90 plan is the $500-M ticket

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Need more congestion? Route 90 plan is the $500-M ticket

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, May. 23, 2023

The projected cost of the city’s plan to widen Route 90 is equivalent to a 6.9 per cent property tax increase for every Winnipeg homeowner. It will take 30 years for Winnipeg taxpayers to pay off the new road, and in the long run, traffic congestion will get worse.

The City of Winnipeg is currently asking for public feedback on a new design for widening Kenaston Boulevard between Ness and Taylor avenues, including related sewer upgrades and an expansion of the St. James Bridge. The city is hoping that other levels of government will share the cost, but Ottawa has already rejected applications twice before, in 2015 and 2018, and the province’s Multi-Year Infrastructure Investment Strategy makes no mention of the project. This likely leaves Winnipeg taxpayers to foot the bill on their own.

The cost of widening Kenaston is typically reported to be $500 million, but a 2019 city document, Unfunded Major Capital Projects Detail, provides a more accurate picture of the total costs. Using the $500 million construction value, it projects that when borrowing and operating costs are included, the project will require annual payments of $38.7 million, (6.9 per cent of the city’s operating budget) amortized over 30 years.

This represents a true project cost of $1.2 billion, and is predicated on construction values not increasing further, having already risen steadily from $129 million in 2009, to $375 million in 2015 and $450 million in 2018.

Read
Tuesday, May. 23, 2023

CITY OF WINNIPEG

The projected cost of the city’s plan to widen Route 90 is equivalent to a 6.9 per cent property tax increase for every Winnipeg homeowner.

Portage and Main has to be people-friendly

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Portage and Main has to be people-friendly

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 1, 2023

Is it too soon? Can we talk about Portage and Main again? It’s been almost five years. The vote was clear, but 2018 feels like a different lifetime, doesn’t it? We’ve been through a lot since then, and a lot has changed.

Read
Monday, May. 1, 2023

Ruth Bonneville / Free Press files

Winter shouldn’t translate to a lower quality of life

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Winter shouldn’t translate to a lower quality of life

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 10, 2023

Falling is the leading cause of injury-related hospitalizations in Winnipeg, and more than one-third of the province’s direct health-care costs are accounted for by injuries related to falls.

Read
Monday, Apr. 10, 2023

MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Brian Spottar goes for a walk on slushy, icy sidewalks in River Heights on Monday, April 10, 2023. For Brent Bellamy story. Winnipeg Free Press 2023.

New life breathed into Carnegie Library

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

New life breathed into Carnegie Library

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 20, 2023

The City of Winnipeg Archives is finally getting a new home, after a decade as a nomad in various warehouses across the city. Council is set to approve $12.6 million in funding to transform the Carnegie Library on William Avenue into a state-of-the-art archives facility.

Read
Monday, Mar. 20, 2023

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press

The Carnegie Library on William Avenue was listed in 2018 as one of Canada’s most endangered historic sites.

Walkable cities become grist for conspiracy mill

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Walkable cities become grist for conspiracy mill

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Feb. 28, 2023

Being a city planner might sound like a mundane job, plodding through zoning regulations that read like riddles written by Gollum from Lord of the Rings. But it can be a polarizing profession that evokes high emotions from citizens opposing change in their neighbourhood or reacting to the very mention of the words “bike lane.”

Read
Tuesday, Feb. 28, 2023

Brent Bellamy photo

The intersection of Lilac Street and Corydon Avenue, an example of a traditional ‘15-minute neighbourhood’ in Winnipeg.

Reclaiming the spirit of the shopping mall

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Reclaiming the spirit of the shopping mall

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 6, 2023

The origin of the North American shopping mall is a story of irony and frustration that sent an architect back to Europe resenting what his idea had become.

Read
Monday, Feb. 6, 2023

This artist’s rendering shows the re-envisioned CF Polo Park mall with surrounding residential development. (Supplied / Shindico)

Arts can lead in downtown renewal

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Arts can lead in downtown renewal

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 16, 2023

Downtown is the cultural and economic engine of our city. It defines Winnipeg’s image and reputation, locally and abroad.

Read
Monday, Jan. 16, 2023

Winnipeg’s vibrant arts and culture sector could be a major motivating force in revitalizing the city’s downtown. (Supplied / Exhange District BIZ)

A chance to reimagine road safety

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

A chance to reimagine road safety

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 19, 2022

Pedestrian and cyclist fatalities are not inevitable, but the solution requires a cultural shift in the way planners, policy-makers and the public think about streets and how we use them.

Read
Monday, Dec. 19, 2022

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO

Traffic-flow-focused thoroughfares such as Osborne Street are designed in a way that makes motor-vehicle collisions with cyclists and pedestrians inevitable.

Board impairs civic decision-making

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Board impairs civic decision-making

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 28, 2022

When Manitoba’s provincial government passed Bill 37 last year, it was lost in the headlines of a global pandemic, but its potential impact on the city of Winnipeg was not lost on then-mayor Brian Bowman.

Read
Monday, Nov. 28, 2022

SUPPLIED IMAGE

Aerial image shows the proposed site of an eight-storey, 55-plus apartment building, which received civic zoning approval but was rejected by the provincially appointed municipal board.

Gaboury favoured organic, regionalist style

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Gaboury favoured organic, regionalist style

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 7, 2022

When Étienne Gaboury died a few weeks ago at the age of 92, Manitoba lost one of its most prominent, most beloved, and arguably its greatest architect.

Read
Monday, Nov. 7, 2022

Brent Bellamy photo

The Esplanade Riel was Étienne Gaboury’s final prominent commission.

A new mayor and council need visionary city-building policies to fix Winnipeg's challenges

Brent Bellamy 12 minute read Preview

A new mayor and council need visionary city-building policies to fix Winnipeg's challenges

Brent Bellamy 12 minute read Wednesday, Oct. 12, 2022

The approaching election is coming at a time when the world seems filled with uncertainty. The future feels unpredictable and our path forward less defined. In the past, civic elections have often been distilled down to police, pipes and pavement, but today we are facing broader city-building conversations. Issues that have been building for many years are converging with more recent challenges to create obstacles of generational impact. As we vote, now more than ever, we must remember that the decisions we make today will define the city we pass on to our children.

Read
Wednesday, Oct. 12, 2022

MIKE SUDOMA / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES.

The pre-COVID momentum of downtown growth and renewal has been set back decades, with major streets, such as Portage Avenue, now lined with hollowed-out buildings and vacant storefronts.

Blank walls diminish pedestrian experience

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Blank walls diminish pedestrian experience

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 12, 2022

The cannabis shop has quickly replaced the corner store as a symbol of Canadian neighbourhoods. Only four years since legalization, cannabis storefronts have become pervasive fixtures on city streets, with more than 3,200 stores now open across the country, an increase of about 1,400 over last year.

Read
Monday, Sep. 12, 2022

Brent Bellamy photo

Blanked-out windows on a Winnipeg cannabis shop create a bleak exterior that discourages pedestrian activity.

The time is right for LRT transition

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

The time is right for LRT transition

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 22, 2022

Winnipeg was built on light rail transit. At its peak, 400 streetcars rode 200 kilometres of track, carrying 60 million riders per year. And almost immediately after the streetcars were replaced with buses in 1955, the debate began over bringing back light rail transit (LRT).

Read
Monday, Aug. 22, 2022

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO

Riders board the C-train light rail in Calgary. That city, like Edmonton and Kitchener/Waterloo, implemented its first LRT lines with a population of about half a million, significantly less than the 800,000 people in Winnipeg today.

Moving forward requires looking back

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Moving forward requires looking back

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Sunday, Jul. 24, 2022

For its first century, downtown Winnipeg was a vibrant and diverse urban neighbourhood. Streets were lined with elegant red-brick apartment buildings, terrace housing and grand Victorian homes. Canopies of elm trees shaded the sidewalks of a neighbourhood peppered with schools, corner stores, churches and parks.

Read
Sunday, Jul. 24, 2022

(Stationpoint Photographic) Innovative redevelopment of 433 Main St. turned an underused 1970s office building into a vibrant mixed-use property that combines retail, office space and rental apartments.

Bold thinking created affordable housing

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Bold thinking created affordable housing

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 13, 2022

In the late 1940s, Canada’s post-war economy was booming, but corresponding global supply-chain disruptions, scarcity of skilled labour and material shortages resulted in skyrocketing inflation. Competition for new housing drove the real-estate market to record highs, leaving low- and middle-income tenants experiencing severe housing need across the country.

These challenges are familiar in our current post-pandemic world, and the bold action taken by the federal government back then provides a provocative point of discussion for today.

As the Second World War began, the country experienced a significant wave of urban migration, with servicemen and war workers moving to cities to be near military bases and industrial employment. This created high demand for affordable urban housing.

The federal government responded to this immediate need by creating Wartime Housing Limited, a Crown corporation that participated directly in the residential construction industry, building thousands of small, wood-framed houses across the country for military and trade workers participating in the war effort.

Read
Monday, Jun. 13, 2022

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
A row of similar structures in Elmwood stands as an example of the ‘strawberry box houses’ constructed by the Crown corporation known as Wartime Housing Limited.

More city than we can pay for

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

More city than we can pay for

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 16, 2022

As people in Winnipeg emerged from a long, frigid and snowy winter, they found a city with roads bearing a striking resemblance to the surface of the moon. This, despite the City of Winnipeg having had its highest road renewal budget in history for each of the last three years. With drought followed by flood, freezing followed by thaw, Manitoba gumbo has been having its way with our city’s roads.

We can’t change the weather, or the soil, and significantly raising taxes wouldn’t be popular, so how will we ever manage our worsening pothole problem? There is one straightforward answer — build fewer roads and get more people to live on the ones we already have. The solution to managing potholes is simple math that reads like a Grade 9 pop quiz.

If 10 taxpayers live on a street that is one kilometre long, each one pays to maintain 100 metres of road. If 10 taxpayers live on a street that is one and a half kilometres long, each one pays to maintain 150 meters of road. Every tax dollar being stretched more thinly by lower density means reduced maintenance and more potholes. It’s a simplistic example, but this is precisely what has happened in Winnipeg, and in most sprawling North American cities, over the last 50 years.

Since the 1970s, Winnipeg’s low-density, suburban growth patterns have resulted in the population increasing by 37 per cent while the built area of the city has almost doubled. Each taxpayer today is responsible for about 40 per cent more land area and its corresponding infrastructure. Looking at infrastructure such as water pipes, according to the city, each Winnipegger today is responsible for nearly 2.5 times more length of pipe than they were in the 1940s, 70 per cent more than in the 1970s.

Read
Monday, May. 16, 2022

Potholes in Wolseley in May (Brent Bellamy photo)
Brent Bellamy photo
The inability to maintain streets properly is the result of low-density suburban growth patterns that require expensive new infrastructure on the edges of the city.

EVs not a ‘silver bullet’ solution

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

EVs not a ‘silver bullet’ solution

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 25, 2022

As governments across the world struggle to meet quickly approaching climate change targets, electric vehicles have begun to find their way into the spotlight. The “Build Back Better” plan in the U.S. and Canada’s 2022 federal budget both focus efforts to decarbonize the transportation sector on incentivizing “zero-emission vehicles” (ZEVs).

Transportation is Canada’s second largest source of GHG emissions, responsible for 25 per cent of the country’s total. In cities such as Winnipeg, vehicle tailpipes are the source of half of all emissions.

It is also clear, however, that electric vehicles are not an “easy button” solution to climate change. A 2,000-kilogram machine transporting an 80-kilogram human cargo for almost every trip made outside of the home is not a sustainable solution, regardless of the machine’s powerplant.

There are many studies that try to quantify ZEVs’ emissions, and the consistent conclusion is that no car is truly a zero-emission vehicle. For a more complete picture, the current focus on tailpipe emissions must be broadened to include the carbon footprint of all facets of a vehicle’s life cycle.

Read
Monday, Apr. 25, 2022

Sean Gallup / Getty Images / TNS FILES
The transition to electric vehicles is only one step in the necessary shift toward alternative modes of transportation.

Selkirk a model of progressive planning

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Selkirk a model of progressive planning

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 28, 2022

Just north of Lower Fort Garry, stretching along the banks of the Red River, is Selkirk. A city with about 10,000 residents, the seventh-largest in the province, it has in the past been largely known for its catfish and its steel mill. Today, however, a new image is being crafted. Through several innovative and forward-thinking planning policies, Selkirk is beginning to stake a claim as the most progressive city in Manitoba.

About a decade ago, Selkirk started down its path of city-building focused on social, economic and environmental sustainability when a group of dedicated residents and political leaders identified the need for more accessible and inclusive mobility options in their city. After years of hard work, Selkirk became only the fourth city in Manitoba to introduce a public transit system. Operating as a non-profit community organization, Selkirk Transit today provides equitable and sustainable transportation.

Since conquering the challenge of public transit, the City of Selkirk has never looked back. In recent years, a long list of strategic plans has been introduced in Selkirk, informing everything from climate adaptation to downtown renewal, recreation and economic growth.

Last year, a five-year Active Transportation Strategy was introduced, building on the sustainable mobility that public transit began. The strategy is a comprehensive action plan that will connect neighbourhoods to downtown, recreational facilities, schools, employment and shopping, through walking, biking and accessible transportation like scooters and wheelchairs.

Read
Monday, Mar. 28, 2022

Scatliff + Miller + Murray main street of the West End Mixed-Use Village. (Supplied)
Graphic by Scatliff + Miller + Murray
Artist’s conception shows plan for Selkirk’s West End Mixed-Use Village, a neighbourhood of 5,000 homes that would double the city’s current population.

Ukrainian influences are everywhere

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Ukrainian influences are everywhere

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 7, 2022

In the face of unspeakable adversity, the world is currently witnessing the resilient and courageous character of the Ukrainian people.

A century ago, these traits would prove vital for the thousands of hard-working peasant farmers who came to the inhospitable Canadian west in search of a new beginning. As partners in a shared story, we on the Prairies have forged a deep connection with the people of Ukraine.

Today, this legacy shapes our towns and cities, physically manifested most prominently through Ukrainian religious architecture that has become an intrinsic part of many communities. Drive across the Prairies between Winnipeg and Edmonton, and you’ll find the characteristic domes of Ukrainian churches piercing the sky as often as the iconic grain elevators.

When the early settlers arrived in the 1890s, a small chapel that combined local construction techniques with traditional Ukrainian shapes was often one of the first buildings to be constructed. Amazingly, three of these tiny chapels still stand in Manitoba, including St. Michael’s Church at Trembowla, near Dauphin, the oldest remaining Ukrainian church in Canada.

Read
Monday, Mar. 7, 2022

SUPPLIED
The ‘Tin Can Cathedral’ was constructed in the early 1900s using old lumber and assorted scrap materials.

Old buildings unite neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Old buildings unite neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 7, 2022

At about 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, fire alarms went off at 575 Portage Avenue. A few hours later, the sky over downtown Winnipeg was filled with black smoke as firefighters battled through frigid temperatures to contain a massive blaze.

The familiar little building that stood on the corner of Langside Street for 110 years was lost forever.

Generations of Winnipeggers passed by that building every day, but few people knew its name — the Kirkwood Block. It was a “you’d know it if you saw it” kind of place. A nice little building, with a cornice and some red brick. Older people might recall spending evenings dancing at Club Morocco upstairs. Some might remember the hobby shop at the corner. Maybe it was your neighbourhood convenience store, or your office.

The Kirkwood Block was not a prominent heritage structure. It was just a quaint old building, a little crooked and kind of falling apart, sitting on a block seemingly ready for an urban renewal scheme. A big new building could bring more residents and more jobs — the goal of any downtown plan.

Read
Monday, Feb. 7, 2022

Firefighters stand outside the ice-encrusted remains of Kirkwood Block, which was destroyed by a fire on Feb. 2. (Brent Bellamy)

Bold steps to redefine downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Bold steps to redefine downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 17, 2022

The first half of the 20th century brought war, pandemic, drought and depression, and in Winnipeg, a catastrophic flood. As cities emerged from these challenges in the 1950s, they were buoyed by the optimism of a better future and were not hesitant to make bold, forward-thinking moves for the next generation.

In 1955, fueled by the vision of Winnipeg as a modern metropolis, a public transit system that moved more than one hundred million passenger trips per year — twice what Winnipeg Transit currently carries — was completely dismantled. More than 400 streetcars were taken off the road and rails torn up to make room for a future with private automobiles and gasoline buses.

Eleven months later, the city doubled down on this vision, announcing that downtown streets would be converted to one-way circulation, accommodating through-traffic to the growing suburbs. Elm trees lining the downtown streets were cut down, boulevards were removed, sidewalks narrowed, and the streets were made wider to accommodate more cars. In the space of less than a year, downtown Winnipeg was changed forever.

Of course, we now know that the overwhelming prioritization of cars over all other modes of transportation, and the creation of a network of surface highways across downtown, would become a dagger in the heart of our once-bustling city centre. The fearless implementation of such bold and transformative ideas, however, is enviable, and almost unimaginable in today’s Winnipeg.

Read
Monday, Jan. 17, 2022

Fort Street is an example of a downtown thoroughfare that was widened and converted to one-way traffic to increase vehicle capacity, thereby diminishing the pedestrian experience. (Brent Bellamy photo)

Perfect storm of construction disruption

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Perfect storm of construction disruption

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 27, 2021

Over the past two years, the COVID-19 pandemic has introduced several new expressions into our everyday vocabulary. We are learning the Greek alphabet (Alpha, Delta, Omicron), and terms such as herd immunity, vaccine efficacy and flattening the curve have become part of regular conversation.

And more recently, we have been learning a lot about the global supply chain.

We live in a highly connected world. The homes we live in, the smartphones in our pockets and the cars we drive are the product of labour and materials brought together from around the world, through an interconnected web called the global supply chain.

The global pandemic has exposed the fragility and interdependence of the connections in this web, and the construction industry has been on the leading edge of its challenges.

Read
Monday, Dec. 27, 2021

(Brent Bellamy photo)
This residential building under construction in St. Boniface is an example of a project that changed from wood studs to steel studs in response to fluctuating material costs caused by supply-chain disruption.

A chance to redefine transportation

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

A chance to redefine transportation

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 29, 2021

Over the next two weeks, the City of Winnipeg is looking for public feedback on Transportation Master Plan: 2050, a 30-year blueprint to guide development of Winnipeg’s transportation network.

In the past, transportation planning has focused primarily on strategies to move cars, but today it’s seen as a central tool for building healthy, sustainable and prosperous communities. Urban mobility is fundamental to economic viability, environmental sustainability and social equity, making Transportation Master Plan: 2050 a key document for the city.

The first step in developing a new transportation strategy will be to learn from the past and accept that current economic challenges, including Winnipeg’s $3 billion infrastructure deficit for roads and bridges, are largely the result of previous planning decisions.

We have spent decades building a city almost singularly focused on automobile transportation, resulting in a sprawling, low-density urban form that has become economically unsustainable. Despite record-breaking road maintenance spending, our current pace of renewal means new roads built today won’t be replaced for more than 100 years.

Read
Monday, Nov. 29, 2021

Manitoba vehicle owners should be getting a bigger rebate from MPI, says the Consumers' Association of Canada (Manitoba). (Mike Sudoma / Winnipeg Free Press files)

Designing pedestrian promenade

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Designing pedestrian promenade

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 8, 2021

As we emerge from a global pandemic and move into the headwinds of a global climate crisis, change has become the only certainty for the world’s cities. Civic leadership that embraces bold ideas to overcome these evolving challenges, specifically in highly impacted downtown areas, will find the most success in the future.

Unveiled last year, but somewhat lost in the headlines of the pandemic, the new Winnipeg Transit Master Plan presents the city with an opportunity to lead this urban evolution. By marrying transit planning with creative urban design, we can leverage transit investment to create generational change in downtown Winnipeg.

There are three important downtown placemaking opportunities identified in the new plan. Major rapid transit stations will be built at Portage and Main and in old Union Station, establishing two significant nodes of activity. These can be leveraged through creative planning to create a gravity that attracts retail, housing and cultural amenities to support new and existing downtown residential neighbourhoods.

A third impactful move, the closing of the Graham Avenue Transit Mall, will create a kilometre-long opportunity to dream. With buses gone, and cars having been removed 30 years ago, Graham Avenue will become a blank slate upon which we can draw our vision for the future.

Read
Monday, Nov. 8, 2021

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Calgary’s Stephen Avenue, closed to vehicles in 1973, abounds with shops and restaurants, creating an important critical mass of activity.

Car co-op a progressive success story

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Car co-op a progressive success story

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 12, 2021

Your car is likely your second largest household expense, and studies show that it’s probably parked 95 per cent of the time. The typical Canadian vehicle is driven for just over one hour per day on average, and according to the Canadian Automobile Association, the SUV that most people drive for that time costs an average of $33 per day to own, with all expenses included.

Imagine if you could, sharing a car with your neighbours, and only paying for it when you are actually using it. No more loan payments, or trips to the mechanic, and as a bonus you would be doing something good for the environment.

Ten years ago, this was the dream for a small group of people in Winnipeg who saw the growing car-sharing trend in larger cities across the world and wondered if it could work here. The group organized, found 40 people to pay $500 membership deposits and, in June 2011, Peg City Car Co-op was born. The idea started small, with three cars in Osborne Village; keys were stored in lockboxes and transactions recorded on paper.

As Peg City celebrates its 10th anniversary, it has grown to more than 2,000 members with 60 vehicles parked across 11 central neighbourhoods, and has hopes of growing to 100 vehicles in 2023. Members can now conveniently make bookings online up to a year in advance, for as little as an hour at a time, and they are automatically billed for their time and distance.

Read
Tuesday, Oct. 12, 2021

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Peg City Car Co-op is a Winnipeg success story, growing to 60 vehicles and more than 2,000 members in just 10 years.

Lifestyle expectations influence housing

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Lifestyle expectations influence housing

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 20, 2021

With the COVID-19 pandemic disrupting global supply chains, and consumer demand rising as the economy rebounds, inflation rates are being pushed to their highest levels in almost 20 years. The federal election campaign has seen affordability emerge as a central issue concerning Canadians, and with home prices skyrocketing across the country, much of the discussion has naturally centred on housing.

Any solution to what is being called Canada’s housing crisis will require close examination of both housing and transportation. These two key drivers of inflation are intrinsically linked, and together represent 50 per cent of Canadian household spending.

Comparisons are often made between the baby-boomer generation and millennials to demonstrate how today’s cost of living has increased. Relative to income growth, average house values, the purchase price of a vehicle and the cost of a litre of gasoline have all more than doubled since the 1970s. These are striking increases, but looking more closely, our lifestyle expectations may be having an even greater impact.

Since 1975, the average size of a new home in Canada has doubled, from 1,050 square feet to 2,100 square feet, despite today’s average household size being one person less. Neighbourhoods in the 1970s were typically 30 per cent more dense than today, with fewer peripheral suburbs requiring long driving distances.

Read
Monday, Sep. 20, 2021

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Development such as basement suites or laneway housing — sometimes referred to as ‘granny flats’ — gently increases neighbourhood density while creating affordable housing options.

An opportunity to re-imagine downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

An opportunity to re-imagine downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Aug. 3, 2021

The pandemic has been devastating for downtown Winnipeg. An abundance of “For Lease” signs in storefront windows has provided an intuitive glimpse, but a new report titled “State of Downtown: The impact of the pandemic to date” has quantified the profound challenges facing the economic, social and cultural heart of our city.

With the exodus of students and office workers, storefront businesses downtown have lost an average of $2 million per week in gross revenue since the pandemic began. This has led to more than 2,000 people losing their jobs and almost 50 storefront businesses permanently closing. The conference, hotel, hospitality, and arts and culture industries saw devastating declines, and more than 1.5 million square feet of office space are now vacant.

The pandemic has also exacerbated long-standing challenges of poverty and homelessness, with social agencies struggling to meet the needs of downtown’s vulnerable population.

The report paints a dire image, but we have been here before. Twenty years ago, downtown Winnipeg was in a similar situation. Population was at an all-time low as people moved to the suburbs, retail shops relocated from Portage Avenue to distant shopping malls, and office space was in decline. In the face of this challenge, government and private industry came together to rebuild downtown.

Read
Tuesday, Aug. 3, 2021

Brent Bellamy PHOTO
The exodus of downtown workers during the pandemic might create longer-term opportunities to re-imagine and redevelop Winnipeg’s commercial and cultural core.

Design must account for climate change

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Design must account for climate change

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 12, 2021

I don’t often write about personal experiences, but the last few weeks have been impactful. We all learned the new phrase “heat dome” and watched temperatures in the western half of the continent skyrocket to historic levels. The unrelenting heat is believed to have killed as many as 500 people in the province of British Columbia alone, along with millions of marine animals along Canada’s Pacific coast.

The small village of Lytton, B.C., recorded the highest temperature ever seen in Canada on three consecutive days, and on the fourth day, it was destroyed by wildfire.

As this climate-change-driven disaster unfolded across the West, I spent the week helping a client apply for a federal government green building grant through Infrastructure Canada. Called the Green and Inclusive Community Buildings Program, it asked for many of the typical requirements — energy-use reductions, lowered greenhouse-gas emissions targets — but the last half of the application focused on how the project will be resilient, how it will survive, in the face of the climate reality.

No longer is sustainability solely about carbon reduction to prevent or mitigate climate change; it is now also focused on adapting to what is already here and what is unavoidably coming toward us. It was a powerful realization.

Read
Monday, Jul. 12, 2021

Brent Bellamy photo
Green roofs, such as the one on the Qualico Family Centre in Assiniboine Park, can help to reduce energy use, moderate temperatures and improve air quality.

Reimagining Wellington Crescent

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Reimagining Wellington Crescent

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 21, 2021

“We heard birds” exclaimed Anne Hidalgo, the mayor of Paris, France, in an interview with Time magazine last summer. She was describing her city, all cities, during the first COVID-19 lockdowns, when, with fewer people driving, we were provided a glimpse into what the future of cities could be. She vowed that Paris would not return to a pre-pandemic world, pledging to learn from the devastating challenges of the last year and emerge as a more socially equitable, environmentally sustainable, cleaner, healthier and happier city.

The changes that have swept across Paris since have been far-reaching and impactful, driven by a policy framework called the “la ville du quart d’heure,” or the “15-minute city.” The strategy focuses on building more diverse, integrated, and mixed-use neighbourhoods that provide residents access to all of life’s core services and amenities, within a 15-minute walk, bike or transit ride. Designing communities with integrated supports such as shops, restaurants, gyms, groceries, offices, schools and parks is in direct contrast to most modern neighbourhoods, where housing is separated by a vehicle trip from employment, shopping, entertainment and industry.

The pandemic has forced many people to work from home and spend more time in their own neighbourhoods. The 15-minute city concept builds on this evolving social and employment landscape, offering an opportunity to improve local economies and deliver lasting health, equity and environmental benefits.

In Paris, incentives are being provided to support development of small businesses and community facilities in targeted areas, emphasizing equal access to services, amenities and green space that strengthen neighbourhoods and actively reduce social divides and inequalities. A new policy has been developed to create pockets of “urban forest” and community gardens for local urban agriculture, in school yards, parks, plazas and other public spaces like city-owned surface parking lots.

Read
Monday, Jun. 21, 2021

JOHN WOODS / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
A person in a wheelchair makes their way down Wellington Crescent alongside two cyclists earlier this month. (John Woods / Winnipeg Free press files)

Alberta cities excel in urban change

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Alberta cities excel in urban change

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 31, 2021

For many years, the fast-growing cities of Calgary and Edmonton have been the stereotype for sprawling, car-dominant urban planning, but recently they have begun to shed that image and are in many ways becoming North American leaders in progressive urban design and city building policy. Other cities might take note.

Private vehicles have shaped our cities more than anything else over the last century, but the environmental, economic, urban quality and social equity impacts of cars has progressive cities looking to diversify mobility options. Calgary and Edmonton both made the investment in light rail transit more than 40 years ago, when they had less than two-thirds of Winnipeg’s current population.

Today, broad public support is fuelling transit investment and expansion in both cities. Backed with significant federal funding available to all cities, current construction of the Valley Line in Edmonton will more than double the city’s 24-kilometre-long LRT system by 2026, and Calgary will soon begin construction on the 20-kilometer-long Green Line, adding to its current 60 kilometres of rail transit. In Calgary, 45 per cent of people who work downtown commute by train. The network is used by more than 300,000 people per day, making it one of the busiest LRT systems in North America, second only to Guadalajara, Mexico.

Calgary has also demonstrated leadership in active transportation development. In 2014, the city installed a complete, temporary downtown grid of protected bike lanes, all at once. The network has since been made permanent and the results have been significant, with more than 18,000 cyclists entering or leaving downtown daily, an increase of more than 300 per cent over 20 years.

Read
Monday, May. 31, 2021

City of Edmonton PHOTO
Edmonton plans to double its 24-kilometre Light Rail Transit system by 2026, thanks partly to federal funding.

Infill guidelines offer prudent way forward

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Infill guidelines offer prudent way forward

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 3, 2021

The average cost of a detached single-family home in Winnipeg is $384,773, an increase of almost 20 per cent over last year. More than 40 per cent of Winnipeg’s population does not live in a house, and with demographics aging, ownership costs rising and new lifestyle preferences emerging, that proportion is growing.

Less than 30 per cent of all new homes being constructed today are detached, single-family structures. In the year 2000, that number was almost 90 per cent.

Despite these trends, the priorities of those with the means and desire to purchase a house dominate how we build our neighbourhoods. The word “condo” is used as a pejorative, renters are often characterized as less important members of the community, and when anything more than a new house is being proposed, Facebook groups rally to protect the “character’ of their neighbourhood.

Walk through the old neighbourhoods in Fort Rouge, however, and you will see small apartment blocks, new and old, sitting comfortably on tree-lined residential streets. Three-storey houses, now broken into multiple apartments, have been neighbours with small bungalows for more than a century, and duplexes go unnoticed in the middle of a block.

Read
Monday, May. 3, 2021

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
A tree-lined street in Fort Rouge shows how different housing styles can comfortably coexist.

Research supports reduced-speed initiative

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Research supports reduced-speed initiative

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 12, 2021

Over the last 10 years, six million vehicles have been added to Canadian roads, an increase of almost 20 per cent. Since the 1990s, the average vehicle horsepower has almost doubled, average vehicle weight has increased by 26 per cent, cars are 17 per cent larger and 80 per cent of vehicles sold in Canada today are trucks and SUVs.

In Manitoba, more vehicles and larger, faster vehicles has led to a 50 per cent increase in collisions resulting in injury during the past decade. On Winnipeg streets in 2019, the last available statistics, every second day a pedestrian or cyclist was struck and injured by a driver seriously enough to be reported. Every third day a pedestrian or cyclist was sent to hospital, and almost once a month one was killed.

Across the country, nearly one out of every five people killed or seriously injured in vehicle collisions is not in a vehicle.

All these statistics are inspiring a wave of change across Canada, as cities are one by one lowering speed limits on residential streets to make neighbourhoods safer for all road users, and more comfortable for pedestrians and cyclists.

Read
Monday, Apr. 12, 2021

Brent Bellamy
Support is growing for reduced speed limits on residential streets.

Transit plan should spark rapid change

Brent Bellamy   5 minute read Preview

Transit plan should spark rapid change

Brent Bellamy   5 minute read Monday, Mar. 15, 2021

Winnipeg, like most Canadian cities, was built around public transit. At one time, 400 streetcars rolled along neighbourhood streets, connected in an efficient grid that allowed riders to jump on and off as they headed in different directions to different destinations.

About 50 years ago, we began building cities around cars. Instead of extending the street grids as the city grew, isolated new subdivisions were built, connected by highways, with winding boulevards and cul-de-sac streets. Public transit followed this growth pattern by incrementally extending existing lines into these new areas. Routes became long, confusing and circuitous, service became inconvenient and less frequent, and ridership dropped.

Winnipeg Transit’s new 25-year master plan hopes to change this by taking a long-overdue step back and proposing a complete re-think of how public transit operates across the city. The plan proposes that Winnipeg join a growing list of cities that are implementing what is known as a “high frequency transit model” focused more on service improvements to grow ridership than on geographic coverage.

The system will be less centred on downtown commuting and more on the ability to use transit for daily trips of all kinds.

Read
Monday, Mar. 15, 2021

Brent Bellamy PHOTO
Winnipeg’s new Transit master plan offers an opportunity for a complete overhaul of how public transit operates.

‘Abilities Village’ plan filled with possibility

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

‘Abilities Village’ plan filled with possibility

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 22, 2021

Provencher Boulevard has a long history as the commercial heart of St. Boniface and Winnipeg’s francophone community. With wide sidewalks, a few historic buildings and local shops, it has the bones to be an active pedestrian street and centre of community life.

Unfortunately, as a busy truck route and commuting thoroughfare, Provencher is challenged to be a welcoming place for a shopping stroll or break on a sidewalk patio. Several surface parking lots and vacant properties further diminish the pedestrian experience, and a low population density in the surrounding neighbourhood offers an insufficient base to support a vibrant commercial street.

The neighbourhood plan for St. Boniface and Provencher Boulevard looks to address some of these issues by supporting development of higher-density and more diverse housing options, encouraging good urban design that is pedestrian focused, enhancing existing parks and celebrating the neighbourhood’s cultural assets.

The City of Winnipeg currently owns two of these cultural assets on the street: the former St. Boniface city hall and the adjacent, long-abandoned fire hall. In November 2019, a request for proposals was issued to find a new owner for the buildings and adjacent parking lots, with the goal of leveraging them to breathe new life into Provencher Boulevard and the surrounding community.

Read
Monday, Feb. 22, 2021

IMAGE: 5468796 Architecture
The planned ‘Abilities Village’ development has the potential to revitalize and diversify a historic segment of Provencher Boulevard.

Parking minimums stifle development

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Parking minimums stifle development

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 25, 2021

For the next few weeks, the City of Winnipeg is seeking public feedback on the Winnipeg Parking Strategy, a five-year vision to manage vehicle parking across the city. It may not sound glamorous, but parking is quietly one of the most powerful forces shaping our cities, having a fundamental influence on cost of living, neighbourhood form and character, and building design.

Six months ago, Edmonton became the first major Canadian city to eliminate parking minimums for new development. The new strategy presents an opportunity for Winnipeg to follow this lead.

Parking minimums are municipal-government regulations that dictate the number of parking stalls a new development must include on its property. The ratio is derived from a decades-old formula based on building size and whether it’s a new house, apartment block, commercial building or other use. In Winnipeg, outside of downtown, 1.5 parking stalls are required for every residential unit, reduced to 1.2 in some inner-city areas.

An important shortcoming of these blanket ratios is that they do not account for variables influencing the amount of parking actually required, such as vehicle ownership in the neighbourhood, adjacent amenities, transit access, suite sizes, demographics and evolving mobility trends. Mandated parking levels have resulted in significantly more parking being built than is required.

Read
Monday, Jan. 25, 2021

Brent Bellamy photo
Older buildings on Corydon Avenue are built right to the street, creating a more pleasant pedestrian experience.

‘For lease’ signs abound downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

‘For lease’ signs abound downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 4, 2021

The year 2020 is finally in the rearview mirror. With vaccines on the way, the pandemic nightmare might soon be over, but what kind of world will we awaken to?

Many lines have been written over the past year, envisioning a world where people are permanently working from their dining-room tables, shopping is all done online, and dinner and a movie is replaced with Skip The Dishes and Home Box Office.

While it is unlikely the world will shift as much as many projections suggest, there will undoubtedly be lasting changes to our cities, with downtowns experiencing the greatest impact.

The overwhelming end of the office worker has probably been overstated, but it is likely that many people will see greater workplace flexibility. With people working even one day per week at home, this shift could have a devastating knock-on effect for downtown economies, where the influx of workers is needed to fill the office buildings, and to support local shops, restaurants and services.

Read
Monday, Jan. 4, 2021

Image by Brent Bellamy
A collage shows some of the many dozens of buildings in downtown Winnipeg that have ‘for lease’ signs, a number that has risen as the COVID-19 pandemic prompted more downtown office employees to work from home.

Bay part of city’s DNA forever

Brent Bellamy  10 minute read Preview

Bay part of city’s DNA forever

Brent Bellamy  10 minute read Monday, Dec. 7, 2020

On Nov. 18, 1926, more than 50,000 people — almost one-third of Winnipeg’s population — came out to celebrate the grand opening of the Hudson’s Bay Co.’s vast new Portage Avenue department store.

At five o’clock last Monday evening, without ceremony, the lights were turned off and the doors locked for the last time, as the grand old store quietly slipped into memory.

The Hudson’s Bay Co. opened Winnipeg’s first retail store within the stone walls of Upper Fort Garry 208 years ago and had maintained a commercial presence downtown until last week. By closing what was once the Bay’s flagship Canadian store, a unique relationship between a company and a city is lost, but HBC’s presence in downtown Winnipeg will forever be embedded in the city’s very DNA.

Evidence of the Bay’s influence in downtown can be found everywhere, even in the street names. Fort and Garry recognize the fort, Edmonton and Carlton were named after other western trading posts, and McDermot, Bannatyne, Hargrave, Donald and Smith all honour HBC employees. The Hudson’s Bay Co. affected almost every aspect of early Winnipeg, and if you know where to look, you can find its influence in the streets, buildings, and places across downtown.

Read
Monday, Dec. 7, 2020

JOHN WOODS / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS

The Hudson’s Bay store in downtown Winnipeg.

City faces limits on sewage

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

City faces limits on sewage

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2020

With recent headlines dominated by the American election and Manitoba’s COVID-19 spike, it is easy to understand how a seven-page administrative report presented last week to Winnipeg’s standing policy committee on water and waste might have slipped under the radar for most people. At the best of times, that committee rarely attracts public interest, but this report will have critical repercussions on our city for the next decade.

The simple explanation of the report’s findings is that Winnipeg’s ability to treat its sewage is quickly running out of capacity, and it will soon restrict the city’s ability to grow. The North End Sewage Treatment Plant is coming to the end of its service life, and replacing it requires a $1.8-billion investment, the largest infrastructure project in the city’s history. The project has been at the top of the city’s priority list for many years, but the scale of investment has led to kicking the can down the road for just as long.

The public service estimates the remaining capacity of Winnipeg’s sewage treatment is the equivalent of adding about 90,000 people to the population of the city. With Winnipeg growing by about 12,000 people per year and the sewage capacity divided between residential, commercial, and industrial uses, the projection is that the system will hit its limit in as soon as five years. A best-case scenario is a new treatment plant will be operational in eight years, creating a real possibility that development could be halted in the city.

Winnipeg’s economic and population growth has been driven largely by international immigration over the last decade and the federal government has already announced that it will increase immigration to record levels over the next three years in a bid to stimulate the post-pandemic economic recovery. Ensuring that we leverage this growth to maximize its impact will be critical to the city’s own fiscal rebuild.

Read
Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2020

WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILE PHOTO
Replacing the North End Sewage Treatment Plant, which is nearing the end of its service life, will require a $1.8-billion investment.

Transit hub could transform downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Transit hub could transform downtown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 26, 2020

At the beginning of this year — back when we could shake hands and see each other’s faces – the city of Winnipeg announced it was no longer planning to build dedicated bus rapid-transit corridors. This came shortly before the opening of the Southwest Transitway, the city’s first completed line. The announcement felt like the end of Winnipeg’s rapid-transit dream.

Two weeks ago, however, the city released a new vision for the future of rapid transit, as part of the Winnipeg Transit Master Plan. The new concept shows a dramatic departure from the original plan of dedicated bus-only roadways, a system that would provide fast service between end points, but — as the Southwest Transitway demonstrates — one with important shortcomings.

The costly and slow-to-implement system runs largely through open fields, with several stations built far from where large numbers of people live, and without access to many of the destinations potential users would want to go.

The new plan focuses on integrating rapid transit onto existing major roadways, using priority signal lanes. Outside of downtown, the plan is to build dedicated transit lines on roads such as Main Street and Portage Avenue that run down the centre of the road, with stations located in the median, similar to Winnipeg’s old streetcar network.

Read
Monday, Oct. 26, 2020

CREDIT: Brent Bellamy
Winnipeg’s new transit plan, which would have Union Station as its central hub, could transform the city’s downtown.

Collective response is the best strategy

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Collective response is the best strategy

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 5, 2020

Remember when we thought schools taking an extra week off at spring break would give us time for the COVID-19 pandemic to pass? It seems laughable in hindsight, but it was not a unique reaction. For decades, we have been racing toward a climate crisis with a similar “It couldn’t happen here” naiveté.

This pandemic could well be a dress rehearsal for the main show, climate change — a far more catastrophic global emergency, with no hope of a vaccine to save us.

The coronavirus has demonstrated that our world is a fragile ecosystem, and when we push it too hard, it breaks. It has proven that a global problem is everyone’s problem. Old tropes, such as the suggestion the climate crisis is the sole responsibility of major polluters like India, China or the United States, no longer fly.

Like tackling a pandemic, the solution to climate change can only be realized through collective response. Global warming has been created through the cumulative effect of billions of small actions, and the only response is an equal number of small solutions.

Read
Monday, Oct. 5, 2020

CREDIT: Brent Bellamy
Cyclists and pedestrians took full advantage of the ‘open streets’ concept along Wolseley Avenue.

Building design needs breath of fresh air

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Building design needs breath of fresh air

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Sep. 8, 2020

The first day of school is always a nervous time. The anticipation of changing routines, new friends, and unfamiliar teachers can fill a student’s stomach with butterflies. This year brings a heightened level of apprehension, not only for students who will be living with new protocols, but for parents frightened that they are sending their kids into a dangerous situation during a global pandemic.

School administrators have been working to create procedures and classroom setups that will help minimize viral transmission, guided by the “fundamentals” of physical distancing and regular hand-washing, the primary recognized defences against respiratory droplets expelled from infected people.

As scientists learn more about how COVID-19 is transferred, an increasing number of studies are finding that aerosol transmission poses a higher risk than initially thought and should also be carefully considered as schools reopen. This type of infection comes from very small particles, released during normal breathing and talking, that remain airborne for longer periods of time and travel greater distances within a room.

The solution to aerosol transmission sounds easy — reduce air recirculation and increase fresh air ventilation in classrooms to dilute and wash away the tiny airborne particles collecting in the room. In practice however, this can be difficult to achieve. Every school’s ventilation is different, but the ability to significantly alter the performance of a building’s mechanical (HVAC) system is generally limited without major reconstruction.

Read
Tuesday, Sep. 8, 2020

Brent Bellamy photo
Pandemic-related concerns about air circulation will prompt a move toward functional windows in school-building design.

Impact-fee decision presents opportunity

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Impact-fee decision presents opportunity

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 17, 2020

In early July, the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench declared the City of Winnipeg’s impact fees, a charge levied on new construction in suburban housing developments, are not within the city’s legal jurisdiction, and ordered that the money collected be refunded to developers.

The controversial fees, which exist in some form in most Canadian cities, were implemented in 2017, attempting to balance the disproportionate cost of infrastructure and services required to support the sprawling, low-density city we have built over the past several decades.

Our city once grew by simply extending the existing roads, sewer pipes and streetcar lines, adding new grid-pattern residential streets along them. One neighbourhood blended seamlessly into the next. Walk south along the length of any street in River Heights, for example, and on the first block you’ll see houses built in the 1910s, with every few successive blocks representing a new decade of growth, until you eventually arrive at the homes built in the 1970s.

That’s when we started building new subdivisions as disconnected islands, far from existing neighbourhoods — a development model that stretches new infrastructure and services across great distances at great cost.

Read
Monday, Aug. 17, 2020

Winnipeg’s infrastructure deficit is a result of reduced density and suburban sprawl, not a lack of revenue.

Manitoba’s a great place to ‘staycation’

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Manitoba’s a great place to ‘staycation’

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 27, 2020

With borders closed and travel restricted, this year’s summer holidays are a unique opportunity to take a provincial “staycation” and explore some of the historic buildings and places in our own backyard. Most of Winnipeg’s important heritage structures are well known, but we sometimes overlook the province’s rich architectural history outside the city, where several National Historic Sites offer an “only in Manitoba” experience as unique as anything found on a vacation abroad.

If you grew up in Manitoba, the last time you visited Lower Fort Garry, just north of Winnipeg, was probably during a Grade 8 field trip. The stone fort rarely receives the appreciation it deserves, as the oldest intact fur-trading post in North America. There are many recreations and reconstructions across the West, but our old fort is a very rare, real thing.

Built in 1830 as the Hudson’s Bay Company’s administrative centre for the vast territory of Rupert’s Land, Lower Fort Garry is a monument of the fur trade, an era which played a foundational role in the development and exploration of Canada. The old stone walls witnessed the signing of Treaty One in 1871, and the pristine structures within are the oldest intact buildings in Western Canada, providing a connection to our country’s history as authentic as the cobbled streets of Old Montreal.

Wandering the manicured grounds, chatting with interpretive guides and absorbing the history of an original, perfectly preserved two-century-old trading fort is an experience that cannot be had anywhere else in the country.

Read
Monday, Jul. 27, 2020

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Most Manitobans haven’t visited Lower Fort Garry since that junior-high field trip. It’s worth another look.

Housing key to deracializing cities

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Housing key to deracializing cities

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 6, 2020

The killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis has ignited a vital conversation about systemic racism across all sectors of our society. An important part of this discussion is how we design our cities, which has been guided by policy rooted in racist history, and reinforced by decisions that continue to divide our cities and create social barriers today.

The COVID-19 pandemic exposed the racial inequity that exists in North American cities, with racialized neighbourhoods being hit disproportionately hard by the virus. The solution to combat systemic racism in urban design reads much like the solution to make cities more resilient against future pandemics. At the foundation of the challenge is housing.

Where a person lives affects all aspects of their life. Reduced access to socioeconomically integrated schools can affect performance and graduation rates for lower-income students, disproportionately divided along racial lines. House values in less diverse neighbourhoods are frequently suppressed. This often has the effect of reducing accumulated wealth for families, an important means of building intergenerational opportunity. Employment, recreation and green space are often concentrated in wealthier, less diverse neighbourhoods, creating barriers for people to improve their economic status and quality of life.

Zoning regulations control where people live and how our neighbourhoods look. By assigning properties into different categories of parkland, commercial, residential and industrial uses, zoning establishes the rules for development. Zoning was created a century ago to ensure factories were not built near houses, but it has a darker history that influences social and racial divisions in our cities today.

Read
Monday, Jul. 6, 2020

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Old Grace Housing Co-operative in Wolseley is a good example of a project that creates 60 affordable units on 14 housing lots, while fitting into the neighbourhood.

Pandemic shows need for affordable housing

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Preview

Pandemic shows need for affordable housing

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Monday, Jun. 8, 2020

As half the world hid in their homes trying to avoid a deadly virus, we had a lot of time to wonder what our “new normal” would look like. As we watched New York melt down, Gotham City imagery of skyscrapers, bustling streets, and tiny apartments made it easy to assume that population density might become a COVID-19 casualty.

Drawing a line between population density and viral transmission seems like simple logic. New York is the highest-density city in the United States and its biggest hot spot for COVID-19. Living near more people intuitively means closer contact with others. It seems to add up.

Closer investigation reveals that density does matter, but it depends on your frame of reference.

At the scale of a city or neighbourhood, population density has not been a key determinant in viral transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. At the very least, it is so far behind other factors such as travel, public policy, collective behaviour and income levels, that little correlation can be drawn.

Read
Monday, Jun. 8, 2020

SUPPLIED
This building at 290 Colony St. is an innovative project developed by the University of Winnipeg Community Renewal Corp. It mixes affordable housing with market-rent suites.

Pandemic presents obligation to change our world

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Pandemic presents obligation to change our world

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, May. 19, 2020

Crisis creates opportunity and leverage for change. As governments prepare to make once-in-a-generation stimulus investments to fight a global recession caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, we are faced with an opportunity, if not an obligation, to use it to change our world.

We are faced with a lot of uncertainty about what the future holds, but we are not powerless against it. The choices we make today will create the tomorrow we live in. Our decisions must be guided by a vision for the future, holding every public dollar we spend up to the light and asking ourselves, what will this do today, and what will it do tomorrow?

Changing our world doesn’t mean we need to start building wind turbines, autonomous vehicles and solar panel factories. The future can learn from the past. It can be simple, low-tech, but effective.

There is an old, not-very-sexy machine that could be the key to making our cities more sustainable, more liveable, and more just — the humble bus. Public transit use has cratered during the pandemic, and it will likely be a lasting casualty. The only way to change that will be with high levels of investment to improve service and reduce crowding.

Read
Tuesday, May. 19, 2020

Daoust Lestage Architects
The Market Lands development on the former Public Safety Building site will bring transformative change to downtown Winnipeg.

Crises helped shape modern architecture

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Crises helped shape modern architecture

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 27, 2020

Modern architecture was born out of a global health crisis. With tuberculosis crippling cities in Europe and North America in the early 20th century, gleaming white medical facilities called sanitoriums were designed to provide patients access to sunlight and fresh air, the only known treatment for the disease. This inspired architects to use the same ideas to promote mental and physical health in all new buildings.

Air and light became viewed as a kind of medicine by Modernist architects, and every building type was a kind of health-care facility. From this grew the clean Modernist aesthetic of high ceilings and open volumes, large operable windows, easy-to-clean white surfaces, terraces, and flat roofs — perfect places to sunbathe. The disease had changed the way our world looks.

It is too early to predict how the world will change after we emerge from this pandemic, but as it did in the last century, architecture and design will likely play a central role in the evolution.

As an immediate response to the current crisis, architects can once again look to health-care design for strategies that safeguard against bacteria and virus transmission. These approaches include a return to more non-porous surfaces in high-touch areas, making them easier to clean and sanitize.

Read
Monday, Apr. 27, 2020

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
The Women’s Hospital at Health Sciences Centre is an example of health-care architecture whose principles could inspire other building design.

Rethinking infrastructure after the pandemic

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Rethinking infrastructure after the pandemic

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 6, 2020

In our desperate battle to slow the spread of the coronavirus, almost four billion people, half the world’s population, are living under stay-at-home orders. In a rare united effort, governments, industry and citizens alike are working together to combat a common global enemy. The scale and speed of societal change left in its wake would have been unthinkable only a few weeks ago.

As we move through and out of this fight, the power of this new social cohesion presents us with an opportunity to boldly rebuild a country that is more economically resilient, environmentally sustainable, socially just and physically healthier. Cities will be at the front lines of this opportunity, and re-thinking the way we move around them will be fundamental to these goals.

We have suddenly learned the importance of physical distancing, and with more people out walking, we are also learning how little pedestrian space there actually is in our cities. Across the world, streets are being closed to cars, as cities scramble to create temporary public space for people to access sunlight and fresh air while maintaining safe distances from each other.

As the increased need for easily accessible space to walk and ride a bike becomes more permanent, so will these solutions.

Read
Monday, Apr. 6, 2020

SHANNON VANRAES / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES
Active transportation can play a key role, both during the pandemic and in rebuilding the city’s physical and social infrastructure afterward.

Shoebox apartments part of city’s heritage

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Preview

Shoebox apartments part of city’s heritage

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Monday, Feb. 10, 2020

On Boxing Day, fire raced through an old apartment building on Agnes Street in Winnipeg’s West End. It was demolished the next day to prevent it from collapsing into the street. A few weeks later, and only a few blocks away, a similar apartment on Maryland Street burned to the ground. Last week, yet another West End block was demolished on Toronto Street.

We take them for granted, but the removal of these little apartment buildings represents a significant loss, not only for those who lived in them, but for the city. They are inconspicuous and unassuming, but the shoebox apartment buildings peppered throughout the city’s old neighbourhoods are as characteristically Winnipeg as the famed yellow brick warehouses of the Exchange District.

They are so prevalent because they come from a time in Winnipeg’s history when a young frontier town was exploding into a bustling, urban metropolis.

As Winnipeg’s population skyrocketed at the turn of the last century, the rising cost of housing meant people looked for new options. These familiar little brick apartment blocks filled the need.

Read
Monday, Feb. 10, 2020

Current zoning dictates the apartment building at 576 Agnes St. can only be replaced with a single duplex. (Brent Bellamy)

Our decisions today create our children’s cities tomorrow

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Our decisions today create our children’s cities tomorrow

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 20, 2020

As the new year arrived, news headlines celebrated the fact Oslo, Norway, had just become the first city to ban cars from its downtown. The notion of banning cars sounds extreme, but they didn’t just throw up concrete barriers on New Year’s Eve and walk away. It was a natural progression in a decades-long journey for the Nordic city.

Comparing a Canadian city such as Winnipeg to one in Europe is always met with skepticism, but there’s an interesting parallel to be found between the decisions made a generation ago in two cities of similar size, leading to one that would ban cars and one that continues to ban pedestrians from parts of their respective city centres today.

Oslo is a much older city, but it had a similar population to Winnipeg when cars came on the scene in the 1920s. By the 1970s, both were experiencing the effects of the vehicle age, seeing an exodus of population from central neighbourhoods and high growth in new suburbs on the edges of the city.

Each had lost about 25 per cent of its population density over 20 years and both downtown cores were struggling. Surprisingly, by 1970, the mature neighbourhoods of Oslo and Winnipeg (ones with grid streets and elm trees) had similar population densities of about 5,000 people per square kilometre, and similar overall populations of about 200,000.

Read
Monday, Jan. 20, 2020

Brent Bellamy Photo
Oslo recently became the first major city to ban motor vehicles from its downtown.

Architecture central to Christmas story

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Architecture central to Christmas story

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 23, 2019

Architecture isn’t something most people think about very much, but the buildings that surround us tell a story of who we are and where we come from. We might not pay much attention to it, but architecture is even deeply embedded in our Christmas traditions, an evolving character in our stories that helps set mood, recall a memory or reinforce the messages being told.

In the year 1223, Italian preacher St. Francis of Assisi created the first nativity scene, hoping to establish a visual connection to the birth of Jesus for his congregation. Since then, setting up a nativity has become an important Christmas tradition in homes across the world.

Most people are familiar with the cast of characters — Jesus, Mary, Joseph, the wise men and shepherds. The often-overlooked character is the stable itself, generally depicted as a fragile wooden frame holding up a peaked roof. It may be an unassuming architectural representation, but it conveys a powerful message with deep religious meaning.

In the nativity, architecture is used to express the humble beginnings of a king. A simple roof says very simply, “He is one of us.” As a character in the scene, the architecture tells more than just the location of the event — it is a clear illustration of how Jesus would live his life and a representation of the idea that he had come for everyone, an important message at the foundation of the religion, delivered through architecture.

Read
Monday, Dec. 23, 2019

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
Stories that have evolved as part of the Christmas tradition are affected by architecture.

Zoning affects a city’s social fabric

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Zoning affects a city’s social fabric

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 2, 2019

All North American cities use zoning to regulate the development of land and buildings. By assigning properties into different categories of parkland, commercial, residential and industrial uses, zoning establishes the rules for what can and can’t be built. The vast majority of residential neighbourhoods in Canadian cities fall under a single-family zoning category called R-1, which generally mandates a land use of one detached house per lot.

The first municipal zoning ordinance in North America was established in Los Angeles in 1908, to ensure factories were not being built beside houses. The move toward specific single-family zoning, however, has a much more disturbing origin, rooted in deliberate social impacts that continue to affect cities today.

In the early 20th century, American cities used racial zoning to establish segregated residential neighbourhoods, by restricting where non-white residents could live. In 1917, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the concept of race-based planning, but municipalities, under pressure from residents, quickly circumvented the ruling by implementing a new form of exclusionary zoning. They would make it illegal to build anything but a single-family home in certain neighbourhoods, often with minimum lot and house sizes.

This new policy, overt in its intention, delivered the same results. By ensuring that only people who could afford the most expensive housing type would have access to single-family zoned communities, neighbourhood segregation continued for less affluent residents, which was often connected to race. The practice was upheld by the Supreme Court in 1926, leading to more racially and socially segregated neighbourhoods in cities across the United States and eventually Canada.

Read
Monday, Dec. 2, 2019

5468796 Architecture
A proposed infill development in Osborne Village will add new residential options to a community that is already a diverse mix of single- and multi-family housing.

City’s expanding footprint has high cost

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

City’s expanding footprint has high cost

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2019

Planners at the City of Winnipeg are currently in the process of writing a residential infill strategy to guide new development in the city’s older neighbourhoods.

The task is challenging. People love their neighbourhoods and have a natural resistance to seeing them change. It’s difficult to use statistics to debate emotional attachment — mathematics rarely wins over the heart — but the hard numbers outline why planning policy has for many years promoted higher density infill growth, despite its unpopularity with residents.

Winnipeg has more old homes than any other city in Canada. Almost one in 10 houses in Winnipeg are older than 100 years, 10 times more than Calgary and Edmonton, twice as much as far older cities such as Montreal and Halifax. The mathematics suggests that change is inevitable for Winnipeg’s mature neighbourhoods.

As part of its public consultation, the city recently released a jaw-dropping graphic that clearly explains why increasing density is considered a priority, as this change occurs. The graphic compares the built-up area of Winnipeg in the 1970s and today. In that time, the footprint of the city increased by 96 per cent, almost doubling, while the population increased by only 37 per cent. The conclusion was that the city is currently growing three times faster in area than it is in population.

Read
Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2019

From 1971 to 2019, Winnipeg grew by 197,021 people — a 37 per cent increase. Over that same period, the city’s built-up area increased by 96 per cent. (City of Winnipeg)

Shared streets create vibrancy

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Shared streets create vibrancy

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 21, 2019

When it comes to moving around our cities, Canadians live in a world of rules — green lights, yellow lights, red lights, speed limits, crosswalks, countdowns, no parking, no stopping, no riding on the sidewalk.

All these rules are intended to order pedestrians, drivers and cyclists into individual corridors where each can move with blind obedience to lights and signs. They are designed to keep vehicles moving quickly, and naturally prioritize traffic flow for the largest, fastest and most dangerous road users.

Sometimes a street has a different purpose, a different story to tell. Some streets are more importantly a great place than a great connector. To be this, they must be designed first as somewhere to linger, not to move quickly through.

A street can be the social and economic heart of its community. Those with a strong sense of place can entice people to the sidewalks and public spaces, key to making urban neighbourhoods attractive places to live, work, shop and socialize. But when vehicle speed is prioritized, these streets feel less safe and become less attractive to sit near, live on or walk along. And as they attract fewer people, the businesses falter, the appeal to new residents decreases and the neighbourhood begins to decline.

Read
Monday, Oct. 21, 2019

Brent Bellamy Photo
Adopting a shared-street concept could make the Exchange District more accessible and much safer for all who visit.

Narrowing sidewalk a step backward for pedestrian access

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Narrowing sidewalk a step backward for pedestrian access

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 30, 2019

Almost since the invention of the automobile, downtown Winnipeg has been shaped by cars. In 1931, right turns on red lights were introduced, diagonal parking was removed and one-way streets began to appear. In 1955, streetcars were discontinued and the elm trees that lined the once-residential streets were cut down to widen the roads.

Housing was slowly bought up and turned into parking lots. Today, with more than 32,000 stalls, a staggering 40 per cent of downtown’s land area is dedicated to parking.

This slow evolution of prioritizing cars over places for people transformed the character of downtown — its pedestrian barricades, wide roads and windswept parking lots left few places for people to linger and enjoy. We designed for cars and we got cars, lots of them. Our once-bustling sidewalks today see the fewest pedestrians and are lined by the lowest number of retail storefronts of any major Canadian city.

There is no longer a downtown shopping street, and even the Exchange District, with all its charm, has fewer storefronts and restaurants than similar areas in other cities.

Read
Monday, Sep. 30, 2019

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
The creation of a drop-off area on Main Street near Bannatyne Avenue has virtually eliminated sidewalk space.

Mennonite history lives on

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Mennonite history lives on

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 19, 2019

Just west of Altona, near the U.S. border, sits a little-known collection of buildings that tell a fascinating story about Manitoba’s past.

Celebrated as a National Historic Site in 1989, the village of Neubergthal is recognized as the best preserved example of a Mennonite street village in Canada. Its distinct town plan and architectural styles are a living illustration of Mennonite building traditions, brought to Manitoba in the late 19th century after 200 years of development in Europe.

The origins of the Mennonite farm village began centuries ago on the lowlands of Prussia. Typical homesteads were organized in long, narrow strips running from higher ground along the river to low-lying marshland. This resulted in multifunctional farm buildings being clustered at the front of each property.

After relocating to Russia, Mennonites began settling in villages for protection and ease of sharing labour and tools. The traditional settlement configuration was maintained, but the river was replaced by a central street.

Read
Monday, Aug. 19, 2019

BRENT BELLAMY
View from the stables at Friesen Housebarn Intepretive Centre in Neubergthal.

New possibilities for Portage Place

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

New possibilities for Portage Place

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 29, 2019

In the late 1980s, Winnipeg’s Portage Avenue was struggling. A shopping trip on a Saturday afternoon no longer meant heading downtown, as people became attracted to new suburban malls that could offer climate-controlled environments and oceans of free parking.

The strategy to curb this trend in Winnipeg, as in many North American cities, was to try to beat the suburbs at their own game. In 1987, three blocks of Portage Avenue were expropriated and demolished to make way for an upscale new shopping centre called Portage Place.

As mega-projects go, this one appeared to have all the ingredients for success. It was a model for the urbanist catch phrase “mixed-use development,” but like most silver-bullet mega-projects, its success never reached its promise.

The shoppers stayed in the suburbs, and for more than three decades, Portage Place has struggled to find its role in the city’s retail landscape.

Read
Monday, Jul. 29, 2019

Slower speeds make safer neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Slower speeds make safer neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 8, 2019

The most dangerous thing most of us will ever do is drive our car. We do it every day without a second thought, yet around the world 1.3 million people are killed in car accidents each year, a number equivalent to the entire population of Calgary.

Canadian roads average 160,000 vehicle accidents annually, resulting in more than 2,000 fatalities and 150,000 injuries. If any other source were killing or injuring 400 Canadians per day, it would be considered a national health crisis.

Perhaps the most sobering statistic of all is that in Canada, almost one out of every five people killed or seriously injured by a car is not even in one — 15 per cent are pedestrians and three per cent are cyclists. In Winnipeg, more than 200 pedestrians and cyclists are struck and injured by vehicles every year, which typically represents almost half the number of people killed in car accidents in the city.

These staggering road-safety statistics have most major Canadian cities investigating new ways to make streets safer for everyone — drivers, cyclists and pedestrians. Many cities are beginning to adopt Vision Zero, a global initiative started in Sweden that promotes a holistic strategy to urban road safety.

Read
Monday, Jul. 8, 2019

BRENT BELLAMY
Vision Zero’s approach to road safety is simple: lowering speed limits reduces injuries to pedestrians and cyclists.

Mansion protest tests limits of infill goal

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Mansion protest tests limits of infill goal

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 17, 2019

A stately old home that has watched over Winnipeg’s most prestigious residential street for the past 110 years has suddenly become the centre of a protracted neighbourhood battle. The mansion at 514 Wellington Cres. was slated to be demolished, potentially making way for a multi-family development, but neighbours rallied in opposition, picketing the site and blockading construction vehicles to save it from the wrecking ball.

On June 7, the home received a temporary reprieve when it was announced that the Crescentwood neighbourhood is being considered as Winnipeg’s second heritage conservation district, which would create new guidelines and review processes for any demolition in the area.

Winnipeg’s first heritage conservation district was created in Armstrong’s Point last April. A neighbourhood that is identified as having special architectural and historic significance can apply for this designation to ensure the unique character of the area is preserved over time. Once an area is so designated, a series of design guidelines and policies are established in consultation with community residents. A committee is set up to review and approve everything from existing home exterior renovations and additions to demolition and new construction, which must receive a heritage permit before proceeding.

Winnipeg’s character is defined by its beautiful tree-lined neighbourhoods, and heritage conservation districts can preserve this legacy. It is important, however, that mature neighbourhoods be allowed to grow and change.

Read
Monday, Jun. 17, 2019

WINNIPEG FREE PRESS files
Protesters picket outside the 110-year-old mansion at 514 Wellington Cres. on June 8.

Transcona a model for the future

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Transcona a model for the future

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 13, 2019

Last week, Re/Max released its 2019 Livability Report, which examines a range of quality-of-life factors to determine which Canadian neighbourhoods are felt to be most “livable.” A surprise finding was that Transcona, often considered to be Winnipeg’s Newfoundland, was identified as a hidden gem. Despite often being the punchline of bad jokes, old Transcona stands as a very good example of what modern suburb design should strive to be.

As cities have sprawled over the past several decades, lower densities have resulted in reduced services and crumbling roads as tax revenue is spread more thinly over a greater proportion of civic services and infrastructure.

Our lifestyles have been transformed by modern suburban design, with almost every activity beginning with a drive in a car. Vehicle use and ownership have increased dramatically, while traffic congestion and commuting times have grown. Children no longer walk to the corner store, and while nearly 60 per cent of their parents walked to school as kids, today 75 per cent of children are driven.

Vehicles are responsible for half of Winnipeg’s total greenhouse gas emissions, by far the largest contributor. According to the city’s climate action plan, the people of Winnipeg drive a combined 5.5 billion kilometres per year, equal to every person over the age of 16 driving alone in a car 26 kilometres every day.

Read
Monday, May. 13, 2019

Brent Bellamy
Transcona is a self-contained, diverse, urban community that offers residents an efficient and intimate pedestrian experience.

When old meets new

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

When old meets new

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 15, 2019

Winnipeg’s Exchange District was named a National Historic Site in 1997 because it is a uniquely cohesive historic neighbourhood. The area was preserved by many decades of slow growth and, since the 1970s, preservationists have worked hard to maintain its cohesion by protecting heritage buildings from demolition.

The Exchange’s rich character has attracted growth and, with the area booming today, a new challenge has arisen for the heritage district. New buildings are beginning to fill some of the empty spaces between the old, leading to a question that is often polarizing: what should a new building in an old neighbourhood look like?

Cities are living and evolving ecosystems. Change is inevitable. In the case of heritage districts, however, it is important that contemporary architecture celebrates and enriches the special character of its context. This relationship between new and old can be established in many ways.

An important publication in 2007 by the American National Trust for Historic Preservation, called Differentiated and Compatible, outlined four strategies that designers can use to create modern additions to historic areas. Later this summer, examples of three of these approaches will be under construction in Winnipeg’s Exchange District.

Read
Monday, Apr. 15, 2019

Provided by 5468796 Architecture
A residential development for Princess Street and Bannatyne Avenue called Warehouse 1885 blends new construction on the right with the heritage-protected portion of the property on the left.

Mature trees worth saving, not just replacing

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Mature trees worth saving, not just replacing

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 25, 2019

The elm bark beetle kills 15 mature elm trees in Winnipeg every day. The emerald ash borer that arrived in late 2017 could kill every ash tree in the city in the next decade.

Winnipeg has the unfortunate distinction of being the only city in North America at war with both of these tree-killing insects at the same time, and the two species they destroy make up almost two-thirds of the city’s public trees.

Our urban forest is on the cusp of devastation, but a sense of public urgency has yet to set in. In Ottawa, more than 100,000 ash trees have been lost in the eight years since the emerald ash borer’s arrival. Our day is coming. As we battle the invaders, management of our street trees will mean replanting more diverse species as old ones are lost, but we should not undervalue efforts to preserve our existing older trees.

The economic, environmental and social benefits of street trees increase exponentially with size, and it can take generations for the value of a lost mature tree to be regained. A replanted basswood, as an example, will be less than half of its mature height and breadth after 30 years of growth. A disease-free American elm can live up to 300 years, and doesn’t reach full maturity until 150 years. With salt and other environmental pollutants in today’s city, most replanted trees will never reach the scale of our current canopy.

Read
Monday, Mar. 25, 2019

CANADIAN FOOD INSPECTION AGENCY
The emerald ash borer has destroyed tens of millions of trees in North America.

Heritage designations are not something to fear

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Heritage designations are not something to fear

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 4, 2019

“Building owner opposes heritage designation” has become a regular headline in Winnipeg over the past few years. One by one, buildings are being nominated for designation — the Bay, the Manitoba Club, the University of Manitoba — and, one by one, owners are trying to fight it.

The genesis of these battles dates back to 2014, when the city passed the historic resources by-law. This transformed heritage designation in Winnipeg from an ambiguous three-tiered grading system to a model in which the specific character-defining elements that are felt to establish the heritage value of individual historic buildings are identified and listed for protection.

For most buildings, key facades are protected, along with important internal elements such as ornate staircases, lobbies or ceiling treatments. Building owners often feel that this will limit development potential, but the system is not intended to freeze a building in time. Once these elements are identified, significant flexibility remains for a building to change and evolve.

Over the past 10 years, more than 30 buildings in Winnipeg’s Exchange District have been significantly altered and given new use while under heritage designation. The latest and most dramatic development is the James Avenue Pumping Station. After sitting empty since 1986, facing demolition several times, the handsome structure with its elegant double-gable roofline has been reborn as a spectacular modern office space, hovering over century-old industrial machinery.

Read
Monday, Mar. 4, 2019

Courtesy of Brent Bellamy
This streetscape in Winnipeg’s Exchange District presents a pretty winter picture, but it also illustrates the value of preserving and protecting heritage buildings.

Winnipeg needs infill-strategy road map

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Winnipeg needs infill-strategy road map

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 4, 2019

Winnipeg city council will soon be presented with details of the new residential infill strategy, a guide for development in the city’s existing neighbourhoods that represents an important opportunity to manage higher-density growth and define what our communities will look like in the future.

The idea of increased neighbourhood density is something that makes people instinctively recoil in opposition, but it is critical to the city’s long-term economic, social and environmental sustainability.

The mathematics of higher density is simple: the more people paying for things, the better. A simplified scenario demonstrates the concept. With 10 houses on 100 metres of street, the property taxes from each maintain 10 metres of road. With 10 houses on 200 metres of street, the property taxes from each maintain 20 metres of road. The result of lower density is either taxes rise, or maintenance is reduced.

This formula works for all infrastructure and services, including sewer, water, snow clearing, garbage collection and emergency services. Our pothole-covered roads and stretched civic budgets are the result of a low-density city, growing more than twice as fast in area as it is in population.

Read
Monday, Feb. 4, 2019

JAMES BRITTAIN PHOTO
A contemporary infill structure on Stradbrook Avenue shows how modern design and innovation can enhance a neighbourhood.

Winter cycling isn’t extreme

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Winter cycling isn’t extreme

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 14, 2019

“The majority of people who are biking in the winter, they’re the extreme. They’re the extreme cyclists and I don’t see that changing.”

Coun. Jeff Browaty made these comments last month at city hall, while questioning the value of clearing snow from Winnipeg bike lanes in the winter. His statement made headlines, but the sentiment that Winnipeg is too cold to support winter cycling is not seen as an extreme viewpoint.

We don’t label cross-country skiers “extreme.” It is not extreme to let our children play in the schoolyard at lunchtime. A game of shinny on an outdoor rink isn’t extreme, and the only thing extreme about skating in the middle of Winnipeg’s frozen rivers is the lineup for skate rentals at The Forks. So, why is riding a bike in the winter seen as extreme?

The difference, of course, is that cross-country skiers don’t share their tracks with 2,000-kilogram machines travelling 60 km/h. Winter cycling is seen as extreme not because of temperature, but because riders must compete with cars for space on slippery, ice-covered roads.

Read
Monday, Jan. 14, 2019

BRENT BELLAMY / Winnipeg Free Press
Winnipeg is a winter city, but cycling in winter is still viewed by many as an extreme activity.

Urban lifestyle keeps young people here

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Urban lifestyle keeps young people here

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 24, 2018

A few weeks ago, I wrote a column mentioning that an alarmingly large number of people are leaving Manitoba for other provinces. The point appeared to inspire enough discussion that further investigation seems warranted.

Statistics Canada data indicate 9,199 more people moved away from Manitoba than came to the province from June 30, 2017, to July 1, 2018. This net loss in provincial migration was the highest number since 1989. Statistics for the third quarter of 2018 show the decline continuing, with the province losing 3,000 more people over that three-month period.

Most of Manitoba’s interprovincial migration losses come from Winnipeg. In 2016-17, Winnipeg lost the second-highest number of people in the country, losing far more than any other city as a proportion of overall population. Typically, about 40 per cent of this migration is people between the ages of 20 and 34.

Winnipeg and Manitoba are continuing to grow through natural increase and international immigration, but the loss of so many young people is a disconcerting trend for the city and province. In an increasingly mobile world, cities that find strategies to successfully attract young people realize the highest levels of economic prosperity.

Read
Monday, Dec. 24, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY
Many young people are choosing walkable neighbourhoods (such as Corydon Avenue, above) and car-free transportation. They’re willing to move to cities that offer this lifestyle.

To grow, Winnipeg needs to think big

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

To grow, Winnipeg needs to think big

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 3, 2018

In the fall of 2014, Winnipeg was engaged in an election campaign that captured the city’s imagination. Three progressive candidates went toe to toe, presenting big ideas to take the city in a new direction.

The recent civic election campaign was a stark contrast to four years ago. Few progressive ideas were debated, and city-building dialogue was again dominated by potholes and crime.

There was a lot of celebration about Winnipeg growing towards a population of one million, but little discussion about how to sustainably manage that growth. In the past year, Manitoba saw an unprecedented number of people moving away. Almost 9,000 more people left Manitoba for other provinces than came to it, by far the highest number in two decades. A large proportion of these left Winnipeg and around 40 per cent of them were young people between the ages of 20 and 34.

Despite this disturbing trend, few ideas were presented to make Winnipeg more attractive to a young, mobile workforce — who, in greater numbers than ever, are looking for a diversity of lifestyle choices beyond the overwhelmingly suburban, auto-centric city we are building. The election campaign offered few ideas to ensure Winnipeg keeps pace with other Canadian cities that are moving swiftly forward, implementing progressive urbanist ideas that attract investment and immigration and retain young people.

Read
Monday, Dec. 3, 2018

WAYNE GLOWACKI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Files
With a strong provincial partnership, there are many big ideas that could be transformational for Winnipeg.

Investing in pedestrian movement pays off

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Investing in pedestrian movement pays off

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 27, 2018

Walking is good for you, and good for the economy. Cities across North America are investing in infrastructure to encourage walking in urban neighbourhoods as a way of improving health, accessibility, quality of life and safety while promoting urban renewal and economic growth.

Toronto, Calgary and Edmonton, cities that Winnipeg competes with for investment, tourism and immigration, all have official pedestrian strategies to guide policy, increase pedestrian numbers and make those cities better places to walk. In contrast, Winnipeggers are voting on the idea of keeping concrete walls, in the heart of our city, that have intentionally repelled pedestrians for four decades.

The key principles of designing an urban area to be walkable are creating direct and simple pedestrian connections along a network of diverse destinations, as well as establishing physically interesting and comfortable places to walk that feel safe and promote social interaction.

Walkability has been quantified by the website walkscore.com using a 100-point scale that measures pedestrian connectivity and distances to employment, education and other amenities. A significant body of research has proven that when neighbourhood walkability increases, so does desirability, and in turn residential property values and the tax base.

Read
Monday, Aug. 27, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Cities that invest in infrastructure that promotes a pedestrian lifestyle are reaping social and economic rewards.

Shedding light on Portage and Main

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Shedding light on Portage and Main

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Wednesday, Aug. 8, 2018

For 40 years, we have been arguing over adding 18 seconds in the morning and 54 seconds in the afternoon to a daily Winnipeg commute that averages 24 minutes each way.

The idea of letting people cross the street at Portage and Main has long evoked images of gridlocked cars lined to the Perimeter Highway, but with a public referendum now foisted upon us, it is time to investigate the facts.

Last year, the respected engineering firm Dillon Consulting completed the Portage and Main Transportation Study, a comprehensive 95-page document which looked at the effects of introducing pedestrians at each corner, during both the morning and afternoon rush hours. Dillon compiled extensive, real-world data and used it to create precise computer simulation models, with cutting-edge software that is considered a global leader in accuracy and precision.

The study found that the greatest impacts to traffic will be experienced in the peak of afternoon rush hour, when the average time it will take for cars to get through the intersection will be 33 seconds longer than today. When the impact of this is telegraphed across downtown, the average time of an overall commute will increase by a total of 54 seconds (cumulative delay for all cars/number of cars).

Read
Wednesday, Aug. 8, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY photo
The cost to complete long-overdue repairs to the barriers at Portage and Main could rival the cost to make the intersection accessible to pedestrians.

Cities recognize basic sanitation is a right

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Cities recognize basic sanitation is a right

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 16, 2018

For several years, a soaring glass tower has risen from The Forks, designed to inspire discussion and awareness of the importance of human rights in our society. This summer, a little orange structure has appeared a few blocks away that is intended to provoke a similar discussion.

Pop-Up Winnipeg Public Toilet is a temporary washroom facility that is the latest incarnation of a decade-long campaign by architect Wins Bridgman to make universally accessible toilets a permanent piece of public infrastructure in downtown Winnipeg.

In 2012, Canada signed a United Nations document recognizing basic sanitation as a human right. As Canada’s social divide widens, access to washrooms has become an issue for a growing number of people in our cities. Possibly more than any other human-rights issue, sanitation is intrinsically linked to the idea of human dignity and is an underlying determinant of physical and mental health.

Lack of proper sanitation for the most vulnerable people in our society can increase incidents of abuse and discrimination, exacerbate the cycle of poverty, drug addiction and health problems and ultimately create greater barriers to a basic quality of life and self-determination.

Read
Monday, Jul. 16, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY
The early success of the Pop-Up Winnipeg Public Toilet pilot project is an encouraging sign that the city is embracing the importance of downtown public washroom facilities.

Time to think different about transit

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Time to think different about transit

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 25, 2018

The City of Winnipeg is currently seeking public input on the proposed alignment for its next Bus Rapid Transit line. The eastern corridor will connect Plessis Road in Transcona with Harkness Station on Stradbrook Avenue, where the existing Southwest Transitway currently terminates. Two routes are being presented, one running through Point Douglas and one through St. Boniface.

The plans begin by proposing an exciting option to locate the transitway on the elevated rail line between The Forks and Main Street, using Union Station as a magnificent transit stop. This creates the potential for the historic structure to become a multi-modal transportation centre for downtown, operating as a central hub for such things as cycling and transit, water-bus, taxi, airport shuttles, and tourist trolleys.

The spectacular central hall of Union Station once again bustling with activity represents an opportunity to stimulate growth around south Main Street, by bringing pedestrian traffic to the sidewalks and drawing the vibrancy of The Forks and its future railside community into the rest of downtown.

Beyond Union Station, the two proposals diverge. The Point Douglas option either continues up Main Street or passes through the Exchange District to Higgins Avenue, before crossing the river on a new bridge. The St. Boniface alignment crosses the river on the existing Provencher Bridge and then runs down Provencher Boulevard to Archibald Street and Nairn Avenue.

Read
Monday, Jun. 25, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY / Winnipeg Free Press
Transit-corridor development could turn Provencher Boulevard into a complete, multimodal street.

Pedestrian bridges a welcome direction

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Pedestrian bridges a welcome direction

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 4, 2018

Winnipeg’s rivers have divided its neighbourhoods since the days when St. Boniface was an independent city with ferry service to the English side of the river. The physical segmentation of Winnipeg, by rivers and railyards, has made it a city of unique neighbourhoods. Communities that are geographically adjacent, but without direct pedestrian connections, have often developed with a distinct character, demographic, economy and history.

Designed primarily to funnel people through neighbourhoods, and not be connectors between them, the city’s many vehicular bridges have had limited success breaking down the traditional divisions between Winnipeg’s communities. A new pedestrian and cycling bridge, however, proposed to span the Assiniboine River and connect the cycling infrastructure of Osborne Village and downtown, might present a new model to effectively link many of Winnipeg’s communities at a more intimate scale.

As always, there is public debate about the cost and details, but the new bridge represents an important opportunity to change the dialogue about mobility in Winnipeg. Done well, it can be a symbol of a progressive and inclusive city that is broadening its transportation options. Calgary’s similar Peace Bridge, designed by renowned Spanish architect Santiago Calatrava, has become a postcard image, representing a forward-looking city. There may be other bridges with shoulders and sidewalks for cyclists and pedestrians, but a dedicated crossing changes the experience of those activities and by giving them priority, elevates the value of active transportation in the city and attracts more users.

With construction costs of about 10 per cent that of a car bridge, cycling and pedestrian bridges could affordably be replicated in strategic areas across the city, introducing a new network of connectivity between Winnipeg’s divided neighbourhoods. This web of active mobility could link communities together and potentially change how we define our neighbourhoods. It could transform how we move around our city, increasing economic opportunity, neighbourhood vibrancy and quality of life.

Read
Monday, Jun. 4, 2018

SUPPLIED
One of the preliminary designs for a pedestrian bridge over the Assiniboine River to connect Osborne Village to downtown via McFadyen Park and Fort Rouge Park.

Sweeping new plaza designed to engage

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Sweeping new plaza designed to engage

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 7, 2018

The Winnipeg Jets’ playoff run has cast a spotlight on our downtown. Images of hockey-crazed fans dancing in the streets have caught the imagination of the country.

Next year, the whiteout celebration will move from its temporary setup to a permanent home at True North Square. The sweeping new plaza, anchored by a six-by-nine-metre video screen, has been planned to accommodate several thousand people for concerts, festivals and other public events, but understanding the potential scale of street parties, the event space has been designed to expand to incorporate Carlton Street to form a huge, block-long festival area set within the four towers of the development.

The long-term success of True North Square as a public space will be measured, however, not only by its function during NHL playoffs, but also by its ability to engage the city and the people who use it every other day of the year. Large public spaces can be a difficult challenge in low-density cities such as Winnipeg, particularly in a downtown that has been designed with much higher priority given to vehicles than pedestrians. Without a determined focus on bringing people to the site and keeping them there, large public spaces can become desolate and unsafe.

The design team of True North Square, Vancouver’s Perkins+Will and PFS Studio, and Winnipeg’s Architecture 49 and McGowan Russell, have developed a plan that grew uniquely from the public spaces outward. Pedestrian connectivity was first considered, establishing pathways and sight lines through the development that link the major buildings in the area, including the arena and convention centre.

Read
Monday, May. 7, 2018

SUPPLIED IMAGES
Artist’s renderings of the Terracotta Level in True North Square (above) and a wider view of the full project (below).

Kapyong a unique opportunity to innovate

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Preview

Kapyong a unique opportunity to innovate

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Monday, Apr. 23, 2018

After 14 years, an agreement in principle has been reached between the federal government and Treaty 1 First Nations, regarding the future of Kapyong Barracks.The abandoned 160-acre site, about three times the size of The Forks, will be divided into two parcels; one-third will be developed by Canada Lands, a federal Crown corporation, and the rest will be held in common by seven First Nations that intend to develop it as a joint urban reserve.

With issues of ownership soon behind us, we can begin to dream as a community about what the site could be, the possibilities for Winnipeg, Canada and all Indigenous people, limited only by our imagination.

Imagine a place that is a crown jewel of Winnipeg — a dynamic urban reserve that stands as a lasting monument to reconciliation, a source of pride for Canada, a source of prosperity and symbol of hope for Indigenous people, and a catalyst for establishing a new relationship between First Nations and the modern Canadian city.

With 91 per cent of all new growth in metropolitan areas happening in car-dependent suburban development, the future prosperity of Canada’s cities will depend largely on how we build new suburbs. The sprawling, low-density growth patterns of the past have led to an economically and environmentally unsustainable urban form. Because of urban sprawl, civic infrastructure is crumbling, public services are being reduced and taxes are rising.

Read
Monday, Apr. 23, 2018

SUPPLIED
The vision for Sidewalk Toronto is a traffic-reduced area with high walkability and high-density residential.

Kenaston pitch deserves a rethink

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Kenaston pitch deserves a rethink

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Apr. 3, 2018

With $450 million, one could build 90 community libraries, or 18 new schools, or 25 two-rink recreation centres. That sum represents the city’s total road maintenance budget for four years.

Winnipeg Transit’s entire 600-vehicle fleet could be replaced with new electric buses for $450 million — with enough money left over to buy 300 more.

Or, $450 million could build one car lane, two kilometres long, on each side of Kenaston Boulevard.

The city of Winnipeg has restarted the consultation process for widening Kenaston, between the St. James Bridge and Taylor Avenue, in an effort to reduce congestion.

Read
Tuesday, Apr. 3, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
The proposed widening of Kenaston Boulevard could incorporate berms and acoustic walls that create a stark landscape, similar to that on south Kenaston in Waverley West.

Parkade plan shows forward thinking

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Parkade plan shows forward thinking

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 12, 2018

There’s a sense of accomplishment that comes with finding a great parking spot. We feel good about ourselves, and brag about it to our friends. As Canadians, we expend a lot of time and energy looking for parking, and it’s no wonder: we own a lot of cars. A million driving-age adults in Manitoba own almost 900,000 vehicles.

Parking all these cars takes up a staggering amount of space. Assuming the province is typical to other North American jurisdictions, with about three parking stalls built for every registered car, the total land area dedicated to parking in Manitoba could be as much as 70 square kilometres — about the size of Brandon.

Accommodating 32,000 stalls, 41 per cent of the land area in downtown Winnipeg is dedicated to parking, half on surface lots. In general, North American cities devote from 10 to 15 per cent of their overall land area to parking, with personal vehicles typically sitting parked 95 per cent of the time.

All of this might soon change. The advent of autonomous vehicles, and a coming revolution in how we drive and park, may provide an important opportunity to take back much of this land and transform the way we have designed Canadian cities for the last century.

Read
Monday, Mar. 12, 2018

Supplied
A digital rendering of the planned 9th Avenue Parkade and Innovation Centre, which will be a unique $80-million, 500-stall structure in downtown Calgary.

Walking key to complete community

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Walking key to complete community

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 12, 2018

Last week, the city’s familiar public notice signs began appearing along three blocks of Academy Road in River Heights. They usually signify a rezoning application for new development; in this instance, the little yellow signs were advertising something quite different.

The application being made is a change to the local neighbourhood plan — called a Planned Development Overlay — proposing to redraw the boundaries between what is called the “Academy Shops and Services Area” and the “Academy Living Area.” This move would restrict three blocks of the street, currently single-family homes, from ever being converted into mixed-use or commercial development.

The application represents another chapter in a long history of resistance to development on Academy Road. River Heights residents have demonstrated a particularly rabid aversion to change, but their opposition is not unique in the city. Whenever change is proposed in any of Winnipeg’s mature neighbourhoods, developers generally face opposition. A recent example was a four-storey mixed-use proposal for a surface parking lot on Provencher Boulevard that had residents at the public hearing lamenting the loss of parking and views, as well as fearing increased neighbourhood density.

There are streets such as Academy Road in most cities, running through neighbourhoods with the density and demographics of River Heights, lined with shops and amenities for their full length, to support the daily needs of community residents. The “high street” would be celebrated as the life of the neighbourhood, a driver of employment and a vital part of a healthy, pedestrian lifestyle, providing supporting services such as shops, restaurants and groceries that are walked to by the residents.

Read
Monday, Feb. 12, 2018

BRENT BELLAMY
Academy Road has the potential to be a complete community, if residents are willing to embrace the concept.

City should consider streetcar revival

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

City should consider streetcar revival

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 22, 2018

One hundred and 17 years ago this week, the first electric streetcar in Winnipeg jingle-jangled its way down River Avenue between Main and Osborne streets. Soon, a network of routes would criss-cross the city. At its peak, almost 400 cars carried 60-million riders annually on more than 200 kilometres of track.

Winnipeg owes much of its current urban form of large streets radiating out from the core to those early streetcar routes. The attraction of public transportation was used to drive development and target growth in new suburbs, by extending streetcar lines down streets, such as Osborne Street, Corydon Avenue, Sherbrook Street, Broadway, Portage Avenue, Academy Road and St. Mary’s Road. These roads would become dense retail and service corridors, running through neighbourhoods of grid-pattern residential streets that provided easy pedestrian access to transit stops.

As car ownership boomed and diesel buses became the future, the last streetcar made its final run down Main Street in 1955, with a banner on its side proclaiming, “I’m giving way to transit progress.” The city form would change to follow this evolution, with primary growth occurring in distant, car-focused, low-density, cul-de-sac subdivisions with regional retail centres.

With most population growth happening on the suburban fringes, many North American cities are looking to establish more sustainable development patterns by attracting greater density to mature neighbourhoods and promoting inward growth in central suburbs.

Read
Monday, Jan. 22, 2018

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Streetcars ran regularly down Portage Avenue in their heyday.

National housing strategy a way to change face of neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

National housing strategy a way to change face of neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 4, 2017

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau recently unveiled details of the federal government’s national housing strategy, a 10-year, $40-billion initiative that will look to collaborate with provinces and municipalities in developing programs that target homelessness and improve access to affordable housing for Canadians in need.

The plan includes the creation of a $15.9-billion national housing co-investment fund, a system of grants and low-interest loans that will help construct up to 100,000 new affordable residential units across the country.

Government programs often work in silos, but if all three levels can come together to harmonize this new spending with other programs, initiatives and long-term planning goals, there is significant opportunity to leverage our investment, inspire innovative private development and affect positive change in Canadian cities.

In Winnipeg, mature neighbourhoods have seen a population decline over the last 40 years, generally due to smaller household sizes. The density in Wolseley, River Heights and St. Boniface, for example, has declined by as much as 30 per cent since the 1970s. This reduction in density leaves fewer taxpayers paying for a greater share of services and infrastructure, while making local commerce, schools, libraries and community centres less viable.

Read
Monday, Dec. 4, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Old Grace Housing Co-op in Wolseley is an inspiring example of affordable housing in an established neighbourhood.

Climate revenues could transform transportation

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Climate revenues could transform transportation

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Nov. 14, 2017

Premier Brian Pallister recently unveiled the made-in-Manitoba “Climate and Green Plan,” a strategy to reduce the province’s greenhouse gas emissions and battle climate change.

The central component of the proposed policy is a $25-per-tonne tax on carbon emissions, typically generated from burning fossil fuels.

The plan has been presented as a work in progress, with details to be finalized in the coming months. How the government spends the projected $260 million raised each year by the carbon tax will be a critical piece to realizing the plan’s projected emissions reductions.

With almost two-thirds of Manitobans living in Winnipeg’s metropolitan area, targeted, forward-looking investment in the city’s urban infrastructure represents a significant opportunity to make bold moves that leverage those dollars to reduce our carbon footprint, grow the economy and build a more competitive and progressive city.

Read
Tuesday, Nov. 14, 2017

BORIS MINKEVICH / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES
Climate-plan revenues should be directed to initiatives that increase Winnipeg’s population density, such as rapid transit.

Time to love Portage and Main

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Time to love Portage and Main

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 23, 2017

Picture the best urban neighbourhood you have ever visited, the most dynamic city centre you’ve been to. Are you surrounded by people on bustling sidewalks, open to busy shops and restaurants? Where is it — maybe Vancouver, Montreal, New York or Paris?

Why do we go on vacation to fall in love with cities with this vibrancy and urban quality, then come home and not demand the same for our own city? Why do we believe a great urban experience can only happen somewhere else?

Winnipeg’s endless Portage and Main debate is a glaring example of this attitude. The value of bringing people back to our central intersection is seemingly only measured by its effect on vehicular traffic. The speed at which we can evacuate downtown in a car is often seen as the only legitimate priority in the debate. Qualitative, and even economic, arguments are brushed aside as meaningless.

Traffic congestion is an important part of the discussion that will need to be resolved. Other intersections, such as Broadway and Main or Portage and Memorial, have a similar range of traffic volumes, and operate without extreme congestion or pedestrian danger. It is important that we not let traffic become the only issue we focus on when making important city-building decisions like this. Elevating the role of pedestrians downtown can be a step towards making Winnipeg one of those vibrant and prosperous cities we fall in love with.

Read
Monday, Oct. 23, 2017

WAYNE GLOWACKI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILE
A focus on pedestrians rather than traffic speed could help make Portage and Main a place to love.

City can learn from Amazon search

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

City can learn from Amazon search

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 2, 2017

Amazon, the Seattle-based online shopping pioneer, recently sent shock waves across the continent when it initiated a search for a location to build a massive second headquarters somewhere in North America. In an unusual move, the company released an open call, seven-page request for proposals (RFP) inviting jurisdictions in Canada and the U.S. to submit plans to lure the technology giant to their city. The winner is promised a capital investment of US$5 billion and employment for up to 50,000 skilled workers.

Predictably, civic leaders from coast to coast, including those in Winnipeg, have announced their intention to enter the lucrative Amazon sweepstakes. Most realists would accept that cities such as Winnipeg have very little chance of winning, but the exercise of responding can be a valuable opportunity to understand what makes a city competitive in the battle for outside investment and new corporate offices. Amazon’s wish list is a clear window into what progressive companies are looking for when evaluating a move to a new location.

The RFP reads like an urbanist’s dream, specifically outlining a preference for sites offering dense, pedestrian-friendly, connected neighbourhoods that foster a sense of place and cultivate the local culture. The document celebrates Amazon’s urban campus in Seattle as a “city maker,” supporting “restaurants, services and coffee shops... with its sustainable buildings and open spaces.” It goes on to indicate the new location could be similar.

Amazon’s evaluation criteria suggest that cities able to offer urban lifestyle options will be the winners in attracting companies in the knowledge-based economy. Car-dominant cities without a diversity in its quality of life choices will be less competitive in the city-versus-city battle for outside investment.

Read
Monday, Oct. 2, 2017

Elaine Thompson / The Associated Press Files
Construction at Amazon’s campus in downtown Seattle. Amazon’s search for a second headquarters provides insight into what makes a city attractive to progressive companies.

Imagination could give Arlington Bridge new life

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Imagination could give Arlington Bridge new life

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Sep. 5, 2017

The three graceful arches of the old Arlington Bridge have cast their curving shadows on Winnipeg’s central rail yards for 105 years. It’s become a quintessentially Winnipeg experience to ascend the bridge’s steep ramp and cross its narrow deck as the rhythm of steel girders ticks by. The sweeping panorama — a rarity in a flat city — lays out below, with rows of trains vanishing into the horizon, the downtown skyline rising over an elm tree canopy beyond.

Few bridges provide an experience as unique as Arlington, and even fewer provide a better story. The prevailing legend explains that the ramps are so steep because the bridge, built in England, was actually designed to span the Nile River. When a contract fell through, the structure was offered to Winnipeg on the cheap and shoehorned into the site. Built specifically to run streetcars to the North End, the steep ramps prevented a single trolley from ever crossing.

With all its quirks, calls for the bridge’s replacement go back more than 70 years. This month, the City of Winnipeg will begin public consultation for the design of a new $300-million bridge, with more lanes, better emergency vehicle and transit access and less-steep ramps for pedestrians and cyclists. Public art will attempt to make the modern roadway more visually appealing.

The starting point for public consultation assumes the old bridge will be demolished, specifically identifying that it cannot be repurposed to another use. The steep ramps and aging structure are provided as anecdotal reasons for this decision, but no formal study identifying the criteria used in this assessment has been made public.

Read
Tuesday, Sep. 5, 2017

OMA+OLIN Architects
The decommissioned 11th Street Bridge in Washington, D.C,. has been reimagined as a multi-functional community space.

Project shows diagonal parking works

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Project shows diagonal parking works

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 14, 2017

There’s something counterintuitive about adding cars to a street to make it a better place for pedestrians, but that’s what happened in downtown Winnipeg when an old idea recently became new.

Three weeks ago, the city implemented an eight-month pilot project on Bannatyne Avenue in the Exchange District. Using paint and temporary planters, existing parallel parking was re-oriented into diagonal parking stalls, like something you might see in a small town or on an old photograph. The goal of the project is to increase the amount of on-street parking, something businesses and area residents have been asking for. While 10 new spaces have been created, the new configuration has had a much broader effect. It has changed the way people drive and has transformed the character of the street.

Modern diagonal parking is part of a phenomenon that began in Germany in the 1970s, called “vekehrsberuhigung” — a great word if you are ever playing German Scrabble, but more easily remembered as “traffic calming.” The strategy introduces design elements to a street that intuitively slow traffic and make drivers more aware. The intent is not to cause congestion, but to create urban streets that are safe and comfortable for all users — drivers, cyclists and pedestrians. Traffic calming attempts to match the physical environment with desired traffic speed, instead of relying on signage and police enforcement.

Some important traffic calming measures include eliminating one-way streets, making tighter radius corners, raised plateau crosswalks and, most importantly, narrowing roads and a driver’s field of vision. This last point is part of the success of diagonal parking as a traffic calming tool. When a driver’s field of vision expands, speeds intuitively increase. We instinctively drive faster on Pembina Highway than on Albert Street, regardless of posted limits.

Read
Monday, Aug. 14, 2017

Diagonal parking instructions eased drivers into the pilot project. (Supplied)

Strong fire-safety measures critical

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Strong fire-safety measures critical

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 24, 2017

In June, the world watched in disbelief as soaring flames and columns of thick smoke ravaged Grenfell Tower in London. Dramatic images and heartbreaking reports of desperate residents trapped inside streamed across social media. So far, at least 80 people are believed to have lost their lives in the tragedy.

The source of the fire appears to have been a refrigerator inside one of the units on the fourth floor. From there, the flames spread rapidly, and within half an hour, the fire was out of control.

A year earlier, the 43-year-old, 24-storey apartment underwent a $15-million renovation. This upgrade included a new heating system, windows and exterior siding. The siding product used was an aluminum panel with a flammable polyethylene backing, layered on top of polyisocyanurate insulation, which burns easily, giving off toxic cyanide fumes.

Fire-safety experts are pointing to this highly flammable exterior siding as a likely cause of the rapid spread of the fire from floor to floor, as well as being the source of deadly gases in the air. At least three survivors were treated for cyanide poisoning.

Read
Monday, Jul. 24, 2017

RICK FINDLER / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS FILES
Smoke billows after fire engulfed the 24-storey Grenfell Tower in west London on June 14.

Heritage builds opportunity downtown

Brent Bellamy 7 minute read Preview

Heritage builds opportunity downtown

Brent Bellamy 7 minute read Monday, Jul. 3, 2017

Winnipeg’s Main Street has long been a symbol of the city itself. Starting out as a muddy cart path between two fur trading posts, it would grow to become the economic engine of Western Canada, lined with magnificent buildings along Banker’s Row. With two grand railway stations welcoming thousands of settlers every day, Main Street was the centre of Winnipeg’s early prosperity. 

As the decades passed, Main Street would also come to symbolize Winnipeg’s decline. Construction of the Trizec Building in 1978 saw demolition of an entire streetscape of almost 40 buildings, resulting in the loss of a neighbourhood and countless small businesses. The pedestrian barricades at Portage and Main have divided the street in half for 38 years and counting. These moves have resulted in the once-vibrant thoroughfare now being lined with surface parking, including a gravel lot at the city’s most important intersection. Land values and development pressure are so low that a one-storey restaurant can offer an entire city block of free parking in the heart of downtown. 

Fortunes may be changing for Winnipeg’s oldest street. The city’s new tallest building will soon rise at Graham Avenue, removing the walls at Portage Avenue will stitch the street back together, and The Forks’ Railside development will bring several hundred new residents to the area. Lost in these major changes, however, are two little old buildings that have stood witness to the street’s ups and downs and are today finding new life, promising to be important contributors to its renewal. 

The three-storey Fortune Block, built in 1882 by real estate speculator Mark Fortune, who would later die aboard the Titanic, comes from a time when Main Street looked like a scene out of a Clint Eastwood spaghetti western. Despite being one of the oldest buildings in downtown, it and the adjoining MacDonald Block were threatened with demolition in 2015. The buildings' owner lobbied for exclusion from the city’s heritage protection list, arguing that they were unsafe, structurally unsound and beyond the point of saving. 

Read
Monday, Jul. 3, 2017

SUPPLIED
Artist’s rendering of the completed Fortune Block.

Boosting Winterpeg’s ‘destination’ status

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Boosting Winterpeg’s ‘destination’ status

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, May. 16, 2017

For many years, Winnipeg has had an image problem. The popular depiction has been one of a city frozen in a never-ending winter with a downtown filled with nothing but dusty old buildings. Most tourists only recognize Winnipeg from the route map on the screen in the airplane seat in front of them as they pass by at 30,000 feet.

Something appears to be happening lately that is altering this perception. Winnipeg has begun to make regular appearances in international travel blogs and periodicals, including Vogue, Elle and Reader’s Digest, all celebrating the unique Winnipeg experience. Somehow, the city’s rough-around-the-edges character has become cool. To outsiders, our frozen city in the middle of nowhere seems oddly exotic, exemplified by its place alongside Seychelles, Bhutan and the Hawaiian volcanoes in a National Geographic list of the Best Trips of 2016.

The irony of this transition is that the very things that have for so long served as fodder for "Winterpeg" ridicule, are now being celebrated as unique attractions. Eating dinner on the frozen river, skating among artistic warming huts or wandering through a largely intact century-old warehouse district are hailed as must-see, uniquely Winnipeg experiences.

The world is becoming smaller, travel is becoming easier and globalization is making cities more homogenous. As a result, tourists have begun to look more often for unique stories and authentic, local experiences in non-traditional destinations.

Read
Tuesday, May. 16, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Design Quarter Winnipeg is a grassroots initiative that’s pushing to make downtown Winnipeg’s artistic community a tourism destination.

Globalization means opportunity

Brent Bellamy 4 minute read Preview

Globalization means opportunity

Brent Bellamy 4 minute read Monday, Apr. 24, 2017

Imagine if every restaurant in the city was part of an international chain. Even if they were all the finest franchises in the world, they could never replace the experience of a neighbourhood eatery with a menu composed through an understanding of regional foods and nuances of local taste.

This past week, I was invited to the University of Manitoba to talk about the future of Winnipeg architecture with graduating students. I used this line as a metaphor to describe the transformational effects globalization is having on their future profession and the cities they will live in.

Rapid urbanization, unprecedented mobility, digital communication and the standardization of building materials and construction techniques are transforming the practice of architecture, and in turn the image of cities across a culturally homogenizing world. Designers and design ideas travel easily across borders today, meaning local design tradition is giving way to globalization.

Like a restaurant franchise, international architects have become brands that can be purchased as a commodity. In cities such as Vancouver and Toronto, developers clamour to attract the latest global “starchitect,” lending instant credibility to their project. As architects move from one city to another, buildings are increasingly becoming representations of the designers and less of the place and the people they are built for.

Read
Monday, Apr. 24, 2017

BORIS MINKEVICH / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES
Winnipeg’s Canadian Museum for Human Rights is an example of the trend toward globalized design.

Time for feds to help preserve heritage buildings

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Time for feds to help preserve heritage buildings

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 3, 2017

For several decades after the Second World War, many Canadians considered the old buildings in their cities to be symbols of decline, representing a lack of progress. Many cities, throughout the 1960s and ’70s, developed grand plans to replace historic downtown neighbourhoods with freeways, parking lots and mega-projects. In one generation, more than one-fifth of Canada’s historic buildings were demolished.

Values have changed and today the areas in Canadian cities that survived the Modernist planning movement are celebrated as places of opportunity and growth. The busiest strip on a Saturday night in downtown Calgary is Stephen Avenue, a street lined with century-old facades. The lanes of Old Montreal, Vancouver’s Gastown and Ottawa’s Byward Market bustle with residents and tourists year-round. In almost every Canadian city, the trendiest, most interesting urban neighbourhoods are the ones filled with old buildings.

Winnipeg is no different. The 1960s had optimistic plans for riverside freeways, broad avenues and ordered, modern apartment blocks, wiping away the past. Only the city’s slow growth saved its old buildings; the blocks of City Hall, Manitoba Museum and Centennial Concert Hall represent the limited manifestation of a plan that was to eliminate the Warehouse District.

Today, the Exchange District National Historic Site, a collection of 117 turn-of-the-20th-century structures, is a catalyst for renewal in Winnipeg’s downtown. Twenty years ago, the area had a population of about 250. Since then, more than 1,500 residential units have been constructed, including 31 heritage building projects, accounting for more than 900 units — the equivalent of six 20-storey apartment buildings. The area is home to dozens of shops, businesses and restaurants and is downtown’s cultural and social hub. The district has even been celebrated recently as a must-see tourist destination in several periodicals, including National Geographic, Vogue, Elle and Reader’s Digest.

Read
Monday, Apr. 3, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Historic buildings that survived the Modernist demolition craze, such as Winnipeg’s popular Exchange District, are highly valued.

Downtown must embrace winter, not hide from it

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Downtown must embrace winter, not hide from it

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 13, 2017

After enduring a week of arctic wind chill in the month of March, it might be a bad time to discuss Winnipeg’s downtown walkway system, but as one of the five coldest major winter cities in the world, how we design for climate is an important consideration.

For many years, the North American response to winter has been to hide from it. In the 1960s, as downtowns started losing a battle to suburban shopping malls and office parks, civic leaders felt the only way to compete was to mimic this climate-controlled trend and consolidate interior spaces in the city centre.

Montreal was the leader in this movement, beginning construction of the Underground City in 1962, growing to become a staggering 32 kilometres of subterranean tunnels and shopping centres beneath the city. Since that time, 17 indoor pedestrian systems have been developed in cities across North America. Minneapolis boasts the longest continuous network of elevated walkways at 15 kilometres, and Calgary has the largest total length at 18 kilometres.

The idea for Winnipeg’s indoor walkway system began with the 1969 Downtown Development Plan, which envisioned a futuristic city of towers and plazas, interconnected by a vast network of elevated and underground walkways to protect people from winter and allow vehicular traffic to flow more efficiently. To discourage sidewalk use in the summer, the plan proposed “the second-storey habit,” a strategy to pull all retail, commercial and social activities away from the ground level and into the corridors, so people could avoid cars and weather year-round.

Read
Monday, Mar. 13, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Winnipeg’s skywalk system is two kilometres long. Compare that with Calgary’s, which is 18 kilometres long.

Examining five pillars of a big-picture plan

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Examining five pillars of a big-picture plan

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Feb. 21, 2017

The recent release of Canada’s 2016 census was like catnip for us statistics nerds. Across the country, we slouched at our computers into the early hours, poring over everything from aggregate dissemination areas to census agglomerations.

The census revealed that Winnipeg is growing faster than it has since the 1960s. After entering this century at No. 9, it is poised to soon retake the position of seventh-largest city in the country. Some visible trends were confirmed: mature neighbourhood populations have generally stayed level, the downtown population is growing and the city’s southern suburbs are booming.

Municipalities surrounding Winnipeg have continued to grow faster than the city itself, with Ritchot, Macdonald and Headingley experiencing a growth rate more than double that of the city and province.

The growth of these municipalities has been concentrated overwhelmingly in existing population centres. Many satellite towns are now ringed with suburb-style, low-density subdivisions and are beginning to experience the economic challenges with growth and municipal services with which Winnipeg is currently wrestling.

Read
Tuesday, Feb. 21, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
The capital region’s sprawling growth is encroaching on important farmland and affecting other natural resources.

Give Union Bank Tower the crown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Give Union Bank Tower the crown

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 30, 2017

Union Bank Tower has quietly watched over Winnipeg from the bend in Main Street for 113 years. Symbolic of a more optimistic time, its full significance has been lost in our civic memory. If this elegant building stood in one of Canada’s more confident cities, it might adorn postcards and tourist brochures. In Winnipeg, a small bronze plaque on its facade timidly boasts, “The city’s first skyscraper.” A deeper investigation, however, reveals it likely deserves to be celebrated with the much loftier title of “Canada’s first skyscraper.”

The term “skyscraper” was coined in the late 1800s as buildings in Chicago and New York used new technologies to race toward the sky. The first innovation that facilitated the highrise era was the invention of the electric elevator by the Otis Company in 1857. This made the idea of taller buildings more practical, but it was the steel-frame structural system that made them possible. Thin exterior walls could be hung from the frame, known as a curtain-wall system, replacing heavy, load-bearing walls supported from the ground. This allowed buildings to be lighter and more flexible, unlocking the barriers to height.

The world’s first skyscraper is generally recognized as Chicago’s Home Insurance Building, built in 1885. It was the first structure to have all four ingredients of a modern skyscraper: a high-speed elevator, steel skeleton frame, curtain-wall exterior and a height that was well above typical (then considered to be 10 storeys or taller).

It would be reasonable to assume the same four conditions must be present to define what was Canada’s first skyscraper. As expected, Montreal and Toronto most commonly claim to have buildings that own this title.

Read
Monday, Jan. 30, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Winnipeg’s Union Bank Tower can rightfully claim to be Canada’s first skyscraper.

Downtown growth didn’t happen overnight

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Downtown growth didn’t happen overnight

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 9, 2017

If construction cranes in the skyline create optimism in a city, then Winnipeggers might feel particularly confident in 2017.

Downtown is projected to see as many as five highrise towers under construction this year, potentially including a new tallest skyscraper, a first since 201 Portage (formerly the TD tower) passed the Richardson Building almost three decades ago. Along with these towers, population growth in downtown will be supported by three mid-rise apartments and four residential heritage building conversions also slated for construction this year.

An important component of these proposed developments is that they are spread across different areas of downtown and often located near other recently completed housing projects, helping reinforce pockets of residential growth in key areas. Developing unique population nodes that can grow together over time is an important strategy to bring renewal to an over-scaled downtown.

Graham Avenue is poised to bustle with construction as the 24-storey residential and 17-storey office towers at True North Square rise together, structurally topping out by this fall. The $400-million project, heralded as the largest development in downtown Winnipeg’s history, will combine with the recently completed Centrepoint towers on Portage Avenue to form the heart of the sports, hospitality and entertainment district.

Read
Monday, Jan. 9, 2017

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
DCondo on Assiniboine Avenue is one of several residential developments planned or underway downtown.

Developing a road map for growth

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Preview

Developing a road map for growth

Brent Bellamy  5 minute read Monday, Dec. 12, 2016

A little 12-unit condominium project proposed by Ventura Developments for Winnipeg’s Crescentwood neighbourhood has caused quite a stir. The project’s rejection at a community committee meeting has once again sparked public debate about the challenges of trying to build in Winnipeg’s older neighbourhoods.

Infill development of this type is generally seen as a tool to reinvigorate established communities, create affordable housing options and provide cost-efficient use of existing infrastructure.

Over the last several decades, Winnipeg’s mature neighbourhoods have seen a significant population decline due to an aging demographic, higher real estate values that prevent younger residents from moving in and a nationwide trend to smaller household sizes.

River Heights, Wolseley and St. Boniface have all seen a population loss of more than 20 per cent since the 1970s. Crescentwood, the neighbourhood of the Ventura project, today has nearly one-third fewer residents.

Read
Monday, Dec. 12, 2016

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Ventura Developments wants to build a 12-unit, four-storey condo complex on two vacant lots on McMillan Avenue and Harrow Street. City councillors will vote on the project Wednesday.

Road safety by design

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Road safety by design

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 21, 2016

If flying were as dangerous as crossing the street, steamships and passenger trains would still be a thing.

On average, about 600 people die in plane crashes across the entire world each year, while in Canada alone, one pedestrian per day is killed in a vehicle collision. In Manitoba, a pedestrian is hit and injured by a car five times per week, resulting in death once per month.

We have engineered our Canadian cities for speed. Our streets have got bigger; lanes have got wider and traffic flow has been given priority over the safety of other transportation modes, such as walking and cycling. Speed reduces reaction times, increases stopping distances and has a significant effect on accident severity. A pedestrian struck by a car travelling 50 kilometres per hour has an 80 per cent chance of being killed, compared with only five per cent at 30 km/h.

Reducing vehicle speeds is key to road safety, but it’s not as easy as putting up signs and red-light cameras.

Read
Monday, Nov. 21, 2016

SUPPLIED
A raised crosswalk in Copenhagen, Denmark, makes pedestrians and cyclists more visible as they encounter cars at intersections.

Designing the perfect winter city

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Designing the perfect winter city

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 31, 2016

Winter is Winnipeg’s thing. It’s what we’re known for. It unifies us like a legion heading into battle. As we prepare to collectively stare down another winter, however, the city of Edmonton is quietly threatening to invade our turf. They not only showed up last week to beat us at our favourite winter sport, they are now trying to beat us at winter itself.

In a few weeks, Edmonton’s urban planning committee and city council will be presented with an official winter design policy, a planning document that outlines an innovative set of winter-specific urban design guidelines, with the goal of transforming the Alberta capital into an international model for winter city design. Once adopted, its recommendations will influence zoning bylaws, design standards and approval processes by viewing them through the unique lens of winter living. With these new guidelines, Edmonton is hoping to turn a traditional winter hibernation into an outdoor urban celebration.

Winnipeg has led the way with several grassroots festivals, activities and community initiatives that have begun to change our attitudes about winter living, but embedding winter-specific design principles into official civic policy is a visionary idea that could have a transformational effect on the character of Edmonton’s architectural and urban form.

The guidelines will implement several design strategies to help make outdoor spaces comfortable and inviting in all seasons, by focusing on the creation of comfortable urban microclimates. Wind and sunlight are the two key elements that impact thermal comfort in urban areas. Environment Canada has indicated by controlling these factors through design, we can make outdoor public spaces feel warmer by as much as 10 C on cold days.

Read
Monday, Oct. 31, 2016

SUPPLIED
By viewing the design of northern cities through the lens of winter living, the opportunity exists to transform the colder months from a time of hibernation to one of celebration.

Pilot projects going permanent

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Pilot projects going permanent

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2016

Resistance to change is a natural human condition. We feel security in what is familiar and see risk in what is unknown.

As cities grow and progress, this inertia can be a difficult obstacle for planners, developers and political leaders trying to implement new ideas. When change threatens to alter familiar, established patterns in a community, opposition galvanizes, and decision-makers face the uphill challenge of articulating the goals and benefits of new proposals in an effort to alleviate neighbourhood concerns.

Cities across North America are looking for new ways to engage in this dialogue and inspire a greater feeling of public inclusion in the decision-making process. In some cases, cities are implementing short-term pilot projects as a method of testing ideas and building community support.

Pilot projects allow residents to observe the real-world effects of an idea, fundamentally changing the nature of public outreach. Traditional open house-type consultation offers case studies from other cities, academic theory and glossy renderings that often do little to change attitudes and preconceptions. By implementing smaller-scale pilot projects, the starting point for public engagement is shifted from a hypothetical description to a discussion about an observed experience.

Read
Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2016

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
New York City’s Times Square has been transformed, thanks to a pilot project that showed how it could be used by pedestrians.

Makes no sense to dismiss rail relocation, riverwalk protection without knowing costs, benefits

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Makes no sense to dismiss rail relocation, riverwalk protection without knowing costs, benefits

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Sep. 19, 2016

There is always a reason not to be bold. There are always other priorities. It is always easier to continue doing what you know.

What has made most of the world’s great cities great is the ability to embrace a vision for the future and demonstrate the courage to make choices that challenge the status quo.

Manitoba’s PC government recently passed on two opportunities to lead a courageous dialogue about the long-term vision for our city. By cancelling the study into rail relocation and deciding not to further investigate a report on the use of the floodway to control summer river levels in the city, the opportunity for informed public debate was lost.

When hearing the words rail relocation, most Winnipeggers instinctively roll their eyes and say it’s a prohibitively expensive dream that could never happen.

Read
Monday, Sep. 19, 2016

KEN GIGLIOTTI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES

City's thirst for growth fees ignores their power as a planning tool

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

City's thirst for growth fees ignores their power as a planning tool

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Aug. 29, 2016

For the last 50 years, Winnipeg’s built-up geographic area has been increasing at a rate of more than twice the city’s population growth. There are 20 per cent fewer people living in River Heights today than in 1970. In Wolseley, the population is down 36 per cent, St. Boniface 23 per cent and even busy Osborne Village has seen a population decline of 11 per cent during that time.

The city’s population density is lower today than it has ever been — and it continues to drop. We want to live large. The average new Canadian home size, growing to almost 2,000 square feet today from 1,050 square feet in 1975, is a clear indication we like space.

Why does it matter? Shouldn’t we be free to live wherever we want?

The difficult reality is that low population density has had a significant effect on the economic viability of our city. Sprawling growth is at the root of almost everything we complain about: taxes, city services, potholes and traffic. Only mosquitoes and winter seem exempt from its effects.

Read
Monday, Aug. 29, 2016

supplied
An infill project in River Heights: the city should use a carrot-and-stick approach with growth fees to discourage sprawl and encourage projects that improve population density, Brent Bellamy writes.

Uniting nations: A look at the design submissions to replace the iconic Peace Tower

Brent Bellamy 13 minute read Preview

Uniting nations: A look at the design submissions to replace the iconic Peace Tower

Brent Bellamy 13 minute read Monday, Aug. 8, 2016

In the southwest corner of Manitoba, nestled within the rolling hills of the Turtle Mountains is a grand, formal garden dedicated to global peace. Its manicured geometric layout, aligned with the international border, is an image one might expect to find cascading from a medieval European castle. The backdrop for this garden, however, is hills, forests and lakes that sprawl north into Canada and an endless horizon of glistening wheat fields stretching into the United States.

Dedicated in 1932, the International Peace Garden is a formal Renaissance-style plan with a symmetrical composition of pathways, terraces and planter beds, centred on a primary axis running for 1.5 kilometres along the international boundary. In 1982, to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the park, Number Ten Architectural Group of Winnipeg was hired to design a Peace Tower that would complete the formal axis at the western end of the garden.

The scheme proposed a monument of four columns, each 37 metres tall, representing people from the four corners of the Earth. Seen on an axis, the four towers appear as two, with the border running between them, a representation of two distinct nations built on shared ideals. The towers have become the iconic symbol and focal point of the formal garden.

Regrettably, over the last number of years, the concrete towers have developed an issue with moisture infiltration that has begun to degrade their internal structure. The concrete has started to crack, and the structural base is crumbling. After exhausting all solutions to save them, the difficult decision was made to demolish the iconic landmark, set to happen this winter.

Read
Monday, Aug. 8, 2016

Interwoven

Lane it on the line

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Lane it on the line

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Jul. 18, 2016

The back lane was a perfect spot to play street hockey when we were kids. The narrow alley was enclosed and protected, houses were close-set, allowing our parents to maintain a watchful eye. The occasional slow-moving vehicle could be accommodated simply with an enthusiastic howl of ‘car!’

The intimacy and human scale that makes residential alleys so great for street hockey are characteristics shared with the narrow urban lanes found throughout many downtown areas. These attractive qualities are leading cities around the world to explore the potential of re-engaging these forgotten urban connectors.

Streets with a similar personal scale inspire the vibrant sidewalk culture that makes European city centres an attractive vacation destination for so many, but in our downtown we demand wide, straight roadways designed primarily to funnel cars as quickly as possible into the suburbs. Any efforts to narrow these thoroughfares and improve the pedestrian experience are often met with strong opposition.

The city’s back lanes, however, might provide an opportunity to efficiently create this welcoming pedestrian environment within existing infrastructure. These narrow, enclosed spaces, generally used for loading and garbage collection, are being reimagined in many cities as an alternate pedestrian network superimposed on the larger street grid, introducing lively, people-first, public space.

Read
Monday, Jul. 18, 2016

Supplied
The silhouette of Batman adorns a downtown alleyway. Public art such as graffiti gives alleyways their unique, urban character.

Cyclist safety in numbers, not helmets

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Cyclist safety in numbers, not helmets

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Jun. 27, 2016

Wearing a helmet when you ride a bike will reduce your risk of injury in an accident. The mandatory helmet law currently proposed by Winnipeg city council likely will not.

This seems like a contradictory statement, but unlike motorcycle-helmet and automobile-seatbelt laws, bike safety relies on a set of unique variables that require a more complex response than simply forcing everyone to wear a helmet.

A 2015 study by the University of British Columbia is the most comprehensive resource for this assertion. It looked at 11 cities in Canada over a five-year period, comparing hospitalization rates between jurisdictions with and without helmet laws. The study was one of the first to pro-rate injuries with the number of bike trips taken. Its conclusions could not find a definitive correlation between helmet legislation and hospitalization rates.

Helmets reduce the risk of head injuries by up to 85 per cent, and helmet legislation generally increases use.

Read
Monday, Jun. 27, 2016

WAYNE GLOWACKI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Wearing a helmet while cycling, as Mayor Brian Bowman did while leading 25 cyclists from at Assiniboine Park to The Forks on Bike to Work Day last Friday, won’t necessarily increase your safety as much as riding in a large group will.

Park upgrades raise the bar

By Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Park upgrades raise the bar

By Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, May. 9, 2016

You would be hard-pressed to find a North American city the size of Winnipeg blessed with a similar number of high-quality cultural organizations and amenities.

The Canadian Museum for Human Rights and the zoo’s Journey to Churchill are the most recent major additions to the city’s cultural scene, but the development is not stopping there.

The Manitoba Museum recently began an expansion of Alloway Hall, and the Winnipeg Art Gallery is progressing on its mission to build the world’s premier centre of Inuit art.

In Assiniboine Park, designs are underway for a unique horticultural attraction that will be the final piece of the park’s modern redevelopment.

Read
Monday, May. 9, 2016

supplied
The Butterfly House will be designed to give visitors to the Leaf the impression they are soaring above the rest of the building.

City issues neglected in election

By Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

City issues neglected in election

By Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Apr. 18, 2016

Nearly 55 per cent of Manitoba’s population lives inside Winnipeg’s Perimeter Highway, representing more than 60 per cent of the province’s employment and two-thirds of its GDP. Despite this concentration of people and commerce, urban issues have seemingly not been a central focus of the provincial election campaign. Manitoba’s provincial budget is 12 times greater than Winnipeg’s municipal budget, meaning the province’s values and civic priorities have a substantial influence on the type of city we build.

A recent Winnipeg Free Press poll found the top priority for Winnipeg voters is roads and potholes. It was identified as being the most important issue more than twice as often as health care or taxes. While this result may be disheartening for those hoping for a more inspiring election dialogue, it is hardly surprising.

We have built a city that has made the car a central focus our lifestyle. For most Winnipeggers, almost every activity done outside of the home requires a drive in an automobile. It logically follows that potholes would become the key voter concern.

The way in which the provincial government chooses to respond to this issue will affect the shape and civic competitiveness of Winnipeg. Will the choice be simply to fill the potholes and hope they don’t come back, or will the province engage in more holistic solutions that address the root causes of our infrastructure deficit?

Read
Monday, Apr. 18, 2016

MIKE DEAL / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS files
Rapid transit has proven a great success in major cities across Canada, yet none of the major parties has touched on it during the provincial election campaign.

Two-ways to revitalize downtown

By Brent Bellamy  6 minute read Preview

Two-ways to revitalize downtown

By Brent Bellamy  6 minute read Monday, Mar. 28, 2016

Building a prosperous downtown is a two-way street — literally.

Later this year, downtown Winnipeg will celebrate its 60th anniversary of becoming a one-way city. Our transition away from urban two-way streets began some 30 years earlier, however, as car ownership grew, and for the first time traffic flows started to become a public concern. This means, of course, we in Winnipeg are also approaching our 90th anniversary of complaining about traffic.

To improve vehicular circulation in the growing city centre, new bylaws were introduced in 1931 that included the elimination of diagonal parking, the allowance of right turns on red lights and the creation of a handful of one-way streets.

In 1955 it was decided even more changes were needed. The boulevard trees that once lined downtown streets were cut down, and roads were widened, streetcars were removed to provide more room for vehicles, and by fall 1956 the majority of remaining streets in the downtown were converted to one-way traffic.

Read
Monday, Mar. 28, 2016

photo by Brent Bellamy
Returning two-way traffic to downtown streets will increase safety, attract more commercial traffic and encourage people to reside in the area.

Sprawl fees ease growing pains

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Sprawl fees ease growing pains

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 7, 2016

‘Growth must pay for growth.’

This was the mantra repeated by Mayor Brian Bowman after revealing in his 2016 state of the city address negotiations are underway to create a new growth fee to help pay for the infrastructure costs associated with suburban development.

Faced with a $7-billion infrastructure deficit and a 2016 municipal budget filled with increased taxes and fees attempting to make up for a $74-million shortfall, our civic leaders appear to be coming to the realization the low-density suburbs we have built for decades in Canada are not financially sustainable in the long term.

Searching for a solution, cities across the country are turning to a ‘sprawl tax’ to help fill suburban-development funding gaps. Calgary recently implemented a charge on new subdivisions that’s expected to increase the cost of a new home by up to $6,000.

Read
Monday, Mar. 7, 2016

BRENT BELLAMY PHOTO
Image is of the Kenaston Underpass, part of infrastructure investment made by the city to accommodate suburban growth that is not factored into developer costs.

Pedestrian traffic at Portage & Main would invigorate all of Winnipeg

Brent Bellamy 8 minute read Preview

Pedestrian traffic at Portage & Main would invigorate all of Winnipeg

Brent Bellamy 8 minute read Tuesday, Feb. 16, 2016

Nothing stirs the passions of Winnipeggers more than talking about traffic. Those emotions boiled over recently when the Downtown Winnipeg BIZ hosted, Imagine Portage and Main, a symposium to stimulate conversation about the future of our city’s once iconic intersection.

The event’s guest speaker was Tim Tompkins, president of the Times Square Alliance, a business improvement district that successfully navigated a public consultation process to transform the New York intersection from a seedy, car-dominated crossing into a safe, pedestrian destination and vibrant public space.

Judging by the response on social media, Internet forums, radio callin shows and newspaper comment sections, the challenge of convincing Winnipeggers to consider a similar evolution for their famous intersection will be even more daunting than persuading eight million New Yorkers.

To move the debate forward, the following paragraphs will identify the key concerns that arose through the symposium in opposition to reopening Portage and Main and provide a brief response from the proponents’ side.

Read
Tuesday, Feb. 16, 2016

Phil Hossack / Winnipeg Free Press files
Rush hour traffic moves through Portage and Main.

Building a better neighbourhood

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Building a better neighbourhood

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 25, 2016

It's not often our little city makes headlines in major international newspapers. When it does, it's rarely the precursor to a positive story.

A recent banner in Britain's prominent daily the Guardian, made it clear its Winnipeg tale would be no different.

Titled Crime in the community: when 'designer' social housing goes wrong, the column presents a less-than-glowing review of Centre Village, a Manitoba Housing complex on Balmoral Street in the Central Park neighbourhood, designed by local firm 5468796 Architecture.

With 441 reader comments and extensive social-media attention, the story received significant levels of negative commentary.

Read
Monday, Jan. 25, 2016

James Brittain
The courtyard at Centre Village in Winnipeg's Central Park neighbourhood is meant to be a safe meeting place for residents.

Winnipeg’s skyline looking up

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Winnipeg’s skyline looking up

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 4, 2016

North American cities are often judged by their skylines. The postcard image of towers set along the horizon seem to stand like a bar-chart representation of a city's power and affluence.

By this metric, 2015 was a pretty good year for Winnipeg, with five new downtown highrise towers under construction. The last time the city saw that many cranes in the skyline, the Winnipeg Jets' top line wasn't Ladd, Little and Wheeler, it was Hull, Nilsson and Hedberg, struggling to make the playoffs in 1974.

In many cities, highrise construction is largely driven by high-end condominium development, but Winnipeg's new towers respond to a range of functions and demographics.

The twin peaks of the CentrePoint development on Portage Avenue feature office space, two ground-floor restaurants, loft-style condominium units and a trendy boutique hotel. Residential density south of Broadway will be bolstered by the luxury condominiums of D Condo and the rental apartments and townhouses of Heritage Landing, both going up on Assiniboine Avenue. The University of Winnipeg's residence rising behind the art gallery will include a unique blend of affordable student housing and market rentals.

Read
Monday, Jan. 4, 2016

brent bellamy photo
The 'flying saucer' under construction at the base of the Disraeli Freeway is among the many new developments making a mark on Winnipeg's skyline.

Building a better city

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Building a better city

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Dec. 14, 2015

Rio de Janeiro, Kyoto, Copenhagen and Paris... it reads like a great bucket list of travel destinations, but these cities are more significantly connected as hosts of high-profile global climate change conferences.

From 1992 in Brazil to last week in France, the nations of the world have repeatedly come together in exotic locales to negotiate agreements for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The general pattern of results has been: set emissions targets, ignore them, set easier emissions targets, ignore them, and repeat.

With an increased recognition that the environmental clock is ticking, there is hope the Paris climate conference is the one that ends the cycle of inaction.

As one of the top-10 GHG emitters in the world, Canada came to France pledging a 30 per cent reduction of 2005 levels by 2030. Partnering in the effort to finally achieve significant reductions, individual provinces have come forward with their own targets -- including Manitoba, where emissions are planned to be cut by one-third over the same period.

Read
Monday, Dec. 14, 2015

Winnipeg's built size in 1970 (in yellow) compared to 2015: the population has increased 30 per cent, but the built area has increased by more than double that.

The past must be part of the future

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

The past must be part of the future

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Nov. 23, 2015

Thirty years ago, Winnipeg's Exchange District was a hollow collection of pollution-stained industrial warehouses surrounded by treeless streets and empty sidewalks. At night, a checkerboard of dimly lit windows behind the facades of darkened buildings would reveal a subculture of artists and musicians using the low-rent spaces as studios and squatter residences. From the street, the heavy brick walls would only partially muffle the nocturnal sound of rehearsing local rock bands, as old single-pane windows pulsed to the beat of the music inside.

Albert Street was heart of the city's seedy 'red light district', anchored by the Royal Albert and St. Charles Hotels. Their dingy bars, smelling like a potent cocktail of sweat, smoke and marijuana, were the centre of a vibrant local punk rock scene. The district itself was the heart of a thriving artistic community.

Today, the Exchange is peppered with luxury condominiums, trendy boutiques and restaurants. Old Market Square has become a focus for summer festivals, and the tree-lined sidewalks are often busy with pedestrians.

The area continues to be the hub of Winnipeg's creative community, but today the rock bands have been replaced by students, dancers, architects, designers, filmmakers and digital entrepreneurs. Several of the area's buildings have been redeveloped, but others remain underused and in danger of falling beyond repair. Many of the low-rent artists' spaces that were the seeds of the area's renaissance have disappeared, as expensive upgrades required to meet current building codes preclude anything but high-return redevelopment.

Read
Monday, Nov. 23, 2015

trevor hagan / winnipeg free press files
A Jets game brought fans to Old Market Square in October. The area's success threatens to overtake itself if the pieces that led to its growth aren't included in its future.

Winnipeg's urban forest could be one of the city's most valuable assets

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Winnipeg's urban forest could be one of the city's most valuable assets

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Nov. 2, 2015

As Winnipeg's trees drop their leaves and brace themselves for another winter, the full effects of the city's tireless battle against Dutch elm disease has revealed itself once again. Trees resigned to their ultimate fate wear an orange dot of paint like a scarlet letter, and significant gaps can now be seen in the once-continuous tree canopy that rises above many of the city's neighbourhoods.

In 1900, Winnipeg's civic leaders decided that to elevate the image of their gritty, featureless prairie town, residential streets should be built with boulevards and lined with grand trees. The American elm was the species of choice because it was beautiful, resilient and readily available to be transplanted from the city's riverbanks.

That forward-thinking decision has defined the image of Winnipeg for more than a century. The quality of light filtered through a cathedral arch of 25-metre-high elm trees is a uniquely Winnipeg experience. These trees today form the backbone of an impressive urban forest, one of the city's truly special attributes.

Looking beyond esthetics, cities across North America have begun to study the value of their urban forests as a tool to inform the political policy and public investment that guides the civic economy and environment.

Read
Monday, Nov. 2, 2015

John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press Files
Winnipeg's cityscape and elm canopy.

Consider parties’ stand on municipal issues when you vote

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Consider parties’ stand on municipal issues when you vote

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2015

To most of the world, the image of Canada is best represented by a snow globe containing a miniature Mountie sitting on his horse, overlooking an emerald lake framed by majestic mountain peaks.

The reality of course, is Canada is one of the most urban (or more precisely suburban) nations on Earth. The 35 largest cities in our country are home to two-thirds of its population, create 70 per cent of all employment and represent three-quarters of the national GDP. Cities are the cultural and economic engine that drives Canada forward, and most importantly to the politicians trying to win the federal election, they are home to most of Canada’s voters.

This election has seen an uncharacteristic focus on the policies that affect our nation’s cities. In past campaigns, discussion has typically stayed away from issues seen as being within the municipal jurisdiction, but over the past month, each federal party has made significant policy announcements hoping to appeal to the urban voter.

Canada is the only member of the G8 and one of the few western nations that does not have a federal department of cities to co-ordinate national strategies and programs with municipalities. In the 1970s, prime minister Pierre Trudeau created a department of urban affairs, but it lasted less than a decade after losing a turf war with the provinces. Despite this fragmented relationship, the federal government continues to play a vital role in city-building simply because it controls most of our tax dollars. This makes it important for city-dwellers to consider each party’s urban priorities before casting their vote next week.

Read
Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2015

Boris Minkevich / Free Press files
WestEnd Commons is an example of how federal investment can have an impact at the neighbourhood level.

Rail relocation should be on radar

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Rail relocation should be on radar

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 21, 2015

The Arlington Bridge originally being built to span the Nile River is one of many stories that live on in Winnipeg folklore. Its legend sits alongside Winnie the Pooh, the real James Bond, Bob Hope's first golf game and a legislative building filled with mystical secrets of the Freemasons.

Sadly however, it appears the story of the Arlington Bridge will soon be lost to us.

The city recently announced that after more than a century of spanning Winnipeg's central rail yard, the familiar silver structure with its steep ramps and skyline views is scheduled to be taken down and sold for scrap.

This weekend, a public open house was held to present the options for its replacement.

Read
Monday, Sep. 21, 2015

Brent Bellamy photo
The century-old Arlington Bridge across the Canadian Pacific Railway yards is currently slated for replacement and demolition.

From parking lot to urban paradise

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

From parking lot to urban paradise

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Aug. 31, 2015

It is rare for a city to be given an opportunity to build a brand new neighbourhood in the heart of its downtown. When it happens, it is usually the result of an industry that was once the economic engine relocating out of the modern core.

In Toronto, the railway lands along Lake Ontario have seen a multibillion-dollar transformation into a forest of highrises, altering the city's postcard skyline image into something resembling lower Manhattan. False Creek was once the industrial heart of Vancouver, but today it is home to 60,000 people living in a signature West Coast condo tower neighbourhood.

When the rail yards at the intersection of the Red and Assiniboine rivers were closed 30 years ago, Winnipeg was given that same opportunity -- but our city went in a different direction.

Instead of a skyscraper community, we transformed our land into an important public place that is today a jewel in the city's crown and one of Western Canada's top tourist destinations.

Read
Monday, Aug. 31, 2015

Submitted image
An artist's rendering of the proposed development of The Forks' Railside lands in the heart of Winnipeg.

Prairie icons in danger of extinction

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Prairie icons in danger of extinction

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Aug. 10, 2015

Summer is a season of road trips. For many Manitobans, the idea of driving across the prairie evokes a nostalgic image of a pastoral landscape. A black ribbon of asphalt is seen vanishing toward a razor-sharp divide between golden wheat fields and a brilliant blue sky. The horizon line is broken only by the angular silhouette of a soaring grain elevator, its familiar form appearing in endless repetition as the miles pass behind.

Today, those iconic wooden towers are becoming an increasingly rare feature in this idyllic image. At their peak, almost 6,000 elevators dotted the Canadian Prairies, sitting every 12 to 16 kilometres along the rail lines. Over the past few decades, as family farms and transportation networks have modernized and consolidated, the role of the local town elevator has been lost. Fewer than 10 per cent of those 6,000 are still standing, with only half of those remaining in operation.

Despite this loss, the grain elevator remains a lasting part of Canada's national identity. Its story is found in the DNA of rural life. Elevators have featured prominently in Canadian art and literature, on currency, postage stamps and even on government advertising used to lure European settlers west a century ago.

The first wooden grain elevator in Canada was built in 1879 in Niverville. It was a small, round building powered by two horses. Until this time, grain was stored in flat warehouses (one such example still exists in Brookdale) and brought to market in bags that were loaded by hand. The arrival of the railway presented an opportunity to ship Prairie grain to the world, but this would require a larger and more advanced system of transfer. In response, the modern grain elevator was born.

Read
Monday, Aug. 10, 2015

Submitted photo

Empowerment on wheels: It’s time to support lifestyle choices of all

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Empowerment on wheels: It’s time to support lifestyle choices of all

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Jul. 13, 2015

In an odd twist of Winnipeg politics, Couns. Jeff Browaty, Russ Wyatt, Ross Eadie, Shawn Dobson and Jason Schreyer are playing a role usually reserved for special-interest lobby groups by airing radio ads to rally public opinion against the pedestrian-and-cycling strategy, which council will vote on Wednesday. The radio ads claim, "Mayor and council are rushing through a long-term plan to spend $300 million on commuter cycling infrastructure."

As with all political sound bites, the targeted message often requires context to be fully understood.

In 2011, council approved the transportation master plan. This document outlines a series of principles intended to guide the development of Winnipeg's transportation infrastructure in the next 20 years. The plan identifies spending of more than $5 billion on a number of projects that include new streets, ring roads, bridges, underpasses and rapid-transit lines.

A companion study called for in the plan was initiated under former mayor Sam Katz in 2013 to provide greater detail to the pedestrian and cycling components, resulting in the comprehensive 350-page document heading to council this week.

Read
Monday, Jul. 13, 2015

Mikaela MacKenzie / Winnipeg Free Press
A cyclist uses the divided bike lane on Sherbrook Street. In Winnipeg, there are only four kilometres where a physical barrier protects cyclists out of 400 kilometres of cycling lanes, pathways and trails.

Libraries still the focal point of neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Libraries still the focal point of neighbourhoods

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 6, 2015

What does New York's Carnegie Hall, one of the world's most prestigious concert venues, have in common with a little red-brick library at the foot of Winnipeg's Maryland Bridge?

Both were built by Andrew Carnegie, the richest man in the world at the turn of the last century. Carnegie was a Scottish-American rags-to-riches industrialist who, in 1901, sold his steel company to J.P. Morgan for a staggering $500 million ($14 billion in today's dollars). The eccentric businessman lived with a personal dictum: spend the first third of one's life getting all the education one can, spend the next third making all the money one can, spend the last third giving it away to worthwhile causes.

True to his blueprint, by his death in 1919, Carnegie had given away 90 per cent of his wealth. His most effective and farthest-reaching philanthropy was a program to build neighbourhood libraries. Believing the best way to help someone was to give them the ability to help themselves, he provided municipalities with funding for library construction, with the requirement they remain freely accessible to everyone in the community.

In the end, Carnegie built 2,507 libraries across the world. Three of them were in Winnipeg, including the city's first library at 380 William Ave., just west of downtown. The city's head librarian, who was working in a makeshift space in city hall, wrote to Carnegie in 1901, asking for assistance in creating a new building for his book collection. The response was swift, with Carnegie pledging to erect a $75,000 building if the city would purchase the land and provide operating funds of at least $7,500 per year.

Read
Monday, Jul. 6, 2015

Submitted image
A projecting glass box, visible from the Maryland Bridge, is to be added to the back of the Cornish Library, one of three Winnipeg buildings funded by Andrew Carnegie.

Even if requirements have been met by developers, local opposition can scuttle plans

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Even if requirements have been met by developers, local opposition can scuttle plans

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 15, 2015

'I support development, just not THIS development'

'People are going to park on my street!'

'My property values are going to plummet!'

'The traffic isn't safe for my children!'

Read
Monday, Jun. 15, 2015

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Mature neighbourhoods such as Academy Road can only benefit from an increase in commercial density.

Plan would redefine downtown

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Plan would redefine downtown

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, May. 25, 2015

Most mid-sized North American cities have struggled to maintain a healthy downtown retail market. Winnipeg is no different. Shops that once lined Portage Avenue have been replaced by government offices and for lease signs. Longtime anchors such as Eaton's and Holt Renfrew are now only a memory and The Bay is withering away like a fruit clinging to a branch in late autumn.

The city's sprawling suburbs are served by big-box stores floating in oceans of asphalt parking.

The shape of the city has changed and so have our shopping habits. In the late 1980s, Portage Place mall was constructed as a last-ditch effort to out suburb the suburbs, but it has struggled almost since the day it opened.

Even with downtown's large surface parking lots and 35,000 stalls, it is unlikely there will ever be enough parking to compete with the convenience of suburban shopping. Portage Place has demonstrated that even connected to a large, heated parkade, downtown retail struggles as a commuter destination. The perception remains, however, that urban restaurants, services and retailers must cater to drive-up customers to be successful.

Read
Monday, May. 25, 2015

RUTH BONNEVILLE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Adopting a new bike-and-pedestrian strategy will breathe new life into downtown and create a demand for commercial space.

Bigger roads mean more traffic

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Bigger roads mean more traffic

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, May. 4, 2015

‘THAT money could be better spent fixing our city’s crumbling roads.”

This familiar sentiment is often heard following any new spending announcement that comes out of Winnipeg city hall.

From downtown development grants and rapid transit to the Canadian Museum for Human Rights and Esplanade Riel, the value of many projects is publicly weighed against the number of potholes the investment could have otherwise filled.

Ironically, the only spending generally not criticized for diverting money from road maintenance budgets are those announcing the construction of new roads that will eventually add to the volume of infrastructure needing to be maintained.

Read
Monday, May. 4, 2015

Submitted photo
As streets get expanded, traffic will increase to meet the new capacity. But city politicians must be more responsive to the needs of cyclists, pedestrians and public transit.

The sneaky parking-lot plot

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

The sneaky parking-lot plot

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Apr. 13, 2015

IN the past decade, downtown has experienced development and renewal. To keep up with increasing electrical demand and serve this growth, Manitoba Hydro will soon begin construction on a new $62-million substation downtown.

It will be located on a large parking lot at the corner of Adelaide Street and Notre Dame Avenue, previously owned by nearby Calvary Temple. As part of the transaction to secure the property, Hydro agreed to replace the church parking by co-ordinating the purchase of an adjacent 40-stall lot with the intent of demolishing four commercial buildings along Notre Dame to make room for another 35 cars. An application to the city for a demolition permit has not yet been submitted, but intentions to do so have been made public.

An important obstacle facing this scheme is that demolition to create surface parking as a primary use on a downtown property is no longer permitted. Building demolition is only allowed with proof that an appropriate redevelopment plan is forthcoming.

Read
Monday, Apr. 13, 2015

IN the past decade, downtown has experienced development and renewal. To keep up with increasing electrical demand and serve this growth, Manitoba Hydro will soon begin construction on a new $62-million substation downtown.

It will be located on a large parking lot at the corner of Adelaide Street and Notre Dame Avenue, previously owned by nearby Calvary Temple. As part of the transaction to secure the property, Hydro agreed to replace the church parking by co-ordinating the purchase of an adjacent 40-stall lot with the intent of demolishing four commercial buildings along Notre Dame to make room for another 35 cars. An application to the city for a demolition permit has not yet been submitted, but intentions to do so have been made public.

An important obstacle facing this scheme is that demolition to create surface parking as a primary use on a downtown property is no longer permitted. Building demolition is only allowed with proof that an appropriate redevelopment plan is forthcoming.

Wood expands possibilities

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Wood expands possibilities

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Mar. 23, 2015

Prosperous residents make prosperous cities. With housing costs typically constituting the largest portion of personal expenditures, housing affordability has become a principal determinant of the standard of living in urban areas. Access to adequate housing plays an important role in building strong communities and is a vital social indicator of health, equality and inclusion.

Consistently rising real estate values during the last decade have made access to affordable housing a difficult challenge for cities across Canada. In Winnipeg, since 2005 the average cost of a home has increased by 100 per cent and rental rates have grown by 70 per cent, while the average annual income has increased by only 34 per cent.

One strategy provincial governments are looking at to help bridge this financial gap is reducing construction costs for multi-family housing by revising provincial building codes to allow an expanded use of less expensive wood-frame construction. Currently in Manitoba, buildings made of wood are restricted to a height of four storeys. In 2009, a strong lumber industry pushed the British Columbia government to increase the allowable limit to six storeys, resulting in more than 250 of these structures now being built or nearing completion. Since that time, Ontario and Quebec have followed suit, and last week, the Alberta legislature passed a private member's bill to do the same.

Cities in these provinces see this move as an opportunity to improve access to quality housing options for citizens while at the same time increasing neighbourhood densities to create a more sustainable overall urban form.

Read
Monday, Mar. 23, 2015

WAYNE GLOWACKI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES
The eight-storey building at 136 Market Ave. is a heavy-timber structure.

Beyond big-box: Transition away from mega-stores bodes well for urban landscape

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Beyond big-box: Transition away from mega-stores bodes well for urban landscape

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Mar. 2, 2015

When Disneyland opened its doors in 1955, visitors experienced for the first time a stroll down Main Street U.S.A., Walt Disney's nostalgic interpretation of the central pedestrian shopping strip most North American cities and towns had grown up around.

Winnipeg's example of this high street was Portage Avenue, stretching through downtown from its famous intersection at Main Street. Anchored by Eaton's, the 10th-largest department store in the world, the avenue's shops, theatres and restaurants made it the social, retail and cultural heart of the city for more than a century.

As postwar North American cities began to expand outward with sprawling, low-density suburbs, retail development responded to this new, auto-centric lifestyle by moving away from main street into enclosed suburban shopping malls, set within large, asphalt parking lots. In 1959, Polo Park opened in Winnipeg, and the first shot was fired in the long war against downtown shopping.

The mall would reign as the king of retail for a generation, but the seeds of what would come next were planted in 1962 when the first large, suburban discount Walmart, Target and K-Mart stores opened in the United States. Decades later, retail culture would shift away from the enclosed mall and move toward big-box stores and retail power centres, a trend that is reshaping the modern North American city.

Read
Monday, Mar. 2, 2015

submitted image
Cibinel Architects' proposal for a mixed-use project at the old stadium site lost out to the Target store.

Racial peace through architecture

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Racial peace through architecture

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Feb. 9, 2015

The Maclean's article -- three words that when spoken anywhere in Winnipeg over the past few weeks would invariably spark a passionate and polarizing conversation. It is not often that a national periodical publishes such a charged condemnation of an entire city, but shining a spotlight on Winnipeg's racial divide has created an opportunity to further an already pervasive dialogue about our city's most complex challenge.

More indigenous people live in Winnipeg than in any other Canadian metropolitan area, representing the city's youngest and fastest-growing community. As a proportion, Métis and First Nations people have gone from constituting 2.9 per cent of the city's overall population in 1981 to more than 13 per cent today.

As such, the prosperity of the indigenous community has become indivisible from that of Winnipeg's success as a whole.

Much of the discussion following the Maclean's article has addressed the need to weave together Winnipeg's torn communal fabric. In order to realize long-term prosperity within the indigenous community, enabling greater social and cultural inclusion is imperative. The opportunity exists for Winnipeg to become a leader in this pursuit by exploring new ways of injecting our city's architecture and urban design with indigenous values that allow aboriginal people to see themselves in the spaces and places we inhabit.

Read
Monday, Feb. 9, 2015

MIKE APORIUS/WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Files
Thunderbird House on Main Street is designed by architect Douglas Cardinal, who infuses modern architecture with indigenous beliefs and traditions.

From why Winterpeg to why not?

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

From why Winterpeg to why not?

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Jan. 19, 2015

It is mid-January, and through hard crusts of frozen breath on their tightly wrapped scarves, Winnipeggers across the city can be heard muttering to themselves "Why do I live here?"

Winnipeg doesn't have many things that can truly be described as world-class, but winter is certainly one of them. For a major city (with a population over 500,000) our January average temperatures are the fourth-coldest on Earth, rivalling cities in Siberia, Mongolia and northern China.

In response, over the last 40 years, we have worked to build a city that turns its back on winter. We defend ourselves from it like it's an enemy invader. Our climate-controlled networks sever us from the outside. Portage Avenue was for a century a bustling 12-month, outdoor shopping strip, the retail heart of the city. Then we decided to move to indoor malls, and today we zig-zag in our cars across massive parking lots from one big-box store to the next. We pushed people at our landmark intersection underground, and our sidewalks were emptied by skywalks. The default reaction to everything from segregated bike lanes to active pedestrian sidewalks and great public spaces seems to always be "It's too cold to do that in Winnipeg."

We have all heard someone from outside the province call our city Winterpeg and laugh a derogatory giggle. Imagine if we could transform that word into a badge of honour. It is difficult for a city to reach its full potential as a smart, vibrant, livable place with a resigned attitude we must endure the winter months. If Winnipeg is to be globally competitive, attracting investment, tourism and immigration, we can't simply accept a lower quality of life for half the year. Winter is part of who we are, it defines us. It can be an asset, if we make it one.

Read
Monday, Jan. 19, 2015

OS31
RAW:almond pop-up restaurant (above rendering), under construction at The Forks, is an example of a unique initiative that celebrates winter city living.

Energy efficiency not cheap

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Energy efficiency not cheap

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Dec. 29, 2014

Every young intern architect in the country has been through the experience of having their eyes glaze over when first trying to solve the Rubik's Cube puzzle known as the National Building Code of Canada. For those in Manitoba, that challenge just became much more difficult.

This month, the province became one of the first in Canada to adopt the National Energy Code for Buildings. The target of these new regulations is to increase the average energy efficiency of new construction by 25 per cent and to reduce levels of greenhouse gas emissions by 450,000 tonnes, equivalent to removing 90,000 vehicles from Manitoba's roads during the next 20 years.

Until now, environmental sustainability has largely been a voluntary initiative, championed by idealistic designers and building owners. Adopting the energy code is a first step to establishing the principles of green building design as mandatory construction requirements. The new code sets a baseline for building energy performance and outlines three methods designers can use to comply.

The first route is called the Prescriptive Path, which provides a checklist of stringent demands that must be met. These include such things as increased insulation values and restrictions on window areas to a maximum of 29 per cent of overall exterior walls. The second method, called the Tradeoff Path, allows designers to substitute higher-performing features to reduce the energy-efficiency requirements of others. As an example, to allow a wall to be more than 29 per cent glass, the increase in area can be traded for a more efficient heating system, as long as the baseline energy levels are still met. The third method of compliance is the most flexible, but also the most complex. Called the Performance Path, designs must demonstrate overall energy efficiency by using detailed computer-model simulations that track hourly performance.

Read
Monday, Dec. 29, 2014

Brent Bellamy photo
An infill project under construction in Osborne Village. The increased costs of the new energy code may make the economics for this type of development a challenge.

Campuses return to core

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Campuses return to core

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Dec. 1, 2014

Weighed down by book-filled backpacks, groups of young people brave the autumn cold as they race between monumental stone buildings set geometrically around a sprawling open lawn. This pastoral scene is the traditional image of a university campus, but today, post-secondary institutions across Canada are creating a new backdrop for student life by returning to the bustling streets and soaring office towers in the cores of cities.

In an age of globalization and mobility, universities increasingly have to compete nationally and internationally for students. Young people today are more often looking for cosmopolitan lifestyle choices and are beginning to focus on educational programming that will make them career- or enterprise-ready upon graduation.

In response to these evolving priorities, universities and colleges are looking to differentiate themselves from their competition by exploring avenues to commercialize education and pollinate research disciplines. Following business, art and technology back to the urban core can enhance collaborative partnerships and identify synergies within local clusters of creativity and innovation.

Connecting students to regional industry promotes the establishment of personal professional networks, which also supports greater retention after graduation.

Read
Monday, Dec. 1, 2014

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
Running a satellite campus can carry logistical challenges, but the U of M has some experience with it, operating its faculties of medicine and pharmacy from Health Sciences Centre.

A new urban agenda

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

A new urban agenda

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Nov. 10, 2014

Two weeks ago, Winnipeggers made an emphatic statement that it is time to move in a new direction. On Election Day, voters rewarded mayoral candidates who were not afraid to dream. They overwhelmingly supported those with urban-focused priorities, moving past the traditional debates of potholes, photo radar and synchronizing traffic lights, to engage with ideas that described a broader vision for the city.

The biggest surprise of the day was the performance of Brian Bowman and Robert-Falcon Ouellette. Both men came into the campaign with low name recognition and little public support. In the end, each captured the attention of voters by presenting big-picture visions for the city. They had many differing ideas, but the underlying commonality in their platforms was a commitment to an openly urbanist agenda.

As mayor, Brian Bowman joins Edmonton's Don Iveson and Calgary's Naheed Nenshi as young, telegenic leaders of Western Canadian cities in need of reinventing their urban-growth policy. Like his western counterparts, Bowman is now the mayor of a city facing the consequences of decades of sprawling, low-density growth, including crumbling infrastructure, reduced civic services, budget deficits and higher taxes.

Several of his campaign announcements were initiatives to build a more sustainable city form, many focusing on the promotion of a walkable and liveable downtown core.

Read
Monday, Nov. 10, 2014

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
Working together to improve the city's urban quality will make Winnipeg more sustainable and prosperous.

How to fall in love with our city

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

How to fall in love with our city

brent bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 14, 2014

Winnipeg's population is increasing only because of immigration. Its downtown is expanding largely because of public subsidies. Crime rates in the city remain high and social inequity is growing. Roads are crumbling, civic services are declining and taxes are rising in an attempt to keep up with the low-density, sprawling city we have decided to build. The people chosen in Winnipeg's upcoming municipal election will have a number of significant challenges ahead.

 

The difficult solution to many of the city's issues is to increase opportunity and prosperity for its citizens, improving their quality of life, growing the economy and civic revenue.

In business, the greatest success is rarely the result of following trends. Wealth comes from being ahead of the curve, predicting and investing in what's coming next. A city is no different. Prosperity, particularly in this age of unparalleled mobility, can only be achieved by building a city that inspires and attracts the next generation.

Read
Tuesday, Oct. 14, 2014

Wayne Glowacki / Winnipeg Free Press Files
Dedicated bike lanes, such as this one on Sherbrook Street, are attractive features to younger city-dwellers.

CMHR’s future is up to us all

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

CMHR’s future is up to us all

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Sep. 15, 2014

It has been 4,549 days since the Winnipeg Free Press first announced media mogul Israel Asper had been secretly championing an idea to construct a national museum at The Forks, in the centre of the city. Children born on that day are now in Grade 8. This weekend, finally, the world will be given the opportunity to step through the museum's doors and into Mr. Asper's imagination.

When the concept of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights was unveiled, it seemed to be an impossible dream. The average house price in Winnipeg was $98,000. The city had 80,000 fewer residents. There was no new airport, Manitoba Hydro tower or Investors Group Field. Our hockey team was a minor-league franchise playing in a 50-year-old arena. We were not used to big things yet.

The museum has travelled a long and difficult path to get to the eve of its opening. For almost six years, we have watched it grow from a gravel parking lot into a towering mountain of glass and stone. Its protracted construction time and ballooning budget have drained much of its public goodwill and given everyone in the city opportunity to formulate an opinion. Its glass tower has seemingly become a metaphorical lightning rod of negative energy.

Debate over the value of public investment in our cultural amenities is a vital discussion to maintaining a healthy community, whether it's subsidizing professional hockey, building a new football stadium or investing in museums. Through this debate, the CMHR has been supported by elected representatives from all stripes, from the federal Liberals and Conservatives to the provincial NDP. The museum's realization is a result of similar levels of government support that all national museums in Ottawa have received, but what sets the CMHR apart is the more than 8,000 private donors who have given a staggering $147 million of their own money in support of the idea.

Read
Monday, Sep. 15, 2014

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
The years of waiting and its soaring cost have soured many in the city on the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, but here's hoping we see it with fresh eyes when it opens.

Many of city’s well-known buildings designed by New York architects

Brent Bellamy 7 minute read Preview

Many of city’s well-known buildings designed by New York architects

Brent Bellamy 7 minute read Monday, Aug. 25, 2014

REFERRING to Winnipeg as the ‘Chicago of the North’ is like comparing the city to a famous child actor who, after his television show was cancelled, spent the rest of his life reminiscing about his time in the spotlight.

Focusing on this Chicago comparison not only discredits the diversity of what Winnipeg is today, it dilutes what the city was during the booming, turn-of-the-century rail-town days that inspired its nickname.

Several entrepreneurs of that time looked for inspiration beyond America’s Second City. Like buying a Cézanne or Van Gogh to legitimize their art collection, many of the power brokers in Winnipeg turned to the big-name architects of New York City for the design of their buildings. This oftenoverlooked connection produced some of the most familiar and iconic structures in the city and has left a significant legacy on the physical character of Winnipeg to this day.

The most prominent architectural firm in the United States at the end of the 1800s was New York-based McKim Mead and White. It was an influential contributor at the Chicago World’s Fair of 1893, at which an ideal prototype city was built with broad avenues lined by fantastical buildings replicating the styles of ancient Greece and Rome. The success of the exposition popularized the colonnades and archways of classical architecture for a brief time across America.

Read
Monday, Aug. 25, 2014

In 1929, the Richardson family announced a new 17-storey tower for Portage and Main but the Great Depression put an end to that venture.

Grand vision for Union Station

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Grand vision for Union Station

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Tuesday, Aug. 5, 2014

In 1908, the headlines of the Manitoba Free Press boldly proclaimed Winnipeg's new train depot, to be constructed at the foot of Broadway, would be "the most modern railway terminal in the world."

It described the building as magnificent in proportions and luxurious in its appointments, the finest in the Dominion. American architects Warren and Wetmore, who were simultaneously designing Grand Central Station in New York, would go on to create a building that stood as the gateway to the Canadian West, a symbol of prosperity and optimism in the young city.

More than a century later, Union Station, now owned by Via Rail Canada, welcomes fewer than 25,000 passengers each year. Gone is the bustle of the surrounding neighbourhood, its stately beaux arts limestone facade is today surrounded by parking lots along a decaying stretch of a once-proud Main Street.

Recently, the promise of change has begun to appear in the area surrounding the old depot. The imminent opening of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights has triggered The Forks to move forward with development planning of the land on the other side of the rail line.

Read
Tuesday, Aug. 5, 2014

Submitted illustration
Union Station�s central hall could again bustle with activity if the historic facility were to become a multi-modal transportation hub.

More than the museum

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

More than the museum

Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Jul. 14, 2014

Nearly 20 years ago, the swirling titanium panels of a new Guggenheim Museum transformed a blue-collar city named Bilbao, Spain into a flourishing centre of culture and design. This inspired cities across the globe to build ever-more sensational public buildings, hoping to recreate the elusive "Bilbao Effect."

As Winnipeg prepares to open its own iconic museum, the lesson that can be learned from the experience of these cities is translating a building like the Canadian Museum for Human Rights into a broader development catalyst, requires a focused effort to build complementary projects that expand the museum's influence beyond its walls.

The opportunity for this development in Winnipeg begins with the massive parking lots that sit directly across from the museum at The Forks. Last week, a conceptual master plan for the five-hectare site along the raised rail line was made public, quickly receiving approval by the standing policy committee on downtown development.

Leading up to the submission of the report, The Forks Renewal Corporation undertook a public consultation process through workshops, interviews and online engagement, to distill a guiding vision for the design. The overall findings outlined a general desire to enhance the current experience at The Forks and improve its economic viability by strengthening connections to downtown, creating public green space, active commercial storefronts and cultural amenities.

Read
Monday, Jul. 14, 2014

Artist's rendering
With the impending opening of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, Winnipeg has a chance to make the surrounding area at The Forks a destination with international appeal.

Let’s make River City a reality

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Let’s make River City a reality

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Jun. 23, 2014

Winnipeg is sometimes referred to as River City. Despite owing its very existence to the conflux of two waterways and having four distinct rivers flowing through its boundaries, the reality is Winnipeg is anything but a true river city.

For more than a century, we have turned our back on the rivers. Travel down the Red or Assiniboine by boat and it is striking how rarely they are engaged by development. From the water it appears almost as though the city doesn't exist. Only downtown office towers that peak over the grand elm trees hint at its urban location. In Winnipeg, rivers are often crossed but they are rarely approached.

The lazy Prairie rivers that meander through the city appear benign at first glance, but their hidden power is revealed with water levels that rise as much as seven metres. These dramatic fluctuations have made it difficult to consistently develop the waterfront, resulting in a city that faces away from its rivers.

Over the last 15 years water levels in the city have become increasingly inconsistent. The Assiniboine Riverwalk, built at a level that historically would rarely be submerged after the spring flood, is today more than two metres under water, a common summer condition. Recreational boating on the rivers has declined sharply, public docks and yacht clubs have vanished, water taxis that once carried 50,000 people per summer are not operating and the iconic paddlewheel cruises that ran for 45 years are now gone, unable to survive the unpredictability of a fluctuating river.

Read
Monday, Jun. 23, 2014

Jeff De Booy / WInnipeg Free Press Files
Pedestrians take advantage of the low water levels on the Red and Assiniboine Rivers, taking walks along the river trail between the Forks and the Legislative building.

Winnipeg: City of architectural delights

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Winnipeg: City of architectural delights

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 26, 2014

In the few decades leading up to the year 1914, Winnipeg transformed itself from an isolated trading post to a brash, cosmopolitan metropolis.

When a new train station needed to be built, the architects of New York's Grand Central were hired. When the Union Bank needed a new building at the bend in Main Street, they constructed Canada's first skyscraper, the tallest in the Dominion. Some of the finest architects in the country designed elegant banking halls, majestic terra cotta towers and grand theatre houses such as the Met, Capitol, Walker and Pantages.

Although the start of the First World War would signal the beginning of the end for this golden era of design, two events of the time would set the foundation of the city's architecture in the future. The University of Manitoba had just opened the first school of architecture west of Toronto, and the profession became organized under the regulatory umbrella of the Manitoba Association of Architects.

One hundred years removed from those formative events, the creative confidence of that pioneer era has begun to return to Winnipeg. Something special is once again happening with the city's architecture, and the world is beginning to take notice. Most people in our city don't know it, but in the international architecture community, Winnipeg has become cool.

Read
Monday, May. 26, 2014

SUBMITTED PHOTO
The Cube Stage in Old Market Square. The unique quality of Winnipeg's architecture has even begun to spark mainstream interest in the city as a potential tourist destination.

Diversity is a place called home

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Diversity is a place called home

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, May. 12, 2014

Winnipeg is a city with few natural advantages. It's flat, isolated and cold. It doesn't have Vancouver's snowcapped peaks, Victoria's elegant harbourfront or Toronto's economic engine.

What Winnipeg does have is old buildings. Although many people view these aging structures as dusty relics that symbolize decay and lack of progress, a change in perspective might reveal an asset that can be leveraged as a catalyst for growth in the same way as Edmonton's river valley or Quebec's historic ramparts.

Winnipeg's Exchange District is one of the most intact turn-of-the-century commercial districts in North America. Its value is not defined by the historic significance of individual buildings, but by the importance of the collection as a whole. Many cities have historic buildings, but few have cohesive heritage neighbourhoods. This is Winnipeg's advantage.

As a rare downtown area designed for pedestrians ahead of cars, its form and layout make it an attractive place for people. Human-scale, mid-rise buildings allow sunlight to reach the sidewalks. Handcrafted masonry structures with small, diverse storefronts offer a visual texture that enriches the pedestrian experience. Neighbourhood blocks are short and walkable, densely lined by facades built to the sidewalk edge that create an intimacy and definition to the streets.

Read
Monday, May. 12, 2014

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
Small businesses such as this support the local community, activate the street and contribute to the livability of the downtown.

How to fill potholes

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

How to fill potholes

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 21, 2014

The people of Winnipeg have become a tired and irritable bunch. They have endured the worst winter since the invention of the automobile and now are living through what might be the worst spring for potholes since they started making roads for those vehicles.

It's understandable then, that as city council was presented with the details of a $590-million plan to complete the city's first leg of rapid transit, the public, politicians and media all wondered aloud if the money would be better spent filling that proliferation of potholes.

As we yet again get dragged into the quagmire of a 60-year-old rapid-transit debate, every Canadian city Winnipeg competes with for investment, immigration and tourism has been lining up to announce their long-term commitment to rapid-transit development. Vancouver is currently constructing a $1.4-billion expansion to its Skytrain system, Calgary and Edmonton have announced billion-dollar additions to their existing networks, Ottawa will be investing $3 billion over the next 10 years and Hamilton and Kitchener are both building new light-rail systems.

Most of these cities face the same infrastructure challenges as Winnipeg, but their leadership believes the solution is not a choice between conflicting priorities of transit spending and road repair. Rapid transit is seen as a complementary strategy that addresses the root causes of infrastructure deficits, helping to make road-maintenance budgets more sustainable, in part by reducing private vehicle use and in turn road wear and capacity demands.

Read
Monday, Apr. 21, 2014

John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press archives
In a surprise move, Winnipeg Mayor Sam Katz puts up $137.5 million for rapid transit.

WAG’s neighbour from the North

By Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Preview

WAG’s neighbour from the North

By Brent Bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Mar. 10, 2014

The powerful forms of Inuit art, a dancing soapstone bear, a majestic ivory narwhal or an etching of a snowy owl, shape the symbolic imagery of Canada's northern indigenous people. The distinctive works that have come to represent this ancient culture are, surprisingly, a modern form of artistic expression.

The idea of establishing a self-sufficient handicrafts industry across the Arctic was promoted in the early 1950s by the federal government as a means of providing economic opportunity in northern communities.

As the program grew, a rich artistic movement began to flourish, driven by a provocative esthetic imbued with 1,000 years of custom and ritual. Lives spent observing the form and movement of Arctic animals and understanding the intimate nuances of an overpowering landscape provided a depth and gravity to the artistic expression. Rich storytelling traditions combined with a craftsmanship refined through generations of constructing delicate kayak frames and carving intricate objects such as snow knives and harpoons, translated into skill and imagination that made artistic carving a natural extension of Inuit culture and tradition.

Former Winnipeg Art Gallery director Ferdinand Eckhardt was an early proponent of the movement, making the WAG one of the nation's first galleries to display the new art form in 1953. In 1964, he organized Canada's first significant exhibition of Inuit sculpture, the beginning of a relationship that would establish the gallery as a global leader in the study and presentation of Inuit artwork. With over 13,000 pieces, the WAG is today home to the largest and most important public collection of Inuit art in the world.

Read
Monday, Mar. 10, 2014

architect Rendering by Michael Maltzan
Artist's rendering of the Inuit Art Centre.

Leadership makes wheels turn

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Leadership makes wheels turn

brent bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Feb. 18, 2014

Winnipeg played host last week to the second International Winter Cycling Congress. Nearly 200 delegates from across North America gathered to discuss the challenges of urban winter cycling and celebrate the benefits it can have for northern cities.

The health and quality-of-life-benefits cycling as urban transportation can bring to the citizens of a city are obvious. Numerous studies show commuters who cycle are generally healthier; they feel less stress, sleep better and have more energy. Physically active employees often show improved productivity, reduced absenteeism and turnover.

Beyond improving the well-being of its citizens, many cities that struggle to keep up with infrastructure deficits are beginning to understand the positive role investment in active transportation can have in building a sustainable city.

As we construct sprawling suburbs, greater commuting distances increase vehicle time on the road, which, in turn, increases congestion levels. The response is often to build new roads or expand existing ones to accommodate higher traffic volumes at peak times.

Read
Tuesday, Feb. 18, 2014

Submitted photo
Creating more opportunities for cyclists to commute can help arrest urban sprawl and reduce infrastructure costs.

Embracing density

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Embracing density

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 27, 2014

It has been a difficult time for Winnipeg's infrastructure. Our water periodically looks, but certainly doesn't taste, like a fine Canadian whisky. A combination of the polar vortex and daily water-main breaks has entombed cars from Charleswood to Transcona in knee-deep ice. Recent snow-clearing efforts left most of us wanting to trade in our car for a late-model Mars Rover, and of course in the not-too-distant future, the annual pothole invasion will begin.

The rising cost of maintaining this infrastructure and other civic services have left the City of Winnipeg scrambling to balance its budget, resulting in a third straight property-tax hike for 2014. This increase will be accompanied by a rise in sewer and water rates and likely, education taxes. A few months ago, a KPMG report recommended a 'winter surcharge' be added to property taxes in years when snow-removal costs exceed the city budget.

These reactionary solutions to infrastructure deficits leave governments trying to catch up by spending greater amounts of money fixing problems, without addressing their root cause. Over the last 50 years, Canadians have built sprawling, car-oriented cities that have resulted in a sharp reduction in population density. This has left civic governments responsible for a larger stock of infrastructure with fewer taxpayers to pay for its construction and long-term maintenance.

Since 1970, Winnipeg has grown in population by 33 per cent, yet its area has increased by almost 80 per cent. The populations of mature neighbourhoods such as Wolseley, River Heights and Riverview have also declined by 20 to 30 per cent in that time. Even Osborne Village, the city's most urban neighbourhood, is 10 per cent less populated than it was four decades ago. This decrease in density means each taxpayer has become responsible for a greater share of infrastructure and city services, stretching tax dollars beyond their limits.

Read
Monday, Jan. 27, 2014

John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press
A crew works on a water-main break on Laxdal Road on Jan. 19.

Prime plan for a pumphouse

brent bellamy 6 minute read Preview

Prime plan for a pumphouse

brent bellamy 6 minute read Monday, Dec. 16, 2013

Imagine a Winnipeg that could build the Union Bank Tower, Canada's first skyscraper, the nation's tallest building, crowned with the British Commonwealth's highest flagpole. Imagine a Winnipeg that could have more construction in a single year than Toronto and Montreal combined. The Winnipeg of 1904 optimistically pushed skyward with every new building, marking its place on the world stage with its towers, just as developing cities such as Dubai and Shanghai do today.

At the heart of Winnipeg's rampant vertical growth was the security of the most sophisticated high-pressure fire-protection system in the world. At full production, 35,000 litres of Red River water could be pushed through a 13-kilometre network of pipes, powered by six massive engines housed in the James Avenue Pumping Station.

Since being decommissioned in 1986, the hulking machinery in the pumping station has been silent, its windows boarded up, its roof and walls decaying. Over the past quarter-century, proposals to transform the building into a brew pub, a restaurant, condominiums, a gallery, a museum and office space have all come and gone. Each time, the cost of converting a century-old industrial building into suitable public space has made the business case for redevelopment unworkable.

Realizing time had become an enemy for this charming old neighbour, a local group of engineers, architects, builders, developers and heritage advocates came together in late 2012 with the goal of finding a final solution that would preserve the pumping station from demolition, celebrate its unique industrial character and transform it into the social heart of its burgeoning urban neighbourhood.

Read
Monday, Dec. 16, 2013

Submitted illustration
Artist’s rendering of the skyline profile of the James Avenue Pumping Station project.

Window to the past, and future

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Window to the past, and future

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 25, 2013

Winnipeg in the 1890s was a bustling city of 30,000 people. Horse-drawn carriages dodged new electric trolley cars as pedestrians click-clacked along oak-plank boardwalks lining the sides of wide, mud-packed streets.

In residential areas, the tradition of planting boulevard trees was initiated to beautify the featureless prairie city. Many of the 12,000 elm trees planted in that first decade were located in the Hudson's Bay Company Reserve, a parcel of land surrounding Upper Fort Garry, retained by HBC as payment for surrendering Rupert's Land in 1870.

Schools and churches were built across the reserve to lure residential development and Broadway, the area's main thoroughfare, was lined with nearly 900 elm trees. These efforts proved successful in transforming the barren land into the city's first distinguishable neighbourhood, home to Winnipeg's wealthiest and most prominent citizens.

One such citizen was Sir Hugh John Macdonald, who would build his Victorian mansion in 1895 on Carlton Street, lined with 324 of those new elm trees. The son of Canada's first prime minister, Macdonald came to Winnipeg to open a law practice with Stewart Tupper, the son of Canada's sixth prime minister.

Read
Monday, Nov. 25, 2013

John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press
While the events centre, office and gift shop have stayed open, Dalnavert Museum;s doors have been shut since the Labour Day weekend.

Think like big-city neighbours

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Think like big-city neighbours

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 4, 2013

Over the past few weeks, Winnipeg newspapers have been filled with scandalous stories of government mismanagement and partisanship that has paralyzed city hall in a quagmire of resignation, accusation and recrimination.

As the citizens of Winnipeg focused on the dysfunction of their city's municipal leadership, voters in Alberta's two largest cities went to the polls to elect what has been dubbed Canada's dynamic duo of civic politics. In Edmonton, former city councillor Don Iveson, 34, received nearly two-thirds of the vote to become Canada's youngest big-city mayor. Calgary's wildly popular incumbent mayor, Naheed Nenshi, 41, swept back into power with support from almost three-quarters of voters.

A Google search of each young leader reveals a long list of adjectives of which any politician would be envious. Headlines are peppered with words like progressive, forward-thinking, dynamic and bold. These types of descriptions are not generally attached to civic leaders who pledge to build their cities using the sprawling, suburban model of the last 50 years. Progressive mayors are typically urban-focused with a long-term vision for a fiscally, socially and environmentally sustainable city.

Both Alberta mayors captured the imagination of their young electorate by running on strong urbanist platforms that emphasized the importance of building cities that are networks of sustainable, walkable, livable and lovable complete communities. Nenshi in Calgary dubbed his urban philosophy 'the three Ds of great cities'--density, diversity and a sense of discovery.

Read
Monday, Nov. 4, 2013

Brent Bellamy photo
Winnipeg needs to learn from cities such as Edmonton and Calgary, where they are taking proactive measures to deal with urban sprawl.

Downtown development will exemplify quality design

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Downtown development will exemplify quality design

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 15, 2013

‘IT is fatal to specialize... the more diverse we are in what we do, the better.’ — Jane Jacobs

In 1961 Jane Jacobs wrote her landmark book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities. It would redefine our understanding of what makes urban areas vibrant, prosperous and safe. Jacobs likened the city to a living organism, where physical elements such as buildings, parks and sidewalks worked in harmony with social and economic conditions to create a spontaneous blend of what she called "organized complexity." She emphasized the importance of buildings that interact with their surroundings and engage pedestrians along the sidewalk, insisting even large buildings be attractive, welcoming and offer a visually rich experience at the human scale.

Jacobs questioned the effectiveness of single-use neighbourhoods such as entertainment or office districts, instead advocating for a diversity of building types and uses. She argued that a variation of buildings, large and small, new and old, commercial and residential attracts a range of people with different lifestyles and daily routines that populate the city at different times, increasing commercial activity and improving urban safety.

In the past, these diverse neighbourhoods evolved organically over time. The challenge for modern urban renewal is to create space that inspires an instant emotional connection with the community. New buildings that are multi-use and designed to reflect local tradition and character, while connecting to their surroundings on a human level, have the greatest opportunity to become successful contributors to a vibrant neighbourhood.

Read
Tuesday, Oct. 15, 2013

Stantec Architecture
An artist's streetscape rendering of the Centrepoint development under construction at the northwest corner of Portage Avenue and Donald Street.

Striving for a people-friendly core

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Striving for a people-friendly core

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 23, 2013

A few weeks ago Toronto's Fortress Real Developments returned to Winnipeg to unveil a set of glossy images for their proposed new skyscraper in the downtown. The evocative illustrations portray a dramatic glistening pinnacle soaring high into the technicolour sky of a Prairie sunrise. Blurred for atmospheric effect, the vaguely familiar utopian depiction of surrounding Winnipeg looks as if the city has been put through an Instagram filter named "Urban." Its dense grid-work of buildings and tree-lined sidewalks appear ready to burst with activity in the morning rush.

The fantasy renderings are an appropriate reminder of our downtown's shortcomings and provide an image to strive for in the real world. The most visible difference, obvious from even a helicopter's perspective, is the drawings portray an urban neighbourhood focused on the human experience. The reality of Winnipeg's modern downtown is it is not a community for people, but a machine engineered primarily to move automobiles.

Decades ago, when Winnipeg became focused on vehicular circulation as its primary goal of urban design, the scale and texture of its environment changed. Public space became over-scaled to accommodate the speed and volume of traffic and entire city blocks were wiped clear for surface parking. At 50 kilometres an hour, the detail of a city is lost. Buildings designed in response to the car became larger, less articulate and more introverted, with fewer entrances and more monotonous blank walls. The human scale gave way to the vehicular scale, resulting in a less intimate downtown that has been designed primarily to be experienced at driving speed.

A glaring example of this priority shift came in 1979 when the Trizec building with its one-storey, opaque walls that run the length of three football fields replaced a rich and varied streetscape of 30 heritage buildings and their pedestrian-oriented, retail storefronts.

Read
Monday, Sep. 23, 2013

ARTIST’S RENDERING
The fantasy renderings are an appropriate reminder of our downtown’s shortcomings and provide an image to strive for in the real world.

Let Portage and Main breathe

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Let Portage and Main breathe

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, Sep. 3, 2013

At 10 o'clock this morning, there will be precisely 2,000 days left until the intersection of Portage and Main, Winnipeg's famous windy corner, can legally be opened once again to pedestrians. Whether it will open or not remains to be seen.

The story is well-known by now. With the construction of the Trizec building in the late 1970s, an underground connection was made to each of the intersection's four corners. In an effort to force people into the shops that lined the concourse, a 40-year agreement was signed with the six adjacent property owners that read, "The city agrees that it will not consent to any construction of a pedestrian crossing over or under any street" (at Portage and Main). Concrete barricades adorned with colourful flowers were installed and the intersection was sealed off to a generation of people.

Last month, the Canadian Institute of Planners nominated Winnipeg's windswept corner one of the "Great Places in Canada." The improbable announcement touched off a public discussion about the future of the intersection, with bloggers, television, radio and newspaper outlets all debating the subject.

Those who favoured the barricades argued pedestrians would be unsafe crossing with the high number of cars that pass through the intersection, yet traffic volumes are similar at Broadway and Main or Portage and Memorial, and pedestrians cross those intersections without incident every day.

Read
Tuesday, Sep. 3, 2013

Supplied photo
The barriers at Portage and Main enhance the perception of lack of safety and isolate that part of the downtown from others in the area.

Let’s have designs on our city

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Let’s have designs on our city

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 12, 2013

Winnipeggers have traditionally had an off and on relationship with the architecture of their city. At the beginning of the last century we built with the optimism of a young metropolis destined to become the Paris of the Prairies. We raised the tallest building in the country and the finest marble and terra-cotta banking halls on the continent stood as a symbol of our promise. Winnipeg was animated with finely manicured parks, bustling sidewalks and busy urban plazas. Its citizens held a deeply rooted connection to their built environment. They had big-city solutions for big-city dreams.

In the decades ending that century, we became indifferent to the built quality of our city. Buildings were no longer constructed with the same permanence. The suburbs exploded, our parks fell into disrepair, the city centre was deserted and urban planning became an exercise in traffic management. We even gave our most famous intersection a makeover with all the charm of a freeway exit ramp.

Today, things appear to be changing. With several world-renowned architects putting their signature on our city and local firms winning prestigious awards for their creative work, Winnipeggers seem to be taking notice and are slowly engaging in a dialogue about the issues of design in our built environment. Recent public outcry over a proposed hotel and waterpark across from the Canadian Museum for Human Rights served as an example of this newfound engagement.

To further stimulate this conversation, a number of grassroots organizations have emerged, working together to incubate a culture of design in Winnipeg and heighten appreciation for the city's urban landscape within the broader community.

Read
Monday, Aug. 12, 2013

Brian Bellamy / For Winnipeg Free Press
TILT is a transformable and inhabitable place for visitors to act or to idle, however they may be inclined.

Long-term planning crucial

brent bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Long-term planning crucial

brent bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 22, 2013

Winnipeg's population is nearing 800,000 and is growing by more than 10,000 per year. Property values are rising, construction is happening and the economy is prospering. We have an IKEA, a professional hockey team and a half-dozen new towers rising in our skyline.

Winnipeg is without question a progressing city -- but is it a progressive one?

After decades of stagnation, Winnipeg is beginning to face the challenges that come with more rapid urban growth. The suburbs are sprawling in every direction, traffic levels are increasing and established neighbourhoods are being redeveloped. The city is evolving and we are at the point of having to ask ourselves: What kind of community do we want Winnipeg to become?

Old Winnipeg was a special place, filled with dense, tree-lined, walkable neighbourhoods of grid-pattern streets, community clubs and corner stores. Will new Winnipeg have the same character and soul, or will we look back on this growth period as a lost opportunity to progressively shape our future city? Will we have the same pride and foresight as those who planted our characteristic tree canopy a century ago, or will we leave a legacy of ubiquitous suburbs, unmanageable civic finances and crumbling infrastructure?

Read
Monday, Jul. 22, 2013

Supplied
Innovative projects such as 5468796 Architecture�s Oz Condominium bring vibrancy and density to neighbourhoods such as Osborne Village, but difficulty meeting minimum parking requirements on small urban sites results in developers enduring a costly and time-consuming approval process.

Downtown’s parking facilities tell story of city’s development

On Architecture / By Brent Bellamy 8 minute read Preview

Downtown’s parking facilities tell story of city’s development

On Architecture / By Brent Bellamy 8 minute read Monday, Jun. 10, 2013

The Archives of Manitoba are filled with photos of buildings, but there are none of parking lots. Urbanites hate them. Mayors and premiers campaign against them. Parking lots are a maligned group.

It is easy to love a building, to find beauty and meaning in stone columns and arched windows, but nobody ever considers the story of a parking lot or wonders what ghosts might linger on their asphalt surfaces.carl

Winnipeg's parking lots define the downtown as much as the towers rising at its core. The neighbourhood between Portage Avenue and Broadway is a particularly fractured urban landscape. Ever wonder why?

The story of how that area became home to so much surface parking is a journey that began 143 years ago when the Hudson's Bay Co. surrendered Rupert's Land to Canada. In the transfer, the company maintained ownership of Upper Fort Garry and 500 acres of adjacent land. This reserve was unsettled prairie in an area defined today by the two rivers, Portage and Main to the north and Memorial Boulevard to the west.

Read
Monday, Jun. 10, 2013

Archives of Manitoba
The McIntyre Block pictured during the 1950s. It was the first office building in Western Canada, and site owner Creswin reportedly is eyeing a hotel tower for the land.

Cultural transformation

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Cultural transformation

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Tuesday, May. 21, 2013

As the sun broke over the horizon on a sleepy Monday morning in July of 1867, the people of British North America awoke as citizens of Canada. With thriving transportation and manufacturing industries, Montreal, at the head of the St. Lawrence River, would be the economic engine of the young Dominion, remaining the largest, most powerful city in the country for the next 100 years.

By the 1960s, Montreal had lost much of its lustre and influence, surpassed by Toronto as Canada's premier city. Development and population growth slowed as business migrated west and traditional industries lost prominence in the modern economy.

Montreal's story is familiar to the people of Winnipeg. Our city's own decline from the powerhouse of the West to a regional capital struggling to compete with our prosperous neighbours, closely parallels Montreal's fall from prominence. Despite (perhaps because of) these economic challenges, vibrant cultural and artistic communities have historically flourished in both cities.

Montreal has long been a pre-eminent city of art and culture in North America and Winnipeg's list of cultural institutions would be the envy of cities many times its size.

Read
Tuesday, May. 21, 2013

An artist's rendering of the 'new' WSO building.

A vibrant vision for Chinatown

By Brent Bellamy / On architecture 6 minute read Preview

A vibrant vision for Chinatown

By Brent Bellamy / On architecture 6 minute read Monday, Apr. 29, 2013

On a late November evening in 1877, the distinctive clip-clop, clip-clop of horses' hooves would pierce through Winnipeg's cold autumn air. The setting sun outlined the silhouette of an overloaded stagecoach staggering along the sharp prairie horizon. Curious onlookers were drawn by the moan of rigid wheels struggling to navigate the city's dusty Main Street. Unfamiliar sounds of foreign voices came from within the American caravan transporting the first three Chinese settlers to the isolated town of 6,500 people.

Charley Yam, the leader of the three, would soon open the city's first Chinese laundry on Post Office Street (now Lombard Avenue). Three months later, demanding better living conditions, his employees would stage an armed revolt. The 'Chinese War' would captivate readers of the Manitoba Free Press, which announced the end of the week-long standoff with the simple message, "Two Chinese laundries are now in operation in this city." Six more would open over the next eight years.

In 1905, the Quong Chong Tai Company opened a grocery at 249 King St., forming the genesis of Winnipeg's Chinatown. In the next year, another grocery and four laundries would open and by 1909 the neighbourhood would take on a distinctive exotic flavour.

Facing significant linguistic and cultural barriers, economic hardship and racial discrimination, early Chinese settlers would band together by isolating themselves on inexpensive land at the fringes of city centres across the country. In search of security, social networks and community support, this voluntary residential segregation would result in the birth of Chinatowns in many Canadian cities.

Read
Monday, Apr. 29, 2013

Submitted photo
Tiffany Leong's Chinatown incorporates traditional second-storey apartments above street-level shops.

Exit of core grocer an opportunity

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Exit of core grocer an opportunity

Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 8, 2013

PREGNANT WOMAN: What's that for?

OBSTETRICIAN: That's the machine that goes 'ping.' (Ping) You see? That means your baby is still alive! Its the most expensive machine in the hospital!

 

If the "machine that goes ping" from the Monty Python film The Meaning of Life, were to be hooked up to Winnipeg's downtown Hudson's Bay department store, the pinging sounds would likely be few and far between. The old store appears to be clinging to life after closing four of its six floors, the Paddlewheel restaurant and most recently its Zellers and basement grocery store.

Read
Monday, Apr. 8, 2013

Mack D. Male
Edmonton's Sobeys Urban Fresh is at the base of a highrise residential unit, providing a built-in market.

There is still hope for Portage Place

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

There is still hope for Portage Place

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 18, 2013

"The face of the city is changing. The heart beat's stronger. You can feel it in the air.  Here's where the city comes alive -- Portage Place!"

These optimistic lyrics, set to an '80s-style pop tune, echoed through the speakers of Portage Place, Winnipeg's grand new downtown shopping mall on its opening day in September 1987. That evening, CBC news anchor Mike McCourt wondered if the downtown streets would be able to handle the traffic volumes heading to the mall in years to come.

Nine months later, the CBC would run a follow-up story outlining the struggles those retailers were facing. Business was half of what had been anticipated, restaurants had already closed and many shops were struggling to pay their rent. As regional malls sprang up across North American suburbs in the 1970s, the traditional shopping experience moved from the sidewalks of bustling urban retail streets to the shiny, ceramic tile corridors of million-square-foot, climate-controlled malls.

With five new suburban malls being constructed in Winnipeg during that decade, Portage Avenue, the city's retail heart for a century, fell into decline. The response was to try to out-suburb the suburbs by replacing three square blocks of the faltering downtown with a sparkling new $80-million shopping mall.

Read
Monday, Mar. 18, 2013

Supplied photo
Portage Place can teach us the lesson that successful urban neighbourhoods cannot be sterile and artificially imposed, no matter how well-conceived.

PSB, St. B cop shop examples of polarizing architecture

By Brent Bellamy / On architecture 5 minute read Preview

PSB, St. B cop shop examples of polarizing architecture

By Brent Bellamy / On architecture 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 25, 2013

The '60s was a decade of sweeping change and exuberant style; Zeppelin and Floyd, Corvettes and Mustangs, bell bottoms and miniskirts. As the baby-boom generation watched man walk on the moon, the ideas of the past were washed away in a tide of forward-looking enthusiasm.

More than four decades later, we remain enamoured with the psychedelic styles and imagery of the Mad Men era, yet architecture finds itself the one artistic expression from that time that is unloved and even reviled in today's popular culture.

Architecture of the '60s was a celebration of new technologies and a reflection of the ambitious society from which it came. Often criticized for lacking personality and texture, the clean lines of '60s modernism rejected the styles of the past, boldly looking toward the future for inspiration. These ideals extended to urban renewal, which was often seen as a government-led initiative that would sweep away entire neighbourhoods, replacing them with the sterilized order of modernist buildings.

The Civic Centre campus, which included the new city hall, Public Safety Building, Centennial Concert Hall and Manitoba Museum was the manifestation of this movement in Winnipeg. In the name of progress, entire blocks of the downtown were demolished and replaced with a series of monolithic structures that would overwhelm the pedestrian scale and dismantle the neighbourhood's organic composition. This disengagement with the human experience at an urban level contributes significantly to the negative perception of 1960s architecture in contemporary public opinion.

Read
Monday, Feb. 25, 2013

supplied photo
The Public Safety Building (above) and St. Boniface police station: you either love brutalist architecture or you hate it. There's no middle ground.

Landscape of professionalism

brent bellamy / on architecture 5 minute read Preview

Landscape of professionalism

brent bellamy / on architecture 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 4, 2013

There is nothing more frustrating than flying into a new city while sitting in the middle seat of an airplane. You stretch to see over the person beside you who's pressed up against the small round window. You strain to catch a glimpse of the city passing below you, trying to formulate that first impression of the place you are about to experience.

We often seem to rate the urban quality of North American cities in this way, as if we are 1,000 feet in the air. The size of its freeways or the height of its skyline resonate as symbols of civic affluence and vibrancy.

The true health of a city, however, must be judged from its sidewalks. Its urban quality can't be measured from the height of its towers. It can only be found in the spaces between those buildings. The human experience is not defined by how buildings engage the sky, but how they engage the ground, how they define public space, how they facilitate a social connection between the people in and around them.

The quality of these spaces is what makes a city livable and prosperous. Active parks, sidewalks, plazas and courtyards work together as an integrated network of open space that can attract people to live, work and invest in a city. When done well, they can be a catalyst for growth and development. When done poorly, they can enable crime and promote urban decay.

Read
Monday, Feb. 4, 2013

Scatliff + Miller + Murray

A design sketch for a commercial streetscape. Landscape architects work as part of a design team to ensure buildings appropriately engage the public realm.

Kapyong Barracks site can become an inspired, modern neighbourhood

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Kapyong Barracks site can become an inspired, modern neighbourhood

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 14, 2013

Winnipeg doesn't have Vancouver's majestic seawall or Calgary's mountain backdrop. It doesn't have a Maritime harbour or a hulking, big-city skyline.

Winnipeg is flat and remote and often way too cold.

In a city like ours, not blessed with any natural advantages, it is vital to nurture the qualities that make Winnipeg unique and work to enhance development that has already been done successfully. Too often, we fail to recognize and build from our strengths while allowing our successes to be eroded through short-sighted development.

An important example is the Exchange District, a neighbourhood that defines Winnipeg's urban character and is one of the most important turn-of-the-century commercial areas in North America. It has been passed down to us through an anomaly of good fortune, but instead of cherishing and protecting this valuable urban asset, the area routinely finds a place on Heritage Canada's Top 10 Endangered Places List. It continues to lose buildings such as the Shanghai Restaurant, the Grain Exchange Annex and many others to make way for parking or empty lots. This is slowly eroding the area's cohesive character, reducing its allure as a catalyst for growth.

Read
Monday, Jan. 14, 2013

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
Lipsett Hall, on Kenaston Boulevard, is part of the former Kapyong Barracks.

Santa’s home can be a castle

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Santa’s home can be a castle

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 24, 2012

There's an old riddle that challenges children to draw a diagram of a house without lifting their pencil or repeating a line. The basic shape is composed of a square with diagonals running from corner to corner, topped with a triangular roof. In Germany, kids are taught to speak one syllable of the phrase, 'Das ist das Haus des Nikolaus,' for each line they draw. The game is known as 'The House of Santa Claus.'

This simple line drawing represents some of the architectural imagery that forms the setting of the Santa Claus myth. His home, village and workshop, have transformed through the centuries in step with the evolution of the man himself.

The historical St. Nicholas was born to a wealthy family in eastern Turkey during the third century. He spent his life helping the poor and sick, giving his money away anonymously to those in need. After his death he was made the patron saint of children and his life was traditionally celebrated on Dec. 6 with the giving of small gifts.

Through the centuries, local European folklore would alter the St. Nicholas story. In the Dark Ages, as the Vikings expanded their influence, he would take on many of the characteristics of Thor, the Norse God of Thunder. Thor was a heavy-set man with a white beard and red coat, who would hand out gifts at the winter solstice, flying above the trees from the North Pole in a chariot pulled by two goats (Cracker and Gnasher).

Read
Monday, Dec. 24, 2012

Brent Bellamy PHOTOS
Half-timber construction (above left, in Normandy, France) was common across northern Europe for centuries and has become the predominant architectural imagery related to Santa Claus. The architecture of Santa Claus, found in Christmas decorations (above right), provides a context and physical setting for his myth.

It’s our Winnipeg, for art’s sake

Brent Bellamy / On architecture 5 minute read Preview

It’s our Winnipeg, for art’s sake

Brent Bellamy / On architecture 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 3, 2012

Ask any Winnipegger what their favourite piece of public art is and the response will likely be a confused look and the question, "Winnipeg has public art?"

Ours is an artistic community. With only two per cent of Canada's population, we have 12 per cent of its musicians. We have the country's oldest civic art gallery, French-language theatre, English regional theatre and dance company. We are home to a renowned symphony and numerous artistic festivals. Despite this creative heritage, we have fallen behind other major Canadian cities in our funding for and implementation of great public art.

North American cities today are turning to public art as a means of defining and enhancing urban identity and character. The visual appeal of a community can play a significant role in cultivating civic pride and emotional attachment from the people who live in them. It is human character to seek out physical beauty in the things that surround us and in the places we live. Public art that is authentic, stimulating and visually appealing can contribute to this sense of public well-being. Although not plentiful, Winnipeg does have some inspiring examples of urban art that illustrate the benefits of this type of economic investment in our communities.

Effective public art can help to articulate a shared sense of place and belonging within a city or neighbourhood. It can celebrate cultural diversity and unite social groups, expressing the history, traditions and identities unique to that community.

Read
Monday, Dec. 3, 2012

Leo Mol's Tree Children

What’s rotten in Denmark?

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

What’s rotten in Denmark?

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 12, 2012

Winnipeg is a garbage city.

We send more of it to the landfill than any other municipality in Canada, generating 750,000 tonnes of waste each year. This is equal to the weight of nearly 200,000 full grown African elephants, representing more than 1,000 kilograms from each citizen. Even with a blue box in every home, we divert only 17 per cent of our waste from the landfill, the lowest recycling rate in the country and one-third of what cities like Vancouver and Toronto accomplish. That's a lot of elephants.

The most recent topic for discussion in Winnipeg's coffee shops and hockey rinks has been the city's less-than-seamless transition to an automated garbage and recycling collection system.

As we wait for the wrinkles to be ironed out, it's important to remember the new garbage bins are a fundamental first step in a comprehensive new master plan that will help improve our city's dismal waste-management statistics. The goal is to double recycling rates to 35 per cent in five years and to achieve 50 per cent by the year 2020.

Read
Monday, Nov. 12, 2012

An artist's rendition of the Amagerforbraending plant in Copenhagen, complete with smoke ring.

Putting a little green up above

By Brent Bellamy / On architecture 5 minute read Preview

Putting a little green up above

By Brent Bellamy / On architecture 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 22, 2012

Do you ever wake up in the morning, turn on the weather channel and notice the temperatures shown at The Forks are often several degrees warmer than those at the airport?

You wouldn't think an area's climate would change over six kilometres, but it turns out that annually, the average overnight low at The Forks is -0.7 C while at the airport it is almost three degrees colder at -3.4 C. On sunny summer days, the temperature variation between the downtown and the outskirts of the city can reach six or seven degrees Celsius.

The answer to this puzzle is something called the 'urban heat island effect.' As the name suggests, cities are literally islands of heat. A Google Earth view of downtown shows a landscape of black roofs, asphalt streets and concrete sidewalks. These impervious materials absorb and store the sun's energy, releasing it back into the air as heat. Natural landscapes of soil and vegetation trap moisture and use the sun's energy for evaporation, releasing water vapour that cools the air.

For much of the year, heat islands can negatively impact human comfort in the city. This can affect urban vibrancy, commercial activity, public health and air quality while increasing direct energy costs for building owners.

Read
Monday, Oct. 22, 2012

��Eduard Hueber/archphoto
Eduard Hueber / archphoto
The roof on Manitoba Hydro Place is one of several in Winnipeg that have gone green.

Copenhagen shows bicycles can improve cities and their citizens

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Copenhagen shows bicycles can improve cities and their citizens

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 1, 2012

2Home to inspiring modern architecture, set within a dense and vibrant urban context, the most significant impression any visitor has of the Scandinavian capital is an overwhelming presence of bicycles.

In Copenhagen, 37 per cent of the population ride their bikes to work every day. With a vast, integrated system of separated lanes and dedicated lights, rush-hour traffic can often be heavier for cyclists than motorists. The system is so safe only 15 per cent of Danes choose to wear a helmet.

During a recent architectural pilgrimage to the Nordic city, I was lucky enough to visit prominent Danish architect and urban planner Jan Gehl. Having written several influential books on the design of livable cities, he has been instrumental in establishing Copenhagen's bike culture. In our discussion, Gehl lamented the lack of cycling infrastructure in most Canadian cities and cited the significant social and economic benefits it can have. He referred to a study commissioned by the mayor of Copenhagen indicating that when taking all factors into account, every kilometre ridden on a bike saves Danish society 25 cents and every kilometre travelled by car costs them 16 cents.

In Winnipeg, the first steps toward implementation of an active transportation network have largely been focused on encouraging healthy lifestyle choices, but expanding on Gehl's business case for an urban cycling infrastructure might be a valuable strategy to galvanize government and public support for its continued development.

Read
Monday, Oct. 1, 2012

Submitted photo
Rush hour in Copenhagen. Nearly 40 per cent of the city's population ride their bikes to work every day.

WAG the arts scene

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

WAG the arts scene

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 10, 2012

In 1912, Winnipeg peaked. The cosmopolitan and bustling young city of 170,000 people was riding a wave of affluence and growth that was without rival in North America. That year, 5,328 buildings were constructed, a boom of prosperity that continues to define the physical character of our city a century later. With a population that had tripled in the previous decade, what had become the third largest city in Canada was the undisputed king of the Prairies.

As office towers pushed skyward along Main Street and new residential districts grew away from the rivers, Winnipeg's optimistic young population looked to create a quality of life that would match the older centres of the east. In an effort to construct a "civilized" new metropolis, they would build grand cultural institutions befitting a city whose destiny was thought to be the stature of a Canadian Chicago. Theatres like the Capitol, Metropolitan, Walker and Pantages would rise in the downtown and a group of prominent businessmen would contribute $200 each to rent space in the new Industrial Bureau Building, providing a home for the Winnipeg Museum of Fine Arts, Canada's first civic art gallery.

Now known as the Winnipeg Art Gallery (WAG), the century-old institution is the centre of a flourishing cultural community that has grown to define the artistic spirit of our city. Today, more than 25,000 people in Winnipeg work in the arts and creative industries, representing four per cent of the city's economic output and 17 per cent of tourist spending. Winnipeg is known internationally as a place of creativity and artistic expression, inspired by the WAG over those 100 years.

In 1967, as the WAG grew in stature to become the sixth-largest gallery in Canada, the decision was made to establish a permanent home on a triangular piece of land along Memorial Boulevard. An international design competition was held that garnered global attention, with 109 submissions from architects around the world.

Read
Monday, Sep. 10, 2012

Ken Gigliotti Winnipeg Free Press archives
The Winnipeg Art Gallery is celebrating its centenary with a plan for a new building.

Rail yard redevelopment would bring density, investment and revenue

Brent Bellamy/On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Rail yard redevelopment would bring density, investment and revenue

Brent Bellamy/On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 20, 2012

First we need to fix the roads, replace the sewers, fill the potholes. Our property taxes are too high already. We can't afford it. It would cost too much. There are bigger priorities for Winnipeg.

Sentiments like these have generally followed recent public discussion over the potential relocation and redevelopment of the Canadian Pacific Railway yards northwest of the downtown. Instigated by a request to government (by the Social Planning Council of Winnipeg) for a feasibility study, the public debate has met with significant skepticism over the value of what seems to be an unachievable goal, considering the apparent costs and current economic pressures on local government.

It appears to be linear thinking to conclude we cannot afford such a grand dream. If we don't have the money, how can we spend it?

However, stepping back and re-evaluating the root cause of our public fiscal deficit, we might be led to the question: How can we afford not to consider this idea?

Read
Monday, Aug. 20, 2012

Mike Deal / Winnipeg Free Press
Redevelopment of the CP rail yards offers the chance to reconnect our city while raising money for roads and other infrastructure fixes.

Rush to raze leaves lingering holes

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Rush to raze leaves lingering holes

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 30, 2012

Dec. 15, 2010: Winnipeg city council approves demolition of the Shanghai Restaurant building at 228 King St. with the following condition for redevelopment: "preparation of a firm redevelopment proposal and a formal application for a building permit."

July 18, 2012: Approval for demolition is granted with the following change to the original conditions: "receipt of an urban design submission that meets the intent of council not to allow a surface parking area."

With this revision, the requirements for demolition of a building that has stood at the heart of Winnipeg's Chinatown for longer than Chinatown has existed went from proving the building would be replaced immediately to the installation of a few thousand dollars' worth of sod and a promise to water and mow. The 130-year-old building will soon make way for a city block-sized grass field being hailed as a "much-needed" passive park for Chinatown's few hundred residents.

This raises the question: Is it the physical presence of cars that makes parking lots detrimental to the quality of a city's urban environment, or are there greater issues that laying sod does not alleviate?

Read
Monday, Jul. 30, 2012

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
While downtown buildings like the Criterion Hotel (below) were successfully redeveloped and repurposed, the Shanghai Restaurant building (above) will become a green space.

Pumping-station conundrum

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Pumping-station conundrum

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jul. 9, 2012

In the spring of 1997, as a prairie ocean slowly formed around our city, we anxiously followed along as the provincial flood forecaster reported the rising water levels each day, describing it as 21, 22 or 23 feet above James. The term became a local catchphrase, but few people knew that "James" referred to the James Avenue Pumping Station, an unassuming little building along the Red River in the Exchange District.

As the waters receded, the spotlight dimmed and the building's last moments of fame faded away. A century earlier, however, the pumping station was one of the most important buildings in our growing young city.

In 1904, a great fire on Main Street threatened to destroy several blocks of downtown. To battle the blaze, the city was forced to release Assiniboine River water into the main lines. This contaminated the drinking supply and resulted in an outbreak of nearly 1,300 cases of typhoid throughout the city. In response, construction would soon begin on one of the most sophisticated high-pressure firefighting systems in the world. The only such facility in Canada and one of two in North America, it was such a wonder of engineering that in 1909, the British Science Association made the arduous journey across the globe to hold its annual general meeting in Winnipeg and tour the impressive new James Avenue Pumping Station, the centrepiece of the system.

Closed in 1986, the pumping station's elegant, rhythmic facade and double gable roofline serve as a reminder that the utilitarian building once stood as a pavilion in Victoria Park, Winnipeg's first municipal green space and ground zero for the 1919 General Strike.

Read
Monday, Jul. 9, 2012

HANDOUT
The James Avenue Pumping Station was an engineering marvel of the early 20th century.

Local buildings display green benefits

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Local buildings display green benefits

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 18, 2012

There is an 89 per cent chance you are inside a building at this very moment. On average, Canadians spend 21 hours and 20 minutes of every day indoors. In a country of 34 million people, we have almost 14 million buildings that consume 70 per cent of our electricity, 14 per cent of our water and 50 per cent of our extracted natural resources. They account for 25 per cent of our landfill waste and emit 35 per cent of our greenhouse gases.

These statistics illustrate the profound effect buildings have on each one of us. Our physical health, emotional well-being and ecological footprint are all closely linked to the types of buildings we choose to build and inhabit.

Once primarily focused on energy efficiency, sustainable building design has evolved in response to a growing understanding of our relationship with buildings and their relationship with the environment. Today, sustainable design addresses issues of construction waste, recycled content, local materials and water conservation and incorporates human health factors such as indoor air quality and thermal comfort.

As pervasive as the environmental movement has become in our society, it seems any universal shift in the construction industry toward these sustainable-design principles will only occur if an economic advantage is clearly established.

Read
Monday, Jun. 18, 2012

Syverson Monteyne Architecture
The Winnipeg Folk Festival's La Cuisine was built using reclaimed materials.

Make residential splash at Forks

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Make residential splash at Forks

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, May. 28, 2012

So... what now?

Over the past few months, Winnipeggers have been captivated by the most recent chapter in one of our city's great legends of modern folklore, the search for the ever-elusive "world-class Winnipeg water park."

Adjacent to The Forks, the location of the most recent water-park proposal created a wave of public opposition that caused Canalta Hotels to pack up its snorkel and swim fins and head back to Drumheller. With the pressure relieved, we now have the opportunity to step back and ask ourselves as a community, what is the best way forward for one of the most important pieces of real estate that we, the citizens of Winnipeg, collectively own?

Parcel Four, as it has come to be known, is a unique piece of property in the city. When The Forks was created in 1987, it was thought a new Provencher Bridge would connect to York Avenue, where the main entrance to The Forks exists today. To accommodate this future development, the land was partitioned from the rest of the site. When the new bridge was eventually built, the roads were maintained to the north, resulting in a large city-owned parcel of land within what is traditionally considered to be The Forks site.

Read
Monday, May. 28, 2012

John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press Archives
Incorporating a residential aspect to the future use of Parcel Four could make The Forks less of a drive-to destination and less isolated.

A fort reborn

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

A fort reborn

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 16, 2012

The Oct. 26, 1881, edition of the Manitoba Free Press reported, "A cow with a bell on, now in the pound, will shortly be sold by auction if the owner doesn't look after her." Secondary to this news, it was noted that, "The buildings within the walls of Fort Garry are to be removed this season, so that Main Street will be continued in a straight line to the Assiniboine Bridge."

Considered insignificant in the moment, the century-long lament of Upper Fort Garry's demolition would begin a mere seven years later in an article from the Montreal Star that proclaimed, "It would have been worth yearly thousands of dollars to future Winnipeg as a bit of pioneer history of the most fascinating sort, but the thick-headed controllers of the city's destiny could see nothing but the immediate realisation of its value in dollars and cents. It is about the most astounding piece of utterly ignorant and vulgar administration that Canada affords."

With the loss of Upper Fort Garry, the site would eventually fade into history, marked only by a small stone gate hidden behind a gas station. In 2006, the city agreed to sell the property to Crystal Developers, who proposed the construction of a 20-storey residential tower.

The project announcement catapulted the historic site into the spotlight of public awareness, inspiring a passionate civic debate over its future. Transforming a long-dormant property into downtown's first new residential highrise in more than 20 years was an attractive proposal. In the end, however, public opposition caused the developer to back away and control of the property was given to the volunteer group, Friends of Upper Fort Garry.

Read
Monday, Apr. 16, 2012

Submitted photos
Artist's models (above and below) of the design for Upper Fort Garry Heritage Park and Interpretive Centre. The centre will tell the fort's story through overlapping layers of contemporary sculptural and graphic imagery, expressed through sophisticated technologies that will create a unique urban gathering place in the city.

Rapid transit slowly arrives

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Rapid transit slowly arrives

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 26, 2012

We waited 15 years for an NHL hockey team. Now we have one. We waited 36 years for an IKEA. Next Christmas we will have one. We waited 53 years for a modern rapid transit system. In two weeks we will have one. Well, sort of.

After more than a dozen studies, countless advisory committees and an endless number of task forces, Winnipeg's first, three-kilometre-long rapid transit line will soon be running. This modest first step comes more than five decades after the now infamous 'Wilson Plan' first recommended the creation of a rapid transit system for Winnipeg.

Since that time, we have overwhelmingly built our city with a focus on car-oriented development. Decades of low-density subdivisions leapfrogging each other towards the periphery have resulted in Winnipeg's urban area growing disproportionately to its population. Between 1974 and 2006, the city's population grew by only 15 per cent, while its area increased by more than 50 per cent.

Winnipeggers engage in few topics of discussion with greater passion than they do the cost of gasoline, the pace of traffic and the physical condition of our streets, yet we continue to support the urban sprawl that compounds these issues. As our city expands outward, we drive farther, buy more gas, build more roads, navigate more traffic and emit more pollution. With a lower-density tax base, government budgets struggle to maintain basic services and infrastructure for an increasingly unsustainable city.

Read
Monday, Mar. 26, 2012

Brent Bellamy
Osborne Street Station references the great train stations of Europe, while its arching trusses evoke Winnipeg's elm tree canopy.

New buildings contain promise

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

New buildings contain promise

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 5, 2012

Moonlight sparkled on the water as a sleek new cargo ship backed away from her Vancouver dock and quietly slipped into the dark November night. Without ceremony, the Clifford J. Rodgers set sail for the Yukon carrying a shipment of beer, stored for the first time in a series of specially fabricated stacking metal containers. On that autumn night in 1955, she became the first cargo ship in the world to use this revolutionary technology that would transform the global economy in the 20th century.

Today, 90 per cent of the world's cargo is transported in standardized shipping containers, with more than 20 million containers making 200 million trips each year.

International trade deficits mean that less than three-quarters of the shipping containers coming to North America head back in the opposite direction. This has led to a surplus of tens of thousands of containers sitting unused in ports across the continent.

The growing importance of environmental sustainability in building design has led architects to explore these mountains of unused steel boxes as a material resource. With prefabricated and modular construction reducing labour, fabrication time and material waste, reclaiming discarded shipping containers can be an effective and affordable component of a sustainable design strategy.

Read
Monday, Mar. 5, 2012

Photo by Jacqueline Young
Bikelab, designed by Peter Sampson Architecture Studio, graces the University of Winnipeg campus.

Shopping for Bay redevelopment

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Shopping for Bay redevelopment

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Feb. 13, 2012

On a cold November morning in 1926, Mayor Ralph Webb handed $1.25 to a young clerk, purchasing a dark-green necktie for his son. Minutes later, 50,000 eager Winnipeggers flooded through gleaming brass doors to celebrate the opening of Hudson's Bay Co.'s new downtown department store.

For the next several decades, the Bay and Eaton's, its red-brick rival down the street, would establish Portage Avenue as the commercial and social heart of our city. By the 1980s, however, the rise of suburban malls and power centres had diminished the role of urban retail in cities across the continent. In an unsuccessful effort to combat this shifting tide, Winnipeg built Portage Place in 1987. But inevitably, a decade later the Bay would lose her Portage Avenue companion and begin her own slow decline.

After reducing its presence in the iconic store to three floors from six, it has been reported recently the HBC is now considering the option of selling its landmark building, casting doubt on the company's future in the downtown.

This news has brought us to a historic crossroads along the 175-year journey that Winnipeg and the Hudson's Bay Co. have travelled together. It is clear the opportunity to implement a development strategy that preserves the Bay's downtown retail presence might soon be lost forever.

Read
Monday, Feb. 13, 2012

JOHN WOODS / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ARCHIVES
The Bay downtown should be preserved as an important component of the district. There are many creative alternatives for a makeover of the 85-year-old building.

Shoppers’ plan has potential

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Shoppers’ plan has potential

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 23, 2012

"So what does Winnipeg have going for it? On the surface, not much. This is a city that counts a difficult intersection as a famous landmark... The concrete pavements are strangely empty; it feels like a ghost town... Most of the shops in the downtown area could have been transported from any Canadian suburban hellhole"

Ben Groundwater, an Australian travel writer, penned this blunt description of Winnipeg in a Nov. 29 column for the Sydney Morning Herald titled, "You're going where? Why would you?" His opinion takes a turn, however, when he is introduced to Osborne Village, the city's "artsy, creative side," saying, "That's when Winnipeg started to make sense."

It's ironic that shortly after his article appeared, residents of Osborne Village would rise up in opposition to a development that many feel would degrade the unique neighbourhood character that Groundwater found so appealing.

Shoppers Drug Mart's board of adjustment application to allow an expansion that would close a popular restaurant and independent video store is seen by opponents as the invasion of a ubiquitous chain retailer that would threaten the personality of one of Winnipeg's few vibrant urban streets.

Read
Monday, Jan. 23, 2012

Brent Bellamy Photo
The Osborne Village proposal could be a win for Shoppers Drug Mart, a win for neighbourhood residents and a win for the urban quality of our city.

Inspiration comes with a cost

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Inspiration comes with a cost

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jan. 2, 2012

Winnipeg had a great year in 2011. The lengthy string of positive urban development headlines was recently interrupted, however, by the announcement that the Canadian Museum for Human Rights (CMHR) is facing a significant funding shortfall. This has provided fuel to the critics of what will forever be a controversial building, but for many in the construction industry it is not a surprising development.

Construction cost inflation is a challenge most projects in Manitoba have confronted in recent years. The double-edged sword of high growth is as construction activity increases and contractors become busier, competitive bidding and cost stability decrease. Over the past years, Manitobas construction cost escalation has been as much as three times the inflation rate.

Compounding this volatility are global increases in building material costs due to construction volume in emerging countries. Since the CMHR began fundraising in 2003, the price of steel has quadrupled, with 45 per cent of global consumption occurring in China, which also consumes 50 per cent of the worlds cement.

With escalation of up to half a percentage per month, large-budget projects with extended timelines can be significantly affected by fluctuating costs. The new airport terminal, football stadium and Manitoba Hydros office tower all met with similar economic challenges.

Read
Monday, Jan. 2, 2012

Handout
Many feel the design-build bid process for the Royal Alberta Museum in Edmonton, which included a requirement for a guaranteed final cost, resulted in an uninspired design.

‘Ghost signs’ evoke city’s past

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

‘Ghost signs’ evoke city’s past

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 12, 2011

Sign, sign. Everywhere a sign. Blockin' out the scenery. Breakin' my mind. Do this. Don't do that. Can't you read the sign?

These famous song lyrics colourfully illustrate how ubiquitous signs have become in our urban environment. Street signs, billboards, traffic signs and video screens are all inescapable components of every cityscape.

Long before giant LCD screens blinked above our streets, the most common and effective commercial signs were painted wall advertisements. Applied directly to a building's exterior brick, these large billboards were once a prominent feature in the commercial districts of Canadian cities.

Today these signs are among the most revered and endangered components of historic neighbourhoods across North America. Painted by hand and left to the elements, these early murals have become known as "ghost signs," both for their visual character resulting from faded paint leaving ghosted images on the sides of buildings and because they often represent companies or products that vanished long ago.

Read
Monday, Dec. 12, 2011

Brent Bellamy photo
The unique sign on James Avenue's new District Condominiums is being left untouched.

Talk to the neighbours first

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Talk to the neighbours first

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Nov. 21, 2011

The setting is an "open house" presentation in an elementary school gymnasium. Nervous architects stand in front of coloured charts and maps, their drawings intentionally vague enough to conceal how far along the design really is. An agitated city councillor tries to control an angry room as local residents in uncomfortable folding chairs cheer and jeer every sentence of a long-winded presentation. When given the chance to speak, each laments the loss of green space or a familiar view, invariably foretelling horror stories of increased traffic on their quiet streets.

From the Fort Rouge rail yards to a Waterfront Drive hotel, condominiums in Osborne Village and apartment buildings in North Kildonan, this scene has become an increasingly familiar one across Winnipeg as neighbourhood residents seemingly rally in opposition to every new construction proposal in the city.

Those looking on from the outside often brand these opponents to development as NIMBYs (not in my backyard). The NIMBY tag, unfortunately, is often used to dismiss opposition by reducing the debate to a catchphrase with a negative connotation, implying that no public concern is justified.

The prevailing attitude in Winnipeg has been that any development is good development, regardless of its long-term impact on the city's urban form. Public consultation is often seen as a roadblock to growth. Projects like the Whellam's Lane apartments in North Kildonan and the Safeway redevelopment in Osborne Village, however, became greatly improved designs in response to what some would label as NIMBY opposition.

Read
Monday, Nov. 21, 2011

Handout
Vague drawings presented to neighbours often reveal little about actual design details.

Old terminal a Modernist gem

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Old terminal a Modernist gem

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 31, 2011

It is no coincidence that in no known language does the phrase "as pretty as an airport" appear -- Douglas Adams 

 Douglas Adams, author of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, might have felt differently about airports had he seen the new Richardson International Airport terminal that on Sunday welcomed its first visitors.

The new airport stands as an impressive welcome mat for our city, a symbol of modernity and progress. Its dramatic curving glass walls anchor the building to the prairie horizon and celebrate in a single sweeping view the light and landscape that define our province. It has space, colour and light in proportions that stimulate the visitor and inspire a feeling of pride.

That last sentence, although an appropriate description of the new building, was actually written in the Winnipeg Tribune in 1964 for the opening of the terminal it is replacing. The completion of the new airport has focused public attention on the fate of its familiar old neighbour, celebrated as one of the finest pieces of Modernist architecture in Canada.

Read
Monday, Oct. 31, 2011

Winnipeg Free Press archives
The city airport terminal opened in 1964 (above) is one of the finest pieces of Modernist architecture in Canada. It adds to the richness of Winnipeg’s architectural history, as shown in the downtown buildings below. So should the old airport terminal be torn down or preserved?

The Jets — and a big-league stadium, too

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

The Jets — and a big-league stadium, too

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Oct. 10, 2011

At 4:20 on Sunday afternoon a puck dropped, a crowd roared and our isolated little burg instantly regained its place in the elite club of major-league cities. With this, a new confidence has emerged, galvanizing our civic pride and public spirit.

While basking in the national spotlight, it is easy to forget that in only eight short months our beloved community-owned football team will be contributing its own bit of swagger to Winnipeg's new big-league attitude, with the opening of its new stadium at the University of Manitoba.

With the vast majority of stadiums being designed by a handful of large, specialized, American architecture firms, it is unique that Winnipeg's new facility has been taken on by the small local firm Raymond S.C. Wan Architect.

One of the greatest challenges for a stadium designer is balancing the practical requirements of public safety, like guardrails and emergency exiting, with more qualitative issues such as sightlines, acoustics and ease of access.

Read
Monday, Oct. 10, 2011

Although most stadiums are designed by large U.S. firms, local firm Raymond S.C. Wan Architect took on Winnipeg's new stadium.

Thriving time for city architecture

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Preview

Thriving time for city architecture

By Brent Bellamy 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 19, 2011

A Google search of the term 'Winnipeg architecture' yields a colourful grid of thumbnail images that graphically illustrates the city's unique physical character. Instantly distinguishable from similar searches of Edmonton, Calgary or Vancouver, the results portray the familiar kaleidoscope of arched windows, Tyndall-stone columns and reflective glass walls that have come to define Winnipeg's modern built form.

Winnipeg's distinct architectural character is largely the result of unique growth patterns in the last century that saw rapid expansion during the two decades before the First World War and after the Second World War, each followed by long periods of economic stagnation. The city's current urban form has been largely defined by the architectural legacy left by these two distinct boom periods.

At the turn of the last century, Winnipeg became a breeding ground for new architectural ideas and technologies, rivalling work being done in larger centres across North America. The city became such an architectural hotbed it attracted some of the continent's most influential architects. McKim Mead and White, Darling and Pearson and Warren & Wetmore were three internationally renowned firms working in Winnipeg who were also designing some of the most significant buildings in Toronto, New York and Chicago at the time.

Beginning in the 1950s, Winnipeg would again become a centre for innovative design. Many local architects returned from schools like MIT, IIT and Harvard to practise in the Modernist style that was sweeping the world. The University of Manitoba, led by MIT graduate John Russell would become a leading academic institution, promoting this new movement in architecture. Many of Winnipeg's Modernist buildings would win national and international acclaim as the city became recognized for its provocative contemporary design.

Read
Monday, Sep. 19, 2011

Architect’s images of the planned facility for the upcoming Venice Biennale, the world’s most prestigious international art and architecture exhibit.

Modern flair lifts historic park

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Modern flair lifts historic park

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 29, 2011

A century ago it was the place for fashionable Winnipeggers to see and be seen. Surrounded by the stately homes of the city's well-to-do, Central Park with its Victorian flower gardens, tennis courts and bandshell stage was the centrepiece of one of Winnipeg's finest residential neighbourhoods.

In 1914, the park would gain a distinctive landmark that stands today as the last remnant of its Victorian beginnings. Local businessman Thomas Waddell was informed three years after his wife's death of an unusual clause in her will stipulating that if he were to remarry, he would be legally required to spend $10,000 building a memorial fountain in Central Park or he would forfeit his claim to her $56,000 estate.

Thomas was already engaged to be remarried by this time, but was nearly bankrupt after a series of poor real estate investments. It would take him four years to raise the money and build what has been known to generations of Winnipeggers as the Waddell Fountain.

Stories such as this exemplify the role Central Park has played in Winnipeg's rich historic narrative. By the 1960s, however, the park's prominent place in the hearts of Winnipeggers had changed. The distinguished old mansions that lined the park were demolished to make way for highrise seniors and public housing in an effort to "modernize" the neighbourhood. This ill-conceived urban renewal strategy wiped away the existing social fabric of the community and accelerated its decay. Central Park would become a desolate and forlorn place with significant issues of crime and poverty. The Waddell Fountain, once a symbol of the neighbourhood's affluence, would sit dry and in pieces, an embodiment of the area's decline.

Read
Monday, Aug. 29, 2011

Brent Bellamy / Winnipeg Free Press
The restored Waddell Fountain in Central Park.

Finding Winnipeg’s hidden jewels

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Finding Winnipeg’s hidden jewels

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Aug. 8, 2011

As the calendar moves into the dog days of August, thousands of Manitobans will head out on their summer vacations to explore the architecture and metropolitan character of different cities across the continent. From weekends in Minneapolis or Chicago, to road trips through Ontario and Quebec, many will travel near and far in search of an inspiring urban experience.

Few of us, however, will explore our own city with the same curiosity we display abroad. We often spend our vacations walking the neighbourhoods of distant cities and then return to our hurried lives, rarely slowing to appreciate Winnipeg from that same pedestrian perspective.

With beautiful, mosquito-free weather this summer, the time is right to take an urban 'staycation' and discover the often unappreciated beauty, history and distinct architectural character that makes Winnipeg as interesting and unique as the cities we visit as tourists.

As beautiful as Old Montreal or Vancouver's Gastown, Winnipeg's Exchange District, with its muscular brick warehouses aligned on cobblestone sidewalks can be as inspiring as any historic urban area in North America. Participating in one of the walking tours offered by the Exchange District BIZ brings to life the intriguing stories those heavy brick walls have to tell. With specialty themes such as Death & Debauchery or Winnipeg General Strike, each tour provides a captivating look into the rich history of the Exchange District.

Read
Monday, Aug. 8, 2011

KEN GIGLIOTTI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ARCHIVES
A view of the great hall’s painted ceiling in the downtown Bank of Montreal building.

Megaprojects alone not enough

By Brent Bellamy 4 minute read Preview

Megaprojects alone not enough

By Brent Bellamy 4 minute read Monday, Jul. 18, 2011

It's been an exciting few weeks for Winnipeg. First, Mark Chipman ended public speculation by confirming that our NHL franchise will once again carry the Jets name. Then it seemed as though every few days brought a press conference celebrating the start of a major new construction project in our city. These announcements included a highrise hotel on Portage Avenue, another at the McPhillips Station Casino, a new University of Winnipeg field house and the long-awaited renovation of the Metropolitan Theatre.

These four projects alone represent almost $200 million in construction activity and will play an important role in the growth of the city's economy, while inspiring optimism and civic pride in our community.

The long-term health of our streets and neighbourhoods, however, is dependent on the smaller, fine-grained development that settles in around these larger projects. Organic, community-oriented growth that promotes commercial, economic and residential diversity is an essential component of successful urban renewal.

A clear illustration of the transformative power of diversified, small-scale development can be seen along Sherbrook Street, south of Broadway, where over the past few years an urban renaissance has been quietly occurring.

Read
Monday, Jul. 18, 2011

COURTESY VERNE REIMER ARCHITECTURE
Sherbrook Centre’s edgy design will reinforce the area’s pedestrian streetscape, while fitting in as well.

New science centre a work of art

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

New science centre a work of art

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 27, 2011

The headline in the Winnipeg Tribune proclaimed "The city is our campus" as the University of Winnipeg celebrated the completion of Centennial Hall in 1972. Its innovative modernist architecture would grace the covers of the world's most influential design magazines and would establish Winnipeg's urban university as a significant part of the city centre.

Through the years, Centennial Hall's iconic character has been diminished by redevelopment and the university's public presence in the downtown has faded. Recently, however, this trend has begun to reverse as the U of W has embarked on an aggressive expansion plan that for the first time in its history has the campus breaking away from its traditional island block. A series of stylish new buildings is redefining the university's physical image and its presence in the downtown, much like Centennial Hall did decades ago.

Designed by Number Ten Architectural Group and built by Manshield Construction, the Richardson College for the Environment and Science complex (RCES), two blocks west of historic Wesley Hall, represents the largest of these new projects. A personal involvement as part of the design team through five years of development affords me a unique personal perspective on this project.

Celebrating its grand opening today, the college exemplifies the university's commitment to environmental sustainability. Implementing a series of first-of-a-kind sustainable technologies developed with SMS Engineering, it is hoped that the RCES will become the most energy-efficient laboratory building in North America, striving to be 50 to 60 per cent more efficient than a traditional teaching laboratory.

Read
Monday, Jun. 27, 2011

DAVID LIPNOWSKI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ARCHIVES
The atrium of the U of W’s new Richardson College for the Environment and Science is lined with the former Winnipeg Roller Rink’s wood flooring.

Eaton’s Building leaves long legacy

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Eaton’s Building leaves long legacy

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 6, 2011

In 1902, 3,000 jubilant supporters packed into the Main Street Auditorium to watch the Winnipeg Victorias come from behind to beat the Toronto Wellingtons 5-3, clinching their third and final Stanley Cup championship.

Two years later, that flourishing young metropolis would further cement its reputation as one of Canada's big league cities as the dramatic Eaton's Building began to rise along Portage Avenue. The tenth largest department store in the world, it was estimated in 1960 that 50 cents out of every shopping dollar spent in Winnipeg happened at "the big store." With a floor area nearly double that of the 30-storey Richardson Building, its scale and presence made her a Portage Avenue icon and one of Canada's most significant buildings of the early 20th century.

When Eaton's fell into bankruptcy in the late 1990s, the store closed and public debate raged over the future of a building that was cherished by generations of Winnipeggers. In 2002, with public opposition, the decision was made to demolish the structure and replace it with a new 15,000-seat arena, then called the True North Centre.

The significance of that decision would not be fully understood until last Tuesday when the city watched an emotional Mark Chipman proudly announce the return of NHL hockey to Winnipeg.

Read
Monday, Jun. 6, 2011

In 1902, 3,000 jubilant supporters packed into the Main Street Auditorium to watch the Winnipeg Victorias come from behind to beat the Toronto Wellingtons 5-3, clinching their third and final Stanley Cup championship.

Two years later, that flourishing young metropolis would further cement its reputation as one of Canada's big league cities as the dramatic Eaton's Building began to rise along Portage Avenue. The tenth largest department store in the world, it was estimated in 1960 that 50 cents out of every shopping dollar spent in Winnipeg happened at "the big store." With a floor area nearly double that of the 30-storey Richardson Building, its scale and presence made her a Portage Avenue icon and one of Canada's most significant buildings of the early 20th century.

When Eaton's fell into bankruptcy in the late 1990s, the store closed and public debate raged over the future of a building that was cherished by generations of Winnipeggers. In 2002, with public opposition, the decision was made to demolish the structure and replace it with a new 15,000-seat arena, then called the True North Centre.

The significance of that decision would not be fully understood until last Tuesday when the city watched an emotional Mark Chipman proudly announce the return of NHL hockey to Winnipeg.

Development needs managing

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Development needs managing

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, May. 16, 2011

As another long winter fades into memory, the temperatures have begun to rise and leaves are starting to appear on the trees. A new season is finally upon us. For many, it's simply known as spring. For others, the colourful umbrellas popping open in front of restaurants across the city are a welcome sign patio season has finally returned.

The cornerstone of Winnipeg's patio culture is, of course, Corydon Avenue, which has blossomed in recent years to become one of Winnipeg's few vibrant pedestrian areas. On a warm June evening, the sidewalks overflow with activity as people enjoy a trademark gelato, do some shopping or simply spend time watching the crowds. It is an urban experience that at times is comparable to that found on streets like Robson in Vancouver or Whyte Avenue in Edmonton.

Much of Corydon's success can be attributed to a layout and physical form that shares many common characteristics with some of the best pedestrian streets in North America.

The key physical qualities of a great street like Corydon work together to create a comfortable pedestrian experience along the sidewalk. The most fundamental of these design attributes is a continuous street edge defined by buildings constructed right up to the sidewalk. This configuration provides a sense of enclosure and promotes an interaction between pedestrians and the adjacent buildings. Ground-floor transparency increases this visual dialogue by blurring the definition between interior and exterior space. Buildings constructed to the sidewalk provide environmental shelter while confining the visual expanse of the street, which creates intimacy, slows vehicular traffic and improves the perception of safety.

Read
Monday, May. 16, 2011

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Corydon Avenue’s popularity makes it sensitive to the pressures of new development.

Urban issues UNDER THE RADAR

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Urban issues UNDER THE RADAR

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 25, 2011

Snow-capped peaks reflecting off a clear alpine lake, a turbulent river cascading over a rocky ledge and golden wheat fields swaying in a Prairie wind. These are the alluring images that make up the Canadian national identity.

The Canadian reality, however, is a stark contrast. Ours is an urban nation, one of the most metropolitan on earth. With more than 80 per cent of us living in cities, Canada is even more urbanized than countries such as Germany, France and Japan.

The 35 largest metropolitan areas in Canada account for 65 per cent of the population, 70 per cent of all employment and 75 per cent of the GDP. Cities are the social, cultural and economic engines of our country, yet Canada is the only member of the G8 without a comprehensive 'national urban policy' addressing the unique issues cities face.

As we head into another federal election, policy debate among political parties and candidates is exposing an absence of urban issues in the national dialogue. The discussion of the federal role in the growth of our cities has generally been limited to the issues of transfer payments and infrastructure programs. There appears to be a lack of recognition that Canada's prosperity, global competitiveness and quality of life are substantially controlled by its urban areas and the government policies that affect them.

Read
Monday, Apr. 25, 2011

friesen tokar / gpp architecture
An artist's rendering of the Osborne Street Rapid Transit Station. Federal support for urban transit is a major issue in Canada's big cities.

Good designs, good neighbours

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Good designs, good neighbours

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Apr. 4, 2011

Public debate over architecture and urban design is a rare occurrence in Winnipeg. Generally, discussion about our city's built form ventures no deeper than the subject of potholes or traffic circles. One exception to this came in early 2009 as the new head office for the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority took shape on Main Street. Politicians, concerned citizens and the media engaged in an uncharacteristic dialogue about the development's design and urban response.

It was argued the removal of elements such as the pharmacy and ground-level retail space diminished the building's interaction with its neighbourhood and concern was raised over the expression of an open-air parkade fronting one of the city's most important streets.

The building provoked important debate about design in our city. With several new projects beginning to redefine Winnipeg's urban character, this type of public discussion and engagement will become even more essential in the future.

Two significant new WRHA projects will likely be celebrated in this dialogue as examples of good design forming positive relationships with their neighbourhood. Both projects demonstrate that even buildings such as health-care facilities, defined by complex and demanding functional requirements, can provide inspiring interior space while having a positive impact on the urban surroundings.

Read
Monday, Apr. 4, 2011

HAndout
The Women and Newborn Hospital project at the Health Sciences Centre has already received an architectural award.

A new purpose for old buildings

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

A new purpose for old buildings

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Mar. 14, 2011

It may not be as simple as throwing a building into a giant blue box and dragging it to the curb, but with construction costs rising and sustainable design growing in importance, the practice of recycling buildings has become a significant development trend around the world.

All cities are filled with buildings that have outlived their original purpose. As an alternative to demolition, these structures are more often being looked at as a 'mine' of raw materials for new development. The recycling of buildings can be as simple as preserving specific components and reusing them in new construction. An excellent example of this is the historic facades that were maintained as part of Red River College's downtown campus.

An even more extensive recycling strategy known as 'adaptive reuse' focuses on maintaining the structure or basic fabric of the building and repurposing its function.

This approach to development often results in unique projects that effectively reduce the amount of new materials that are needed for construction, which can have economic, environmental and social benefits to developers and the community.

Read
Monday, Mar. 14, 2011

Friesen Tokar Architects rendering
Friesen Tokar Architects have developed a plan for a modern, four-storey apartment building inside the shell of St. Matthew�s Anglican Church.

You gotta love it: Winnipeg brims with tradition, history

By Brent Bellamy 3 minute read Preview

You gotta love it: Winnipeg brims with tradition, history

By Brent Bellamy 3 minute read Sunday, Mar. 13, 2011

Winnipeg is a harsh city. It's isolated and it's flat, a place of extremes. It's hot and it's cold. Only Ulan Bator, Mongolia; Irkutsk, Siberia; and Harbin, China can claim more frigid winters than ours. In fleeting summers, we fight floods, potholes and mosquitoes.

Yet, it's a place I love.

Winnipeg is subtle, it's proud and it's real. Its hard edges are softened by the majestic elm trees that strain to reach across and embrace each other high above our residential streets. The meandering rivers form the backdrop to sun-filled urban parks, from Kildonan to King's to Assiniboine.

Ours is a city of tradition. For generations, we have spent warm summer nights at the BDI or cruising out to Skinner's for a hotdog. We cheer the Bombers on cold October weekends and play shinny at the local club on brisk winter days. Our traditions unite us as a community.

Read
Sunday, Mar. 13, 2011

Brent Bellamy at the corner of McDermot Avenue and Albert Street.

Let’s build a city we can love

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Let’s build a city we can love

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2011

The stars of the romantic comedy Sex and the City spent six seasons searching for love. Relationships came and went, Big, Aidan and the Russian, but the love affair that remained constant was the one they had with their city. Their emotional connection to the vibrancy, character and style of New York was the show's consistent thread.

Marking the end of the 2010 Cultural Capital celebrations, the Winnipeg Arts Council invited former Vancouver senior community planner Larry Beasley to the My City is Still Breathing Symposium to discuss how this type of urban love affair can be a defining factor in the image, physical expression and economy of a city.

Beasley described that since the Second World War, urban planning in cities like Winnipeg has been primarily an exercise in vehicle management, trading the human experience for the conveniences of modern life.

While urban design has focused on the engineering of movement, it has ignored the issues of beauty, social engagement and livability that inspire emotional connections to the city. Who could be in love with the oceans of asphalt and the concrete canyons of Pembina Highway?

Read
Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2011

KEN GIGLIOTTI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS archives
Once derided as a needless extravagance, Esplanade Riel is now a beloved civic icon thanks to its emotional connection with Winnipeggers.

2010: a year of civic progress

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

2010: a year of civic progress

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Jan. 31, 2011

As the calendar turned to 2011, year-end reflections and "best of 2010" countdowns dominated the media. It has become a New Year's tradition to solve the difficult questions such as who had the better album, Kanye West or Arcade Fire, or was The King's Speech a better movie than Inception?

How then will 2010 be remembered in Winnipeg? Should we look back on its development as a countdown of highlights or should Mr. Blackwell put us on his worst dressed list?

One indicator that is used to gauge a city's growth and development is the value of building permits issued each year. Winnipeg's total in 2010 (Q3) increased by 27 per cent over the year before and was twice what it was in 2005. At a time when much of the continent was mired in recession, this should be celebrated.

It is often lamented, however, that the evidence of this growth is not as easily identified as it is for our western neighbours, whose skylines are filled with cranes constructing gleaming glass towers. Even with several projects on hold, Edmonton, Calgary and Vancouver each had between five and 10 highrises under construction in 2010. The only crane on our horizon was at the site of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights.

Read
Monday, Jan. 31, 2011

Submitted photo
Cube Winnipeg (below) in the Exchange District and the Buhler Centre (above) at the site of the demolished United Army Surplus: examples of projects that are better, not bigger, and provide a connection with the neighbourhoods they are located in.

Heart of Chinatown tossed aside

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Heart of Chinatown tossed aside

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Jan. 10, 2011

In 1882, three years before the CPR would drive the "Last Spike" and Louis Riel would lead the Northwest Rebellion, the first frontier town of the Canadian West began to establish itself on the banks of the Red River.

In that year, Sir John A. Macdonald would win re-election, newspapers across the American West would report the scandalous murder of the outlaw Jesse James and in Winnipeg, a shanty town of dirt roads and wooden sidewalks, a building boom would begin.

As the town's population soared to nearly 15,000, at the dusty corner of King and Alexander the new Coronation Block would begin to rise. It would be home to the mayor's office and council chambers while the elegant Victorian city hall was being built down the street.

After the turn of the century, a Chinese immigrant community would establish itself in the neighbourhood and the Coronation Block would become a focal point in the area. For seven decades it would find a place in the collective hearts of Winnipeggers as home to the Shanghai restaurant.

Read
Monday, Jan. 10, 2011

SUBMITTED PHOTO
The Coronation Block at the corner of King Street and Alexander Avenue housed the mayor’s office and council chambers before the Shanghai restaurant opened there.

Shopping for an urban esthetic

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Shopping for an urban esthetic

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Dec. 20, 2010

Christmas 1949: As the clanging bells of passing streetcars fill the air, Winnipeggers with arms weighed down by shopping bags struggle for space on the busy sidewalks of Portage Avenue. The streets glow with coloured light, the gingerbread city hall sparkles in the distance. Children watch as mechanical figurines bring the Eaton's windows to life.

Christmas 1959: As festive music chimes down from above, encouraging shoppers to spend, a new Christmas tradition is born as Winnipeggers stroll on covered sidewalks past the manicured courtyards of Polo Park, the city's first shopping centre.

Christmas 1979: With long lines of children eagerly awaiting their turn with Santa, a different Christmas carol playing in every store, the warm corridors of the regional mall has become the backdrop for Winnipeg's Christmas experience.

Christmas 1999: As 'big box' power centres proliferate, the familiar holiday scene becomes a search for parking along an endless row of cars, braving harsh winter winds while scrambling between stores across a sea of treeless, ice-covered asphalt.

Read
Monday, Dec. 20, 2010

SUPPLIED PHOTO
Winnipeg’s Exchange District could benefit from the ‘new’ retail centre approach.

Density makes cities richer

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Density makes cities richer

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 29, 2010

In December of 2002, the Frontier Centre for Public Policy released a document entitled Let's Worry about Stagnation, not Sprawl. It concluded that because Winnipeg had maintained its density in comparison to other cities, urban sprawl should not be a public concern. Planning policies that promoted density were dismissed as "an unnecessary prescription for a problem that doesn't exist in Winnipeg."

How times have changed.

While it may have been true that after decades of slow growth Winnipeg had until then managed to avoid the sprawling suburban development that was beginning to define cities across Canada, in the eight years since, we have more than caught up to the others. With a population increase of nearly 50,000 people over that time, a wave of new auto-centric, low density suburbs are today pushing the city's edges outwards in every direction.

Generally unaware of the connection, Winnipeggers voiced a number of concerns during the recent civic election that can be tied directly to the effects of this outward growth. Property taxes, road maintenance, the provision of civic amenities and services were all identified as important issues and each becomes a greater challenge as the city sprawls. In simple terms, with a lower population density every individual taxpayer becomes financially responsible for maintaining a greater proportion of roads, community centres and services like snow clearing and garbage collection.

Read
Monday, Nov. 29, 2010

+White Architecture
The plan for the Yards at Fort Rouge includes high-rise apartment build­ings, but close to existing homes it features low-rise townhouses to better blend into the neighbourhood.

Modernist buildings have a story to tell

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Modernist buildings have a story to tell

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 8, 2010

In 2007, the American Institute of Architects launched a public survey to identify "America's Favourite Architecture." With the Empire State Building, the White House and the Washington National Cathedral finishing in the Top 3, the list exposed a strong public connection with heritage buildings. Of the Top 50 favourite structures in the United States, only five were built after the Second World War.

These results raise the question: Do people prefer historic buildings for their character and style or, like a favourite pair of faded blue jeans, is time and familiarity an important factor in the public perception of architecture? Will the steel and glass modernist buildings that replaced these styles be just as well-loved when they are old enough to be considered historic? If so, should we work to protect them in the same way we do the brick buildings of the Exchange District?

The answers to these questions are of particular importance for Winnipeg, a city celebrated for its historic buildings, but less well known as home to one of the finest surviving collections of modernist architecture in Canada.

Emerging in the 1950s, modernism was an architectural movement that rejected the ornamentation of the past and celebrated the technological advancements of the 20th century. Heavy walls of stone were replaced with large curtains of glass flooding light into open interior spaces. The decorative motifs of the past gave way to a machine-inspired look of exposed structure and clean, austere lines.

Read
Monday, Nov. 8, 2010

The old terminal building at Richardson International Airport is one of Winnipeg’s most significant representatives of modernism.

Kenora putting on its best face

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Kenora putting on its best face

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Oct. 18, 2010

Anyone who has seen the Disney film Cars knows the sad story of the fictional town of Radiator Springs. The once-lively stop on Route 66 was effectively erased from the map when a new freeway was built bypassing the town. The economy crashed. The tire shop couldn't sell tires, the hotel couldn't rent rooms and the sleepy main drag fell into disrepair.

The city of Kenora, Ont., was faced with the possibility of this story becoming a reality when in 1990 the decision was made to build a bypass on the Trans-Canada Highway. This new road would divert 3,500 vehicles every day away from the city's picturesque main street. Coupled with the closing of the paper mill, the city's largest employer for 80 years, Kenora seemed destined to become a real life Radiator Springs.

The economic challenges facing the businesses of downtown Kenora were compounded by the suburban big box retail invasion that has devastated small business in cities and towns across North America. Walmart, the poster child for this phenomenon, even set up shop on the city's east side.

In reaction to these pressures, a group of forward-thinking business leaders and elected officials began to implement creative long-term urban design strategies that would capitalize on the region's tourism potential and move the city in a new, more prosperous direction. A vibrant and attractive downtown was identified as a key component of the makeover, setting the backdrop for a quality-of-life marketing campaign that could draw new investment, business and residents.

Read
Monday, Oct. 18, 2010

Brent Bellamy photo
Downtown Kenora's image has been transformed with heavy trucks gone and pedestrian-friendly streetscape in place.

Shining a light on downtown

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Shining a light on downtown

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Sep. 27, 2010

In 1820, Paris established itself as the 'City of Light' when it became one of the first in the world to illuminate its streets with gas lanterns. This transformed the character, economy and culture of the city as it came alive at night with shops and cafés remaining open long after dark. The soft orange light cast on the limestone buildings was considered so beautiful it inspired the works of impressionist painters like Renoir and Van Gogh.

Over the next two centuries, urban lighting across the world has most often been considered from a purely functional perspective, flooding streets and buildings with consistent, high-intensity light. With the emergence of new technologies, exterior lighting is again becoming an inspiring urban feature and creative extension of architectural design. Good architecture transforms itself as light conditions change around it. A unique example of this is the Buhler Centre on Portage Avenue by DPA+PSA+DIN Collective, which creatively uses metal tabs as nighttime reflectors, subtly animating the façade as they capture the moving light of passing cars.

This choreography of light and shadow is becoming a renewed trend in modern architecture. With the emergence of LED (light-emitting diode) technology, creative lighting opportunities are almost limitless. These ultra-efficient, extremely long-lasting fixtures allow designers to manipulate the colour and intensity of light cast on and from buildings at night.

Exterior lighting design can be an affordable way for building owners to add value to their properties by improving energy efficiency and enhancing the overall appearance and public perception of their buildings.

Read
Monday, Sep. 27, 2010

Gerry Kopelow photo
The walkway on St. Mary Avenue (above) and the Paris Building are two examples of using light to create a warm and inviting atmosphere downtown.

Exchange needs a delicate blend

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Exchange needs a delicate blend

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Tuesday, Sep. 7, 2010

Many Winnipeggers share the childhood memory of eagerly tearing open the wax-paper wrapping, chewing that stale stick of gum while flipping through a new pack of hockey cards in search of their favourite players.

For most, the trading cards have been lost somewhere in time, but occasionally an old collection forgotten in the back of the closet is uncovered to reveal a valuable link to the past.

Like that collection of old hockey cards, hidden away for years, the buildings of Winnipeg's Exchange District have survived because they had largely been forgotten. Decades of slow growth has meant little pressure to redevelop the area, resulting in a substantially intact collection of historic buildings.

Today's rediscovery of the Exchange District is attracting new development that is threatening to alter its character and feel. This sudden pressure has exposed the need for strong public policy that defines a long-term vision for the heritage neighbourhood.

Read
Tuesday, Sep. 7, 2010

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Buildings are de­molished in Win­nipeg’s historic Exchange District to make way for new development.

Pedestrian mall? Groovy, man

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Pedestrian mall? Groovy, man

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Aug. 16, 2010

Every year at the height of summer, the Fringe Festival invades Winnipeg and the cobblestone sidewalks of the Exchange District come alive as artists' kiosks, shops and restaurants overflow with people late into the evening.

It's almost as if, for a short time, our tranquil warehouse district masquerades as a little piece of New York's Greenwich Village. When the Fringe moves on and the streets again fall quiet, we are left to wonder what might be done to capture a small piece of that vibrancy and maintain it throughout the year.

The latest edition of the Fringe may have inadvertently uncovered an idea worth investigating in an effort to accomplish this goal. Construction at the Union Tower forced the relocation of the kiosks and children's stage to Albert Street, which was closed to automobiles. This lured people away from Old Market Square and into the neighbourhood, increasing foot traffic and economic activity to the adjacent businesses. In light of this success, might a similar move be considered a permanent strategy for the area?

Creating pedestrian malls by closing streets to vehicles was an idea explored across North America 40 years ago as cities battled against the draw of suburban shopping centres. More than 200 cities closed streets in their failing downtowns, rolling out benches and planters in hopes it would bring shoppers back to the core. In the end, almost 80 per cent of these developments failed and were eventually reopened to cars.

Read
Monday, Aug. 16, 2010

BRENT BELLAMY / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Albert Street is an ideal location for a pedestrian arcade in the Exchange District. Cities across Canada are finding success today with car-free zones.

Sports facilities help cities avoid ‘doughnut’ look

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Sports facilities help cities avoid ‘doughnut’ look

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Jul. 26, 2010

It's an ironic coincidence that during the last three decades, with the rise in popularity of Tim Hortons, not only are Canadians' collective midriffs beginning to resemble the shape of a doughnut, but so too are many of our cities.

Referred to as the "doughnut effect," places like Winnipeg have seen a migration of population and commerce to the edges of the city, creating an economic void in the centre. As sprawling suburbs and big-box retail centres leapfrog each other outward, the city becomes less dense, less sustainable and weakened at its core. Many once-proud inner-city neighbourhoods now struggle with issues of crime and poverty as a result.

Politicians, planners and development agencies in many cities have long been searching for ways to combat this social inequity between the core and the suburbs. With Winnipeg's traditional slow growth, we have only recently joined the club of "doughnut cities" and might learn from the experience of others in finding solutions.

Although many cities concentrate on attracting residential, retail and office development as a means of strengthening the urban centre, in Great Britain, sport and recreation are included as an effective strategic tool for urban regeneration. The value of athletic facilities, both amateur and professional, has been recognized as a means of injecting economic and social improvement into the core and has become a key component in the approach to improving neighbourhood environments.

Read
Monday, Jul. 26, 2010

JANEK LOWE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
North End Wellness Centre (above) at Mountain and McGregor, and North Centennial Recreation Centre at Dufferin and Sinclair are an integral part of their communities.

Provocative designs may redefine city

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Provocative designs may redefine city

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Jul. 5, 2010

Imagine a Paris with no Eiffel Tower.

It seems incredible today, but from the moment the French icon began to rise skyward, it faced widespread opposition. The newspaper Le Temps wrote that the tower "threatened French art and history," its radical design destroying the "intact beauty of Paris."

Novelist Guy de Maupassant famously ate lunch every day in the tower's restaurant because, as he put it, "It's the only place in Paris where I don't have to look at it."

This shows that even in great cities like Paris, change is and has always been received with hesitation. Negative reaction to the unfamiliar is human nature no matter where you live.

Read
Monday, Jul. 5, 2010

Imagine a Paris with no Eiffel Tower.

It seems incredible today, but from the moment the French icon began to rise skyward, it faced widespread opposition. The newspaper Le Temps wrote that the tower "threatened French art and history," its radical design destroying the "intact beauty of Paris."

Novelist Guy de Maupassant famously ate lunch every day in the tower's restaurant because, as he put it, "It's the only place in Paris where I don't have to look at it."

This shows that even in great cities like Paris, change is and has always been received with hesitation. Negative reaction to the unfamiliar is human nature no matter where you live.

Downtown’s status symbol

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Downtown’s status symbol

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 5 minute read Monday, Jun. 14, 2010

Pedestrians gazed in wonder as her steel frame rose high above the city in the summer of 1903. The Manitoba Free Press wrote: "The huge steel stanchions have reached a point skyward where it almost begins to make one dizzy to view the upward progress." She was a symbol that this confident young city had arrived on the national stage, a declaration that it could compete with the great cities of the east.

Union Bank Tower at the apex of the bend in Main Street took its place in Winnipeg's skyline more than a century ago. Many of the great events in our city's history have happened in her shadow, yet most of us pass by without appreciating her significance or engaging in the stories she can tell.

Designed in the Chicago School style by prominent Toronto architects Pearson and Darling, the decorative cornice hangs 47.6 metres above the sidewalk. This height would for two years allow Winnipeggers to boastfully lay claim to the "tallest skyscraper in Canada" as the first building to exceed 10 storeys. The flag pole on its roof proudly flew the highest Union Jack in the British Commonwealth.

Costing $420,000 to construct, Union Tower incorporated the latest technologies used in the world's first skyscrapers. Traditional load-bearing brick walls were replaced with a light steel skeleton frame, allowing the tower to reach its soaring height and skyscraper status.

Read
Monday, Jun. 14, 2010

Submitted photo
Prairie Architects' rendering of the revamped Union Bank Tower on Main Street.

Spanish city model for future Forks

Brent Bellamy/On Architecture 5 minute read Preview

Spanish city model for future Forks

Brent Bellamy/On Architecture 5 minute read Tuesday, May. 25, 2010

Imagine a city in the not-too-distant future. A medium-sized city, isolated and far from the power centres of the country.

Clinging to the banks of a muddy old river, the evidence of early prosperity is seen in the rail yards, once its lifeblood. For a century, the trains screeched and smoke billowed from the central yard, but when the asphalt railway took over, the area fell silent.

Over the years, the riverside industrial land was reclaimed as a great public space for the city. The old buildings were transformed into markets, and a waterfront walkway and a dramatic new bridge were built. Park space, a hotel, a theatre and restaurants were all part of the plan.

A rapid transit line brought the site to the city. The area changed forever when a world-class museum went up, attracting tourists from around the globe. Embraced as a jewel in the city's crown, it became a source of pride for all.

Read
Tuesday, May. 25, 2010

Bellamy commercial real estate
Artists's conception of The Forks, featuring an increased residential component that could be key to revitalization of the wider area.

Blot on downtown landscape

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Blot on downtown landscape

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, May. 10, 2010

'Our Golden Business Boy will watch the North End die, and sing I love this town, then let his arcing wrecking ball proclaim, I hate Winnipeg'

As this line from the Weakerthans song One Great City candidly expresses, Winnipeg's long history of building demolition to make way for open parking lots has left our downtown resembling the toothless grin of hockey Hall of Famer Bobby Clarke.

Winnipeg is home to some of the largest urban parking lots in Canada. These inhospitable asphalt deserts create pedestrian dead zones that fragment the city centre. A low downtown residential population and years of declining transit ridership have resulted in high demand for parking from 70, 000 daily commuters. Optimistically designed for "Chicago of the North," it has historically been difficult to maintain density in our oversized city centre.

Many recent downtown developments seek to provide the same drive up and park convenience that the suburbs offer. While it is unlikely the downtown will ever out-suburb the suburbs, a clean, safe, walkable and interesting urban experience will attract people because it offers something different than what can be found at Kenaston and McGillivray. Downtown surface parking lots dilute all of these desirable characteristics.

Read
Monday, May. 10, 2010

Urban gems helping city shine

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Urban gems helping city shine

By Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Apr. 12, 2010

The recent global economic downturn has had a devastating effect on the architecture industry in North America. Nearly one-quarter of all jobs in the profession have been lost in the United States and with construction dropping by 25 per cent last year alone, Canadian firms have also been hit hard.

Seemingly against this global trend, Winnipeg's architecture community has been flourishing in recent years. Several new firms have opened and many others have expanded their business in Winnipeg and abroad. While megaprojects designed by acclaimed international architects rightfully receive much of the fanfare, local designers have seized this period of growth to do imaginative work on smaller projects that are transforming the city's neighbourhoods.

Good architecture at any scale has the ability to inspire the public spirit. Often, the hidden gems that we interact with on a personal level have a greater influence on the emotional connection we make with our city than any new downtown skyscraper could.

Sitting quietly among the elm trees in Wolseley is one of these little surprises. Retail architecture is often merely a platform for the largest sign allowable by zoning, but the expansion of Tall Grass Prairie Bakery, by Syverson Monteyne Architects, exemplifies how with good design and elegant materials a retail building can make a memorable statement without relying on brightly coloured stucco and glowing signs. Constructed using reclaimed wood from fallen grain elevators and the old Winnipeg Arena, the new building appears as a grey box floating over a wall of glass that floods an airy, two-storey interior space with warm sunlight.

Read
Monday, Apr. 12, 2010

H*[

Star power elevates skyline

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Preview

Star power elevates skyline

Brent Bellamy / On Architecture 4 minute read Monday, Mar. 22, 2010

American tennis star Andre Agassi famously claimed, "image is everything." Actress Jennifer Lopez sells music, clothing and perfume bearing her name. Until recently, golfer Tiger Woods' trademark smile was used to sell everything from cars to soft drinks. The pervasive nature of today's mass media has created an explosion of celebrity culture in society.

Image-based celebrity branding has infiltrated even the traditional world of architecture, where media savvy 'starchitects' and their signature styles have become commodities to be purchased like the latest fashions off the runways of Milan. Cities around the globe clamour to have the latest works of the hottest 'it' designer. Having one of their buildings in your skyline is seen as the equivalent of having an Armani suit in your closet. Like casting Brad Pitt to star in your movie, building owners often hire 'starchitects' to ensure a level of prestige for their projects. While this phenomenon has traditionally been the playground of global cities such as New York and Toronto, three current Winnipeg projects indicate it may have found its way to our humble city.

The new Richardson International Airport terminal was designed by one of the most high-profile architects to ever work in Winnipeg. Argentine César Pelli is most famous for creating the striking Petronas Towers in Malaysia. Once the tallest buildings in the world, they starred prominently alongside Sean Connery and Catherine Zeta-Jones in the Hollywood movie Entrapment.

The dramatic design of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, under construction at The Forks, is by celebrated American architect Antoine Predock, who received the commission after winning a design competition that included nearly every 'starchitect' in the world.

Read
Monday, Mar. 22, 2010

American tennis star Andre Agassi famously claimed, "image is everything." Actress Jennifer Lopez sells music, clothing and perfume bearing her name. Until recently, golfer Tiger Woods' trademark smile was used to sell everything from cars to soft drinks. The pervasive nature of today's mass media has created an explosion of celebrity culture in society.

Image-based celebrity branding has infiltrated even the traditional world of architecture, where media savvy 'starchitects' and their signature styles have become commodities to be purchased like the latest fashions off the runways of Milan. Cities around the globe clamour to have the latest works of the hottest 'it' designer. Having one of their buildings in your skyline is seen as the equivalent of having an Armani suit in your closet. Like casting Brad Pitt to star in your movie, building owners often hire 'starchitects' to ensure a level of prestige for their projects. While this phenomenon has traditionally been the playground of global cities such as New York and Toronto, three current Winnipeg projects indicate it may have found its way to our humble city.

The new Richardson International Airport terminal was designed by one of the most high-profile architects to ever work in Winnipeg. Argentine César Pelli is most famous for creating the striking Petronas Towers in Malaysia. Once the tallest buildings in the world, they starred prominently alongside Sean Connery and Catherine Zeta-Jones in the Hollywood movie Entrapment.

The dramatic design of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, under construction at The Forks, is by celebrated American architect Antoine Predock, who received the commission after winning a design competition that included nearly every 'starchitect' in the world.