Keeping a promise, I’ll share a story that we need to hear

Advertisement

Advertise with us

I promised my late husband, Mendel, I would write a novel dedicated to the memory of his half-brother and half-sister, who were murdered in a Nazi extermination camp when they were nine and 10.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Opinion

I promised my late husband, Mendel, I would write a novel dedicated to the memory of his half-brother and half-sister, who were murdered in a Nazi extermination camp when they were nine and 10.

I have a colour-tinted photo of these children at three and four. It is the only surviving representation of them. Theirs was the first family story Mendel told me. In marrying him, I married his story. We carried it together. I carry it now after his death.

I will launch the novel this spring.

For any other of the pieces I have published, Mendel was present, an advocate, firing off emails to family and friends, organizing details, filling the car with the “stuff” I needed to pull off an event or make a presentation, supporting me in everything I was trying to do.

Imagine a love like that, I say to myself. Imagine that kind of care. I find I am forever humming “I had a love of my own like yours.” I hum it more frequently when the seasons change. I seem to stop humming in November when winter comes to whiten the landscape, but then the days get longer and the song comes back to me. I am seasonal, I guess.

The humming continues through spring, summer and fall. Sometimes the song shifts to Fools Rush In; sometimes it morphs into All By Myself, no matter the season, when the day is too long and the silence hurts.

I live what it is like to have loved and lost. Shakespeare observes it better to do so than “never to have loved at all.” I always think and feel through that observation knowing it has merit, but also knowing that losing a loved one through the dimly lit corridors of a relentless chronic illness, stings, derails and darkens.

During the course of the ambiguous grief that distinguishes this reality, I try to learn acceptance (not my strong suit), patience (not my strong suit) and resignation (different from acceptance insofar as it speaks more poignantly to the loss of possibilities once held dear — dreams of grandchildren, of meaningful engagement with the world in a vibrant last act together).

The grief that comes at the moment of death has its own key signature, as does the grief that comes through the dying process, when the diagnosis is first revealed; when the person suffering the illness loses parts of himself; when it is too hard to say out loud what is being stolen.

Grief changes over time, but remains in myriad, altered forms as the measure and the cost that attends the risk of loving, attachment, a shared life. It comes often without warning — while backing the car out of the garage, loading a dishwasher, dusting. It comes with warning — during the setting of the sun or its rising; while preparing a meal for one; when a favourite song starts up on the radio. It tackles the heart, brings the breath to suspension, silence to cacophony.

I have a little altar I made with Mendel’s ashes in a handwoven basket, a photograph of him at his peak, gazing at me (a gaze whose like I shall never find again), photos of his children, their partners and babies growing into young ones he will never know.

I add a candle holder, incense burner. The altar sits on top of a time-worn, olive-green metal medical cabinet with bevelled glass doors.

The altar memorializes. My life lives in and through memory and memory-making. The nine-year anniversary of Mendel’s death (it seems as if yesterday and also light years ago) arrived at the end of March.

I am many years older, but young in my heart when remembering our beginning — a first date in university during a snow storm that stranded us downtown after we had watched The Boston Strangler (Mendel’s choice), played a game or two of pool in a seedy establishment (Mendel’s choice), and enjoyed junk food (our choice).

I may forget where I park the car, where the water main shut-off is located, what I did with my hearing aid, but I do not forget the shifting balance in the galaxy all those decades ago when our eyes met in that deeper pool where love conducts her frequency. Bolts from the blue. Second sightedness. Recognition. A world turning. All those vibrant images whose currency spans lifetimes.

In my forgetting of small things (though I understand that locating the car, the water main, the hearing aid is significant), I remember through shifting sands the big things — the story Mendel told me of his family, a story alive in the photograph I cherish. It is a hard story, one that persists in fascist ideology and action despoiling and extinguishing children’s lives, dehumanizing us all if we fail to rise up and protect them.

arts@freepress.mb.ca

Deborah Schnitzer

Winnipeg writer Deborah Schnitzer explores life lessons from women in their Third Act.

Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.

Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Low-income residents of 114-year-old downtown block staggered by proposed rent hikes

Malak Abas 9 minute read Preview

Low-income residents of 114-year-old downtown block staggered by proposed rent hikes

Malak Abas 9 minute read Thursday, Aug. 20, 2026

Marcel Blanchette’s life has not travelled down a smooth road.

In 2014, he was violently assaulted in his home, an unprovoked attack that left him with severe injuries, including permanent brain damage. He underwent months of hospitalization and rehabilitation. During that time, he learned his possessions had been sold off when the Office of The Public Guardian and Trustee took over his affairs.

Twelve years later, he finds himself in another fight. This time, it comes in the form of a proposal from the new owners of the Conway Court apartment block that would nearly double his monthly rent. While he’s been able to live in the Kennedy Street unit with the support of disability income assistance for nearly five years, the sudden spike, he said, could leave him homeless.

“To go through that, and now I’m going through this, it’s another obstacle,” Blanchette told the Free Press. “I fought the Public Guardian and Trustee, and I’ll fight this too, with whatever I have.”

Read
Thursday, Aug. 20, 2026

Brandon’s Nachtigall comes up short of Canadian Mid-Am title

Mike McIntyre 5 minute read Preview

Brandon’s Nachtigall comes up short of Canadian Mid-Am title

Mike McIntyre 5 minute read Yesterday at 7:52 PM CDT

Evan Nachtigall was about 12-feet away from making history.

But a slippery downhill birdie putt for the win on Friday afternoon in Ontario proved to be a bit too aggressive, leaving the 25-year-old Brandon golfer with a nervy comeback attempt that ultimately fell painfully short.

The resulting bogey, on the 72nd and final hole of play at the Canadian Men’s Mid-Amateur Championship, left him one shot behind playing partner Garrett Rank, who tapped in his par to claim victory.

“It kind of stings,” Nachtigall told the Free Press shortly after finishing up at the Brantford Golf & Country Club. “At the end of the day, second place in my first time playing this event and losing to a guy who’s now won it four times, I guess I’ll have to take it.”

Read
Yesterday at 7:52 PM CDT

City blames bad weather for creating new sinkhole on Sturgeon Creek path

Malak Abas 2 minute read Preview

City blames bad weather for creating new sinkhole on Sturgeon Creek path

Malak Abas 2 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 1:17 PM CDT

After a massive water-filled hole on a Sturgeon Creek active-transportation pathway took more than a year to fix, a new sinkhole has opened nearby.

In June 2023, the Free Press reported on a gaping depression stretching seven metres long, three metres wide and up to a metre deep that opened on a pathway leading to a playground on Amarynth Crescent near the Sturgeon Creek active-transportation route. The city finally made repairs in October 2024.

Now, about 12 metres away from that spot, a new crater has appeared.

The hole, about three metres long and 2.5 metres wide, has been blocked off using metal rods and plastic netting, but resident Philip Kaban said the opening is getting larger.

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 1:17 PM CDT

City inundated with thousands of complaints after launch of new transit system

Morgan Modjeski 11 minute read Preview

City inundated with thousands of complaints after launch of new transit system

Morgan Modjeski 11 minute read Yesterday at 12:25 PM CDT

Despite complaints from thousands of dissatisfied users, Winnipeg hasn't hit the brakes on the rollout of its new primary transit network. And it appears that ignoring the public response cost Winnipeg Transit millions of dollars in lost revenue and ridership.

Read
Yesterday at 12:25 PM CDT

Executive exodus continues at Shared Health with three recent departures

Chris Kitching 5 minute read Preview

Executive exodus continues at Shared Health with three recent departures

Chris Kitching 5 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 4:18 PM CDT

Manitoba’s provincial health authority is looking for its fourth chief financial officer since 2023 and additional replacements after the recent departures of three executives.

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 4:18 PM CDT

Seniors left hanging during Bell MTS outage: property manager

Morgan Modjeski 3 minute read Preview

Seniors left hanging during Bell MTS outage: property manager

Morgan Modjeski 3 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 5:02 PM CDT

Shelly Durham said when it comes to many of her elderly tenants of a downtown highrise apartment, their landline is their lifeline.

That lifeline was disconnected Tuesday after a copper cable that provides telephone service was cut Tuesday during construction work.

“It could be a matter of life and death,” said Durham, the building manager at Broadview Manor. “That’s the scary part.”

Manitoba Hydro spokesperson Peter Chura said a contractor working for the utility contacted the underground communications cable while installing a streetlight cable.

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 5:02 PM CDT