Rising from the ashes of Phoenix

Phoenix’s killers appeal

2 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2009

A Manitoba couple found guilty of killing the woman's young daughter will argue today their conviction should be reduced to manslaughter.

In separate briefs filed with the Manitoba Court of Appeal, Samantha Kematch and Karl McKay argue they were unfairly convicted of first-degree murder. Their appeal begins today in Winnipeg.

They point out they denied during their trial that they confined five-year-old Phoenix Sinclair to a basement where she died on the cold floor after the last of many beatings.

Under the Criminal Code, someone is deemed to have committed first-degree murder instead of second-degree murder or manslaughter if he or she forcibly confined the victim at the time of the slaying.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Weather

Oct. 17, 12 AM: 11°c Cloudy with wind Oct. 17, 6 AM: 12°c Cloudy with wind

Winnipeg MB

11°C, Light rain with wind

Full Forecast

Wish lists from the front line: band chief

By Mary Agnes Welch 2 minute read Preview

Wish lists from the front line: band chief

By Mary Agnes Welch 2 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

REMOTE reserves need more control over child welfare, along with staff and training, says the chief of one of the province's poorest communities.

"Child welfare is now fully governed by the province. Each First Nation should have full jurisdiction over its own people, and there's still a lot of work that needs to be done there," said Chief David Harper of Garden Hill First Nation.

Harper's community is one of four Island Lake bands on the province's east side, one of the most remote and troubled. Last spring, almost 300 kids from the four reserves were in care.

Garden Hill is one of the northern bands experiencing friction with the Northern Authority, the provincially-mandated umbrella office that oversees six aboriginal child-welfare agencies.

Read
Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

MIKE DEAL / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS 0601013 Chief David Harper talks to the media about the dire situation northern communities are facing because of the lack of winter roads which are the main means of access for most supplies. GMC Acting Grand Chief Dennis Meeches of Long Plains is in the background.

MIKE DEAL / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS 0601013 Chief David Harper talks to the media about the dire situation northern communities are facing because of the lack of winter roads which are the main means of access for most supplies. GMC Acting Grand Chief Dennis Meeches of Long Plains is in the background.

Phoenix’s legacy takes shape

By Mary Agnes Welch and Lindor Reynolds 4 minute read Preview

Phoenix’s legacy takes shape

By Mary Agnes Welch and Lindor Reynolds 4 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

Manitoba will set a wretched record this year -- 8,000 abused and neglected kids, almost all of the aboriginal, will be in the care of child-welfare authorities or foster families.

Read
Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

Patsy Desmarais

Patsy Desmarais

Wish lists from the front line: Children’s advocate

By Lindor Reynolds 2 minute read Preview

Wish lists from the front line: Children’s advocate

By Lindor Reynolds 2 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

MANITOBA'S Children's Advocate has a long list of ways the child welfare system could be improved.

One of the most critical, Billie Schibler says, is tracking what happens to children who age out of care.

"If they're 18 when they die, we would not receive that information from the chief medical examiner," says Schibler. "We know that statistically these children are the most vulnerable."

Traditionally, children are out of the child-welfare system (and on their own) when they turn 18. Sometimes, they can remain in care until they are 21.

Read
Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

WAYNE GLOWACKI/WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Billie Schibler, Children�s Advocate at news conference re; the release of two reviews of the child welfare system in Manitoba.Mia Rabson story. Oct. 11 2006

WAYNE GLOWACKI/WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Billie Schibler, Children�s Advocate at news conference re;  the release of two reviews of the child  welfare system in Manitoba.Mia Rabson story.   Oct. 11  2006

Wish lists from the front line: Medical examiner

By Lindor Reynolds 2 minute read Preview

Wish lists from the front line: Medical examiner

By Lindor Reynolds 2 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

MANITOBA'S chief medical examiner says the most profound damage done to children doesn't result from a troubled child-welfare system.

For Dr. Thambirajah Balachandra, the root of the problem is poor parenting, exacerbated by atrocious living conditions on the province's remote reserves.

"If the parents are capable, if they don't drink or neglect their children, so much of this can be prevented."

He says addressing the root causes of family violence would save children.

Read
Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

Colin Corneau/Brandon Sun
Manitoba medical examiner Dr. Thambirajah Balachandra speaks to the media, Wednesday afternoon in Brandon. (Colin Corneau/Brandon Sun)

Colin Corneau/Brandon Sun
Manitoba medical examiner Dr. Thambirajah Balachandra speaks to the media, Wednesday afternoon in Brandon.  (Colin Corneau/Brandon Sun)

System overhauled, but the deaths continue

By Mary Agnes Welch 6 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

Before five-year-old Phoenix Sinclair's body was discovered in March 2006 and the horrors of her abuse and torture spotlighted a child-welfare system in crisis, 145 kids in care had died, according to a provincial report, since devolution began in 2003.

Problems, prescriptions and progress

Mary Agnes Welch and Lindor Reynolds 8 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

There's been a flurry of fixes to the child-welfare system since Phoenix Sinclair's death. They come under the umbrella of Changes for Children, and they come with a hefty $42-million price tag.

But what's really changed in the child-welfare system since March 2006?

 

Child safety

Province hopes to import success from Minnesota

By Lindor Reynolds 3 minute read Preview

Province hopes to import success from Minnesota

By Lindor Reynolds 3 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

The Manitoba government has looked south to Minnesota for ways to improve its beleaguered child-welfare system.

There, the state government has rolled out a unique model that sees social workers working constructively with families in crisis to prevent children being removed and taken into care.

"I think there was a feeling the system wasn't working as well as it could," says Chuck Johnson, assistant commissioner for Child and Family Services at the Minnesota Department of Human Resources.

"We were really looking for a way to approach families -- a different way that saw us work more in partnership with families. We didn't want to be confrontational."

Read
Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

c_

c_

Coming in ’09: A new approach

By Mary Agnes Welch 2 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

GET ready for next year's child-welfare catch phrase: Differential response.

That's social work-speak for programs and specialized staff that gently weasel their way into troubled families and prevent abuse and neglect before it happens. The goal is to keep families together rather than sending kids to foster homes.

It represents a fundamental shift in the way child welfare is done, and it will mean another 50 or 60 new front-line workers will be hired, say provincial officials.

Two agencies are testing differential response, also known as family enhancement or family support. One agency is testing a new made-in-Manitoba risk-assessment tool that has prevention built into it. It works for families whose risk levels might not trigger foster placement but could benefit from counselling, regular visits from social workers and perhaps some fetal-alcohol services.

Mapping out Manitoba’s CFS system

By Mary Agnes Welch 4 minute read Preview

Mapping out Manitoba’s CFS system

By Mary Agnes Welch 4 minute read Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

A look at child-welfare agencies around the province.

Read
Sunday, Dec. 21, 2008

LOAD MORE