July 10, 2020

13° C, Fair

Full Forecast

Close this
Winnipeg Free Press



Exhausted, sleep-deprived workers on trains in Manitoba, reports reveal

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 7/1/2019 (549 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

OTTAWA — CN trains travelling across Manitoba are being operated by overtired railway staff who are unable to take their mandated rest breaks, with some even falling asleep while on shift.

Fatigue is one of a handful of rail-safety issues the Free Press uncovered after obtaining complaints filed by rail workers with the Transportation Safety Board — complaints the watchdog deemed serious enough to flag for CN Rail.

The issue largely surrounds scheduling breaks for rail workers crossing the country on multi-day trips, on lines increasingly used to transport crude oil.

In a December 2016 letter, the TSB raised a whistleblower's report of rail staff arriving at the CN bunkhouse in Rivers who "encountered situations where all of the rooms at the rest facility are occupied," and were sent 40 kilometres away to hotels in Brandon. The complainant claimed that CN supervisors were counting as much as 90 minutes of travel back and forth between the hotel and the railway as part of the staff’s allotted sleep time.

The issue re-emerged 12 months later, when the TSB received two complaints that staff arriving at Rivers "are being instructed to book off-duty and commence their rest period, even when the bunkhouse is full and no rooms are available."

The allegations involved crews based out of Winnipeg and Melville, Sask., some of whom ended up sleeping on couches and kitchen floors, according to sources familiar with the decades-old Rivers bunkhouse.

The facility sits near one of Canada's busiest rail lines, housing dozens of rooms with individual beds.

"While waiting for rooms, these employees remain in the common areas of the facility," the TSB relayed. "In one situation, the wait time (before a room became available) was four hours."

The TSB has documented rest issues for Manitoba rail staff for years, which have persisted until at least this past summer. In July, the TSB relayed an incident involving Winnipeg CN crews travelling to Minnesota. The employees claimed they weren’t being given the 10 hours of rest required under American laws upon reaching a rest facility in International Falls, Minn., on the border with Fort Frances, Ont.

In one alleged incident along that line, staff worked 15 hours, and were granted a total of eight hours break at the facility before heading back to work.

That chunk of time includes leaving the train, preparing for rest, sleeping and then preparing for the workday. Sleep researchers have long suggested humans need time to ease into sleep, and should get seven or eight hours of shuteye.

CN Rivers bunkhouse is a facility in which staff can sleep.


CN Rivers bunkhouse is a facility in which staff can sleep.

The TSB, an independent body that probes systemic risks and alerts the regulator, Transport Canada, has identified fatigue in 93 of its investigations since 1992, a third of which involve trains.

The watchdog has listed rail-worker fatigue as one of Canada's top safety risks for two years, and last fall it expanded its watchlist to include fatigue issues among air and marine workers.

TSB chair Kathy Fox said the problem is not just the amount of sleep workers get, but also companies providing guesthouses with too much noise and light to get a decent rest. Meanwhile, federal rules say companies have to schedule shifts that account for "accumulated sleep debt" and accommodate circadian rhythms.

"This has to be approached from a more modern, holistic, scientific perspective," Fox told reporters last October.

"There's a lot that needs to be done for how these are scheduled, and how long the shifts are, and how much rest you need in between to really recover." – Transportation Safety Board senior member Faye Ackermans

In fact, an internal May 2018 memo obtained by CBC News had Transport Canada officials warning federal rail-worker rules that were last updated in 2002 "are not effective in preventing fatigue due to work schedules, and do not adequately mitigate the risks of fatigue."

The note cited "a patchwork of approaches, most of which are outside (Transport Canada's) control."

TSB senior member Faye Ackermans said one of those is the constantly changing work schedules for rail employees.

"They don't know when exactly they'll be called into work, so they might wake up in the morning fully rested, but they might wait six or seven hours for the call to work. And by the time they get to work, they might be pretty tired because they've been up for so long," she said.

"There's a lot that needs to be done for how these are scheduled, and how long the shifts are, and how much rest you need in between to really recover."

Such fears emerged in a TSB warning from November 2017. A tipster reported to the agency that that CN "operating employees" in Winnipeg were too afraid to report being unfit for work, even if they hadn’t had enough sleep.

In one case earlier that year at Symington Yard, a whistleblower claimed that "CN officials discovered the employee asleep and woke up the employee. The employee was allowed to complete the shift and there were no further sleep events for the employee during that shift." The TSB told the Free Press this involved an employee at the yard in the cabin of a train, who was likely keeping watch as a colleague outside the train moved it using a remote-control belt pack.

A whistleblower claimed CN had investigated 36 employees in Winnipeg who said they were unfit to work and even disciplined 19 of them.


A whistleblower claimed CN had investigated 36 employees in Winnipeg who said they were unfit to work and even disciplined 19 of them.

The tipster also claimed that CN had investigated 36 employees in Winnipeg who said they were unfit to work — that can mean anything from being too tired to work to having a medical issue — and even disciplined 19 of them.

NDP MP Daniel Blaikie said he regularly hears concerns about worker fatigue from labour groups affiliated with all three major railways operating in the city, not just in his Transcona riding.

"Anyone who's been stuck in traffic in Winnipeg by a train knows that there's a lot of oil cars moving through Winnipeg, on both train lines," said Blaikie, who’s particularly concerned about the railways and railyards "sandwiched right in the middle of the city."

The amount of oil being transported on rail is increasing, with Canadian exports of crude to the American Midwest doubling this fall, raising concerns about Canada's safety oversight. Just last Thursday, two trains collided near Portage la Prairie, with one leaking diesel and the other carrying hazardous goods. The incident remains under investigation, and it's unknown whether fatigue played a factor.

Transport Minister Marc Garneau maintains that safety is his top priority, and his department cites progress on rail safety, like phasing out riskier train cars.

In late December, Garneau ordered rail companies to update their rules around rest periods, shift duration and advance notice for scheduling. Those rules are due in May, and Ottawa will take a month to review them.

A year prior, Garneau issued a notice that his government would start consultations on updated regulations, which prescribe standards on companies instead of crafting them together. His department commissioned research on fatigue science, but it won't be completed until at least February.

Last October, the TSB called for "a profound change in attitudes and behaviours" to prevent fatigue. Garneau told the Free Press last month that such regulations will take time to craft.

"We are working in an expeditious manner, but when you have to do something as important and as big as this, you have to do the necessary consultation — not only with the railways, but also with the unions, with the academic world, so that we make the best decisions."

CN referred queries to the Railway Association of Canada, which wrote that its industry is committed to safety, with the group hosting "medical advisory group" that looks into the causes of fatigue issues and how to mitigate risks.

"RAC believes that fatigue is a matter requiring empirical evidence and a scientific approach to identifying and delivering effective solutions to address fatigue in the workplace," wrote spokesman Michael Gullo.

Fox said the clock is ticking:

"Promising action is not the same as delivering it, especially when the plain truth is that inaction can cost lives."


This is the final instalment in a three-part series examining safety issues along Winnipeg’s rail lines, amid a historic rise in the volume of oil being shipped on trains.

Your support has enabled us to provide free access to stories about COVID-19 because we believe everyone deserves trusted and critical information during the pandemic.

Our readership has contributed additional funding to give Free Press online subscriptions to those that can’t afford one in these extraordinary times — giving new readers the opportunity to see beyond the headlines and connect with other stories about their community.

To those who have made donations, thank you.

To those able to give and share our journalism with others, please Pay it Forward.

The Free Press has shared COVID-19 stories free of charge because we believe everyone deserves access to trusted and critical information during the pandemic.

While we stand by this decision, it has undoubtedly affected our bottom line.

After nearly 150 years of reporting on our city, we don’t want to stop any time soon. With your support, we’ll be able to forge ahead with our journalistic mission.

If you believe in an independent, transparent, and democratic press, please consider subscribing today.

We understand that some readers cannot afford a subscription during these difficult times and invite them to apply for a free digital subscription through our Pay it Forward program.


Updated on Monday, January 7, 2019 at 10:25 PM CST: Fixes spelling of name.

The Free Press will close this commenting platform at noon on July 14.

We want to thank those who have shared their views over the years as part of this reader engagement initiative.

In the coming weeks, the Free Press will announce new opportunities for readers to share their thoughts and to engage with our staff and each other.

You can comment on most stories on The Winnipeg Free Press website. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or digital subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.

Have Your Say

Have Your Say

Comments are open to The Winnipeg Free Press print or digital subscribers only. why?

Have Your Say

Comments are open to The Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?

By submitting your comment, you agree to abide by our Community Standards and Moderation Policy. These guidelines were revised effective February 27, 2019. Have a question about our comment forum? Check our frequently asked questions.