Music Review: The Replacements’ ‘Tim: Let it Bleed Edition’ captures the band’s sublime songwriting

Advertisement

Advertise with us

Near the 40th anniversary of their fifth studio album and major label debut, “Tim,” The Replacements are releasing “Tim: Let it Bleed Edition.” The massive box set features a loving remaster of the original release of “Tim,” but the real value is in the live performance, the unreleased tracks, and the contributions of producer Ed Stasium.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 19/09/2023 (1116 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Near the 40th anniversary of their fifth studio album and major label debut, “Tim,” The Replacements are releasing “Tim: Let it Bleed Edition.” The massive box set features a loving remaster of the original release of “Tim,” but the real value is in the live performance, the unreleased tracks, and the contributions of producer Ed Stasium.

Rhino Records has lately made a cottage industry of mining the alternative rock band’s sea of alternate takes and raucous live recordings. The “Let it Bleed Edition” is a tightly focused snapshot of the band’s messy energy and sublime songwriting at a pivotal moment, as The Replacements teetered on the edge of stardom.

The remaster is a marked improvement over the 1985 release. Original producer Thomas Erdelyi, better known as Tommy Ramone, perhaps could have been a brilliant collaborator on the band’s punkier early albums, but this production fell oddly flat against the complexities of “Tim.”

This cover image released by Rhino Records shows
This cover image released by Rhino Records shows "Tim, Let it Bleed" by The Replacements. (Rhino Records via AP)

The new remix by Stasium corrects some of the missteps. “Here Comes a Regular” and “Swingin Party” make Paul Westerberg’s crackling lyrics sound like heartbreak and a million cigarettes. “Bastards of the Young” and “Left of the Dial,” cranked up loud, now sound more immediate than they did 40 years ago.

The spiritual heart of the box set is the concert segment, “Not Ready for Prime Time, Live at the Cabaret Metro, Chicago, January 11, 1986,” which was recorded just a week before their national television debut on “Saturday Night Live.” The band cemented a passionate following with their chaotic live shows, and here, they deliver a characteristic roller-coaster ride.

The Chicago show progresses at breakneck speed through delta blues, hardcore, folk, and sludgy Rolling Stones and Beatles covers. The Replacements presented as punk, but at heart, their emotional content is more akin to The Smiths than to The Sex Pistols. Fans might be stagediving one moment and crying a little inside the next. It was a fully unique mood at the time, soon to be refined by Nirvana.

The alternate takes on “Sons of No One: Rare & Unreleased” captures wildly different takes on the “Tim” track list. The best of them, such as “Can’t Hardly Wait (Acoustic Demo)” highlight Westerberg’s brilliant delivery as a storyteller.

“Tim” was adored by critics, but commercial success proved elusive. The mayhem of their “SNL” appearance earned them a lifetime ban for on-air profanity. They refused to release videos in the heart of the MTV era. And guitarist Bob Stinson was soon to leave the band after ongoing battles with Westerberg and his own demons.

But just as in slushy upper Midwestern television programs such as “The Bear” and “Shameless,” the found family sometimes holds its members down just as it keeps them alive, and it ends up all the more loved for it.

___

AP music reviews: https://apnews.com/hub/music-reviews

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Winnipeg more than its worst headlines

Marwa Suraj 4 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

Winnipeg takes a reputational beating sometimes and some of the criticism is deserved.

Concerns about public safety are real. Homelessness remains painfully visible. Too many people are struggling with addiction, poverty, mental illness and inadequate housing in plain sight.

Those concerns deserve to be taken seriously. But a city can be making measurable progress, struggling badly in other areas and still be reduced unfairly to its worst headlines. Winnipeg deserves neither denial nor caricature.

Take public safety.

Music Review: The Replacements’ ‘Tim: Let it Bleed Edition’ captures the band’s sublime songwriting

Jim Pollock, The Associated Press 3 minute read Preview

Music Review: The Replacements’ ‘Tim: Let it Bleed Edition’ captures the band’s sublime songwriting

Jim Pollock, The Associated Press 3 minute read Tuesday, Sep. 19, 2023

Near the 40th anniversary of their fifth studio album and major label debut, “Tim,” The Replacements are releasing “Tim: Let it Bleed Edition.” The massive box set features a loving remaster of the original release of “Tim,” but the real value is in the live performance, the unreleased tracks, and the contributions of producer Ed Stasium.

Rhino Records has lately made a cottage industry of mining the alternative rock band’s sea of alternate takes and raucous live recordings. The “Let it Bleed Edition” is a tightly focused snapshot of the band’s messy energy and sublime songwriting at a pivotal moment, as The Replacements teetered on the edge of stardom.

The remaster is a marked improvement over the 1985 release. Original producer Thomas Erdelyi, better known as Tommy Ramone, perhaps could have been a brilliant collaborator on the band’s punkier early albums, but this production fell oddly flat against the complexities of “Tim.”

The new remix by Stasium corrects some of the missteps. “Here Comes a Regular” and “Swingin Party” make Paul Westerberg’s crackling lyrics sound like heartbreak and a million cigarettes. “Bastards of the Young” and “Left of the Dial,” cranked up loud, now sound more immediate than they did 40 years ago.

Read
Tuesday, Sep. 19, 2023

Get to know your Jet: Mario Ferraro

Mike McIntyre 8 minute read Preview

Get to know your Jet: Mario Ferraro

Mike McIntyre 8 minute read Yesterday at 5:39 PM CDT

A one-on-one conversation with a Winnipeg Jet about the stuff you don't always hear in the media scrum

Read
Yesterday at 5:39 PM CDT

Fraser Institute report places Manitoba near bottom of all provinces, states in productivity, income advancement

Gabrielle Piché 5 minute read Preview

Fraser Institute report places Manitoba near bottom of all provinces, states in productivity, income advancement

Gabrielle Piché 5 minute read Yesterday at 8:01 PM CDT

Manitoba trails behind most Canadian provinces and American states in economic well-being, according to a new study.

The Fraser Institute, a right-leaning think tank, compared provinces’ and U.S. states’ GDP per person, among other economic measures, in a report released Thursday.

It places Manitoba 56th of 60 jurisdictions. Most provinces and every state except Mississippi had a higher GDP per person in 2024 than Manitoba, the Fraser Institute calculated.

It used data from Statistics Canada and the United States Census Bureau.

Read
Yesterday at 8:01 PM CDT

Jets goaltender quickly taking on folk hero status with hot start

Ken Wiebe 7 minute read Preview

Jets goaltender quickly taking on folk hero status with hot start

Ken Wiebe 7 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 10:03 AM CDT

Stuart Skinner is giving the hometown crowd plenty to cheer about.

The Winnipeg Jets new No. 1 netminder came up with another brilliant performance, making 32 saves — including several of the highlight-reel variety — to propel his team to a 3-2 victory over the Colorado Avalanche on Wednesday night at Canada Life Centre.

With each save he makes and each win he records, Skinner is doing what he can to help turn the page on the Connor Hellebuyck era.

“I would say that they are big shoes to fill 100 per cent, but I’m not looking into the scenario of filling his shoes,” said Skinner, who lowered his goals-against average to 2.62 and raised his save percentage to .920 through three starts. “My job’s the same job as any other goalie in this league. So it’s a little bit of a difficult question for me to truly answer.”

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 10:03 AM CDT

Crime spree lands accused murderers behind bars

Dean Pritchard 4 minute read Preview

Crime spree lands accused murderers behind bars

Dean Pritchard 4 minute read 6:00 AM CDT

Three men have been sentenced to jail terms for a commercial robbery spree in southern Manitoba launched just two weeks after they were accused of killing a 19-year-old man in Abbotsford, B.C.

Twenty-two-year-old Ravdeep Gill of Winnipeg, pleaded guilty Monday to four counts of robbery and Harmandeep Gill, 27, of Brampton, Ont. and Jaskaran Singh, 21, of Surrey, B.C., each pleaded guilty to two counts of robbery for a 10-day crime blitz that targeted gas bars in Swan Lake, Teulon and St. Laurent, and a meat shop in Winnipeg.

Ravdeep Gill was sentenced to four years custody while Harmandeep Gill and Singh each received sentences of 30 months.

According to B.C. media reports, all three men are charged with first-degree murder in a Feb. 1, 2025 killing in Abbotsford that police there described as a targeted hit.

Read
6:00 AM CDT