Confounding concept, with a bit of whimsy

Advertisement

Advertise with us

WHEN Iain Pears’ latest novel Arcadia was announced, the format — 10 intertwined stories in three distinct time periods, to be released as both a book and an interactive app — seemed ambitious but unsurprising. Pears has long shown himself to be inclined towards, and successful at, experimental storytelling — whether exhibiting multiple perspectives on the same event in An Instance of the Fingerpost or weaving a trio of narratives together in The Dream of Scipio.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 20/02/2016 (3835 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

WHEN Iain Pears’ latest novel Arcadia was announced, the format — 10 intertwined stories in three distinct time periods, to be released as both a book and an interactive app — seemed ambitious but unsurprising. Pears has long shown himself to be inclined towards, and successful at, experimental storytelling — whether exhibiting multiple perspectives on the same event in An Instance of the Fingerpost or weaving a trio of narratives together in The Dream of Scipio.

The results this time, however, are more leaden than the concept — and Pears’ previous works — would suggest. Linking its pastiche of familiar-feeling tales through time travel and magic doorways, Pears largely eschews both character and craft in favour of the meticulous, high-stakes plotting required to justify the book’s imposing heft and structure.

The novel begins in Anterworld, the pastoral creation of Henry Lytten, a professor (and former wartime spy) in the 1960s who has spent years outlining every inch of his seemingly fictional, fantastical construct. Seemingly, because — as Rosie, the young girl who looks after his cat, accidentally discovers — Lytten maintains a mystic doorway to Anterworld in his basement.

The doorway’s origins are revealed as the novel sidesteps into a dystopian future, where we are introduced to Angela Meerson, inventor of the time machine. She uses the apparently versatile machine both to initiate an affair with Lytten during his wartime days and to run a working simulation of Anterworld. From this complex set-up, it’s revealed that Rosie’s journey into Anterworld in the novel’s “present” causes an expansion of the fiction that threatens to engulf the real world whole — a fate Pears’ array of characters must now strive to prevent.

Tonally, Arcadia traffics in whimsy, nodding vigorously towards the obvious inspirations of Alice in Wonderland and Narnia, but perhaps standing more firmly at the intersection of current young-adult serialized fiction and the arch fantasy of a Piers Anthony or a Neil Gaiman. This serves the story well — easing and undercutting the intense, world-shattering drama — but unfortunately also radically oversimplifies the characters, adding a flimsy cartoonishness to their thoughts and dialogue.

As for the app: it ostensibly provides a different reading experience, laying out the full text (plus additional material) with each character’s storyline arranged individually. But while other novels — notably Julio Cortázar’s Hopscotch — have employed various rearrangements of the text to vividly enhance the story, the Arcadia app essentially presents a shuffle of papers, taking the chapters and spreading them out on a colourful, multi-tiered subway map. And, as the 1963 publication date on Cortázar’s masterpiece shows, the authorial sleight-ofhand required to build an interchangeable narrative doesn’t actually require the aid of modern technology.

Unfortunately, what the app highlights is the lack of propulsion and urgency in the narrative as a whole, presenting the chapters and stories as static and equivalent. It also asks, and inadvertently answers in its flat effect, what readers want from a story at all and what the role of the writer should be in providing it. Pears’ publishers herald the app as a way of making the reader the “master of their own journey through the book” — as though readers had been clamouring for that particular power.

It’s possible the Arcadia app ultimately suggests the opposite: that storytelling of this sort may best be experienced as a journey with a guide, one that is enhanced — rather than structured or steered — by the reader’s imagination. By nestling so many references to the seemingly invulnerable tales of Shakespeare, Tolkien, Bradbury and le Carré within his diffuse, tangled narrative, Pears may, unfortunately, have created a comparison point that does damage to the structure — if not the very foundation — of his experiment.

Doug McLean is a Winnipeg writer and musician.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Confounding concept, with a bit of whimsy

Reviewed by Doug McLean 4 minute read Preview

Confounding concept, with a bit of whimsy

Reviewed by Doug McLean 4 minute read Saturday, Feb. 20, 2016

WHEN Iain Pears’ latest novel Arcadia was announced, the format — 10 intertwined stories in three distinct time periods, to be released as both a book and an interactive app — seemed ambitious but unsurprising. Pears has long shown himself to be inclined towards, and successful at, experimental storytelling — whether exhibiting multiple perspectives on the same event in An Instance of the Fingerpost or weaving a trio of narratives together in The Dream of Scipio.

The results this time, however, are more leaden than the concept — and Pears’ previous works — would suggest. Linking its pastiche of familiar-feeling tales through time travel and magic doorways, Pears largely eschews both character and craft in favour of the meticulous, high-stakes plotting required to justify the book’s imposing heft and structure.

The novel begins in Anterworld, the pastoral creation of Henry Lytten, a professor (and former wartime spy) in the 1960s who has spent years outlining every inch of his seemingly fictional, fantastical construct. Seemingly, because — as Rosie, the young girl who looks after his cat, accidentally discovers — Lytten maintains a mystic doorway to Anterworld in his basement.

The doorway’s origins are revealed as the novel sidesteps into a dystopian future, where we are introduced to Angela Meerson, inventor of the time machine. She uses the apparently versatile machine both to initiate an affair with Lytten during his wartime days and to run a working simulation of Anterworld. From this complex set-up, it’s revealed that Rosie’s journey into Anterworld in the novel’s “present” causes an expansion of the fiction that threatens to engulf the real world whole — a fate Pears’ array of characters must now strive to prevent.

Read
Saturday, Feb. 20, 2016

Mole Mobile on move for your dermatological needs

Sheldon Birnie 3 minute read Preview

Mole Mobile on move for your dermatological needs

Sheldon Birnie 3 minute read Yesterday at 6:00 AM CDT

This weekend, the Mole Mobile will set up shop at three Winnipeg Walmart locations. The mobile clinic will have certified dermatologists on site to screen suspicious-looking moles or lesions for skin cancer.

Read
Yesterday at 6:00 AM CDT

Low-income residents of 114-year-old downtown block staggered by proposed rent hikes

Malak Abas 9 minute read Preview

Low-income residents of 114-year-old downtown block staggered by proposed rent hikes

Malak Abas 9 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 11:27 AM CDT

Marcel Blanchette’s life has not travelled down a smooth road.

In 2014, he was violently assaulted in his home, an unprovoked attack that left him with severe injuries, including permanent brain damage. He underwent months of hospitalization and rehabilitation. During that time, he learned his possessions had been sold off when the Office of The Public Guardian and Trustee took over his affairs.

Twelve years later, he finds himself in another fight. This time, it comes in the form of a proposal from the new owners of the Conway Court apartment block that would nearly double his monthly rent. While he’s been able to live in the Kennedy Street unit with the support of disability income assistance for nearly five years, the sudden spike, he said, could leave him homeless.

“To go through that, and now I’m going through this, it’s another obstacle,” Blanchette told the Free Press. “I fought the Public Guardian and Trustee, and I’ll fight this too, with whatever I have.”

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 11:27 AM CDT

‘Frustrated’ Selkirk nurses plead for help

Morgan Modjeski 3 minute read Preview

‘Frustrated’ Selkirk nurses plead for help

Morgan Modjeski 3 minute read Wednesday, Aug. 19, 2026

The province must take immediate action to increase low staffing levels that are putting Selkirk emergency room nurses at risk, a letter sent to the premier and health minister says.

The letter, sent by the Manitoba Nurses Union and signed by 35 ER nurses, detailed multiple recent incidents at the Selkirk Regional Health Centre. In one case, a nurse was stabbed with a pen by a patient who had been waiting 24 hours for care. In another case, a nurse was bitten by a patient.

“Nurses in that emergency department are extremely frustrated,” said Manitoba Nurses Union president Darlene Jackson. “This is not something that happened in the last month — or overnight — these are problems that have been growing.”

The five-page letter was sent Tuesday to Premier Wab Kinew, Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara and leaders of the Interlake-Eastern Regional Health Authority. It contained 10 requests to improve safety inside the emergency department, including establishing safer nurse-to-patient staffing levels, eliminating the practice of “single physician coverage” in the emergency department and implementing an institutional safety officer around the clock.

Read
Wednesday, Aug. 19, 2026

Costco breaks ground on new West St. Paul store

Gabrielle Piché 4 minute read Preview

Costco breaks ground on new West St. Paul store

Gabrielle Piché 4 minute read Tuesday, Aug. 18, 2026

Construction has begun on the American retailer's newest Manitoba location which developers expect will open in August 2027.

Read
Tuesday, Aug. 18, 2026

Kids need some sense of split parents’ situation

Maureen Scurfield 5 minute read Yesterday at 2:00 AM CDT

DEAR MISS LONELYHEARTS: On our last day at a beach rental cabin the kids and I were packing up later than the rules asked for, when a familiar car pulled in next door. It was my ex-husband with his new woman and her kids.

My children yelled out, “Look Mom, it’s Daddy! He came to the lake to see us!” and ran over to him for hugs. His girlfriend had the cabin keys dangling, nodded at me, and went inside quickly.

I said to my former husband, “Fancy meeting you here! Come on kids, we’re going home now.” My ex said, “Oh, settle down. Give me a few minutes with my kids, will you?”

So, I finished packing and locked the cabin door, and waited for the kids for 30 minutes in our car. Then I started to cry. It just came gushing out and I couldn’t control it. Finally, my ex brought the children back out. He could see I’d been crying and said in disgust, “Get over it, princess. I have!”