Who wrote The Book of Rock?

10: The Rolling Stones They were the bad-boy alternative to the Beatles, but they also took music to the next level

Advertisement

Advertise with us

AS with so many lists, this one originated over pints, consumed with fellow rock 'n' roll obsessives Bill Saunders and Craig Toomey. These articles, which spring from the list of names the three of us came up with, will run weekly as we make our way to the top position.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 27/05/2012 (5215 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

AS with so many lists, this one originated over pints, consumed with fellow rock ‘n’ roll obsessives Bill Saunders and Craig Toomey. These articles, which spring from the list of names the three of us came up with, will run weekly as we make our way to the top position.

In this series, I pay tribute to 10 rock ‘n’ roll-era visionaries who came up with the musical vocabulary we’re still hearing today, the ones without whom the language of rock ‘n’ roll would not sound the same. One of my criteria is how often I jot down their name or think of them when I cover a concert or play a new disc, whether the artist I’m listening to is 25 or 65.

The series does not purport to define the absolute originators of anything. In popular music, everything can be traced back somewhere, so arguing about firsts is a loser’s game. Accordingly, the pre-rock pioneers who made it all possible will have to be saved for other lists.

Mark Seliger / The Associated Press archives
This 2005 file photo, originally supplied by the Rolling Stones, shows the group posing during a photo shoot. They are, from left to right: Charlie Watts, Keith Richards, Mick Jagger, and Ron Wood.
Mark Seliger / The Associated Press archives This 2005 file photo, originally supplied by the Rolling Stones, shows the group posing during a photo shoot. They are, from left to right: Charlie Watts, Keith Richards, Mick Jagger, and Ron Wood.

Nor are the choices about factors such as longevity, sales, glamour, image, cultural influence or similar elements. This is strictly music — although it’s not a list of the best singers, writers or players, either.

And finally, since there are only 10 spots, the focus had to be narrowed to rock ‘n’ roll, so rap, blues and jazz, for example, will have their day at another time.

Inevitably, many will disagree with the selections. Some will be outraged performers they consider obvious nominees have been left out. Others will wonder how in heaven’s name some of ours ever made it in.

With respect to all the giants who could have easily filled a Top 100, here’s the first entry in my list of artists who wrote the book of rock ‘n’ roll.

 

Mythology would have it the Rolling Stones came to North America as the unkempt, scary-looking bad boys your teenage daughter might run away with, never to be heard from again. An alternative to the clean, polite Beatles who just wanted to hold your hand and have tea with your mom, some say.

Even today, “I was always more of a Stones person than a Beatles person” has become shorthand for how much cooler or rebellious one was or is.

That’s a revisionist con job, of course. Still, I never forgot what my cousin Mel told me when I was 11 and he was 13. I got it only on an intuitive level, but it still kind of makes sense: “The Beatles are life. The Stones are action,” he said.

And they were.

The Stones got their inspiration from black blues artists such as Muddy Waters and Slim Harpo, rather than more gentrified acts like the Everly Brothers and Buddy Holly, who were the deities of many of the group’s British Invasion brethren. The Stones were grittier than most of the English pop groups. And… OK, maybe they did seem a little nastier.

But what ultimately sets the Stones apart from groups such as the Animals and Manfred Mann, who were equally blues-savvy and arguably better musicians, was their ability to take it to the next level.

That was down to the formidable writing partnership of Mick Jagger and Keith Richards. Bullied into easing up on the covers and coming up with their own material by their manager, Andrew Loog Oldham, they responded, legend tells us, with the pop ballad As Tears Go By.

But it wasn’t long before some of the rock era’s most unforgettable tracks came rushing out of these two kids from the London suburbs. The Last Time, (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction, Get Off of My Cloud, 19th Nervous Breakdown, Ruby Tuesday and Jumpin’ Jack Flash, to name only a few, followed in a burst of Technicolor.

And those were only the chapter headings. A new Stones single in an outrageous picture sleeve or an album with an appropriately dark-lit cover was always a major event.

They had it all: showmanship, songs and satanic majesty.

With the albums Beggar’s Banquet (1968) and Let It Bleed (1969), their musical vision reached a self-confident peak, with a swagger few could approach. It was one of the greatest one-two punches in rock history.

From that point on, the oeuvre is more debatable, although there have been some undeniable highs.

The Rolling Stones still roam the Earth as the self-proclaimed world’s greatest rock ‘n’ roll band, a title even they must realize is undeserved. But in fairness, that title belongs to 1,000 different groups on 1,000 different nights. It is owned by no one.

What the Stones do own is an attitude that made a couple of generations want to get behind an instrument and climb onstage, a raunchiness that redefined the rock in rock ‘n’ roll, a guitar sound — Richards’ five-string “open-G” tuning — that bands still copy and a deadly combination of hood-like menace and incongruous effeminacy that altered the look of rock forever. Most of all, they gave us those powerhouse songs that still stop us dead in our tracks within a note or two.

May a pint be raised in their honour tonight and every night.

 

— Postmedia News

 

 

KEY TRACKS

 

1. The Last Time

 

2. Get Off of My Cloud

 

3. Street

Fighting Man

 

4. Gimme Shelter

 

5. Tumbling Dice

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Westwood standoff ends with two arrested

Morgan Modjeski and Erik Pindera 3 minute read Preview

Westwood standoff ends with two arrested

Morgan Modjeski and Erik Pindera 3 minute read Thursday, Sep. 3, 2026

An hours-long standoff in Westwood came to an end Thursday with Winnipeg police arresting two men and seizing a gun.

Winnipeg Police Service officers were called to Byrd Avenue shortly before 9:30 a.m. after a man was seen walking with what appeared to be a firearm, said police spokesman Const. Claude Chancy.

Officers identified a home connected to the investigation, he said.

Two men were arrested but Chancy could not yet say what they will be charged with. It’s not clear whether either of the men arrested was the male spotted with a gun.

Read
Thursday, Sep. 3, 2026

Agriculture sector wary of ‘strong headwind’ from south

Laura Rance-Unger 4 minute read Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

Industry analysts talked in circles on a recent webinar as they discussed the implications for agriculture of Canada’s deteriorating relationship with its largest trading partner.

On one hand, panellists for the hastily convened Canadian AgriFood Policy Institute event acknowledged the futility of negotiating on quicksand: a deal made today with the United States might be sucked into the muck tomorrow.

But on the other, webinar panellists speculated with varying degrees of optimism over what it will take to get negotiators back to bargaining.

This disconnect isn’t unique to this cluster of analysts. However, it underscores the difficulty of coming to terms with the seismic shift in America’s attitudes towards Canada.

Art piece connects viewers to broader national landscape

Allison Gillmor 4 minute read Preview

Art piece connects viewers to broader national landscape

Allison Gillmor 4 minute read Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

WHAT IT IS: Copy Paperis a 2014 textile-based piece by Ontario-born, Winnipeg-based artist Kristin Nelson, currently on view at WAG-Qaumajuq as part of the exhibition Terra Cognita/Incognita.

Of the 125 works in the show — which uses historical and contemporary pieces from WAG-Qaumajuq’s permanent collection to explore how artists have represented the landscape over time and across cultures —probably the most attention-getting are the beautiful paintings of Canada’s lakes, plains, forests and mountains.

So, how does this seemingly modest, somewhat enigmatic work connect to Terra Cognita/Incognita’s larger themes?

WHAT IT’S ABOUT: In the middle of the exhibition, an antique desk holds several objects of beauty and utility, and this is where Copy Paper sneaks in, as something both “cognita and incognita,” known and unknown.

Read
Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

Back to school means increased costs for parents, post-secondary students

Joel Schlesinger 6 minute read Preview

Back to school means increased costs for parents, post-secondary students

Joel Schlesinger 6 minute read Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

In the words of advice for students from Thornton Melon: “It’s rough out there. Move back in with your parents.”

As comedian Rodney Dangerfield’s character alluded to in the 1986 comedy Back to School, it is indeed a tough financial environment as students head back to the classroom in 2026.

A Capital One Canada survey found families are struggling with costs, with nearly six in 10 parents surveyed stating back-to-school expenses are higher than expected.

It’s not just tuition, new clothes and supplies. Extracurricular activities — like hockey, figure skating, ringette, soccer, dance, etc. — also ramp up, involving tuition-sized payments.

Read
Yesterday at 2:01 AM CDT

St. Malo’s summer hot spot relies on dedicated community to make sure park-goers can kick back and relax

Melissa Martin 16 minute read Preview

St. Malo’s summer hot spot relies on dedicated community to make sure park-goers can kick back and relax

Melissa Martin 16 minute read Friday, Sep. 4, 2026

It’s shaping up to be a hot late-August Friday in southern Manitoba; the forecast warns of a thunderstorm in the late afternoon, but that won’t stop Manitobans from flocking to savour one of the last great beach days of the summer.

Read
Friday, Sep. 4, 2026

Class delayed a day after mould found in Tyndall Park school

Maggie Macintosh 6 minute read Preview

Class delayed a day after mould found in Tyndall Park school

Maggie Macintosh 6 minute read Thursday, Sep. 3, 2026

The first day of school has been postponed at École Stanley Knowles School after teachers discovered mould on chairs, rugs and other items when they were setting up their classrooms.

Families were alerted Thursday afternoon that an “HVAC malfunction” required extensive cleanup and, as a result, a one-day delay to the new year.

“I called it a couple weeks ago — it smelled really strong of mould,” said Amanda Bell, a mother who’s gone to the building regularly all summer to drop off and pick up her children from the on-site daycare.

Bell recalled she and her partner got a whiff of “wet mould” in a first-floor hallway near the library in mid-August and flagged it to an employee who told them they’d contact a custodian.

Read
Thursday, Sep. 3, 2026