U.S. nuclear company seeks to make Pinawa home to its reactor demonstration site

A nuclear energy company has applied to make the Manitoba community of Pinawa a global hub in small modular reactors that can be used to power off-grid communities and mining camps.

Read this article for free:


Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe with this special offer:

All-Access Digital Subscription

$4.75 per week*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Pay $19.00 every four weeks. GST will be added to each payment. Subscription can be cancelled anytime.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 05/07/2018 (1668 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

A nuclear energy company has applied to make the Manitoba community of Pinawa a global hub in small modular reactors that can be used to power off-grid communities and mining camps.

StarCore Nuclear Ltd. submitted its application June 11 to build a $150-million SMR demonstration site on the Atomic Energy Canada Ltd. grounds near Pinawa, about 110 kilometres east of Winnipeg.

Based in Maryland, StarCore is one of four companies to make an application after Canadian Nuclear Laboratories invited submissions last fall. CNL says at least two more companies are preparing applications.

MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Whiteshell Laboratories in Pinawa opened in 1965.

However, StarCore may be the only company proposing to build on the AECL site outside Pinawa. The general preference expressed by other companies is to build on the atomic energy site at Chalk River, Ont.

“Everybody is excited as hell about this,” said Blair Skinner, mayor of the Local Government District of Pinawa. “We would create a green energy park to demonstrate the concept” of SMRs.

Local governments have banded together and been active in talks with StarCore, Skinner said, adding Pinawa has letters of agreement signed with Beausejour, Whitemouth, and the rural municipalities of Lac du Bonnet and Brokenhead.

“We’ve had nuclear for 55 years now (at AECL). If we don’t do anything, we’re going to lose the last 350 jobs we have here by 2024.”

That’s when the AECL site is scheduled to be fully decommissioned. The site once employed more than 1,000 people.

“Our area’s been whacked by job losses with (paper mill) Tembec closing in Pine Falls, and the Bissett mine closed again,” said Skinner, a former scientist at the nuclear research site.

Whiteshell Laboratories at a glance

– Whiteshell Laboratories (initially called Whiteshell Nuclear Research Establishment) opened in 1965, after a three year construction period.

– Whiteshell Laboratories (initially called Whiteshell Nuclear Research Establishment) opened in 1965, after a three year construction period.

– Whiteshell Laboratories (initially called Whiteshell Nuclear Research Establishment) opened in 1965, after a three year construction period.

– It is on an 11,000-acre parcel, on the northwest tip of Whiteshell Provincial Park.

– The town of Pinawa was built concurrently to house workers, and marks its beginning in 1963.

– Whiteshell Laboratories employed up to 1,000 people in the 1970s.

– The nuclear laboratory’s primary research focus was CANDU reactors.

– The nuclear reactor, called WR-1 or Whiteshell Reactor-1, ceased operation in 1985, and has been in semi-storage since.

– Atomic Energy Canada Ltd. built a controversial $40-million underground laboratory in 1985, 15 kilometres north of the laboratory site, to research storage of nuclear waste in the Canadian Shield.

– Decommissioning began in 1997, and Pinawa was rocked a year later by the loss of about 700 jobs.

– In 2015, one of the Harper federal government’s last acts was to contract AECL laboratories to Canadian Nuclear Laboratories.

– CNL is an alliance of leading engineering and technology companies including CH2M (out of Englewood, Colo.), Fluor (Irving, Texas), Atkins (England), Rolls-Royce (England), and SNC-Lavalin Inc. (Montreal, with an office in Winnipeg).

– CNL applied to entomb the nuclear reactor, the first such procedure in Canada.

– About 350 employees remain on the AECL site.

– The new timetable to complete decommissioning is now 2024. Employment levels are scheduled to start declining in 2020.

A SMR demonstration site near Pinawa (population 1,300) would save many of AECL’s remaining jobs, plus add another 350 in related business in the area, David Dabney, StarCore chief executive officer, said in a telephone interview.

In total, the SMR demo site would create about $750 million in economic activity over 10 years, from construction of the facilities, salaries and taxes, and related business around the site, Dabney said. (The figures are part of its submission to CNL and subject to review.)

The site would eventually be used to provide Pinawa’s electrical needs and StarCore envisions using the SMRs to power water desalination facilities in countries such as Australia, and water purification in Africa.

Dabney said Canada currently spends more than $2 billion in subsidizing the cost diesel fuel for about 220,000 remote residents who live off the grid. The communities pay from 50 cents to $1 per kilowatt hour for energy, depending on the level of subsidization, versus 8.6 cents most Manitobans pay with Manitoba Hydro.

MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Blair Skinner, mayor of the Local Government District of Pinawa: "Everybody is excited as hell about this."

Higher energy costs impact every aspect of a remote community, and all but eliminate any hope for economic development, Skinner said.

“Not only that, the diesel generators pollute the immediate area with soot and run 24-7. So they’re noisy, and in small communities, there’s no escape from the noise,” he said.

Canadian Nuclear Laboratories views SMRs as a good growth opportunity within Canada’s nuclear research capabilities, said Kathy McCarthy, vice-president of research and development at CNL.

“This is a real opportunity for Canada. Right now, this is an opportunity for Canada’s nuclear industry to take a leadership role that could potentially lead to exports as well,” she said.

Applicants must pass through a four-stage process, with each stage requiring more detailed information.

The race to develop SMRs includes about 50 companies worldwide, but Canada is ahead of most because the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission has been active in developing a protocol.

“There’s a lot of interest in Canadian nuclear laboratories because we have built and operated multiple nuclear reactors over the years, and we have the supports for reactor design,” said McCarthy.

McCarthy would not divulge details about applications, and they do not specify the site preference at this time. However, she acknowledged StarCore has been open about its interest in the Whiteshell.

Chalk River has greater supports for a nuclear program than Pinawa, and it is not being decommissioned. However, Dabney cited several items in Pinawa’s favour, including a community that’s receptive to maintaining a presence in the nuclear sector.

Whiteshell Laboratories also have six hot cells that were refurbished only a few years ago. With hot cells, scientists use lead-loaded gloves and tongs to manipulate radioactive material, viewed through windows at least four panes thick. “Brand new, they’re worth $150 (million) to $200 million, minimum,” he said.

StarCore representatives were in Winnipeg last week for the second time in the last six months, and met with numerous parties including the University of Manitoba faculties of science and engineering and the Manitoba Building Trades. The company has also had discussions with Manitoba Hydro and provincial government members.

MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS A deer wandering the streets of Pinawa. Set in the picturesque Canadian shield, Pinawa was formed in 1963 to house the employees of the nearby Whiteshell Nuclear Research Establishment.

The StarCore application proposes building the demo site without government assistance. Dabney said many other companies look for matching funds from government, but StarCore raises money through a community of investors.

There is currently no SMR demo site in the world. Without a demo site, “the technical, procedural, political obstacles and challenges would be huge” to building SMRs in a remote community, Dabney said.

StarCore SMRs would deploy high-temperature helium gas reactors (capable of reaching 750 to 900 C), instead of pressurized water reactors used in most reactors operating today (350 C).

Helium is also safer because it does not become radioactive, unlike water, he said.

“The interest in high-temperature gas reactors is very great. It’s the only nuclear technology designated as inherently safe by the International Atomic Energy Agency,” Dabney said.

Such reactors are in operation in many countries, including the United States, United Kingdom, Germany, Japan, and China. “We’re not taking a technology that hasn’t been commercially proven,” Dabney said.


Updated on Friday, July 6, 2018 4:23 PM CDT: Corrects to Manitoba Building Trades.

Report Error Submit a Tip