U-turn on Portage and Main Most Winnipeggers now support reopening intersection to pedestrians: poll By: Chris Kitching Posted: 5:14 PM CDT Wednesday, Mar. 20, 2024

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 20/03/2024 (849 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

A majority of Winnipeggers is in favour of reopening Portage and Main to pedestrians six years after an overwhelming “no,” a new poll suggested ahead of a council vote Thursday.

More than a quarter of those polled in the Free Press-Probe Research survey said they voted against the proposal in a 2018 plebiscite, but have since changed their mind.

Related Articles

Tectonic shift shows we’re turning the corner on Portage and Main

Yes, open Portage and Main. No, don’t close the concourse Building owners stunned by Portage and Main underground closure proposal

More than 100 years of history at Portage and Main

Committee votes to give $13M for initial design, construction at Portage and Main

Jaywalking Portage & Main protester in 1979 unsure about removing barriers now

’Over the moon’: longtime proponents of opening Portage and Main plan ‘crossing the street’ party

Winds of change bring mixed reaction to famous intersection

Council votes to reopen Portage and Main to pedestrians, close underground concourse

Portage and Main is ‘just an intersection’; but it represents much more to Winnipeg

Work to reopen Portage and Main to pedestrians set to begin by Nov. 15

“When you look at this new information, I think a lot of people, like me, are making a different decision than they did six years ago,” Mayor Scott Gillingham said Wednesday.

The “new information” is the estimated $73 million cost and up to five years of traffic disruption associated with proposed repairs to the pedestrian concourse beneath the iconic downtown intersection.

“When people, like I did, get this new information, it moves us toward the practical alternative, which is to reopen the intersection at-grade,” said Gillingham.

The online survey of 600 Winnipeg adults was conducted between March 5-18.

A total of 61 per cent said they strongly or somewhat support restoring pedestrian access, while 39 per cent are strongly or somewhat against it.

Women, younger adults, university graduates and supporters of the provincial NDP and Liberals were among those more likely to be in favour.

Portage and Main has been closed to pedestrians since 1979.

In 2018’s non-binding plebiscite, 65 per cent of voters were against removing concrete barriers and reopening the junction to foot traffic, while 35 per cent were in favour.

The Free Press-Probe Research poll suggests 28 per cent of those who voted “no” are now strongly or somewhat in support.

“We have seen a pretty significant chunk of suburban Winnipeggers think this is the right thing to do, given the cost and the support (on council),” said Probe Research principal Curtis Brown. “There hasn’t been as much vocal opposition compared to six years ago.”

“We have seen a pretty significant chunk of suburban Winnipeggers think this is the right thing to do, given the cost and the support (on council)”–Curtis Brown

Support outpaced opposition in four of five areas of the city.

The strongest support is in the city’s core (72 per cent in favour), followed by the southwest (61 per cent), northwest (60 per cent) and southeast (58 per cent).

Northeast Winnipeg had the highest proportion of opposition (53 per cent).

Potential traffic impacts and negative attitudes toward downtown were probable factors, said North Kildonan Coun. Jeff Browaty.

The finance committee chair said he is open to allowing pedestrians to cross only at off-peak times. He said a full reopening should be trialled for 12-18 months — to assess traffic pattern changes and economic impacts — before a final decision is made.

“I don’t believe it’s worth the traffic impacts it will cause,” he said.

A 2017 study by a consulting firm suggested a few minutes would be added to most commutes. Since then, the COVID-19 pandemic has changed work and commuting patterns for some Winnipeggers, the mayor has said.

Browaty said council shouldn’t consider closing the underground concourse until it sees a complete study. He fears property and rental values could decline if the concourse is closed.

At a March 12 executive policy committee meeting, Browaty was the lone member to vote against a motion to reopen Portage and Main to pedestrians by July 1, 2025, and proceed with an eventual concourse closure in consultation with affected businesses and property owners.

Council is scheduled to vote Thursday.

“It seems like the mayor has the votes for it,” said Brown. “No matter what happens, there definitely will be people who are not happy.”

“No matter what happens, there definitely will be people who are not happy”–Curtis Brown

Gillingham believes the motion has enough support, but he is not expecting a unanimous vote.

If approved, an external engineering study will help to determine the design and cost of a pedestrian-friendly intersection.

The vote is taking place less than three weeks after Gillingham announced he is now in favour of reopening Portage and Main to pedestrians.

The U-turn was prompted by a report from the city’s acting urban planning manager, who said it could cost $73 million to replace a leaking membrane under the concrete that protects the concourse.

Repairs would involve digging up parts of Portage and Main, with traffic disruption estimated to last four to five years.

“I could see why that could sway people’s decision,” said Coun. Vivian Santos, who supports pedestrian access to the intersection, which is in her Point Douglas ward. She believes the reopening will spur economic benefits.

A new membrane would have to be replaced in the future, given its service life of 40 years, the staff report said.

Decommissioning the concourse, meanwhile, could cost between $20 million and $50 million, subject to further study. Gillingham has said it costs the city about $1 million annually to operate and maintain the concourse.

The Building Owners and Managers Association of Manitoba has spoken out against the proposed closure, describing it as “short-sighted” and “based on incomplete information.”

The city said about 72,000 vehicles pass through Portage and Main on a weekday, which is 10 per cent less than in 2016. It is Winnipeg’s sixth busiest intersection.

Last year, a study counted more than 2,100 pedestrians in the underground circus during a two-hour period at midday on a weekday. More than 1,500 people walked by the intersection on adjacent sidewalks during above-ground counts in mid-January.

Probe Research said its survey comprised a random and representative sampling of Winnipeggers. Live operators, an automated phone system and an online panel were used to recruit respondents.

The polling firm said the survey has a margin of error of four percentage points, 95 per cent of the time.

Margins of error are higher within sub-groups, such as gender, age and education.

chris.kitching@freepress.mb.ca

Chris Kitching
Reporter

Chris Kitching is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He began his newspaper career in 2001, with stops in Winnipeg, Toronto and London, England, along the way. After returning to Winnipeg, he joined the Free Press in 2021, and now covers a little bit of everything for the newspaper. Read more about Chris.

Every piece of reporting Chris produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press‘s tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press’s history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.