Concussions: It's a know-brainer

Finally, NHL GMs will take steps to outlaw headshots

By Tim Campbell 8 minute read Wednesday, Mar. 10, 2010

Today's NHL is unquestionably bigger, faster and stronger.

Small, slow and weak, however, describes the league's actions -- especially compared to every other major brand of hockey -- when it comes to headshots and concussions.

A step into the modern hockey era is scheduled today, when general managers will finalize a proposal for a rule change to make illegal blind-side shoulders to heads.

 

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Weather

Feb. 5, 6 PM: 0°c Cloudy Feb. 6, 12 AM: -8°c Partly cloudy with wind

Winnipeg MB

2°C, Sunny

Full Forecast

‘Terrible day of reckoning’

By Tim Campbell 6 minute read Preview

‘Terrible day of reckoning’

By Tim Campbell 6 minute read Wednesday, Mar. 10, 2010

TSN hockey insider Bob McKen­zie didn’t ask for the invitation to the concussion story but he has no plans to uninvite himself from the debate.

McKenzie speaks out in favour of better enforcement rules against headshots and more prevention of concussions. The veteran journalist is an outspoken critic of those who do nothing.

That includes the NHL, which is the main focus of his television work. McKenzie's oldest son Mike is a 21-year-old senior at St. Lawrence University (NCAA) in Canton, N.Y. Four years ago, a concussion cost him three months of a season but he has recovered with no further symptoms or blows to the head.

 

Read
Wednesday, Mar. 10, 2010

Vancouver’s Mark Messier slams into the post after scoring a goal against Calgary in this 1998 photo. Messier sustained a concussion on the play.

Vancouver’s Mark Messier slams into the post after scoring a goal against Calgary in this 1998 photo. Messier sustained a concussion on the play.

Headshot issue has GMs thinking

By Chris Johnston 3 minute read Tuesday, Mar. 9, 2010

BOCA RATON, Fla. -- As more ugly headshots make news, the NHL's 30 general managers are still wrestling with how to handle the issue.

The GMs were presented with an avalanche of information about concussions and various types of checks on the opening day of their annual meeting Monday, but they seemed no closer to a recommendation that could lead to fewer hits to the head.

And the pressure is mounting.

After watching Boston Bruins forward Marc Savard carried from the ice on a stretcher and hearing players start to voice concern, many are looking to the GMs to make some kind of recommendation by the time their meetings wrap up Wednesday.

Hockey needs an attitude adjustment

By Tim Campbell 4 minute read Tuesday, Mar. 9, 2010

11Steve Spott was an assistant coach with Canada's national junior team and his regular job is head coach of the Kitchener Rangers of the Ontario Hockey League, which has recently revised its rules to forbid all contact to the head.

"I think our league's done a real nice job being a pioneer here and we're proud of it," Spott said. "And the game's not ruined."

Spott's experience this season has been on both sides of the fence.

He has coached young players, both with Team Canada and his own team, who have done unsavoury things.

When helmets don’t help

By Tim Campbell 10 minute read Preview

When helmets don’t help

By Tim Campbell 10 minute read Tuesday, Mar. 9, 2010

Dr. PAT Bishop just may be a hockey player's best friend.

His research to improve protective equipment, especially helmets and faceguards, has saved countless players from serious injury.

For example, when the first face shields and cages were introduced to hockey, Bishop's research revealed most sat too close to the face and not properly on the chin. He warned that the impact of a puck could cave in the shield or even break it.

The result was a new standard that brought the shield or cage safely away from the face.

Read
Tuesday, Mar. 9, 2010

Julie Jacobson / The Associated Press
Collisions with the boards or with other players can cause skull or facial fractures that a helmet and faceguard can help prevent. But researchers say a hockey helmet has not yet been made that will help prevent concussions caused by the brain sloshing around inside the skull.

Julie Jacobson / The Associated Press
Collisions with the boards or with other players can cause skull or facial fractures that a helmet and faceguard can help prevent. But researchers say a hockey helmet has not yet been made that will help prevent concussions caused by the brain sloshing around inside the skull.

To play, or not to play — a hard question

By Tim Campbell 5 minute read Tuesday, Mar. 9, 2010

Concussion does not spare the young.

Jake Heisinger was only 14 in March 2007, when he was knocked from behind into the boards twice within minutes. The first time he cut his chin; the second it was his nose.

One or both blows caused the concussion, which kept him out a little more than a week.

His dad, Manitoba Moose GM Craig Heisinger, admits to momentarily considering letting Jake play the next game before a late-night solo walk in the snow clarified the proper decision to hold him out.

The prescription nobody wants

By Tim Campbell 9 minute read Monday, Mar. 8, 2010

They bring their rattled brains, and usually their parents, to him on a regular basis. These young athletes, many of them hockey players, are in varying states of recovery from concussion, but prominent neurosurgeon Dr. Charles Tator knows that far too often there is only one recommendation he can make: It's a line that should not be crossed again.

The doctor vs. Grapes

By Tim Campbell 4 minute read Monday, Mar. 8, 2010

HE was in front of a sympathetic audience eager to learn more about concussions in hockey, so noted neurosurgeon Dr. Charles Tator called out Don Cherry.

"Don Cherry is a negative influence," Tator told Hockey Canada's concussion seminar in Regina last December. "And it's about time we started calling a spade a spade."

The comment caused a small firestorm as many media outlets went for the headline instead of the substance.

Shortly after the conference, Cherry ran head-first into a determined radio reporter who was waiting for him outside a Toronto studio. Cherry had earlier told the reporter he wouldn't be getting an interview, but the reporter persisted, all the while his tape recorder running.

ThinkFirst pushes awareness, education

By Tim Campbell 4 minute read Monday, Mar. 8, 2010

Manitoba’s chapter of ThinkFirst not only takes the prevention message to the masses but it has the advantage of a strong connection with the national founder.

Its chapter director is Health Sciences Centre pediatric neurosurgeon and associate professor and residency program director Dr. Patrick McDonald, who studied under Dr. Tator.

"He's a unique individual because he does everything," says Dr. McDonald. "Not only is he an accomplished neurosurgeon, internationally renowned for his surgical skills and for how many lives he's saved that way, but I think he's saved even more with his injury-prevention message.

"In addition to that, as if being a busy neurosurgeon wasn't enough, founding, running and being the driving force behind ThinkFirst, he's led one of the world's leading spinal-cord basic science research labs. I always think of him first as a role model, but I don't know how he does it because he's got three or more full-time jobs that would be more than enough for any normal individual. He's the Superman of neurosurgery, I like to think."

Taking dead aim at headshots

By Chris Johnston 4 minute read Monday, Mar. 8, 2010

BOCA RATON, Fla. -- The issue of headshots in hockey will be put under the microscope when the NHL's 30 general managers gather together this week.

It will be one of the many topics discussed during the annual GM meetings from today to Wednesday and seems to be the one most likely to result in a potential rule change.

It's something the GMs have grappled with a few times already. Former NHL Players' Association executives Paul Kelly and Glenn Healy raised the heading issue during a presentation at these meetings a year ago, saying it was the most important concern for players.

However, it didn't gain much traction then or during a subsequent meeting at the Stanley Cup final in June. The nature of the conversation changed when the group convened in November, prompted in part by a couple vicious hits early in the season -- notably the one Mike Richards put on David Booth.

CONCUSSIONS: it’s a know-brainer

2 minute read Saturday, Mar. 6, 2010

Today, in the first of a four-part series on the issue, Free Press hockey writer Tim Campbell talks to some of the casualties. One of them, former NHLer Jamie Heward, is still dealing with the aftermath of another concussion that finally ended his career 14 months ago.

Heward, unfortunately, is not alone. The victims of headshots are everywhere -- from the NHL to junior to minor hockey -- and the damage is considerable.

In Monday's Part 2, we introduce you to Dr. Charles Tator, a Toronto neurosurgeon who has become a crusader for concussion awareness while also daring to take on the formidable Don Cherry in the debate.

In Part 3, Campbell examines the role of equipment and prevention in the concussion discussion.

Heading for trouble: A concussion can mean it’s safest to hang up the skates

By Tim Campbell 11 minute read Preview

Heading for trouble: A concussion can mean it’s safest to hang up the skates

By Tim Campbell 11 minute read Saturday, Mar. 6, 2010

Jamie Heward takes a lot less for granted than he used to.

It's a self-imposed side-effect from having suffered as many as 20 concussions, some from hockey, some from normal kid activities and falls, up to the end of his NHL career at age 37.

The last, when he was hit from behind by reckless superstar Alexander Ovechkin of the Washington Capitals, knocking his head hard and awkwardly into the glass on Jan. 1, 2009, was one too many for the Tampa Bay Lightning player.

Heward was unconscious for a minute. He was then carried off the Washington ice on a stretcher. To this day, he remembers little about the events before and after that hit.

Read
Saturday, Mar. 6, 2010

Today is Tim Campbell’s first instalment of a four-part series dealing with concussions and their consequences.

Today is Tim Campbell’s first instalment of a four-part series dealing with concussions and their consequences.

LOAD MORE