Local

Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION

Tire problem factor in plane's belly landing

Gear deployment wasn't possible

By: Kevin Rollason

7/11/2009 1:00 AM | Comments: 3

Enlarge Image

(SUPPLIED)

Enlarge Image

City firefighters at the scene of the Perimeter Aviation plane’s belly landing at Richardson International Airport March 3. (MIKE DEAL / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ARCHIVES)

PUT a tire that's too wide on your car, and you'll find it won't stay on the rim -- but if you try the same thing with an airplane's wheel, you might have to make a pancake landing on a runway.

That's part of what federal aviation crash experts have determined happened to a Perimeter Aviation plane earlier this year when its landing gear failed to come down and the two pilots were forced to make a belly landing at Winnipeg's Richardson International Airport on March 3.

The two crew and eight passengers on board, en route from St. Theresa Point to Winnipeg, walked off the plane with no injuries, but were taken to hospital as a precaution.

Peter Hildebrand, regional manager of the Transportation Safety Board of Canada, said on Friday the twin-engine Metro II plane's right landing gear door didn't open all the way because the tire was about a centimetre too wide, causing it to hook up on the gear door's raised ledge.

Hildebrand said not only was there a problem with the ledge, but the gear door was also installed incorrectly.

"The landing-gear doors aren't like your car's door, which is installed at a factory and goes years without change," Hildebrand said.

"Landing doors are subject to vibration (and) high speed and they're out in the cold and heat. They have stress and they're always in a state of flux.

"And then you put on a newly recapped tire. It (the doors) would work with the original tire, but when you put one on a bit larger, it changes things."

Hildebrand said it all culminated in the pilots not being able to put down their right landing gear.

Hildebrand said the plane was manufactured in 1976 by the Fairchild Aircraft Corp. He said the landing gear door on later Metro IIs were designed without the ledge, which on the earlier models were there to give the door more strength.

And Hildebrand said in the wake of the pancake landing, the manufacturer reissued its 1984 notice on tire-size information for airlines flying the aircraft.

Mark Wehrle, Perimeter's general manager, said they've already designed a new device to ensure the tire's width is the right size before it is put on a plane.

But, Wehrle said "tires tend to grow from the heat and the centrifugal force.

"And it's a tight fit there. The original aircraft had much smaller tires, but then they put in larger tires... and the manufacturer's specifications change over the years."

Wehrle said the company is also looking at redesigning the landing gear doors.

Wehrle said the plane was damaged on its belly, flaps and propellers, but it has been repaired and put back into service.

"The damage was very minimal," he said, noting it cost less than $30,000 to fix.

"Our pilots did a great job of setting it down fairly gently."

kevin.rollason@freepress.mb.ca

Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 7, 2009 A3

Rate this
This article is currently rated an average of 4.5 out of 5 (2 votes).

We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.

You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.

Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.

3 Comments

Posted by: Robert Brise

November 7, 2009 at 7:11 PM

Wrong tire will pop off the rim!!!
Dumbest comment I have heard in quite a while !!
You can drive with all 4 tires being different sizes on a car and let me assure you you won't have to make a belly landing!!!!!!

Report abusive comment

Posted by: AgentFrank

November 7, 2009 at 4:33 PM

The unfortunate unknown is how weather or wind might effect operation at a later date. A cross wind could cause a door to deflect a few milimeters, and that would be all it would take in this situation. However I do agree, Good enough isn't !

Report abusive comment

Posted by: morebs

November 7, 2009 at 9:03 AM

...simple enough to operate the device a couple of times after repair to at least see that it "looked" to be operating OK [i.e. not binding]... Sounds like Wherle and Hildebrand are blaming it on some mysterious, unavoidable force, or "gremlin." Doesn't do much to inspire confidence! When and where will the gremliln strike next?