Searching for Somethings in grandson’s Nothing

Advertisement

Advertise with us

We recently lost a most precious family member, a woman of remarkable grace, ability, and heart: my son’s mother-in-law, my co-Baba.

Read this article for free:

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Opinion

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 30/09/2024 (660 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

We recently lost a most precious family member, a woman of remarkable grace, ability, and heart: my son’s mother-in-law, my co-Baba.

None of us knows how to manage such a loss. We all grieve as we must. We try to support one another, to explain to grandchildren what has happened.

In the past months, the littlest one, at three, has known something has been changing as his Baba’s illness took hold, because there were appointments that meant he could not visit, for example, and a process that altered his Baba’s appearance. He was unsettled, aware, wondering.

When his Baba died, he thought of his absent Zaida Nummy, the name his older sister had created for my husband, Mendel, gone before this little boy was born but whose recorded voice still answers calls on my landline.

When my grandson hears this voice, I explain to him that while this Zaida is no longer alive, he is somewhere loving him, present in the stories we tell and the photos we examine, further entwined in his very being because he is named after him.

My grandson is alternately charmed, mystified, and frustrated. Occasionally, he simply announces that this Zaida Nummy is a “Nothing” and then looks up to see if that will have any consequence. Would his Zaida suddenly materialize? Might the sky fall?

I listen to his ongoing calculations. I have a garage opener I’ve let him use as we approach in the car. He loves to do things like that. The opener has two buttons and the one with two dots he declares does “Nothing.” He always reminds me that this is true and when he says “Nothing,” I can hear his disdain. Why is this feature available if it is useless? A “Nothing” offends his sensibilities.

One day, he announces that his Baba and Zaida Nummy are flushed down the toilet into “a Nothing.” I think about how a young child’s understanding of potty training — the miraculous unseen, inner landscape of a digestive system — might relate. The fear and fascination of parts of his body being flushed becomes a comparison that helps him grasp what disappearance, what death might mean.

While his Baba and his Zaida are now together in a sphere none of us can define with certainty, except insofar as they are missing, the inexplicable, for him, finds this concrete explication.

I watch to see how else he might articulate his grasp. He overhears a conversation between his adult cousins about a woman who has died, someone’s mother. He turns round to tell me, “Judith died.” Neither one of us knows who Judith might be. It doesn’t seem to matter.

He is solemn as he makes this announcement. I am solemn in hearing it. I don’t add anything. I let the statement settle. The next moment, we are off onto something else, but I feel him putting two and two together in a world that is big and often scary.

Further signs of this wrestling with reality emerge. What begins as a curious and perhaps eccentric preoccupation with the weather, stemming, we think, from his experience of a thunderous storm at daycare, grows to include an unwillingness to go outside. No amount of evidence-based reassurance we might provide by pointing to blue sky and bright sun convinces him that it is safe.

A momentous change has happened in his world. I wonder: Is he trying to control his reality as best he can by staying indoors and constantly consulting the weather channel on his iPad?

Days pass. I try to tempt him with a further inspection of the goodies from the small garden we have planted on the deck at our cousin’s cottage. Cherry tomatoes, prickly cucumbers on the vine. I tell him we could measure the emerging, purple eggplants he prizes, for he is very fond of the colour purple and keeps an eggplant stuffie in his bed. He might take a baby step or two, but then immediately scurries back indoors.

And, then, one mid-August day, without prompting, he willingly goes outside. He tells me he has “changed his mind.” Is this an encouraging acceptance of change, a recovery of the possibility of something less troubling?

My grandson’s understanding of “Nothing,” manifest in the comparisons he conceives, is revelatory. His testing of the outside world demonstrates that regardless of age, each member of our family is trying to endure what death feels like; what grief, this hole in our hearts and world, looks like; if we can find some kind of footing once more.

As his Baba, I am taking this time to appreciate the profound ways in which a little boy’s “Nothing” holds the great many somethings vital to our longing for the magnificent woman we love and have lost.

arts@freepress.mb.ca

Deborah Schnitzer

Winnipeg writer Deborah Schnitzer explores life lessons from women in their Third Act.

Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.

Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

School security camera footage of a nearly 15-second hug between a teacher and one of her students was repeatedly screened and scrutinized at a historic hearing.

“This isn’t a fleeting or a casual embrace. The two were comfortable with each other,” teacher commissioner lawyer Tristan Sandulak told a professional disciplinary panel on Tuesday.

Sandulak made a case for cancelling Janice Wen Ying Ma’s teaching certificate, citing the early career educator’s alleged conduct and “credibility issues.”

The lawyer presented on behalf of Noni Classen, the independent commissioner who oversees Manitoba’s new teacher registry, during a videoconference that took up much of the day.

Landlord miffed after city orders cleanup of riverside homeless camp

Scott Billeck 6 minute read Preview

Landlord miffed after city orders cleanup of riverside homeless camp

Scott Billeck 6 minute read 6:26 PM CDT

A West Broadway landlord is angry the City of Winnipeg has ordered him to clear away a homeless encampment from his riverfront property or have the cleanup cost added to his property tax bill.

Marvin Sharp, CEO of Astroid Management Ltd., which manages the Pen-Eve Apartments at 35 Balmoral St., said the city is forcing private property owners to deal with a problem they didn’t create.

“This is kind of like the neighbours throwing their garbage over the fence, every single day, and the city’s saying, ‘You have to go clean this up, but we’re not going to go tell the neighbour to stop doing that,’” Sharp said. “What do you want me to do here? You’ve got a serious problem here. We’re not talking about someone throwing garbage on the ground. We’re talking about encampments.”

Sharp said he received a city compliance order on July 10 order, which was viewed by the Free Press. It says a bylaw officer observed “an accumulation of garbage” on the property, including abandoned goods of manufacture, tents and unattended shopping carts.

Read
6:26 PM CDT

‘Heartbreaking loss’: Sandy Bay First Nation offers condolences after apparent dog attack

Morgan Modjeski 3 minute read Preview

‘Heartbreaking loss’: Sandy Bay First Nation offers condolences after apparent dog attack

Morgan Modjeski 3 minute read Sunday, Jul. 19, 2026

Leaders with the Sandy Bay Ojibway First Nation are offering their condolences after an animal rescue worker died following an apparent dog attack in the community and say the “stray and aggressive” animals are a longstanding issue.

Amanda Nobiss, 37, was volunteering in the community on the shores of Lake Manitoba with K9 Advocacy. Her remains were discovered on Friday morning.

The Manitoba First Nations Police Service said in a news release that it had been contacted by a friend of Amanda’s who was trying to locate her, around 12:45 a.m.

Using her cellphone location, police determined she appeared to be in Sandy Bay, said the release. Resources were dispatched to the area, including a drone, but due to the large radius of the cellphone “ping,” no one was located until 6 a.m.

Read
Sunday, Jul. 19, 2026

Patients to return to Ste. Anne hospital Wednesday

1 minute read Preview

Patients to return to Ste. Anne hospital Wednesday

1 minute read 7:55 PM CDT

Southern Health says patients who were transferred out of the hospital in Ste. Anne after its HVAC system malfunctioned will return to the facility Wednesday.

Transportation has been arranged for patients who need to return to the hospital, the health authority it said in a statement on its website.

The emergency department is scheduled to reopen on Thursday.

“We would like to extend our sincere thanks to everyone who assisted during this time. Your dedication and hard work helped ensure that patient safety remained our top priority throughout this temporary closure,” the health authority said Tuesday.

Read
7:55 PM CDT

Killer makes ‘amends with his maker

Dean Pritchard 3 minute read Preview

Killer makes ‘amends with his maker

Dean Pritchard 3 minute read 8:54 PM CDT

A Winnipeg man, who once faced two counts of first-degree murder for slayings that were three days apart, has been sentenced to seven years in prison for manslaughter.

Rory Shane Nash, 42, entered a guilty plea to the lesser charge in the Feb. 1, 2023 killing of Lee James Boulette.

Nash was also one of four people arrested in the killing of Carl George Wescoupe three days earlier at the Manwin Hotel on Main Street. Prosecutors later stayed the first-degree murder charge against Nash due to insufficient evidence.

Nash co-operated with prosecutors in both cases, but ultimately did not testify in court, Crown attorney Brent Davidson told provincial court Judge Margaret Wiebe at a sentencing hearing Tuesday.

Read
8:54 PM CDT

Searching for Somethings in grandson’s Nothing

Deborah Schnitzer 5 minute read Monday, Sep. 30, 2024

We recently lost a most precious family member, a woman of remarkable grace, ability, and heart: my son’s mother-in-law, my co-Baba.

None of us knows how to manage such a loss. We all grieve as we must. We try to support one another, to explain to grandchildren what has happened.

In the past months, the littlest one, at three, has known something has been changing as his Baba’s illness took hold, because there were appointments that meant he could not visit, for example, and a process that altered his Baba’s appearance. He was unsettled, aware, wondering.

When his Baba died, he thought of his absent Zaida Nummy, the name his older sister had created for my husband, Mendel, gone before this little boy was born but whose recorded voice still answers calls on my landline.