Garbage pickup at encampments gets mixed reviews ‘Bumps along the way’ seen after first month of pilot program By: Joyanne Pursaga Posted: 6:07 PM CDT Wednesday, Jul. 10, 2024

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 10/07/2024 (796 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

One month into weekly garbage pickups at three Winnipeg homeless encampments, a few thousand gallons of trash have been removed, though some neighbours aren’t sure the sites are much cleaner.

About 3,880 gallons (14,687 litres) of garbage was collected from encampments at Assiniboine Avenue, Waterfront Drive and Maple Street since the pickups began around June 10, Sherwood Armbruster, the City of Winnipeg’s interim chief administrative officer, said.

“We’ve still got a ways to go through the summer but the early signs are very encouraging, as far as the collaboration … There’s been some early positive signs and lessons learned,” said Armbruster.

The pilot project to clean up the areas relies on non-profit organization Main Street Project to reach out to encampment residents. Every week, the Downtown Community Safety Partnership distributes garbage bags and returns to pick up the bags the next day, after those living at the sites fill them.

Siloam Mission conducts larger cleanups, such as when an entire encampment is abandoned, while the city helps co-ordinate the effort and provides $170,000 to cover the costs, said Armbruster.

“There’s many organizations involved and there’s often different views and there are bumps along the way but … everybody wants to see something better,” he said.

Mayor Scott Gillingham said it’s too soon to say if the cleanups have made the three encampments cleaner or if the pilot should lead to permanent garbage collection at such sites.

“I don’t have the answer to that question at this point. Residents who live near encampments have expressed concern about the need for cleanup … (And) we want to make sure individuals who are living in encampments get dignified treatment and the service that they need to meet their needs,” he said.

The mayor stressed the overall response to homelessness must focus on supplying more housing with social supports.

”The garbage is a big problem but the biggest problem is that there’s people living on the river”–Laurie Nealin

An Exchange District resident who lives near the Waterfront Drive encampment said she’s not sure if the cleanups have made a difference. Laurie Nealin said two of her neighbours spent three hours cleaning trash from one abandoned encampment last weekend, removing many garbage bags worth of trash and six shopping carts.

“My question (is): Why are my neighbours spending three hours doing this back-breaking work, when supposedly there is this program?” said Nealin.

She said some areas, such as Fort Douglas Park near the Alexander Docks, tend to accumulate so much trash, volunteer garbage collectors within the neighbourhood have given up on cleaning them.

“Even if they did something, the next day or three days later, it’s going to look like they weren’t even there,” said Nealin.

Fort Douglas Park contained several tents on Wednesday, along with some broken tree limbs and torn up cardboard boxes.

Nealin stressed encampments aren’t safe or healthy for those who live in them, lacking basic amenities like bathrooms, so the focus must always be on trying to find vulnerable people permanent housing.

“The garbage is a big problem but the biggest problem is that there’s people living on the river … You can’t make a step forward … when you’re trying to survive living on the riverbank,” said Nealin.

An agency tasked with picking up the trash for the pilot project said staff do attempt to connect people with housing.

“This (program) is addressing cleanliness and the immediate care of the encampment … But if they are looking for long-term services and supports, then (Downtown Community Safety Partnership’s) Clean Slate team can refer (encampment residents) to our other teams … to help out with housing, addiction services, whatever needs (are there),” said Matt Halchakar, director of operations for the safety partnership.

Halchakar said the outreach effort includes asking homeless people questions about housing, not just responding when they raise the topic.

“We’re definitely going out and offering our services, not just waiting until it’s asked for,” he said.

Halchakar said encampment residents have responded well to the garbage pickups and more frequent pickups could be considered in the future, if trash still accumulates.

Kendall Giilck, a building futures employment program manager for Siloam Mission, said encampment residents asked for regular trash pickups before the program started.

“They were expressing that they would like to be able to clean up those sites that they were living in, so that they could live in clean and dignified spaces,” said Giilck.

She said Siloam has seen a visual improvement at the three sites and positive feedback since the pilot program started.

“So far, the reports that we’ve seen have been really positive, from the encampment residents themselves and anyone whose spoken (to us) about the sites that we’ve been servicing,” said Giilck.

Main Street Project declined comment.

joyanne.pursaga@freepress.mb.ca

X: @joyanne_pursaga