Umbrella-gate stirs outrage

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 19/05/2013 (4703 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

WASHINGTON — Slogging through a drizzly Rose Garden news conference Thursday with Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, U.S. President Obama took a break to ask for some rain protection.

“I am going to go ahead and ask folks, why don’t we get a couple of marines — they’re going to look good next to us — just because I’ve got a change of suits but I don’t know about our prime minister,” he said as two marines appeared at the podiums with umbrellas. “There we go. That’s good.” He gestured to the soggy press corps, adding, “You guys I’m sorry about.”

It was a lighthearted moment in the midst of a grim few days for the White House. But in a week of Benghazi emails, Justice Department subpoenas and Internal Revenue Service targeting, some of the administration’s critics saw another example of overreach.

Obama breaches marine umbrella protocol, read the headline on one conservative blog.

Per U.S. Marine Corps uniform regulations, the men are not allowed to carry or use umbrellas while in uniform. Female marines can carry “an all-black, plain standard or collapsible umbrella at their option during inclement weather,” and only with service and dress uniforms.

All of which means when marines stand sentry outside the White House, they often get wet.

“Marines are always out getting rained on. That’s sort of what we do,” said Capt. Eric Flanagan, a marines spokesman. A request from the president to a marine who serves at the White House, however, would be an “extenuating circumstance,” he said.

Flanagan also pointed to Title 10 of the U.S. Code, which states members of the marine corps shall “perform such other duties as the president may direct.”

In this case, Obama had clearly directed the marines to be ready with umbrellas if necessary.

The same umbrella rules hold true for the army; in the navy and air force, all service members can carry an umbrella when not in field uniform.

Neither Flanagan nor a U.S. Army spokesman could explain the reasoning behind the gender divide. An attempt to change the policy in the 1990s failed, with some suggesting there was something effeminate about umbrellas.

“They seem to be very nervous what constitutes unmanly behaviour,” said Cynthia Enloe, a professor at Clark University who researched military uniform codes in the book Maneuvers: The International Politics of Militarizing Women’s Lives.

Seeing a trained marine holding the president’s umbrella just rubs some observers the wrong way.

‘Mr. President, when it rains it pours, but most Americans hold their own umbrellas’

— Sarah Palin message on Facebook

“Obama expects our troops to hold damn umbrellas rather than go inside: It’s disrespectful, inconsiderate, classless,” tweeted Lou Dobbs.

“Mr. President, when it rains it pours, but most Americans hold their own umbrellas,” former Alaska governor Sarah Palin added on Facebook.

The conservative Move America Forward PAC likened the umbrella-holding to what conservatives view as Obama’s weak response to September’s attack in Benghazi, Libya. A fundraising email from the group read, “Rain: ‘Hold My Umbrella.’ Benghazi: ‘Stand Down.’ “

Perhaps Obama could have turned to a member of the Secret Service instead. Are they allowed to carry umbrellas?

“This falls under our methods and means information, which we don’t discuss,” Secret Service spokesman Edwin Donovan said.

— Washington Post-Bloomberg