Meta-murder mystery more style than substance

Advertisement

Advertise with us

In his return to the recursive world of the Hawthorne and Horowitz series, British mystery maven Anthony Horowitz has decided to up the metafictional ante.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

In his return to the recursive world of the Hawthorne and Horowitz series, British mystery maven Anthony Horowitz has decided to up the metafictional ante.

For the uninitiated, Horowitz has written a series of novels in which his protagonist, novelist and television writer “Anthony (don’t call him Tony) Horowitz,” plays Watson and biographer to the ill-mannered but brilliant private detective Daniel Hawthorne. A Deadly Episode is the sixth book in the series.

This time, Hawthorne and Horowitz find themselves embroiled in a murder that takes place on the set of a film adaptation of their first case/book, The Word Is Murder.

Anna Lythgoe photo
                                Anthony Horowitz

Anna Lythgoe photo

Anthony Horowitz

So… the real writer Anthony Horowitz has written a mystery novel in which the fictional writer “Anthony Horowitz” accompanies his associate Hawthorne to the set of an adaptation of a past case that is both a real novel in the real world and a work of non-fiction within the fictional universe of the series. A Deadly Episode is simultaneously the real (fictional) novel and the “real” account of this murder in the made-up world. Oh, and the victim? The actor playing Hawthorne. Are you keeping up?

Your tolerance for A Deadly Episode will likely depend on how much of this sort of self-referential malarkey you find charming. But nestled within all the circular prose is the mystery itself.

Up-and-coming actor-slash-careerist weasel David Caine has been stabbed to death in his trailer during production of The Word Is Murder. There’s no shortage of suspects — and for good reason. David was awful: smug, devious, cynical and seemingly engineered from every well-trodden cliché about narcissistic actors.

Was it the production assistant he had fired? The director he’s infuriating? His jilted agent? The writer with whom he shares a past? His co-star and rival? The financially busted producer? Or was David Caine not even the intended target at all? Could the whole thing be a mix-up in which the real target was Hawthorne himself, as payback for a case from his past?

With production shuttered, Hawthorne and the fictional Horowitz are on the case. The real Horowitz seeds the novel with all the hallmarks of the genre: red herrings, plot twists, a stately manor house and dark secrets uncovered. As the author of five previous Hawthorne novels, not to mention the 13-book young-adult Alex Rider series, two Sherlock Holmes novels, the Susan Ryeland mysteries and countless Midsomer Murder TV episodes, the real-life Horowitz remains a steady hand at detective fiction.

Where A Deadly Episode falls short is not so much as a whodunit but as a “who cares.” The characters are paper-thin, drifting in and out of the novel without making much of an impression. The constant self-reflections of the fictional Horowitz quickly become tedious, and even the brilliant but caustic Hawthorne barely registers as a presence. The result is an episode that may be deadly but also feels oddly weightless and, at times, dull.

A Deadly Episode

A Deadly Episode

What we’re left with is an exercise in style over substance: a clever structural gimmick without the memorable characters needed to sustain it.

Capably executed but slight, A Deadly Episode feels aimed primarily at devoted fans of the series. For everyone else, it lands somewhere between skippable and the sort of beach read you wouldn’t kick yourself for forgetting at the beach.

Scott Montgomery is a Winnipeg-based writer with a limited tolerance for malarkey. He is the co-creator of Apple TV’s Camp Snoopy and a writer on numerous other shows you may or may not have seen.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

‘Huge resource gaps’: judge shortage leads to circuit court cuts

Dean Pritchard 4 minute read Preview

‘Huge resource gaps’: judge shortage leads to circuit court cuts

Dean Pritchard 4 minute read 5:43 PM CDT

A shortage of judges is forcing Manitoba’s provincial court to slash sittings across the province.

The court announced in a notice to the profession Wednesday that it will be reducing the number of annual court sittings at nine rural circuit locations and St. Boniface provincial court in Winnipeg by 68 sittings, effective April 1, 2027.

The reductions are necessary to balance “access to justice needs with the complement of judicial resources currently insufficient to maintain the current court schedule,” said the notice, signed by provincial court Chief Judge Ryan Rolston.

Affected circuit courts include Altona, Arborg, Beausejour, Easterville, Cranberry Portage, Lundar, Grand Rapids, Moose Lake, and Pine Falls.

Read
5:43 PM CDT

Labour board ruling halts Dynacare strike

Carol Sanders and Erik Pindera 6 minute read Preview

Labour board ruling halts Dynacare strike

Carol Sanders and Erik Pindera 6 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 5:58 PM CDT

The Manitoba Labour Board has cut short a strike by 350 lab workers employed by Dynacare who administer blood and urine tests for patients in Winnipeg, Brandon and surrounding communities.

The board ruled late Tuesday afternoon that the workers, who hit the picket line at 6 a.m., must return to work Wednesday.

Jason Linklater, president of their union, the Manitoba Association of Health Care Professionals, slammed the board’s decision.

“The Manitoba Labour Board is doing exactly what the government asked them to do: they are taking away our members’ right to fight for fairness,” he said in a statement.

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 5:58 PM CDT

Bumps in the road as students collect free bus passes

Maggie Macintosh 5 minute read Preview

Bumps in the road as students collect free bus passes

Maggie Macintosh 5 minute read Yesterday at 9:17 PM CDT

Alexis Enns left her guidance counsellor’s office empty-handed, but no less excited about starting Grade 12 — even though she still didn’t know how she would get there or her timetable — on Tuesday.

Read
Yesterday at 9:17 PM CDT

Gillingham to push for new crisis response model at EPC

Malak Abas 3 minute read Preview

Gillingham to push for new crisis response model at EPC

Malak Abas 3 minute read 3:24 PM CDT

Mayor Scott Gillingham’s proposal to overhaul the city’s crisis-response system to try to divert thousands of calls away from police, firefighter and paramedic response, will be presented to council’s inner circle next week.

The model, described as a “fourth crisis response pathway,” would transfer 911 calls that are non-violent in nature to citywide crisis response teams. Potentially, 10,000 calls could be removed from police, fire and paramedic response, Gillingham said during the July 28 announcement.

Gillingham is set to present his idea to city council’s executive policy committee Tuesday. His motion asks that the city adopt the crisis response model, in part through a “partnership framework” with the provincial government.

The motion notes the partnership would “support a co-ordinated whole-of-government and whole-of-community approach to implementation, recognizing that sustainable crisis response reform cannot be achieved by any single organization, sector, or order of government acting alone.”

Read
3:24 PM CDT

Ferraro, Skinner getting lay of the land before training camp starts

Mike McIntyre 8 minute read Preview

Ferraro, Skinner getting lay of the land before training camp starts

Mike McIntyre 8 minute read 5:45 PM CDT

They’ve both been around the NHL block a bit, but make no mistake, Stuart Skinner and Mario Ferraro are experiencing some “new kid at school” type jitters this week.

The pair were prized July 1 free agent signings by the Winnipeg Jets and are now quickly trying to get the lay of the land — from teammates and systems and structure to restaurants, schools and the best routes to the rink — in what is a frantic time on both a professional and personal level.

“It’s a big change, right?” Ferraro said Wednesday following a pre-training camp skate at the Hockey For All Centre.

“Like moving cities, getting settled somewhere else, with my family, my wife, my daughter, our two dogs. But I think it’s gone really well and smooth. We found a great place here, and we’re really happy with where we’re living.”

Read
5:45 PM CDT

Premier tells grieving parents site of fatal collision under review

Chris Kitching 4 minute read Preview

Premier tells grieving parents site of fatal collision under review

Chris Kitching 4 minute read 5:48 PM CDT

Premier Wab Kinew promised to pursue safety improvements at an Interlake intersection when he spoke to parents of some of the four teens who died in a crash at the site on the Labour Day weekend.

The collision at Highway 8 and Provincial Road 229, just west of Winnipeg Beach, prompted a review by Manitoba Transportation and Infrastructure, which is standard after a fatal crash, while some of the victims’ families and community leaders publicly called for changes.

“When you see the loss of these beautiful young lives, any parent, any Manitoban feels a sense of loss. On behalf of the whole province, I send my condolences to these families,” Kinew said in Winnipeg Wednesday.

“I did so directly earlier today, and I heard some of the parents’ suggestions for how we could make this safer for everybody. I committed to them that we’re going to take those actions — both stuff we can do relatively quickly and some longer-term fixes, as well.”

Read
5:48 PM CDT