Deliberate dike breach delayed until Saturday


Advertise with us

WINNIPEG — The Manitoba government once again delayed its plan to purposefully flood rural properties across a huge area southeast of Portage la Prairie.

Read this article for free:


Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe with this special offer:

All-Access Digital Subscription

$1.50 for 150 days*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Pay $1.50 for the first 22 weeks of your subscription. After 22 weeks, price increases to the regular rate of $19.00 per month. GST will be added to each payment. Subscription can be cancelled after the first 22 weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 12/05/2011 (4115 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

WINNIPEG — The Manitoba government once again delayed its plan to purposefully flood rural properties across a huge area southeast of Portage la Prairie.

Emergency Measures Minister Steve Ashton said Thursday crews will wait until Saturday morning — at 6 a.m. — to cut through a dike along the Assiniboine River at the Hoop and Holler bend.

The cut will send flood water southeast, flooding an estimated 150 properties on 225 square kilometres of land.

JONATHAN HAYWARD / The Canadian Press Members of 2nd battalion Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry take a break from laying sandbags along a weak section of the dike running along the Assiniboine River, about 25 kilometres from Portage La Prairie on Thursday.

On Thursday, Ashton tried to soothe the concerns of people whose land will be deliberately flooded.

“It will be moving fairly slowly. There are areas … that will not see any water for days,” Ashton said.

When the cut in the river’s southern dike is made, far less water will be released than first anticipated: 500 cubic feet per second (cfs) initially, flood officials said Thursday. That could be increased in 500 cfs increments daily as needed.

JONATHAN HAYWARD / The Canadian Press Members of the 2nd Battalion, PPCLI, help load sandbags onto helicopter slings to be transported to weak sections of the dike running along the Assiniboine River, 25 kilometres from Portage la Prairie.

Ashton described 500 cfs as “a very minimal flow.” It’s about enough water to fill an Olympic-sized swimming pool every three minutes.

The province raised the spectre of the intentional flood on Sunday. The move is considered the lesser of two evils because doing nothing could cause the Assiniboine to spill its banks in other areas as well, swamping twice as much land and affecting 850 homes and properties in the rural municipalities of Cartier, St. François-Xavier and Headingley.

Provincial officials had earlier said the Hoop and Holler cut could happen as early as 8 a.m. Wednesday, then 2 p.m. Wednesday.

province of manitoba Map shows the effects of the Hoop and Holler cut.

Excavators were already starting to dig out the dike Thursday as nearby residents scrambled to pile sandbags around their homes.

The main reason for the delay is the success provincial crews have seen in building up the Portage Diversion, increasing its capacity to 32,000 cfs, up from 25,000 cfs, Ashton said.

Crews remained at work to boost the capacity to 34,000 cfs. As a result, increasing amounts of water were being diverted into Lake Manitoba through the Portage Diversion.

BRUCE OWEN / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS The controlled release of the Assiniboine River near the Hoop and Holler Bend may occur Thursday, provincial officials said today. The cut at Provincial Road 331 at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, will allow part of the Assiniboine River's flow into the Elm River and on to the La Salle watershed.

“Our objective is to delay the controlled release as long as it is safely possible to allow us as much time as possible (to prepare),” Ashton said.

Another 50 homes on both sides of the Portage Diversion were issued precautionary voluntary evacuation notices Thursday. About 150 families had already been told earlier in the week to leave.

When the cut in the dike does happen, “it will pond up behind the first north-south road and then slowly spill over to the second one,” said Steve Topping, executive director of Manitoba Water Stewardship.

MIKE.DEAL@FREEPRESS.MB.CA A view from the sky of the Assiniboine River overflowing its banks in Brandon on Thursday.

“And actually, as it progresses downstream, it will slow down.”

Homes that are above road grade may not suffer any flooding, officials said. People who own homes that are below the roadway have been advised to build up sandbag barriers to a level 60 centimetres above the road level.

Sandbagging continued at a furious pace south of Portage la Prairie as families, friends and volunteers prepared for Saturday.

MIKE DEAL / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ARCHIVES The Assiniboine River as seen from the air near Brandon. The province says the objective is to delay the controlled release as long as it is safely possible to allow as much time as possible for homeowners to prepare.

Truckloads of sandbags arrived in the town of Newton, and were snapped up quickly.

“Everyone is doing what they can,” said Brad Dick of Newton Enterprises. “This gives us more time for us to prepare.”

Tanya Souque said if there is one bright spot in the stress of the past few days, it’s the coming together of people to help each other.

“I live in the danger zone and have spent three days sandbagging my house, families’ houses, neighbours’ and complete strangers’ houses,” Souque said.

“We are trying to move grain out and save anything possible. It is amazing how many family, friends and complete strangers who are not being affected in any way have come to help.”


One of the first properties to be hit by the artificial flooding — if the cut is made — is owned by quarter-horse rancher Ted Bray. 

His farm is on the edge of the Elm River, which will be used to siphon off flood water from the Assinibine through the cut.

“I haven’t been sleeping,” Bray, 60, said of what could in store for him and his small farm. “There’s just too much to think about.”

“The support has been outstanding,” Bray said. “People from the community have been great. There’s such urgency. Everyone understands it.”

Bray said he was first told Tuesday morning about his house and farm being at risk. He’s moved his animals, but hasn’t had time to move his machinery to higher ground, not that there is any higher ground in this part of Manitoba.

“We’ve tried to do everything we can,” he said, as he and son John beefed up the sandbag dike around the house.

“But we’ve just been so busy.”

Bray and others want a firm commitment from government that they will be compensated 100 per cent for their losses, and what they’ve spent protecting their properties.

“I spent $400 on lunch to feed everyone who helped me the other day,” he said. “Will I be compensated for that?”

Should the cut in PR 331 be made, it’ll take a day or so for Assiniboine River floodwater flow east down the Elm River towards Bray’s farm.

“They say they’ll be able to control it, but if they can’t, it’ll be a disaster,” he said.

“I don’t think they really know for sure what will happen,” Bray said.

Bray’s farm, about two kilometres south of Oakville, was last flooded in the 1950s, before the province built the Assiniboine Diversion at Portage La Prairie.

Several kilometres north of Bray’s propery, the situation is just as critical for hundreds of soldiers from Shilo and Edmonton. They’re working furiously to strengthen weak spots in a dike built several weeks ago along the Assiniboine on either side of PR 430.

The highway has been blocked off and turned into two landing zones for half a dozen helicopters to continuously ferry sandbags, loaded in cargo nets hooked underneath, to soldiers from the First and Second Battalions of the Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry working on the dike below.

Soldiers from Shilo starting working on the dike several days ago; more from Edmonton arrived Thursday.

Cpl. Mitch Wilson was one of about two dozen reservists working to protect a home.

The 19-year-old from Winnipeg had been shovelling heavy sand for several days and was running on five hours sleep, but still had a smile on his face.

“It’s tiring but we make it fun,” he said. “I think people really appreciate the help. It feels good to be out here and help people out. I feel proud to be a part of it.

“It feels good to know I’m helping out Canadians.”

Also on Thursday, Ashton said recent heavy rains in eastern Saskatchewan and western Manitoba are causing flood forecasters to predict a new higher crest along the Qu’Appelle River near the western Manitoba town of St. Lazare.

He said the community is working to raise its dike by a foot.


Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 11:26 AM CDT: Delay in time of cut

Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 1:26 PM CDT: Adds update regarding helicopter sandbagging.

Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 2:20 PM CDT: Updates release-time information

Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 3:54 PM CDT: Updates with possible Saturday cut.

Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 4:30 PM CDT: Adds detail of new expected flow; information from Newton.

Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 5:18 PM CDT: Adds cut delayed until Saturday

Updated on Thursday, May 12, 2011 10:22 PM CDT: Adds quotes and details.

Report Error Submit a Tip


Advertise With Us

Flood Fight