CMHR exhibition leads to more questions than answers

Advertisement

Advertise with us

I am thinking about the word “opinion,” the ones I interrogate and revise, as well as ones I have abandoned over time.

Read this article for free:


or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Subscribe and receive a limited-edition Free Press branded hat or tote.

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $205*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*First annual payment billed as $205.00 + GST for one year. This annual subscription will automatically renew at $233.00 + GST every 52 weeks (10% off the regular annual price of $259.35). Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Opinion

I am thinking about the word “opinion,” the ones I interrogate and revise, as well as ones I have abandoned over time.

Such a reflective process provides a continuing opportunity in my third act. It depends on the kind of curiosity, courage and commitment I bring to opportunities for rethinking and reassessing.

Within this context, I reflect on the variety of opinion pieces I have read, most recently those that reference the exhibition at the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, Palestine Uprooted: Nakba Past and Present.

I attended the exhibition the morning after it opened. I could not come to any conclusion before I saw it. I wanted to be informed. I wanted to be as transparent as I could be, as aware of my history and experience, in relation to the complex ongoing history integral to the Palestinian experience.

I entered the exhibition with my story, just as others will carry their own. Mine includes the trauma that comes as a Jew and member of an oppressed minority that has repeatedly faced the possibility of annihilation. I cannot enter Palestine Uprooted without that history, but I can also enter with a desire to know how stories by others who have been displaced and oppressed are being represented.

This is the sensibility that museum CEO Isha Khan references: “We want people to come and see it and we hope that what they take from this exhibit is that it engenders empathy, understanding, reflection and dialogue.”

While I knew the dimensions of the exhibition beforehand, even then I did not expect that it would be so small. How could it not be more expansive, I wondered. Given the space constraints, how could it effectively contextualize Palestinian stories told about disruption, displacement and loss?

I read the framing informational panels and wondered anew: Where is the critical information that is necessary to grasp the turmoil defining the foundational events of 1947 and 1948? Where are the key details about the partition offers that were accepted and rejected? When offers were designed and brokered, who decided who belonged in this region and who did not? What political and historical forces defined these formulations? How do they persist?

I knew the museum began developing this exhibition in 2021. I wondered further: How is it possible that it did not respond to reasonable questions posed about transparency and contexts but merely restated the right to curatorial independence?

Given the events that occurred during the course of the exhibition’s development, how could the museum not reveal the catastrophic ignorance of so many who controlled the region before 1948 and bargained in bad faith? How could the museum’s informational panels omit vital historical and geopolitical contexts that would thus deepen my grasp of the Palestinian experience “then and now”? How could it squander this opportunity? To what extent did it enfeeble its mandate by doing so?

A story of displacement demands a multidimensional approach. Compassion and understanding are actualized by contexts that comprehend the difficult and the disputed. Imagine — given the misinformation, intolerance and race-hatred flourishing in this country, the charged political and psychological atmosphere that attended the exhibition’s planning process — if the museum had established detailed frames of reference and analysis for the Palestinian experience in a region tormented by war, grief, violation and grievance.

Surely the curator of this exhibition, and the advisory committee whose names were withheld by the museum, pursued those frames and that analysis with a profound investment in a truth-seeking that comprehends bias, grief and grievance, that comprehends the torment of competing, contested claims, broken promises, broken-heartedness and seemingly irreconcilable differences.

Could this not have brought us closer to the very reflection and understanding Khan hopes for? How could the museum’s framing be so underdeveloped? How could its planning and execution not include explicit programming that would facilitate the difficult conversations that support listening, learning and reciprocal relation? Why has the exhibition given such scant attention to these vital possibilities?

I took a copy of the poem by Mahmoud Darwish, Think of Others, available to visitors when I left the exhibition. It is a poem that suggests interdependence as crucial. The poem’s penultimate line reminds us: “As you think of others, the distant ones, think of yourself. /(‘say: ‘If only I were a candle in the darkness’.)”

I descended in the elevator wondering: How could the museum compromise its presentation of the Palestinian experience by so under-representing the profound and complex contexts informing that experience? How could it not think of the contexts that we need so that our understanding can be further illuminated?

arts@freepress.mb.ca

Deborah Schnitzer

Winnipeg writer Deborah Schnitzer explores life lessons from women in their Third Act.

Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.

Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

‘Disrespectful’: residents frustrated after Wyatt arrives hour late to committee meeting

Joyanne Pursaga 3 minute read Preview

‘Disrespectful’: residents frustrated after Wyatt arrives hour late to committee meeting

Joyanne Pursaga 3 minute read Updated: Yesterday at 1:00 PM CDT

Several Winnipeggers attending a city development hearing on Thursday expressed frustration that one councillor arrived about an hour late, delaying the matter from being heard.

Coun. Russ Wyatt, who continues to attend city hall while facing criminal charges, began participating in the 9:30 a.m. East Kildonan-Transcona community committee meeting at 10:35 a.m.

A resident who hoped to speak at the meeting about a development plan in south Transcona noted the tardiness led the committee to bump the topic down on its agenda, while dozens waited to speak on it.

Christina Pyra eventually opted to leave city hall instead of waiting for her turn to make a presentation, to avoid missing a work commitment.

Read
Updated: Yesterday at 1:00 PM CDT

Trailblazing Western Scrap Metals heavy-equipment operator relishes role at massive crane’s control

David Sanderson 7 minute read Preview

Trailblazing Western Scrap Metals heavy-equipment operator relishes role at massive crane’s control

David Sanderson 7 minute read Yesterday at 10:15 AM CDT

Less than five per cent of heavy-equipment operators in the country are women but that number is trending upward, according to a study conducted by trade magazine Crane & Hoist Canada.

It was reported that in Ontario roughly eight per cent of jobs in the transport and heavy-equipment field are currently held by women. Furthermore, in 2024 almost 20 per cent of graduates at an Edmonton-based heavy-equipment operator training school were female, the article stated.

That brings us to Harmony Guspodarchuk, the first female crane operator in the 70-year history of Western Scrap Metals, a family-owned business at 18 Sutherland Ave.

Three years ago, Guspodarchuk literally stepped into the driver’s seat of a 27,500-kilogram, Liebherr C 924 Heavy Lift Litronic crane. The 29-year-old hasn’t looked back much since.

Read
Yesterday at 10:15 AM CDT

HSC weapons scanners effective, needed at other hospitals: nurses union

Carol Sanders 5 minute read Preview

HSC weapons scanners effective, needed at other hospitals: nurses union

Carol Sanders 5 minute read 9:57 AM CDT

The AI weapons scanners at Health Sciences Centre have detected close to 2,000 items since they were installed at Manitoba’s largest hospital.

From March 6, 2025 to the beginning of this month, a total of 1,973 items had been flagged by the scanners and identified for further review, Shared Health said this week.

Knives, Swiss army knives and other multi-tools, drugs, alcohol, box cutters, syringes and other injection devices were detected, it said. The technology set up at entrances to the adult and children’s emergency rooms and the crisis response centre is designed to identify a wide range of objects that may require review under site safety protocols.

But Manitoba Nurses Union president Darlene Jackson said the technology isn’t available everywhere at HSC, and a sawed-off rifle was discovered in the adult ER earlier this month.

Read
9:57 AM CDT

Men’s recovery home dedicated to ‘homeless hero’ Faron Hall’s memory

Scott Billeck 14 minute read Preview

Men’s recovery home dedicated to ‘homeless hero’ Faron Hall’s memory

Scott Billeck 14 minute read Yesterday at 12:30 PM CDT

Faron Hall never got the chance to begin recovery. Once heralded as Winnipeg’s “homeless hero” after twice plunging into the Red River to save strangers from drowning, Hall told St. Boniface Street Links executive director Marion Willis shortly before his death in 2014 that he wanted help for his alcoholism.

Read
Yesterday at 12:30 PM CDT

Manitoba family finalist for cattle producers environmental award

Aaron Epp 3 minute read Preview

Manitoba family finalist for cattle producers environmental award

Aaron Epp 3 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

A family in western Manitoba is one of seven finalists for a national environmental award honouring beef cattle producers.

Connor and Kyla English, alongside Connor’s parents, Brian and Leanne English, are nominated for the Canadian Cattle Association’s Environmental Stewardship Award. The 30-year-old award is presented to beef farmers and ranchers who explore innovative ways to protect, preserve and enhance their operations and the environment simultaneously.

This year’s recipient will be announced on Wednesday during a banquet at the Canadian Beef Industry Conference in Winnipeg.

The English family’s roots near Bradwardine — about 265 kilometres west of Winnipeg — date back to 1898. Today, Connor, Kyla, Brian and Leanne manage a herd of about 320 breeding cows on nearly 445 hectares (1,100 acres) of owned and rented pasture and forage land.

Read
2:00 AM CDT

August in the kitchen garden

Colleen Zacharias 7 minute read Preview

August in the kitchen garden

Colleen Zacharias 7 minute read 3:00 AM CDT

Lynne Hermiston is passionate about growing her own food. Her backyard food garden in south Winnipeg is an amazing example of the abundance and diversity of food that can be grown in a relatively small space. But it’s also a prime example of how a zest for learning innovative methods can make food gardening more fun.

Hermiston’s backyard is approximately 10 metres wide and 15 metres deep. The growing area consisting of raised beds and a couple of in-ground beds between her deck and back fence is about nine metres deep. There is not a single blade of turf grass in sight. The design for this attractive and productive space was created by Classic Landscaping four years ago. A series of raised wooden beds mulched with straw are neatly arranged on a light grey, slate-like surface. An inviting centre arbor acts as a focal point and supports climbing plants. The square-shaped raised-bed area receives eight to nine hours of sun daily. It is flanked on one side by a long, linear-shaped bed, planted with flowering perennials that attract and support pollinators.

The food plants Hermiston is growing this summer include tomatoes, cucumbers, squash, beets, chickpeas, beans, onions, sweet potatoes, horseradish, garlic, peppers, carrots, pumpkin and cauliflower. She is growing Chinese Pink celery, an heirloom variety with bubblegum-pink stems, for the first time, as well as eggplant.

She also grows salad greens and herbs, which have made delicious additions to her summer recipes this year. Only a few harvests remain of the spinach she planted. But, compared to last year’s growing season, some food plants are taking their time, Hermiston says.

Read
3:00 AM CDT