Google urges CRTC to use restraint with Online Streaming Act

Advertisement

Advertise with us

OTTAWA - Google asked the federal broadcast regulator Wednesday to exercise caution and restraint in regulating online platforms.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 25/06/2025 (444 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

OTTAWA – Google asked the federal broadcast regulator Wednesday to exercise caution and restraint in regulating online platforms.

Representatives from Google, which owns YouTube, appeared before a CRTC hearing on market dynamics. It’s one of a series of hearings being held as part of the regulator’s work to implement the Online Streaming Act, which updated broadcasting laws to capture online platforms.

Arun Krishnamurti, senior counsel at Google Canada, said most content made available on social media platforms is already exempted from regulation under the Online Streaming Act.

Participants make their way through a Google booth and display at the APEC summit in Lima, Peru on Friday, Nov. 15, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Participants make their way through a Google booth and display at the APEC summit in Lima, Peru on Friday, Nov. 15, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick

But the company is pushing back against the prospect of mandatory data-sharing. The CRTC has said it wants to collect data on revenues and programming expenditures from both traditional and online players, and make that information public.

Google is arguing the proposal raises privacy and confidentiality concerns and could disrupt the market in unintended ways.

It’s also taking issue with the application of “undue preference” rules on online platforms.

Those rules state that a CRTC-licensed entity can’t give itself or another party an undue disadvantage or advantage. That means, for example, that a cable company that also owns a broadcasting division can’t give its own channels an unfair advantage.

Krishnamurti said undue preference rules were designed for traditional players that own both telecom and broadcasting divisions. That includes companies like Bell and Rogers, broadcasters that own TV channels but also sell cable and satellite TV subscriptions.

“Google urges the commission to exercise caution and restraint,” he said.

“There’s simply no rationale for transposing these regulatory tools onto online undertakings. It would be highly inappropriate for open platforms like YouTube, in particular.”

CRTC commissioner Bram Abramson pushed back on that argument as he questioned the Google representatives. He said the concept of undue preference goes back to railways and is also used in telecom regulation.

Krishnamurti said Google’s platforms don’t prevent anyone from uploading content.

“Those rules around undue preference were particularly designed for where … there was choice being made, where services were being kept out of view of users and viewers,” he argued.

Abramson responded: “I would have thought if there’s a rule saying don’t colour outside the lines and somebody says, well, we don’t need that rule because we always colour inside the lines, that there’d be a pretty good fit between those two.”

Abramson also asked the Google representatives if they would still have an issue with sharing data, such as information on finances and audience size, if concerns about personal and commercially-sensitive data could be addressed. He noted that request was put forward during the hearing by those who make programming content.

“I think we still have significant concerns for a variety of reasons,” responded Krishnamurti.

“It’s not clear where the commission’s authority to require the disclosure of that information to a commercial partner emerges from.”

Both traditional and online players are appearing at the hearing. Last week, music streamer Spotify said the CRTC shouldn’t impose rules meant for radio on streaming services. Bell and Rogers called on the CRTC to loosen existing rules for traditional players, taking aim at regulations governing how cable channels must be packaged and disputes about carriage of cable channels.

The CRTC is scheduled to hear from Apple on Thursday, while Amazon is set to appear next week.

Spotify, Amazon and Apple are fighting in court an earlier order requiring streamers to make CRTC-ordered financial contributions to Canadian content and news.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 25, 2025. 

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Artist’s inspired work brings Red River Métis story back to Portage and Main

Conrad Sweatman 8 minute read Preview

Artist’s inspired work brings Red River Métis story back to Portage and Main

Conrad Sweatman 8 minute read Updated: 2:47 PM CDT

Jennine Krauchi calls them the “grandmothers.” “They speak to you very silently. You never hear a word, but they speak,” Krauchi says, referring to the antique pieces of Métis needlework she’s carefully studied for years. But there are few precedents for her latest art project: a 85-foot-wide by 32-foot-high chain curtain of Métis needlework that drapes over the historic Bank of Montreal’s neoclassical facade.

Read
Updated: 2:47 PM CDT

Exhibition examines the bonds we make with humanoid objects

Jen Zoratti 8 minute read Preview

Exhibition examines the bonds we make with humanoid objects

Jen Zoratti 8 minute read 6:27 PM CDT

For the past few years, Winnipeg visual artist Emilie St-Hilaire has been fascinated by the way humans relate to artificial bodies — dolls, robots, mannequins — through play, care and connection, and how those synthetic relationships can produce very real emotions in humans.

Objects of Fidelity: Barbies, bots, bébés, her solo exhibition on view now at La Maison des artistes visuels francophones, explores this space between object and companion. It’s what she calls the “visual culmination” of work that began with her 2024 PhD dissertation at Concordia University in Montreal, which examined Reborn Dolls — hyper-realistic art dolls that resemble newborns — from a feminist perspective.

But when a robot included in the exhibition started malfunctioning and giving signs that it was at the end of its life, St-Hilaire was given a new question to puzzle: what does it mean for a robot, or any other artificial body, to “die”?

To understand that, one must first understand how these human attachments to humanlike objects form in the first place.

Read
6:27 PM CDT

The plane truth about a dangerous president

Editorial 4 minute read Preview

The plane truth about a dangerous president

Editorial 4 minute read Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

U.S. President Donald Trump has crossed firmly into cutting-off-your-nose-to-spite-your-face territory.

Read
Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

‘We feel lucky — and a bit traumatized’: Tornado confirmed in River Heights Sunday

Malak Abas 6 minute read Preview

‘We feel lucky — and a bit traumatized’: Tornado confirmed in River Heights Sunday

Malak Abas 6 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 6:10 PM CDT

Tanner Lemieux wasn’t surprised to learn the violent winds that tore through River Heights and reached their peak near his home Sunday night have been classified as a tornado.

While driving back to his Lindsay Street home from a shopping trip with his wife Sunday, it became clear they were not in the middle of an ordinary thunderstorm when rain and wind started coming from every direction and hit every side of their truck.

The forceful wind made it impossible for him to open his door after they had parked. He climbed through the window, over the top of his vehicle, and the couple struggled to fight the whipping winds to make it into the house.

“As we were running in, the wind started pulling me backwards out of the door,” he told the Free Press while cleaning debris from his yard Thursday.

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 6:10 PM CDT

Lone Manitoba 9/11 victim's legacy lives on helping Inuit students become nurses

Melissa Martin 13 minute read Preview

Lone Manitoba 9/11 victim's legacy lives on helping Inuit students become nurses

Melissa Martin 13 minute read Yesterday at 5:24 PM CDT

On the night before the morning that everyone remembers, Ellen Judd spoke to her partner, Christine Egan, several times on the phone. Egan was in New York, where she’d gone to look after her nephews so her beloved brother, Michael, and his wife, Anna, could treat themselves to an anniversary vacation.

Usually, Judd would have been there, too. The couple had been together for more than 15 years, and loved sharing all the good parts of life. But at the time, she was an anthropology professor at the University of Manitoba, and the school year was just starting; she had classes the next day. Staying connected by phone would have to suffice.

In their calls that night, Judd remembers, Egan was happy. Christmas was the main topic. They were planning to spend the holiday with Judd’s family in Ontario, and talked about when to book flights. Egan was looking forward to that visit; Judd’s family “loved her to bits,” the now-retired professor says, and the affection was mutual.

The next day, Egan said, she planned to go into Manhattan with Michael. He was an executive at Aon, a global risk, retirement and health services corporation, and had an office on the 105th floor of the World Trade Centre’s South Tower.

Read
Yesterday at 5:24 PM CDT

Highway-safety upgrades in progress after tragic Interlake crash

Chris Kitching 5 minute read Preview

Highway-safety upgrades in progress after tragic Interlake crash

Chris Kitching 5 minute read Updated: 6:25 PM CDT

Provincial workers have started to update or install safety measures at a rural Interlake intersection where four teenage friends died in a crash on Labour Day weekend.

Pavement markings were repainted at Highway 8 and Provincial Road 229, just west of Winnipeg Beach, ahead of work to refresh worn-down rumble strips, starting Monday, and install flashing lights atop two stop signs, following an assessment earlier this week.

“They will also need to incorporate any information from the RCMP report that might be helpful if we were to consider any additional safety measures at this intersection,” Transportation and Infrastructure Minister Lisa Naylor said of department staff.

“The most important thing is safety, and any kinds of changes we make at any intersection actually have to make it safer.”

Read
Updated: 6:25 PM CDT