January 17, 2021

Winnipeg
-15° C, Light snow

Full Forecast

Contact Us Subscribe Manage Subscription Chat with us
Log in Create Free Account Help Chat with us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertising Contact
    • Submit a News Tip
    • Subscribe to Newsletters

    • Finding your
      information

    • My Account
    • Manage my Subscription
    • Change Password

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate

    • Log Out
    • Log in
    • Create Free Account
    • Help

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate
  • Coronavirus Coverage
  • Replica E-Edition
    • About the E-Edition
    • Winnipeg Free Press
    • The Herald
    • The Headliner
    • The Lance
    • The Metro
    • The Sou'Wester
    • The Times
  • Above the Fold
  • Front page
  • Arts & Life
    • All Arts & Life
    • The Arts
    • Autos
    • Books
    • Book Club
    • Cannabis
    • Celebrities
    • Diversions
    • Puzzles
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Faith
    • Food & Drink
    • Your Health
    • Life & Style
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Science & Technology
    • TV
    • Travel
  • Business
    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Personal Finance
  • Canada
  • Local
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send a Letter to the Editor
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Amateur
    • Auto Racing
    • Blue Bombers
    • Curling
    • Football
    • Goldeyes
    • Golf
    • High School
    • Hockey
    • Horse Racing
    • Winnipeg Jets
    • Manitoba Moose
    • WHL
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • Olympics
    • Soccer
  • World
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Advertising
    • Contact Us
    • Carrier Positions & Retailer Requests
    • FP Newspapers Inc.
    • History
    • Internships
    • Job Opportunities
    • News Café
    • Privacy Policy
    • Retail Locations
    • Staff Biographies
    • Terms and Conditions
  • Archives
  • Canstar Community News
    • All Canstar Community News
    • The Headliner
    • The Herald
    • The Lance
    • The Metro
    • The Sou'wester
    • The Times
    • Sports
    • Events
    • Contact Us
    • E-Editions
  • Classifieds
  • Contests
  • Coupons
    • All Coupons
    • Staples Copy & Print Coupons
    • Ripley's Aquariums Coupons
    • The Bay Coupons
    • Staples Canada Coupons
    • Altitude Sports Coupons
    • Nike Coupons
    • Tuango Coupons
    • Ebay Canada Coupons
    • Sport Chek Coupons
    • Roots Coupons
  • Sponsored
    • Publications
    • Sponsored Articles
  • Flyers
  • Homes
    • Property Listings
    • Featured News
    • Renovation and design
    • New homes
    • Resale homes
  • Newsletters
  • Obituaries
  • Puzzles
  • Photostore
  • More

©2021 FP Newspaper Inc.

Close
  • Quick Links

    • Coronavirus Coverage
    • Above the Fold
    • Home
    • Local
    • Canada
    • World
    • Classifieds
    • Special Coverage
    • Flyers
    • Newsletters
    • Obituaries
    • Photostore
    • Archives
    • Contests
    • Publications
    • Sponsored Content
    • Privacy Policy

    Ways to support us

    • Pay it Forward program
    • Subscribe
    • Day Pass
    • Read Now Pay later
  • Replica E-Edition

    • About the E-Edition
    • Winnipeg Free Press
    • The Herald
    • The Headliner
    • The Lance
    • The Metro
    • The Sou'Wester
    • The Times

    Business

    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Personal Finance
  • Arts & Life

    • All Arts & Life
    • The Arts
    • Autos
    • Books
    • Cannabis
    • Celebrities
    • Diversions
    • Puzzles
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Faith
    • Food & Drink
    • Your Health
    • Life & Style
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Science & Technology
    • TV
    • Travel
  • Sports

    • All Sports
    • Amateur
    • Auto Racing
    • Blue Bombers
    • Curling
    • Football
    • Goldeyes
    • Golf
    • High School
    • Hockey
    • Horse Racing
    • Winnipeg Jets
    • Manitoba Moose
    • WHL
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • Olympics
    • Soccer
  • Opinion

    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send a Letter to the Editor

    Media

    • All Media
    • Photo Galleries
    • Videos

    Homes

    • Property Listings
    • Featured News
    • Renovation and design
    • New homes
    • Resale homes
  • Canstar Community News

    • All Canstar Community News
    • The Headliner
    • The Herald
    • The Lance
    • The Metro
    • The Sou'wester
    • The Times
    • Sports
    • Events
    • Contact Us
    • E-Editions
  • Coupons

    • All Coupons
    • Staples Copy & Print Coupons
    • Ripley's Aquariums Coupons
    • The Bay Coupons
    • Staples Canada Coupons
    • Altitude Sports Coupons
    • Nike Coupons
    • Tuango Coupons
    • Ebay Canada Coupons
    • Sport Chek Coupons
    • Roots Coupons
  • About Us

    • About Us
    • Advertising
    • Contact Us
    • Carrier Positions & Retailer Requests
    • FP Newspapers Inc.
    • History
    • Internships
    • Job Opportunities
    • News Café
    • Privacy Policy
    • Retail Locations
    • Staff Biographies
    • Terms and Conditions
Winnipeg Free Press
Articles Read
Your Balance +tax
Day Pass Till
Day Pass
    • Contact Us
    • Advertising Contact
    • Report an Error
    • Send a Letter to the Editor
    • Staff Biographies
    • Submit a News Tip
    • Subscribe to Newsletters

    • Finding your
      information

    • Log in
    • Create Account
    • Help
    • Chat with us

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate
    • My Account
    • Manage My Subscription
    • Change Password
    • Chat with us

    • Grid View
    • List View
    • Compact View
    • Text Size
    • Translate

    • Log Out
Log in Create Account Contact Us
Contact Us Manage Subscription
  • Sections
  • Local
  • Arts & Life
    • All Arts & Life
    • The Arts
    • Autos
    • Books
    • Diversions
    • Environment
    • Faith
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV
    • Travel
  • Business
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Amateur
    • Blue Bombers
    • Curling
    • Football
    • Goldeyes
    • High School
    • Hockey
    • Winnipeg Jets
    • Manitoba Moose
    • WHL
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • Soccer
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send a Letter to the Editor
  • E-Edition
  • Homes
  • Classifieds
    • All Classifieds
    • Announcements
    • Automotive
    • Careers
    • Garage Sales
    • Merchandise
    • Pets
    • Real Estate
    • Rentals
    • Services
  • Sponsored
    • Publications
    • Sponsored Articles
  • Coupons
    • All Coupons
    • Staples Copy & Print
    • Ripley's Aquariums
    • The Bay
    • Staples Canada
    • Altitude Sports
    • Nike
    • Tuango
    • Ebay Canada
    • Sport Chek
    • Roots
  • Obituaries
  • Subscribe
Opinion Analysis

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Peru's child-welfare warning

By: Jessaca Leinaweaver
Posted: 12/10/2018 3:00 AM

  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Print
  • Email
Rodrigo Abd / The Associated Press Files</p><p>Peruvian children play in the Amazon community of Iquitos, which is nicknamed Venice of the Jungle because canoes are the most popular form of transport.</p>

Rodrigo Abd / The Associated Press Files

Peruvian children play in the Amazon community of Iquitos, which is nicknamed Venice of the Jungle because canoes are the most popular form of transport.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 10/12/2018 (769 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Opinion

As reported in the Free Press, Manitoba’s Child and Family Services Act is being amended to state explicitly that poverty cannot be the sole reason for taking a child into protective custody.

This is an important move to decriminalize poverty, and NDP MLA Bernadette Smith is to be congratulated for introducing the amendment.

However, based on my research on Indigenous-child-welfare provision in Peru, I worry that it still doesn’t go far enough.

While living in Winnipeg a decade ago, I wrote a book on child fostering and adoption in Peru — a predominantly Indigenous nation.

Under Peruvian law, "under no circumstances should the lack of material resources lead to a finding that a child is abandoned." But what I found was that poverty was often just one step removed from the reasons cited.

As I carried out ethnographic research, spending time in a Peruvian adoption office and getting to know individual children’s cases, I was surprised at how often food was mentioned in case files.

One baby was placed in a children’s home because health-care workers became concerned for his health after taking turns providing food to his mother. He was described as "mildly malnourished," but otherwise healthy.

Another pair of siblings, who lived with their grandmother and accompanied her to sell fruit in the market, were placed in a local children’s home after authorities were concerned that, on a fruit seller’s income, their grandmother would have a hard time meeting the children’s support needs. They were described as slightly underweight. Their file notes that their grandmother continued to visit them after they were sent to the children’s home, bringing them gifts of fruit.

At the time of my research, more than a quarter of Peruvian children were malnourished (that rate has been halved in recent years thanks to smart policy). Most of them weren’t subject to removal from their families — but some child removals were justified by pointing to malnutrition.

Rather than tackling the conditions under which so many Peruvian children came to be malnourished, a law that refuses poverty as a reason for the intervention of child-protective services paradoxically ends up encouraging authorities to say that poor parenting is the cause of malnutrition.

In other words, even if children cannot legally be removed from their birth families simply on the basis of poverty, the many forms that poverty takes are nonetheless routinely used to claim that a child is ‘‘morally and materially abandoned’’ by a parent.

The result was a sense that poor parents alone bear responsibility if their children are not receiving adequate care.

A legislative review committee report released in September noted, "Among Canadian provinces, Manitoba has the highest rate of children in care" — nearly 90 per cent of whom are Indigenous. This overrepresentation is not new — the Pe-kiwewin Project, led by Prof. Raven Sinclair at the University of Regina, examines policies from 1945-85 that lead to a "system of Indigenous child removal."

In Manitoba, similarly to Peru, the Child and Family Services Act offers examples of when a child might be found in need of protection. For example, a child might be "in the care, custody, control or charge of a person… who is unable or unwilling to provide adequate care…." An "inability" to provide care may stem directly from poverty.

Stay informed

The latest updates on the novel coronavirus and COVID-19.

Subscribe to COVID-19 Briefing
Sign Up

Another example, which I also saw in Peru, was that a child’s caregiver "neglects or refuses to provide or obtain proper medical… treatment." Those in poverty may be far more likely to need medical treatment — but also, they might have a more difficult time accessing it because of long distances to health services in rural communities, or a job that doesn’t easily allow time off for medical treatments.

To be sure, Child and Family Services are still needed. In the words of one community advocate and former child in care quoted in the legislative review committee report, "I’m not anti-CFS; it is needed. However, I don’t believe that all apprehensions need to happen."

The new amendment offers room for considered reflection on some of the reasons for taking children into custody, stating, "A child must not be found to be in need of protection only by reason of their parent or guardian… lacking the same or similar economic and social advantages as others in Manitoba society."

But a lot of the rest of the reasons for taking a child into custody, offered in the Child and Family Services Act, look like poverty by another name.

With Peru’s child-protection law as a cautionary tale, Manitoba legislators should treat this amendment as a first step of many in a long path toward making child protection law more culturally sensitive.

Jessaca Leinaweaver directs the Center for Latin American and Caribbean Studies at Brown University’s Watson Institute in Providence, R.I.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

  • Report Error
  • Submit a Tip
  • Refund

The Winnipeg Free Press invites you to share your opinion on this story in a letter to the editor. A selection of letters to the editor are published daily.

To submit a letter:
• fill out the form on this page, or
• email letters@freepress.mb.ca, or
• mail Letters to the Editor, 1355 Mountain Avenue, Winnipeg, Manitoba, R2X 3B6.

Letters must include the writer’s full name, address, and a daytime phone number. Letters are edited for length and clarity.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Top