Rookie QB proves to be Fearless

Tianna Hutter hopes to be a member of Manitoba’s law enforcement one day so she can help those in need.

It’s a fitting career choice for a young woman who says she’s never been afraid to take a lead role when others are in distress.

This summer, the 18-year-old Winnipegger is being asked to revitalize the Manitoba Fearless, who have been handcuffed by their offence for a couple of seasons and are adamant about returning to their winning ways.

The first-year quarterback has shown promise for a club that went 1-3 before getting bounced at home in the first round of playoffs in the Western Women’s Canadian Football League last season — the largest women’s tackle football league in Canada.

It was the second year in a row that the Fearless ended with a losing record, something they had avoided from 2018 to 2023. While they were backed by one of the best defences in the league, much of their misfortune was owed to a struggling offence that never got off the ground.

“It was unfortunately around that quarterback role, and we just weren’t able to find someone with the right fit with the program that we’re running, even though we had some really, really stellar people who were able to receive and block,” said co-head coach Andrea Backlund.

Enter Hutter, a rookie in almost every sense.

The 5-5 signal-caller has played football for the last seven years, but never quarterback — or on offence, for that matter — beyond her time in flag football. Now she joins a team in need of a spark at the most important position.

So, why do the Fearless believe the answer to their problems is an inexperienced teen?

The way Backlund describes it, you just need to watch Hutter throw, which is what she did for the first time at the Fearless’ rookie camp in February.

“I didn’t know who she was, and she was just warming up, and I saw her throw the ball, and I immediately had to just go over and get to know her and talk to her and say, ‘You know what? You’re clearly an athlete. Clearly, you know how to place the ball where you need it to go. Have you given any thought to quarterback?’” Backlund recalled.

Hutter was interested in playing a different position for the Fearless, so there was naturally a bit of resistance. Backlund put on her saleswoman hat, insisting the young recruit was cut out for the position, and Hutter was sold a short time later.

“At first, it seemed like she was a little bit taken aback by that, but I kind of wouldn’t take no for an answer, just given her natural abilities. And so we very quickly kind of slid her into that, and it fostered an excitement among the whole team,” Backlund added. “Tianna bought in with full force… and she was excited to see that she can step in there and fill that hole for us.”

Hutter will get her first chance to prove the Fearless made the right decision when they open their 2026 campaign on Sunday against the Regina Riot at St. Vital Mustangs Field (1 p.m.).

Hutter, who grew up in a football family, got her start in 2019, playing with boys on the St. James Rods. Ironically, she was one of the biggest players on the team at that time, which, aside from the ponytail coming from her helmet, allowed her to blend in seamlessly.

She aligned at defensive back and made opposing quarterbacks pay on several occasions throughout the season. She was a bright spot in an otherwise dim season for the Rods that year and took home league Rookie of the Year honours.

“Growing up, I had three older siblings — two being brothers and one an older sister — so we were always being rough with each other. I wasn’t scared to take a hit or to hit other boys in football, from always playing with my older brothers,” Hutter said. “It was successful as I kept playing, and I really liked it. I really did enjoy it a lot.”

There were challenges on the field. Hutter remembers being picked on by opposing teams, both schematically and physically. She also carried the burden of constantly feeling the need to prove she belonged, which she feels again entering this season.

“I guess one of my challenges is leading those older girls who have way more experience than me, who have been playing longer and have more knowledge of the game, and I’m the one — the rookie — coming in, one of the youngest, and leading all of them,” Hutter said. “I think that is the hardest part for me.”

Hutter has still managed to display confidence on the field since the Fearless began practising in March. She understands that gaining the trust of her teammates is key, and it’s evident that she’s done that in short order.

“It has just been electric,” said linebacker and captain Brenna Hargrave, who enters her eighth year with the Fearless.

“Especially now that we have a quarterback that can really make stuff happen, she’s got an amazing arm, and, from what I’ve observed, a very positive attitude and wanting to learn. She’s been rocking with it and making it work, and it’s really, really awesome to see.”

Of course, there was a natural period of working out the jitters and getting on the same page with her receivers when the team began practising in March, but while those got ironed out, it was easy to see Hutter’s football intelligence.

Backlund credited Hutter’s humility when it comes to taking and applying advice. She’s been a sponge when it came to learning the playbook, which can be like learning a foreign language for someone who has never seen it.

“Knowing that you have that kind of buy-in from a player, and although she’s young and new to the team, she has a presence to command the offence,” Backlund said. “When she’s in the huddle, she has the team rallying behind her to listen and support her in what she wants. She just has that presence about her and given her effort at every practice, and her willingness to learn and understand, everyone’s supporting her in that, and they want her to help lead this offence.”

Hutter won’t be the only rookie taking the field. The Fearless have already been tested with some key injuries, especially on defence, which has forced a few young players into more prominent roles. That’s admittedly left more uncertainty in some areas, but it’s also bred intrigue around the potential of the club.

“The anticipation is really high. We have a lot of rookies on our team this year, not just our quarterback, so it’s really going to be a, ‘Let’s see what we can do’ on Sunday, as well,” said Hargrave, who has changed the way she’s led the defence with the many fresh faces.

Hargrave was already familiar with many younger players from her time coaching Manitoba’s high-performance U18 team.

“I kind of have, I guess, a little bit of a protection over them, and I want them to feel welcome, and I want them to feel accepted, and I also want to make sure that they’re understanding what the coaches are saying to them,” she said.

“There is a lot of new terminology, there are a lot of things that are happening. It can be really intimidating to be playing six-man or nine-man, and now you’re playing 12-man with women who are in their 20s and 30s. The way that I lead has absolutely changed.”

winnipegfreepress.com/joshuafreysam