A housing hero gets her due

Documentary looks at 1950s, '60s urbanization with a view to the future

Advertisement

Advertise with us

Documentaries always benefit from human drama, and this new look at influential urban thinker Jane Jacobs has a clear conflict and crackerjack characters.

Read this article for free:


By clicking the button above, an account will be created and you will begin to receive some of our recommended newsletters. You may opt out of any newsletter by visiting your Email and Communication Preferences page or by clicking "unsubscribe" at the bottom of any email.

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $1.44 a week*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Billed as $5.77 plus GST every four weeks. After 52 weeks, price increases to the regular rate of $19.95 plus GST every four weeks. Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 24/06/2017 (3402 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Documentaries always benefit from human drama, and this new look at influential urban thinker Jane Jacobs has a clear conflict and crackerjack characters.

On one side, we have Jacobs, scrappy grassroots activist. On the other, Robert Moses, power broker, money man and master builder. In this cogent, urgent, zippy doc, director Matt Tyrnauer (Valentino: The Last Emperor) has them duking it out for the soul of New York City in the 1950s and ’60s.

Jacobs, who started as a journalist, believed that urban development had to begin with people and how they really lived, not with overarching theories. Her landmark 1961 book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, advocated for vital urban neighbourhoods with a messy mix of old and new buildings and diverse uses. For her, everything started at the street level.

Moses, an unelected official who amassed an enormous amount of bureaucratic clout, took a God’s-eye view of the city. With a hardline modernist vision that favoured tower blocks and expressways, he tore down low-income neighbourhoods to make way for massive planned building programs.

Jacobs’ and Moses’s conflict over urban issues is bound up with gender and race.

At a time when most professional city planners were men, Jacobs was often treated with condescension and dismissed as a meddling housewife. Social critic Lewis Mumford referred to her book as “Mother Jacobs’ Home Remedies” in the New Yorker.

Bloomberg IFC Films / Sundance Selects
As a woman in the 1950s and ’60s, Jane Jacobs was often dismissed as a meddling housewife. Her book was even referred to as ‘Mother Jacobs’ Home Remedies’ by the New Yorker.
Bloomberg IFC Films / Sundance Selects As a woman in the 1950s and ’60s, Jane Jacobs was often dismissed as a meddling housewife. Her book was even referred to as ‘Mother Jacobs’ Home Remedies’ by the New Yorker.

The neighbourhoods that Moses tore down were often predominantly African-American and Hispanic, with vast numbers of people displaced into isolated and dysfunctional high-rise social housing.

Citizen Jane concentrates on key Jacobs-Moses showdowns in New York City, including one that would have levelled SoHo to make way for a freeway. There is little about Jacobs’ later life in Toronto, where she moved in 1968. The film focuses on her beliefs, not her biography.

And while this is essentially a documentary of ideas, Tyrnauer keeps things lively and fast-moving with a deft mix of archival footage and opinionated talking-head interviews.

Citizen Jane is not meant to be an even-handed argument — the title makes that clear. There is no mention of recent revisionist takes on Moses’s legacy. There is no acknowledgement that the dense urban neighbourhoods Jacobs championed as havens of social and economic diversity have become, in many North American cities, enclaves of white affluence.

Tyrnauer makes his own activist argument in calls to action that bookend the film. The particular New York battles between Jacobs and Moses may be in the past, he suggests, but the war goes on, with the super-accelerated rate of global urbanization making it even more crucial. With footage that looks like something out of a dystopian sci-fi movie, one interview subject describes current city development in China as “Robert Moses on steroids.”

We are making decisions right now, Citizen Jane makes clear, that will affect our world for generations.

alison.gillmor@freepress.mb.ca

Alison Gillmor

Alison Gillmor
Writer

Studying at the University of Winnipeg and later Toronto’s York University, Alison Gillmor planned to become an art historian. She ended up catching the journalism bug when she started as visual arts reviewer at the Winnipeg Free Press in 1992.

Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.

Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Not much of a race when most of the field can’t find their running shoes

Dan Lett 5 minute read Preview

Not much of a race when most of the field can’t find their running shoes

Dan Lett 5 minute read Yesterday at 2:52 PM CDT

In Winnipeg's mayoral race, there are few truly bad ideas, but hardly any really good ones.

Read
Yesterday at 2:52 PM CDT

Austen adaptation a handsome, delicate cinematic dance

Alison Gillmour 5 minute read Preview

Austen adaptation a handsome, delicate cinematic dance

Alison Gillmour 5 minute read 4:00 AM CDT

Marianne (Esmé Creed-Miles) can look rather bedraggled in this new version of Jane Austen’s first published novel, which has once again ignited the “loose hair” controversy that has raged among Janeites since the casually coiffed 2005 reimagining of Pride & Prejudice.

Purists might be vexed, possibly even discomfited or discomposed by some of the details in this take on Sense and Sensibility, part of a wave of Austen adaptations and Austen-adjacent material released to mark the 250th anniversary of the writer’s birth.

Would prudent Elinor (Daisy Edgar-Jones) be penning letters to a man to whom she is not engaged? Would even spirited Marianne be running barefoot through the woods?

Possibly not. But if director Georgia Oakley (Blue Jean) and rookie screenwriter Diana Reid don’t adhere to the strict letter of Austen’s work, they catch much of its spirit. This is a vivid and deeply felt examination of the enduring power of sisterhood, which is at the core of not just the 1811 novel, but of Austen’s own life in the profound importance of her relationship with her sister Cassandra.

Read
4:00 AM CDT

Author Emily St. John Mandel’s Exit Party a story of hope in dark times

Ben Sigurdson 6 minute read Preview

Author Emily St. John Mandel’s Exit Party a story of hope in dark times

Ben Sigurdson 6 minute read 4:00 AM CDT

If Emily St. John Mandel’s new novel Exit Party is in any way prophetic, Americans should be worried.

The B.C.-born, New York-based author’s bestselling fourth novel, 2014’s Station Eleven, chronicled a performing troupe in a post-pandemic world. The novel experienced a second wave of popularity when the COVID-19 pandemic took hold, and when HBO’s Station Eleven miniseries premièred in late 2021.

Mandel launches Exit Party, her seventh novel, at McNally Robinson Booksellers’ Grant Park location tonight, where she’ll be joined in conversation by Winnipeg novelist Joan Thomas.

Published in September by HarperCollins, Exit Party sees Mandel once again working in the near future, in this case in a novel that features two timelines — one (dubbed the A-side in the novel) where the U.S. has fractured into a number of small countries following a civil war, and another (the B-side) where a singular, autocratic surveillance state has tightened its grip over its citizens.

Read
4:00 AM CDT

Playoff hopes dwindle for Bombers after loss to Edmonton

Taylor Allen 6 minute read Preview

Playoff hopes dwindle for Bombers after loss to Edmonton

Taylor Allen 6 minute read 4:33 AM CDT

EDMONTON — It’s a script the Winnipeg Blue Bombers should’ve shredded, burned, and buried.

Go to Edmonton, dominate the first half, crumble in the final two quarters and lose.

That’s what happened in Week 12, when the Bombers blew an early 16-point lead in a 22-19 loss. And in their return to Commonwealth Stadium on Friday night, the Bombers went down a nearly identical path in a 35-27 defeat to the Edmonton Elks.

In their latest disappearing act, the Blue and Gold led 21-10 with less than a minute remaining in the first half before seemingly vanishing into thin air.

Read
4:33 AM CDT

Get to know your Jet: Neal Pionk

Mike McIntyre 6 minute read Preview

Get to know your Jet: Neal Pionk

Mike McIntyre 6 minute read Thursday, Oct. 15, 2026

“Give it 110 per cent.” “Get pucks in deep.” “One shift at a time.” “Play our game.” “Keep it simple.”

Hockey has a language all its own. Unfortunately, after hearing the same phrases repeated often enough, that language can start to sound a lot like white noise.

So we’re going to try something different.

The Free Press will occasionally sit down with a Winnipeg Jets player at his locker-room stall for a wide-ranging conversation about the stuff you don’t always hear in a media scrum.

Read
Thursday, Oct. 15, 2026

Misused ensemble, underconfident script keep Street Fighter game adaptation from landing its blows clean

Darren Ridgley 5 minute read Preview

Misused ensemble, underconfident script keep Street Fighter game adaptation from landing its blows clean

Darren Ridgley 5 minute read 4:00 AM CDT

Adaptations of fighting games come built-in with a major problem: how does one tell a coherent story about a game with no true protagonist?

Sadly, Street Fighter doesn’t know.

When it debuted in 1991, Street Fighter II (upon which most of this film is based) featured 12 “world warriors,” eight of them playable and with their own motives.

Managing such a cast requires a script capable of efficiently introducing them and then giving everyone decent reasons to interact — or homing in on a few and letting the rest be set dressing. Director Kitao Sakurai opts for the latter, focusing on Japanese warrior Ryu (Andrew Koji), American Ken Masters (Noah Centineo) and Interpol agent Chun Li (Callina Liang).

Read
4:00 AM CDT