Keep calm and plant some trees


Advertise with us

A friend from Ottawa visited recently, and as soon as she arrived, she pulled a copy of her local newspaper out of her purse and handed it to me. “It’s a gift,” she said.

Read this article for free:


Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Monthly Digital Subscription

$4.75 per week*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Billed as $19.00 plus GST every four weeks. Cancel anytime.


Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 24/08/2022 (290 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

A friend from Ottawa visited recently, and as soon as she arrived, she pulled a copy of her local newspaper out of her purse and handed it to me. “It’s a gift,” she said.

OK, I thought. A little unusual, but I’ll go with it.

“There’s an article about trees in it,” she added, then proceeded to launch into another topic.

So I set the newspaper aside and forgot about it until this morning, when I picked it up and read the front-page headline: “Tree Myths, Misconceptions and Why Planting Trees Is Good.” And as I read the associated article, I realized that it really was a gift — the kind that will keep on giving if I can convince a majority of you to plant some trees next to your homes or businesses.

Now, I know that a lot of you are heartbroken when your boulevard tree comes down, but I’ll bet many of you don’t have a single tree growing in your front or backyard lawns.

So, why is that? Why are so many people loathe to plant a tree next to their homes, despite the fact a hefty full-grown tree — say, a Siberian elm or a lovely Amur cherry — will cool a house by three to five degrees in the summer, break the impact of fierce cold winds in the winter and just generally cheer up the chemical-gobbling expanse of grass that sits outside your door.

“They’re messy,” a neighbour proclaimed to me. “All those seeds and leaves. It drives me crazy cleaning it up.” “They’re dangerous,” intones another, who is obsessed with cutting down every tree within five metres of his house, for fear one of them might fall on his kid or damage his roof.

So are trees really all that messy, or worse, dangerous? Well, look at this way — if you walk, bike, go to the gym or obsessively mow your fertilizer-guzzling lawn, what’s so tough about sweeping up some seeds or raking up a few leaves? You get your steps in, and you even get to do some bending and stretching. Not to mention breathing in the luscious scent of fallen leaves.

More importantly, if it’s properly planted, cared for and pruned, its roots won’t rise up to break your lawnmower, nor will it fall down and smash things. If our city trees had been pruned prior to the October 2019 snowstorm, we wouldn’t have had to spend $10 million to clean up the mess.

Same goes for tree roots breaking into house foundations and sewer pipes and wrecking sidewalks. All three claims are urban legends. Tree roots may enter a crack in your foundation, but the crack has to be there first. Ditto your sewer pipe. Tree roots can’t break through concrete, stone or cast iron; nor do they buckle sidewalks.

In fact, studies have shown heaving walkways are generally the result of the wrong paving surface laid on the wrong soil.

So, why do trees get such a bad rap? Beats me, because all I can see are their benefits.

Which is why it pains me to see so much grass, and worse, asphalt, taking up so much space in a city that’s facing increasingly hot summers.

Truth is, we have enough private land in Winnipeg to plant hundreds of thousands of heat-defying, carbon-sequestering trees. And given the number we’re currently losing to Dutch elm and other diseases, we better get cracking and plant them before the full impact of climate change sets in.

Now, don’t get me wrong. I’m not placing the burden for private-property tree planting solely on the backs of homeowners. Far from it. There’s ample land around hundreds of businesses; just look at the Royal Canadian Mint on Fermor – acres of lawn in front of the building, with barely a tree in sight. Or take a gander at new subdivisions and infill projects that don’t just fail to incorporate sufficient trees, but all too often mow them down.

And what about those oftentimes-empty parking lots? Could developers not sacrifice half a dozen stalls for some trees, the shade of which actually improves the longevity of asphalt? Or better still, could the city not buy up some of those stalls to create micro-parks?

The work of expanding and protecting Winnipeg’s tree canopy should be a top priority for everyone, from corporations, small businesses and homeowners to arts groups, developers and the construction industry.

The only question is, will we do it? Or will we continue to buy into the myth that trees are destructive, instead of embracing the reality: that planting trees — our oxygen-producing, pollution-eating urban companions – could be the safest, easiest route to a more beautiful, healthy, climate-resilient city.

Erna Buffie is an author, filmmaker and interim chair of the Trees Please Winnipeg Coalition.

Report Error Submit a Tip


Advertise With Us