Semi-autobiographical sequel masterfully layers art, life

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 26/02/2022 (1700 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

You don’t often see sequels in art-house cinema, these second go-rounds usually relegated to the money-hungry world of the commercial blockbuster.

But here we have the followup to British filmmaker Joanna Hogg’s astonishing semi-autobiographical indie drama The Souvenir (2019), which was a creative coming-of-age story, an account of a destructive but transformative first love affair and an examination of the personal, often painful line between life and art.

Part II isn’t a sequel, exactly, but rather an expansion of Hogg’s portrait of the artist as a young woman. Julie (Honor Swinton Byrne, again doing subtle and powerful work) is still living in her posh-punk corner of Thatcher-era London, attempting to finish her film-school project while grieving the death of her enigmatic lover Anthony (played so charismatically by Tom Burke in the first film).

Anthony always claimed to be doing something hush-hush at the Foreign Office, but it turns out his sudden mysterious absences had more to do with heroin addiction.

Julie is now dealing with her loss, partly by turning it into a film. She casts a film-school friend (Ariane Labed) as a version of herself and a young actor (Harris Dickinson) as her dead lover, and then they have long, earnest conversations about the characters’ beliefs and motivations, which are also conversations about her and Anthony’s beliefs and motivations.

Since Julie is still trying to figure out exactly what happened, it’s no surprise, perhaps, that her profs, all middle-aged men, and even her student crew are concerned that the project feels formless and unfinished.

There are also Julie’s sessions with her therapist, a visit with Anthony’s bewildered and devastated parents, and weekends at the country home of her own aristocratic parents, who are well-intentioned but unable to help much. (“Did you know what was going on with this chap?” her father asks.)

Hogg catches the specific look and sound of 1980s England — the sweeping tweed coats and the swooping hair and the Eurythmics on the soundtrack — but she also conveys the feel of what it’s like to be young in any era, with that poignant mix of certainty — about politics and cinema and the politics of cinema — along with so much uncertainty about everything else.

The relationship between art and life is even more layered than it was in the original film, which is saying something. Swinton Byrne is Hogg’s real-life goddaughter, while Rosalind, Julie’s onscreen mother, is played by Tilda Swinton, a friend of Hogg’s from her film-school days, who is also, of course, Swinton Byrne’s actual mother. There’s also a scene is which Julie talks with a Scottish actor friend (Alice McMillan), who is probably a version of the young Tilda.

In the first film, Hogg constructed a replica of her undergrad London flat, and that re-creation features here, but now we also have Julie’s soundstage replica of the replica, which has been constructed for her student film project.

The making of Julie’s thesis film plunges us into the collaborative, sometimes combative nature of the movie-making process, and glimpses of the finished product seem to resemble Hogg’s work.

We also see a kind of dream film, an experimental fantasia filled with artifice and cinematic references.

This might all sound super-meta, maybe even obnoxiously, irritatingly self-indulgent. But it never is. Hogg (Unrelated, Archipelago, Exhibition), whose touch is at once so assured and so delicate, never forces the connections. Her scenes are precisely considered but also feel naturalistic, casual, human. The Souvenir: Part II might be even more emotionally affecting than its predecessor.

Several scenes involve Julie visiting the set of a tetchy, temperamental, more established filmmaker friend (Richard Ayoade). (“You’re forcing me to have a tantrum!” he screams at his cast and crew.)

He’s making a stylized musical set against vivid painted backdrops because he’s tired of “every British film ever made” in the grey, unstinting rain.

His project fails, but he’s not without hope for the filmmaking life.

“Avoid the temptation to be obvious,” he tells Julie. “That’s all you can hope for.” With this completely original and unexpected sequel, it’s clear Hogg agrees.

alison.gillmor@winnipegfreepress.com