May 21, 2022

Winnipeg
7° C, Overcast

Full Forecast

Contact Us Subscribe Manage Subscription Chat with us
Log in Create Free Account Help Chat with us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertising Contact
    • Submit a News Tip
    • Subscribe to Newsletters

    • Finding your
      information

    • My Account
    • Manage my Subscription
    • Change Password

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate

    • Log Out
    • Log in
    • Create Free Account
    • Help

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate
  • Coronavirus Coverage
  • Replica E-Edition
    • About the E-Edition
    • Winnipeg Free Press
    • Community Review East
    • Community Review West
  • Above the Fold
  • Front page
  • Arts & Life
    • All Arts & Life
    • The Arts
    • Autos
    • Books
    • Book Club
    • Cannabis
    • Celebrities
    • Diversions
    • Puzzles
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Faith
    • Food & Drink
    • Your Health
    • Life & Style
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Science & Technology
    • TV
    • Travel
  • Business
    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Personal Finance
    • Manitoba's Top Employers
  • Canada
  • Local
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send a Letter to the Editor
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Amateur
    • Auto Racing
    • Blue Bombers
    • Curling
    • Football
    • Goldeyes
    • Golf
    • High School
    • Hockey
    • Horse Racing
    • Winnipeg Jets
    • Manitoba Moose
    • WHL
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • Olympics
    • Soccer
  • World
  • The Star
  • Reader BridgeNEW
  • WFP EventsNEW
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Advertising
    • Contact Us
    • Carrier Positions & Retailer Requests
    • FP Newspapers Inc.
    • History
    • Internships
    • Job Opportunities
    • News Café
    • Privacy Policy
    • Retail Locations
    • Staff Biographies
    • Terms and Conditions
  • Archives
  • Free Press Community Review
    • All Free Press Community Review News
    • East Edition
    • West Edition
    • Sports
    • Events
    • Contact Us
    • E-Editions
  • Classifieds
  • Contests
  • Coupons
    • All Coupons
    • Staples Copy & Print Coupons
    • Ripley's Aquariums Coupons
    • The Bay Coupons
    • Staples Canada Coupons
    • Altitude Sports Coupons
    • Nike Coupons
    • Tuango Coupons
    • Ebay Canada Coupons
    • Sport Chek Coupons
    • Roots Coupons
  • LifestylesNEW
    • All Lifestyles
    • Business Hub
    • Community
    • Drink & Dine
    • Life
    • Wellness
    • Whiskers & Wings
    • Sponsored Articles
  • Homes
    • Property Listings
    • Featured News
    • Renovation and design
    • New homes
    • Resale homes
  • Newsletters
  • Obituaries
  • Puzzles
  • Photo and Book store
  • More

©2022 FP Newspaper Inc.

Close
  • Quick Links

    • Coronavirus Coverage
    • Federal Election
    • Above the Fold
    • Home
    • Local
    • Canada
    • World
    • Classifieds
    • Special Coverage
    • Newsletters
    • Obituaries
    • Photo and Book store
    • Archives
    • Contests
    • Publications
    • Sponsored Content
    • Privacy Policy

    Ways to support us

    • Pay it Forward program
    • Subscribe
    • Day Pass
    • Support Faith coverage
    • Support Arts coverage
  • Replica E-Edition

    • About the E-Edition
    • Winnipeg Free Press
    • Community Review East
    • Community Review West

    Business

    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Personal Finance
  • Arts & Life

    • All Arts & Life
    • The Arts
    • Autos
    • Books
    • Cannabis
    • Celebrities
    • Diversions
    • Puzzles
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Faith
    • Food & Drink
    • Your Health
    • Life & Style
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Science & Technology
    • TV
    • Travel
  • Sports

    • All Sports
    • Amateur
    • Auto Racing
    • Blue Bombers
    • Curling
    • Football
    • Goldeyes
    • Golf
    • High School
    • Hockey
    • Horse Racing
    • Winnipeg Jets
    • Manitoba Moose
    • WHL
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • Olympics
    • Soccer
  • Opinion

    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send a Letter to the Editor

    Media

    • All Media
    • Photo Galleries
    • Videos

    Homes

    • Property Listings
    • Featured News
    • Renovation and design
    • New homes
    • Resale homes
  • Canstar Community News

    • All Free Press Community Review News
    • East Edition
    • West Edition
    • Sports
    • Events
    • Contact Us
    • E-Editions
  • Coupons

    • All Coupons
    • Staples Copy & Print Coupons
    • Ripley's Aquariums Coupons
    • The Bay Coupons
    • Staples Canada Coupons
    • Altitude Sports Coupons
    • Nike Coupons
    • Tuango Coupons
    • Ebay Canada Coupons
    • Sport Chek Coupons
    • Roots Coupons
  • About Us

    • About Us
    • Advertising
    • Contact Us
    • Carrier Positions & Retailer Requests
    • FP Newspapers Inc.
    • History
    • Internships
    • Job Opportunities
    • News Café
    • Privacy Policy
    • Retail Locations
    • Staff Biographies
    • Terms and Conditions
The Free Press
Articles Read
Your Balance +tax
Day Pass Till
Day Pass
    • Contact Us
    • Advertising Contact
    • Report an Error
    • Send a Letter to the Editor
    • Staff Biographies
    • Submit a News Tip
    • Subscribe to Newsletters

    • Finding your
      information

    • Log in
    • Create Account
    • Help
    • Chat with us

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate
    • My Account
    • Manage My Subscription
    • Change Password
    • Chat with us

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate

    • Log Out
Log in Create Account Contact Us
Contact Us Manage Subscription
  • Sections
  • Local
  • Arts & Life
    • All Arts & Life
    • The Arts
    • Autos
    • Books
    • Diversions
    • Environment
    • Faith
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV
    • Travel
  • Business
    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Personal Finance
    • Manitoba's Top Employers
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Amateur
    • Blue Bombers
    • Curling
    • Football
    • Goldeyes
    • High School
    • Hockey
    • Winnipeg Jets
    • Manitoba Moose
    • WHL
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • Soccer
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send a Letter to the Editor
  • E-Edition
  • Homes
  • Classifieds
    • All Classifieds
    • Announcements
    • Automotive
    • Careers
    • Garage Sales
    • Merchandise
    • Pets
    • Real Estate
    • Rentals
    • Services
  • Lifestyles
    • Business Hub
    • Community
    • Drink & Dine
    • Life
    • Manitoba’s Top Employers
    • Wellness
    • Whiskers & Wings
    • Sponsored Articles
  • Coupons
    • All Coupons
    • Staples Copy & Print
    • Ripley's Aquariums
    • The Bay
    • Staples Canada
    • Altitude Sports
    • Nike
    • Tuango
    • Ebay Canada
    • Sport Chek
    • Roots
  • Obituaries
  • Subscribe$1.50 for 5 months
Home Opinion Analysis

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Mixed-model home care's iffy politics

By: Mary Jean Hande and Christine Kelly
Posted: 4:00 AM CDT Saturday, Oct. 21, 2017
Last Modified: 5:45 PM CDT Sunday, Oct. 22, 2017 | Updates

  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Print
  • Email
  • Save to Read Later

Manitoba is undergoing a major, rapid transformation of health and social services, including the closure of ERs, privatization of occupational and physiotherapy and the recent proposal to introduce “mixed-model home care.” Many commentators have characterized these changes as part of a privatization and austerity agenda that is shifting health-care values in Manitoba.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 21/10/2017 (1673 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Opinion

Manitoba is undergoing a major, rapid transformation of health and social services, including the closure of ERs, privatization of occupational and physiotherapy and the recent proposal to introduce "mixed-model home care." Many commentators have characterized these changes as part of a privatization and austerity agenda that is shifting health-care values in Manitoba.

On Sept. 20, Health Minister Kelvin Goertzen announced Priority Home service, which is set to launch in November. This service aims to provide short-term, intensive home care for up to 90 days in order to divert individuals from entering personal care homes or hospitals. This allows patients to be panelled for services at home, rather than undergoing this process in the hospital.

Currently, many aging people and their families do not initiate the home-care application process until they are in crisis, which doesn’t account for administrative time, home assessments or any waiting lists for services. Providing intensive "bridging" at times of crisis, with the aim of avoiding more costly and institutionalized care solutions, does indeed respond to urgent gaps in the health-care system.

However, the WRHA news release glosses over the "mixed-model" aspect of Priority Home. Two-thirds of the $15.7-million budget will go toward private companies providing these intensive services. While receiving intensive home care is often preferable, there are legitimate concerns about private companies providing these services.

Evidence shows that privatized health care geared toward finding greater "efficiencies" and cost savings means that social-health approaches are further removed from care delivery, and patients/clients often have little choice or autonomy when it comes to their care. Rather than striving for well-rounded care delivery, this mixed-model "fix" erodes hard-earned public infrastructure and may also exacerbate social inequalities that make care less accessible in the long run.

WRHA proposes Priority Home as "an intensive intermediary" until public infrastructure can reabsorb these services. This raises questions about the job security of care workers and how this might affect clients/patients. This privatized "fix" to a crisis of Canadian health care is a familiar refrain. Simon Enoch and Christine Saulnier of the Canadian Centre for Policy of Alternatives refer to a recent report from Privatization Nation, saying, "We thought this to be conclusive evidence that despite 30 years of experience, governments rarely seem to get privatization right, and more often get it wrong with astonishing regularity."

The Free Press | Newsletter

Winnipeg Gardener

What you need to know now about gardening in Winnipeg. A monthly email from the Free Press with advice, ideas and tips to keep your outdoor and indoor plants growing.

Sign up for Winnipeg Gardener
Sign Up

Experts on public-private health-care models, such as Heather Whiteside at the University of Waterloo, argue that these temporary "fixes" rarely (if ever) live up to their promises, and mostly represent politically motivated incentives not to seek out public solutions. Given this track record, it’s hard to imagine how the public sector will simply re-absorb the "private transitional care beds" after two years, as promised.

In many ways, policies and practices of care are a litmus test for how socially progressive a given society is. Disability activist Mia Mingus describes care as an essential part of valuing marginalized people — particularly older people and disabled people so often isolated in inadequate health-care systems. Mingus urges us to nurture alliances among workers and those who use services to reveal the urgent politics of care.

Donna Baines of the University of Sydney says care is part of an ethos of social justice that addresses poverty, class relations, sexism, heterosexism, ageism and ableism. What does Priority Home say about the politics of care in Manitoba? It tells us that disabled and older people are considered a "burden" on the health-care system, and that the "best" care is provided by the lowest bidder, regardless of how it might undermine public health-care infrastructure or care worker security.

Manitoba Health proudly reminds us that we have the "oldest comprehensive, provincewide universal (home care) service in Canada" — and we can continue to develop home-care policies that hold Manitoba up as a leader nationally and internationally. Amid stories about "budget cuts," "rising health-care costs" and the necessity to "overhaul" an outdated system, there is opportunity to approach care as a complex system, one that is interrelated with other social services and driven by a broader ethos of social wellbeing and even justice.

Rather than adhering to narrowly defined metrics of "quality of care," let’s use this juncture to develop publicly funded home care that is guided by the best research on the social, political and geographic dimensions of care and the experiences of the people on the front lines of care — workers, clients, families and patients.

Mary Jean Hande is a postdoctoral fellow in community health sciences at the University of Manitoba whose work examines the politics of care under austerity in Canada. Christine Kelly is an assistant professor in community health sciences at the University of Manitoba who is leading a national study on directly funded, or self-managed, home care.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

History

Updated on Sunday, October 22, 2017 at 5:45 PM CDT: updates byline

  • Report Error
  • Submit a Tip
  • Refund
  • The Free Press is certified by

The Winnipeg Free Press invites you to share your opinion on this story in a letter to the editor. A selection of letters to the editor are published daily.

To submit a letter:
• fill out the form on this page, or
• email letters@freepress.mb.ca, or
• mail Letters to the Editor, 1355 Mountain Avenue, Winnipeg, Manitoba, R2X 3B6.

Letters must include the writer’s full name, address, and a daytime phone number. Letters are edited for length and clarity.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Top